Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School PE lessons, children made to pick teams, disgusting or what

256 replies

DistingusedSocialCommentator · 28/02/2024 22:05

I've just read a thread by an FM here asking if "schools were getting children to choose teams" and FM felt it was "old-fashioned"

Schools bang on about inclusion/fairness/caring/MH well-being, etc etc

FFS (sorry about my language) how the F does a child feel when they are the group of children who are almost the last ones to be picked???

What ruddy clowns at schools still allow this disgusting and ignorant method of choosing teams?? Are you not ruddy aware that this method of choosing teams can and does affect children's MH and can scar them for like

Any teachers here care to comment, or justify this ludicrously pathetic and ancient method of hosing teams??

does it go in your child's school or one you work in? If so, have you pulled up the culprits?

AIBU to believe this method of choosing teams is outdated and harmful to many of our DC?

Tomorrow, I will get on to the papers/radio and tv stations to outlaw this crass method of choosing teams in PE and other settings in schools.

OP posts:
MissMelanieH · 29/02/2024 01:58

Create a hundred cards with letters of the alphabet on them and keep throwing them up into the air until they land to form a child’s name. Rinse and repeat to get the next team member. Oh and do it to find the name of the kid who will be doing the throwing. Can’t get fairer and less traumatising than that

...or how about the adults who are supposed to be teaching the lesson take a few minutes to plan balanced teams and then tell the children which teams to go and stand in?

You know like in every other subject where teachers have to spend a little bit of time thinking about grouping as part of their teaching style.

Picking teams is lazy and there's far too much poor, lazy teaching of PE that favours those who are good at it and expects those that aren't to "develop resilience" by being ritually humiliated rather than actually attempting to develop and teach them something.

This is a major bugbear of mine, how badly PE is taught in school compared to other subjects.

user1477391263 · 29/02/2024 01:25

Wolfpa · 28/02/2024 22:08

How would you suggest that teams get picked?

There are a million ways you could pick teams without resorting to these kinds of awful strategies. Letters of the alphabet, or just walk down a line of kids saying "a, b, a, b, a, b...."etc. etc.

No team-picking should be allowed in this day and age. This kind of casual cruelty and humiliation would never be tolerated in an adult social club or workplace.

Given how serious an issue sedentary lifestyles are, the absolute last thing we should be doing is making exercise into a miserable experience for kids.

ItsAllAboutTheDosh · 29/02/2024 01:20

It does not traumatise children for life. It does teach them that sport is not for them.
I was always picked last, I suspect I have undiagnosed dyspraxia. I hated it and avoided all sports as an adult as I was terrible at all of them. DP loves sports and taught me to enjoy playing at a fun level even though I am still not any good at sports.
PE should be about encouraging every child to be more active for life. Instead it puts lots of children off sports for life.

And building resilience is bollocks. I knew I was bad at sports. All my classmates knew I was bad which is why I was picked last every single time. I was not brilliant at anything else. Instead I just felt pretty much like a public failure once a week. Until I started faking illness to avoid PE.

ZebraDanios · 29/02/2024 01:14

Ireallycantthinkofagoodone · 29/02/2024 01:01

I agree with you; I was the same - and I’m not scarred for life. Children need to learn resilience, and understand that everyone has different strengths and limitations.

This is another justification that gets trotted out in these discussions: “children need to learn what they’re not good at”.

Oddly enough though there isn’t a single story here from someone who thought they were God’s gift to PE and then was absolutely astonished when they got picked last one day.

Kids who aren’t good at something know they aren’t good at it just from going to those lessons: they don’t need their incompetence showcased in front of everyone else in the class to be aware of it themselves.

user1745 · 29/02/2024 01:08

I think the problem is that PE teachers, by definition, were the sporty kids in school, and therefore are unlikely to fully understand what it is like to always be picked last.

No, it's not the most traumatising thing in the world that can happen to a child, but when it happens again and again, it does hurt, and it can so easily be avoided if teachers use a different method.

