Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To cancel seeing a friend because she asked to invite someone else

238 replies

Sundaycoffee · 28/02/2024 23:27

I've had a 1:1 catch up in the diary with a friend for over a month now. I haven't seen her since the beginning of January and was looking forward to a "proper" chat. There's been a few things going on in my life (which she knows I wanted to discuss) and hers and I got the impression there would be some personal, more intimate things for us both to download on. She keeps going on about how she hasn't seen me in ages and there's so much to catch up on.
It was a lunch date (we had booked a bottomless brunch just the two of us).
Today she's messaged saying her other friend is also free and is it ok if she invites her? I've met this woman maybe 3 or 4 times over the past couple of years in group situations but wouldn't call her a friend.
I've told her I would rather it just be the two of us and it would change the dynamic a bit. She said that was ok but tbh I'm feeling a bit irritated that she clearly would rather this other person join and have more of a social chat rather than the more personal 1:1 meet that we had planned. Almost like my company alone isn't good enough and I now can't shake that feeling that I now know she would rather bring another person along and I had to be the one to say no.
I almost feel like saying to her, you guys catch up and we can do another time. The meeting I was looking forward to just feels a bit tarred now. Feel a bit silly and undervalued as a friend for her even just to ask. AIBU feeling this way?

OP posts:
Abeona · 29/02/2024 11:08

You're absolutely right. It wasn't important to her to catch up with just you, she doesn't need you in the same way you need her

I can hear that being said in Eeyore's voice. Good friendships aren't based on need. I have a variety of friends, some of whom live in difficult circumstances (terminally ill partners, children with MH issues, money and housing troubles) and we talk about 'deep' stuff, but they aren't needy — just sad or anxious sometimes and I'm there to listen. But often they want to meet up to have a laugh and talk about ideas and anything other than what's going on at home.

Sorry to have to say it but nothing's less attractive than neediness and people will run from it. Other people don't exist to meet your needs.

Mosaic123 · 29/02/2024 11:07

I think you are right to feel a bit miffed. I probably wouldn't have said no to the friend coming though.

But would have booked in another date and had my friend over so she couldn't ask anyone else.

So she would have got the message.

MaggieFS · 29/02/2024 10:59

You'd be daft to cancel. Only spiting yourself.

It's ok to feel like that for a fleeting moment, but you need to take her response at face value, and go and meet her. She asked, you said no, move on.

Isittimeformynapyet · 29/02/2024 10:57

Bestyearever2024 · 29/02/2024 06:33

You're absolutely right. It wasn't important to her to catch up with just you, she doesn't need you in the same way you need her

I think it's good that you know this. You can factor it into how you meet her going forward. And maybe you can rethink what you choose to tell her, or not. But you now have more information about her which can help you make choices

Oh dear. My heart sinks when I see a negative poster validating an OP's negative thinking.

It's really sad that you judge other people so harshly, especially when it's you that ends up losing out and feeling bad.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 29/02/2024 10:54

I recall a few years ago I was meeting a friend and was going to be talking about a break up, I was a bit depressed also due to family bereavements and also period issues (yeah great stuff!). She ended up bringing along her new boyfriend. This boyfriend ended up tagging along on future meetups too, which I didn't mind as he was nice (they're now married) but it could always be slightly awkward.

It turned out down the line that he'd moved to London from the North when they met, had no friends in London and was lonely. My friend also didn't want him to come along every time but he put pressure on her to come along. I get his predicament but I also think that sometimes, especially in these situations, you'd say "oh yes, you're seeing Gonna today, I'll let you have some girl time together and go to the pub/play sport and maybe catch up with you at the end of your catch up".

Now when we meet up he's sometimes there but we meet far more on a 1-1 basis - trickier as she has a 9 year old. But my friend relishes 1-1 time and an evening out without DH and kids!

@Globules - I see what you say and how this friend has phrased this. But if OP would like a heart to heart with her friend, she needs to say this really, rather than expect her friend to be a mindreader.

LIZS · 29/02/2024 10:51

She asked, you said no, so she has not invited them. What is your problem exactly?

HROSESATTERS · 29/02/2024 10:50

I can see why it would be a bit annoying, but she adjusted as soon as you said you would rather be just you two. It might be her other friend is going through a lot and and she wanted to pick her up too - usually more context to these things. I think you have a right to be a little bit irritated she suggested she bring a third wheel but given she said no probs when you said no, you need to let it go x

Phoebefail · 29/02/2024 10:49

Could you not briefly explain that you want to ask her advice about how the bereavement affects you. Or something else that is personal but lighter IYSWIM.

