Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To cancel seeing a friend because she asked to invite someone else

238 replies

Sundaycoffee · 28/02/2024 23:27

I've had a 1:1 catch up in the diary with a friend for over a month now. I haven't seen her since the beginning of January and was looking forward to a "proper" chat. There's been a few things going on in my life (which she knows I wanted to discuss) and hers and I got the impression there would be some personal, more intimate things for us both to download on. She keeps going on about how she hasn't seen me in ages and there's so much to catch up on.
It was a lunch date (we had booked a bottomless brunch just the two of us).
Today she's messaged saying her other friend is also free and is it ok if she invites her? I've met this woman maybe 3 or 4 times over the past couple of years in group situations but wouldn't call her a friend.
I've told her I would rather it just be the two of us and it would change the dynamic a bit. She said that was ok but tbh I'm feeling a bit irritated that she clearly would rather this other person join and have more of a social chat rather than the more personal 1:1 meet that we had planned. Almost like my company alone isn't good enough and I now can't shake that feeling that I now know she would rather bring another person along and I had to be the one to say no.
I almost feel like saying to her, you guys catch up and we can do another time. The meeting I was looking forward to just feels a bit tarred now. Feel a bit silly and undervalued as a friend for her even just to ask. AIBU feeling this way?

OP posts:
Flatdog · 29/02/2024 20:30

Completely unreasonable. She asked (didn’t tell!) and when you said no she said okay and respected your feelings. Relax and get a grip.

Fireworkgrannyblanket · 29/02/2024 19:11

Ooh - that Askers Vs Guessers thing is pure gold, it's put a whole new perspective to my relationship with my Mum!

Vonesk · 29/02/2024 18:12

SHE ' S not being unreasonable as such by inviting another person but the fact that the New girl not part of a ' Bonded' group ( it is possible for a group of more than 2 girls can be solidly ' Bonded' which makes no difference who joins lunches) Then shes on dodgy ground .
YOU feel betrayed, as its possible you might spill private information to a unknown bystander.
This is borderline out of order.
Not the actions of a Loyal friend.
The original reason to meet has changed. From a interpersonal discussion to a superficial lunch date.
Message her and say " when can we meet to have a heart yo heart..???????..
B. T. W. Dont feel too put out because you could have suffered a deeper hurt if you had messaged her and she said " Actually, theres already four of us at table so your presence is not required. " As what happened to me.!!!!!!!

Emmz1510 · 29/02/2024 17:22

If she suddenly cancels between now and then then I guess you’ll know she’s miffed and would rather it was the three of you and your suspicions will be proved right.
But as it stands right now you said you’d rather not, she accepted it and the lunch date is still on so I wouldn’t overthink.

beanii · 29/02/2024 16:49

You're definitely not being unreasonable although most of here probably won't agree with me.

I'm an introvert so to me I'd find it extremely uncomfortable and I'd actually be hurt that the friend even suggested it to be honest 🤷‍♀️

Mummyofbananas · 29/02/2024 16:35

I don't think either are being unreasonable. I know personally I have very little free time so I'd rather meet my friends in groups however if you don't know the other person well that does change the dynamic for you. I think you both dealt with it right and it's nothing to worry about.

Isittimeformynapyet · 29/02/2024 16:02

SoapiesChoice · 29/02/2024 14:48

That was interesting thanks!!

I thought it was going to be something else, about people who try to second guess what someone is thinking about a situation vs those who just ask them.

But my head probably went there at the article title because that's where my thoughts often go when reading AIBUs.

Yes, it was interesting.

I had very similar situation this week. Friend and I booked for cinema and I asked if we should invite others "or keep it cosy". She replied "just you and me" and I said "Lovely".

We're both askers.

I suppose the difference is that the value of a 1-1 was actually voiced in my question.

I suppose OP's friend could have included something like that in her acceptance of the "no" and none of this second guessing would have been necessary.

Alalalalalongalalalalalonglonglilong · 29/02/2024 15:37

benid · 29/02/2024 13:48

I think this highlights the difference between Askers and Guessers- this blew my mind when I first read it. Looks like she's an Asker and you're a Guesser so you have different interpretations of how (un)reasonable that request is.
https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2010/may/08/change-life-asker-guesser

I'm a Guesser too and it can lead to a lot of overthinking!

Enjoy your brunch OP Smile

Thanks for this! Its very interesting. It describes the difference between my sister and I perfectly. She is textbook asker, I'm a guesser. Its not surprising that she generally has more success in life!

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 29/02/2024 15:36

The question isn't was the friend BU to invite a 3rd but was OP BU to CANCEL the whole thing because she took this as some deep, personal slight

Alalalalalongalalalalalonglonglilong · 29/02/2024 15:32

I see both sides, if my friend suggested she would prefer 1 to 1 I would presume she had something to tell me and I would respect that. If however she made a habit of it I would struggle as i find 1 to 1 a bit intense and prefer meeting in groups. So I guess it depends on context and if OP is a clingy friend normally.