I agree that it's good for children to recognise weaknesses and strengths, but that's not what this is about. When I remember being picked last for PE, it's not the fact that I was bad at PE that hurts (I don't care about that), it's the fact that every single lesson, this weakness - which incidentally was the result of a disability - was essentially rubbed in my face as I stood waiting while every single other child was picked. The worst was when the children would audibly groan when I ended up on their team.

ColourMeBlue · 29/02/2024 01:02

I was always the last but one to be picked for the school team.The popular sporty ones were Captains,allowed to pick their teams.I hated it.I hated it so much,knowing i would be the last resort to my friend,who was overweight,hence being picked last.I imagine she felt absolutely awful.The Captains were never nice either,they didn't want you on their team so give you the worse position and spoke to you like crap the entire time.

Ireallycantthinkofagoodone · 29/02/2024 01:01

Towerofsong · 28/02/2024 22:12

Well I was always the last to be picked for a team, but I also learned that this was fair enough as I had poor hand eye coordination.
I also sat exams and - shock, horror - we were ranked in our results!

I simply learned that I was exceptionally good at certain subjects and that I was probably better to focus on those rather than a sports career.

It didn't affect my mental health or scar me for life, it gave me a realistic understanding of my strengths and weaknesses.

I agree with you; I was the same - and I’m not scarred for life. Children need to learn resilience, and understand that everyone has different strengths and limitations.

ZebraDanios · 29/02/2024 00:51

Ah, resilience.

There was a thread a while back about why we forced all kids to join in with Sports Day when mandatory participation in public competitions didn’t exist in any other area of life. Lots of people said “but how will they ever learn resilience without everyone they know and all their parents watching them finish a race five minutes after everyone else?”. And then one poster pointed out that actually educational psychologists pretty much agreed that resilience doesn’t come from making kids endure unpleasant experiences, it comes from the security of their relationships, but we persist with the idea that it comes from making them endure unpleasant things because then we feel better about making them endure unpleasant things.

Just saying.

IvorTheEngineDriver · 29/02/2024 00:25

I was always one of the last to be picked but since I hated PE at school I couldn't have cared less.

Magnastorm · 29/02/2024 00:22

"Tomorrow, I will get on to the papers/radio and tv stations to outlaw this crass method of choosing teams in PE and other settings in schools."

Ahhh, you took it too far OP. Next time, dial back a little.

Alargeoneplease89 · 29/02/2024 00:10

My son's school is doing this method and I hate it. He isnt good at sports and always last - it certainly isn't doing his confidence much good. He has been brought up resilient and we joke about it but it really does piss me off inside. We all have to do things we hate in life but I don't understand how this encourages enjoyment of sport when you are basically shown you aren't wanted.

You don't see teachers in other subjects board casting how rubbish you are.

FluffletheMeow · 29/02/2024 00:10

Do you remember the special needs kid in school. The one that just about scraped into mainstream school. Academics were hard, sport was hard, making friends was hard?

What if you're that kid?

It's so easy to do this a better way. Why not do so?

ZebraPensAreLife · 29/02/2024 00:08

I’m surprised so many people still remember how teams were picked at school. I literally have no recollection of that; we probably had kids choosing teams and I imagine I was last to be chosen as I am very shit at all sports.

I’m also surprised people are saying teams at work events etc are chosen randomly. IME they’re very carefully selected, although it may seem random to someone not involved with organising it.

Really not worth going to the papers about in any case.

QueenCamilla · 28/02/2024 23:59

What a complete overreaction!

In PE we always had two leaders in that sport alternate at choosing the next team member - it was the best way to ensure two teams of pretty equal players (good and bad) to have a game. Maybe we were very sports-minded but it definitely wasn't a popularity contest - all based on ability.

We also had someone at school who couldn't be on a team because of his amazing physical provess - he alone was a guaranteed win. So he had to sit it out. Until NBA picked him 😁🏀

My own son is not very sporty (though popular) and can cost a team it's win. So in sports clubs he doesn't even get play time on the team - only training time. Fair enough I say, and he hasn't been upset about it yet 🤷

elliejjtiny · 28/02/2024 23:52

We used to do that all the time in the 90's. I was always picked last or second last because I was hopeless at sport. One time the teacher let me be one of the children who picked the rounders team. I picked all the people who were always last to be picked. Our team lost really badly, I think the score was about 20-0. Everyone else in the class told me I'd been really silly doing it like that. I think the teacher must have done too because I was never asked to pick teams again!