KreedKafer · 29/02/2024 10:40

It's fine that you're not keen to meet up with a third person that you don't really know very well.

However, being annoyed that she even asked and talking about things being 'tarred' and 'feeling undervalued' is a massive overreaction.

I also think that perhaps your friend is actually not as keen on the idea of 'downloading' as you are. Maybe she was worried that the two of you would end up spending the whole brunch talking about really heavy stuff when she was more keen to have more of a laugh?

thepastinsidethepresent · 29/02/2024 10:36

user1477391263 · 29/02/2024 07:53

I've noticed in the past few years, there's been a bit of a tendency towards people shying away from social encounters or opportunities to meet new people. I don't think it's a healthy trend.

I'm not sure it's a trend as such. I do think lockdown has made a difference, but I think that's partly because a lot of introverts (not necessarily assuming OP is one btw, I'm just giving my views from my own standpoint) have come to realise they don't have to go through life constantly pretending to be extrovert in order not to be seen as antisocial, and mentally exhausting themselves doing stuff they don't really want to do. I think people (both extrovert and introvert) are just being more selective these days, and personally I think that's healthy. Life isn't a one-size-fits-all thing, and it's too short to waste on doing stuff that doesn't feel meaningful.

AinsleyHayes · 29/02/2024 10:34

She was NBU to ask. You were NBU to say no. She accepted your response and hasn't pushed you on it. That's reasonable all round. YABU and a bit precious to say that the event is now tarnished.

I am going to say this gently because I don't think there's any evidence that your company alone won't be enough, but is it possible that she isn't in a place to listen to a trauma dump and wants this to be a lighter event? You're looking forward to a deep-and-meaningful but you need to be sure that this is what she wants, too.

Abeona · 29/02/2024 10:25

@SoapiesChoice The friend didn't put the OP on the spot: she asked in advance and the OP said no and the friend said 'OK'. Perfectly reasonable. Putting OP on the spot would involve turning up with the third party at the meeting, giving OP no say in the matter.

MrsSkylerWhite · 29/02/2024 10:24

If someone gave me the heads up that it was going to be a bit of a downer, I’d probably want to bring someone else along too.

SoapiesChoice · 29/02/2024 10:21

I had never heard of bottomless brunches until this thread and assumed it meant bottomless food until I read some later posts. OP I hope you don't mind my slightly straying to say I'm curious how a bottomless alcohol meal can even work from a pricing/business point of view.

Back on topic, how judgy of people to assume a meet up with wine has to be a cheery affair.

If I was meeting a friend for a mutual catch-up, get things off our chests etc meal and we planned to drink with it, surely it would be up to us whether we felt a bottomless brunch would suit us best.

Or is it in the small print of bottomless brunches that "all conversation must be sunshine and smiles to take part in this deal"?

Abeona · 29/02/2024 10:21

Mumoftwo1312 · 28/02/2024 23:40

You seem intent on a deep meaningful intense picking over your lives. But maybe she was looking forward to a fun catch up and an escape from difficult life issues?

I agree with this... I've got a couple of friends I don't really like seeing 1-1 because they end up being intensely monologue-y and I don't get a word in. In groups, they don't bring up their Stuff and it's just way more light hearted.

This feels so familiar. I have a friend who turns every meeting into a kind of therapy session with her talking endlessly about the latest problems in her life for most of the time we spend together. When I was younger I used to enjoy the intensity and drama of it, then began to feel bored and used. Now I'm actively angst-avoidant. I'll happily listen to someone if they have serious, pressing issues but I'm so over the psychodrama stuff. And gossip. I have zero tolerance of it. I increased the gaps between meetings as far as possible and when we do get together I try not to engage and to change the subject. Maybe next time I'll take someone else.

DrJoanAllenby · 29/02/2024 10:20

She invited the other friend as she may have got the feeling it would be a bit of a downer with just you and her offloading each others problems.

By inviting the other woman it would be more of a jolly meet up and having fun talking about good stuff as you obviously wouldn't feel comfortable about discussing personal problems in front of her.