Personally I hate it when people invite others along. I have a friend who does this a lot, not just me but with everyone. Many years ago when I was young and in my 20s I arranged to meet her for lunch on a Friday, 7 days after my mother died. We picked somewhere by her workplace. I saw her walk out of the building as I was there early and saw her bump into someone, pointing to the restaurant and gesturing. She brought a randomer to lunch, yes I knew this girl but not very well. I am still friends with the same person but honestly on some level I didn't ever forgive and forget the unbelievable insensitivity of it. Just wanted to share that and get it off my chest!

StaunchMomma · 29/02/2024 15:05

We're all different, OP. Many will say it's good to add more people into a social situation, more fun etc. I, like you, would rather that not happen, especially when you've been planning to 'catch up' for a while, have things to discuss and don't really know the other person.

There's nothing wrong with being honest or going with what's best for you. There is also nothing wrong with wanting to spend time with a friend 1-1.

SoapiesChoice · 29/02/2024 14:48

benid · 29/02/2024 13:48

I think this highlights the difference between Askers and Guessers- this blew my mind when I first read it. Looks like she's an Asker and you're a Guesser so you have different interpretations of how (un)reasonable that request is.
https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2010/may/08/change-life-asker-guesser

I'm a Guesser too and it can lead to a lot of overthinking!

Enjoy your brunch OP Smile

That was interesting thanks!!

I thought it was going to be something else, about people who try to second guess what someone is thinking about a situation vs those who just ask them.

But my head probably went there at the article title because that's where my thoughts often go when reading AIBUs.

SoapiesChoice · 29/02/2024 14:38

HollyKnight · 29/02/2024 14:03

No, I don't say that to her because it isn't really about her and I wouldn't want her to feel bad about it. Like I said I love her. I don't want to hurt her. But I know she would take it personally, like I find her too much or I don't want to be her friend. But it really is just that I am unable to handle any more negativity sometimes. That sometimes I can't provide her with what she needs. The rest of the time I can handle it fine. I wouldn't cancel plans or change plans after they are made, but I purposely don't make plans too far in advance because I know I don't know how I am going to feel closer to the time.

I see what you mean since you know that friend well enough to know that she would take it personally, and be hurt, no matter how you put it.

Thank-you for responding. I hope you are currently in a good spot, but if you are not then I hope a good spot is not far away.

Flamingos89 · 29/02/2024 14:35

If she is such a good friend you need to cut her some slack… it’s quite normal for her to think ‘oo why don’t we meet together’ if her friend asked her to meet up the same day. It’s good she asked you first. The more the merrier is a saying for a reason.

Does not mean she does not love or value you.

Rubbishconfession · 29/02/2024 14:05

Noirdesir · 29/02/2024 13:54

Good grief, what on earth is wrong with starting a very polite anonymous thread on MN for perspective? Do you have an approved list of topics for us?

Interesting how its ok for the OP to vent her feelings yet when anyone else does they're apparently wrong.

You are being just as rude/snarky here as the people you are attacking for doing the same.

Why do you need to vent your feelings on a stranger? That says more about you than the OP. At least the OP has a genuine AIBU, you are all just piling on to be rude and snarky for the sake of it.

And no, defending OP's right to start a thread does not mean I have said no one else can do it, how ridiculous of you to suggest it.

HollyKnight · 29/02/2024 14:03

SoapiesChoice · 29/02/2024 13:45

I'm just curious, not criticising. Do you ever just tell her "I'm sorry I would struggle with a heavy conversion at the moment" when she asks to meet? So she knows why you are dodging her sometimes. Or so she could say she'd like to meet anyway but to try having a break from her troubles with you instead of using the meet to talk about them.

Someone further up made a similarly valid point as yours that in the past they were well up for all kinds of gossip, drama, heavy talk etc but no longer have the patience/headspace for it (I'm paraphrasing, but hopefully close enough).

So they are distancing themself from a friend who is always heavy chat.

I found myself wondering if they had ever told the friend they feel differently these days offering the friend a chance to still meet up but with a different dynamic. Of course they are under no obligation to see the friend but if that were the only issue I would tell the friend rather than expect them to just know why I was backing off.

No, I don't say that to her because it isn't really about her and I wouldn't want her to feel bad about it. Like I said I love her. I don't want to hurt her. But I know she would take it personally, like I find her too much or I don't want to be her friend. But it really is just that I am unable to handle any more negativity sometimes. That sometimes I can't provide her with what she needs. The rest of the time I can handle it fine. I wouldn't cancel plans or change plans after they are made, but I purposely don't make plans too far in advance because I know I don't know how I am going to feel closer to the time.

Mumoftwo1312 · 29/02/2024 14:01

benid · 29/02/2024 13:48

I think this highlights the difference between Askers and Guessers- this blew my mind when I first read it. Looks like she's an Asker and you're a Guesser so you have different interpretations of how (un)reasonable that request is.
https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2010/may/08/change-life-asker-guesser

I'm a Guesser too and it can lead to a lot of overthinking!

Enjoy your brunch OP Smile

Wow thanks for sharing! Today I learned.. I'm an Asker. And I have indeed fallen out with at least one Guesser in my lifetime, one of whom op strongly reminded me of.

If op's name starts with K and lives in Surrey... I think I know you and I'm sorry we've drifted apart

Fireworkgrannyblanket · 29/02/2024 13:56

Don't cancel! You'll be doing yourself out of a nice 1 to 1 for no reason. Your friend probably just double-booked herself and didn't realise you'd feel disrespected by her asking for a plus one.

Full disclosure - l've done this and l'd be horrified if the original friend felt put out. In my case l was meeting up with one mate for a couple of days in London and another friend who lives abroad was going to be in town for a work thing and wanted us to go to a show. OriginalFriend was agreeable so we went and had a great night. I'd have been cool with it if she had said no, though, as she had first dibs - if you see what l mean?

Just go and enjoy - don't overthink it!

Noirdesir · 29/02/2024 13:54

Good grief, what on earth is wrong with starting a very polite anonymous thread on MN for perspective? Do you have an approved list of topics for us?

Interesting how its ok for the OP to vent her feelings yet when anyone else does they're apparently wrong.

You are being just as rude/snarky here as the people you are attacking for doing the same.

Globules · 29/02/2024 13:52

Herdinggoats · 29/02/2024 09:37

Really? If I was suspecting a friend was going to emotionally unload onto me then I’d be looking for unlimited booze to get through it. 🤷🏻‍♀️

That is the other way to look at it 😂

I know I'd speak my mind far more bluntly with alcohol in my system. I wouldn't be as gentle as they may need me to be.

benid · 29/02/2024 13:48

I think this highlights the difference between Askers and Guessers- this blew my mind when I first read it. Looks like she's an Asker and you're a Guesser so you have different interpretations of how (un)reasonable that request is.
https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2010/may/08/change-life-asker-guesser

I'm a Guesser too and it can lead to a lot of overthinking!

Enjoy your brunch OP Smile

This column will change your life: Are you an Asker or a Guesser?

Are you an Asker or a Guesser? Oliver Burkeman explains the difference

https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2010/may/08/change-life-asker-guesser

Rubbishconfession · 29/02/2024 13:46

IReallyStillCantBeBothered · 29/02/2024 13:11

If OP values her friendship it 15 years she wouldn’t have created this post on mumsnet.

If after 15 years she doesn’t know if her friend values her and she needs strangers on mumsnet to tell her, then she can end her friendship and move on.

sorry but her post sounded sos childish and immature, really the meeting is now tarred?

Do you think her friend of 15 years would be happy if she came across this thread?

Edited

Good grief, what on earth is wrong with starting a very polite anonymous thread on MN for perspective? Do you have an approved list of topics for us? Hmm

Your black and white view of people suggests that you are not the easy going drama free person you are trying to paint yourself as.

SoapiesChoice · 29/02/2024 13:45

HollyKnight · 29/02/2024 13:26

It could be she's just not in the right frame of mind at the moment for a deep heavy discussion about life and was hoping to lighten the meeting a bit by bringing this other person along. I have an intense friend who I love dearly, but I always come away feeling quite down after seeing her because our chats are so negative. I can't always handle it when I'm having a hard time too so tend to either avoid her a little, or arrange to meet somewhere where it is harder to have those types of conversations.

I'm just curious, not criticising. Do you ever just tell her "I'm sorry I would struggle with a heavy conversion at the moment" when she asks to meet? So she knows why you are dodging her sometimes. Or so she could say she'd like to meet anyway but to try having a break from her troubles with you instead of using the meet to talk about them.

Someone further up made a similarly valid point as yours that in the past they were well up for all kinds of gossip, drama, heavy talk etc but no longer have the patience/headspace for it (I'm paraphrasing, but hopefully close enough).

So they are distancing themself from a friend who is always heavy chat.

I found myself wondering if they had ever told the friend they feel differently these days offering the friend a chance to still meet up but with a different dynamic. Of course they are under no obligation to see the friend but if that were the only issue I would tell the friend rather than expect them to just know why I was backing off.

OpieMo · 29/02/2024 13:40

BeakyBlinders · 28/02/2024 23:43

I'd be mortified putting my friend in that situation of saying no! That's probably tarred the friendship a bit from her side.

Huh, really? The OP and friend had a plan, friend asked to change plan, OP declined. Friend said okay. There's really nothing to be mortified over, OP hasn't put her friend in that situation' lol. Friend has put herself in the situation, and that's perfectly okay as there's nothing wrong with asking and nothing wrong with saying no.

OP does seem a bit intense though and I wonder if friend sensed this and that's why she fancied asking someone else too... sounds a bit like OP wanted it to be more like a therapy session, and I know it can be so draining with friends like that. OP's friend might well love her and want to see her but not be capable right now of the sort of intense in depth emotional thing OP is desiring.

OP, I would suggest you have the hang out anyway but try something a bit different and make an effort to make it a bit more fun and light. Of course you can talk about how you've been and what's been going on, but definitely make sure to have some fun and lightness too, ask about your friend's life, how she's doing.

Abeona · 29/02/2024 13:37

@SoapiesChoice let me introduce you to @Sundaycoffee You both sound as if you would get on with each other. There might be the opportunity for a friendship here. I'm relatively new to Mumsnet, but there is probably a way of DMing each other privately. It would be nice to think something positive came out of this thread.