Boomarang · 28/02/2024 23:47

I think I might be the sad little Irish one 😂

Always last to be picked! Admittedly grew up and educated in Eire so I can’t plead or blame racism. I did get bronze the egg and spoon race one year but that’s because I had a very large serving spoon and a rather small potato on it.

The good news is that I survived all… thrived in music and academics, and am now a tutor for Oxford Uni post graduates.

I’m one of 5 children raised in a single income house.

Don’t overthink OP. Teach your children. They are good at some things, not the best at others. My kids are 8 & 12. Best thing they ever did was get into competitive sport. It teaches them they aren’t the best at everything, working to improve, it’s not an equal playing field where everyone gets a medal and you need to figure out their strengths and play to them.

DancefloorAcrobatics · 28/02/2024 23:44

🤷🏻‍♀️ we had a mixture of a leader picking own teams and the 123123 method.

Sometimes it was just a divine yourself into 2 teams, with some shuffling for the less sporty kids.
I think each method has it's flaws. It's just one of the many things that some kids hate about PE.

User373433 · 28/02/2024 23:36

I definitely agree with the poster saying it's a drop in the ocean though, as there are so many equally unfair and damaging things in school, newspapers won't be interested.

Crazycatlady79 · 28/02/2024 23:36

I was always picked last, as I was unpopular. I was actually pretty average at most sports.

I'm sure it's affected my self-esteem, but I really don't think the media would give a flying fuck about this topic.

Terfosaurus · 28/02/2024 23:33

The issue I had with this method of picking teams was that the same kids were always picked to be team captains, so the same kids were always left until last.
If the teachers had changed the captains every lesson I think it would have mixed that up a bit.

User373433 · 28/02/2024 23:30

I hate it, but probably because I was always picked last. I didn't focus on what I was good at because I was last at everything. Grades were always read out and mine were lowest. Always picked to be an understudy in plays. Last to get my pen license (on the last day of the final year you could get it, so just a token gesture). It wasn't that I didn't try, I just scraped in to a selective school being very average ability full of very gifted students, but I didn't really grasp that. I probably would have been fine in a non selective school but the constant being bottom for everything made me give up thinking I could succeed at anything. I think this style of competing can certainly be damaging, and is just lazy.

FluffletheMeow · 28/02/2024 23:29

DistingusedSocialCommentator · 28/02/2024 23:03

Just read you post having just posted,
So true hence my previous post

I recal f--ing dancing classes innPE, chose your partner, I felt sick to the stomach and tried to avoid those classes - it was not because i did not lok like the average child, I was in a minority group when the rest of the class where indigenous kids.

Children can be very nasty and the pairing of two was worse come to think about it - but again geting people to pair in numbers is the way forward

Yes, I agree this is a better kinder way to do it.

Teachers take note, for some kids, this can make a big difference to someone's day.

Really, really.

Jellybeanz456 · 28/02/2024 23:27

HowardsWayward · 28/02/2024 22:11

1,2,1,2,1,2 - there you go.

This is how it was done when I was in school 20+ years ago.

WhatHeSaid33 · 28/02/2024 23:27

I agree with you OP. Found it cringey and scarring as a child, induced loads of anxiety and I’m shocked it’s still in play. I thought having different coloured houses was an easy solution. The teacher just divving them up also is better

Maray1967 · 28/02/2024 23:23

twingiraffes · 28/02/2024 22:56

If I were the PE teacher, then I'd do it myself, and ensure that there was a reasonable split between the teams.

There are few things worse than being picked last every fucking time, twice or three times a week, for years on end, knowing that nobody wants you on their team.

I simply cannot believe that in this day and age, PE teachers still allow this ritual humiliation and bullying of children by their peers.

Agreed. I was always one of the last, but as I was top in several academic subjects I could cope with it fairly well. However, I am extremely mentally tough- and I saw what it did to others.

It is a bloody awful method of sorting kids into teams. Teachers should do it randomly and quickly. No kids should be able to humiliate others in that way.