Everythinggreen · 29/02/2024 10:11

Do you not chat on the phone in between meeting up if you have a problem that's been going on so personal that you need her undivided attention? Bottomless brunches are really for light hearted catch ups.
She asked, you said no, she said OK and hasn't cancelled. I don't really understand the issue here.

Ohanotherflippingcold · 29/02/2024 10:08

Well,

  1. A tacky bottomless brunch ( an excuse for women to be absolutely paralytic by 2.00pm) is not the place for a heart to heart 1-2-1 joint therapy session.
  2. I also hate extra people being invited to social occasions when my expectations are set in stone. So, whilst you are not BU to be annoyed by your friend wanting to invite a 3rd person, it does sound like she doesn't want the kind of meet up you do. Just because you were there for her, it doesn't mean she has to automatically reciprocate.
SoapiesChoice · 29/02/2024 10:07
  1. I think it was unreasonable of your friend to put you on the spot by putting that on you at this stage. Unless you were both good friends with the other woman.

If I had a very good reason to want to include the other one, the most I'd do is mention that I think they'd like to come but that it would change the dynamic. That would make it easier for you to say no by just agreeing with that.

If I was feeling like you are I would have said I wasn't keen on changing the dynamic this time but, as part of that conversation, I would naturally also have asked my friend why she wanted to bring the other person.

  1. Your feelings of unhappiness at having been put on the spot are NBU.

  2. But assuming the worst about why it was asked is unreasonable (to yourself). If you cancel you will never know and will continue to feel awkward with that friend.

  3. I agree with those saying some posts are harshly worded (given that you posted because the request has knocked your confidence in the friendship a bit}, the ones suggesting you could be a vampire friend.

It could just as easily be nothing like that at all. So please don't take that all badly to heart.

If you were already wondering about that, you could ask your friend as part of conversation at the brunch. But only if you feel able to accept hearing it if it's true, and only if you'd feel able to recognise it as her just being honest about her own limits/needs rather than trying to hurt you.

I mean ask her calmly in an "I just feel I'd better check not piling too much on you" way, not accusing her of judging you. But only if you think there is a possibility of it. It sounds from your posts as though confiding/venting has been a 2 way street in the friendship so there's maybe no need to ask unless you pick up any vibe that she's feeling differently at the brunch this time.

TLDR:

Your friend was unreasonable to put you on the spot like that. But since you don't know why she asked, it's best to not even try to second guess it.

If I were you I would tell myself to assume the best and go to the brunch but, if anything on the day made me think that maybe it's true that she wasn't up for such heavy discussions, then I'd ask her about it, in a "wanting to check it's not overloading you" way.

(But I would have already asked her why she wanted to add the 3rd person anyway, when she asked. Not by messaging though! I would have tried to find a time that was OK to briefly phone her so I could ask as part of replying to her, with no risk of it being read in the wrong tone).

posey22 · 29/02/2024 10:03

What a mean girls thread. The poster was only asking for opinions. Personal attacks on someone you absolutely don’t know. Nice.

Isittimeformynapyet · 29/02/2024 10:01

AltheaVestr1t · 29/02/2024 07:29

YANBU. Are you an introvert? I've spent many years gently explaining to my extrovert friends that when they invite random plus ones the activity changes from something I really look forward to to something that feels like work. They don't get it but they (mostly) respect my boundaries.

Again, the AIBU wasn't about preferring one-on-one meets, it was about cancelling her friend just for suggesting it.

Ariela · 29/02/2024 09:54

Why not see if friend can overlap you I'd say to my friend something along these lines:
Would love to catch up on a 1:1 first as not seen you for ages and suspect (other friend) might be bored with my news, why not see if your friend can join us later at say about (time, however long you think) so I can meet her too, I'll then have to dash off about (half an hour later or so, so as to not look rude) so you can then catch up properly with your friend too.

toomanyleggings · 29/02/2024 09:50

I’d just be grateful to have a friend to go out with. I think you’re being precious

PixieLaLar · 29/02/2024 09:50

Isn’t a bottomless brunch meant to be loud, boozy and well….fun?!

I would have thought the more the merrier. It seems an add choice of booking for a private 1-1 chat.

Spirallingdownwards · 29/02/2024 09:46

I voted YABU because she asked and you said you would rather she didn't and she simply accepted that. No big deal made by her so unsure why you are making it into one.

Perhaps the "bottomless brunch" suggested to her that it was a social fun occasion rather than a heart to heart. But either way you said no and she was fine with it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread