Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School PE lessons, children made to pick teams, disgusting or what

256 replies

DistingusedSocialCommentator · 28/02/2024 22:05

I've just read a thread by an FM here asking if "schools were getting children to choose teams" and FM felt it was "old-fashioned"

Schools bang on about inclusion/fairness/caring/MH well-being, etc etc

FFS (sorry about my language) how the F does a child feel when they are the group of children who are almost the last ones to be picked???

What ruddy clowns at schools still allow this disgusting and ignorant method of choosing teams?? Are you not ruddy aware that this method of choosing teams can and does affect children's MH and can scar them for like

Any teachers here care to comment, or justify this ludicrously pathetic and ancient method of hosing teams??

does it go in your child's school or one you work in? If so, have you pulled up the culprits?

AIBU to believe this method of choosing teams is outdated and harmful to many of our DC?

Tomorrow, I will get on to the papers/radio and tv stations to outlaw this crass method of choosing teams in PE and other settings in schools.

OP posts:
NotTerfNorCis · 29/02/2024 08:32

Naptrappedmummy · 29/02/2024 08:12

‘Soul destroying’? Being orphaned is soul destroying, living with painful chronic illness is soul destroying, being a child in Gaza/Ukraine/famine hit parts of Africa is soul destroying.

Should ‘not being picked first for a sports team in PE’ be added to that list, or should we all stop with the constant melodrama?

Disagree. If someone is being reminded on a regular basis that they're 'last', hopeless or disliked, that would be soul destroying - especially if that person is young.

Todayzname · 29/02/2024 08:31

How very last century.

It can't be educationally justified.

I was rarely picked - rugby needed 30 lads. 30+ in the group. The spares were sent on a road run, like a cross country but on country lanes.

Supposed to go round twice - we did it once and stopped off at a friends house for a cup of tea, sat in barns. To be honest it was preferable.

A school doing that today would have a 20 minute OFSTED. Unsatisfactory.

Those who aren't picked can have failure stamped on them. Every child needs to experience some public success.

Naptrappedmummy · 29/02/2024 08:30

Boringlaptopday · 29/02/2024 08:29

The irony of the author of this hyperbolic post accusing others of melodrama 🙄

Why are those situations hyperbole? They’re playing out as we speak.

Boringlaptopday · 29/02/2024 08:29

Naptrappedmummy · 29/02/2024 08:12

‘Soul destroying’? Being orphaned is soul destroying, living with painful chronic illness is soul destroying, being a child in Gaza/Ukraine/famine hit parts of Africa is soul destroying.

Should ‘not being picked first for a sports team in PE’ be added to that list, or should we all stop with the constant melodrama?

The irony of the author of this hyperbolic post accusing others of melodrama 🙄

Bythefireside · 29/02/2024 08:29

BakedTattie · 29/02/2024 07:57

I actually agree with you op in a toned down way - it’s not nice being the last picked.

but I think you need to calm down a bit.

Tone it down?

tell that to the kid who is physically sick the night before PE as they’re so stressed and worried about being embarrassed about this.

Tatonka · 29/02/2024 08:28

millymollymoomoo · 29/02/2024 07:40

No wonder we have a generation of snowflakes with zero resilience or emotional strength. Jeez

Snowflakes are generally a result of being spoilt and pampered and are usually quite entitled people, that's very different to being belittled or sidelined. Resilience isn't built by treating people badly, resilience is built by strength. Very, very different things

OneInEight · 29/02/2024 08:28

I was always picked last too. Unpopular in general and hopeless at sport. It was years after I left school that I actually realised that there were some sports that I could do and get some enjoyment of it. It was the ds's judo teacher who made me realise that actually what sports teachers should be doing is encouraging the hopeless ones not discouraging them further.

Boringlaptopday · 29/02/2024 08:27

broccolienthusiast · 29/02/2024 08:12

Me! I was shit at team sports but started running as an adult. I've done 6 marathons so far and I'm quite good at it

See, thanks to being picked last, you’ve internalized the belief that you are shit at team sports and no one would want you. Same here. I only do solo sports for that reason too.

it’s not a good message to teach kids though. Is it?

Boringlaptopday · 29/02/2024 08:21

I had no idea schools still do this. Even more surprised people here support it.

Its crap. I was always third last. You can’t really enjoy being in a team knowing no one wants you there. It doesn’t inspire you to try harder. It makes you live down to their low expectations.

School sports just taught me I was crap at being active. If it weren’t for a friend when we left school asking me to accompany her to her keep Fit class, which, to my great surprise I enjoyed, I may have rolled through life with the internalized belief that being active was not for me, that I was bad at it and it made me feel bad. I still avoid team sports like the plague as I still have that firm belief that I am shit at them and no one will want me on their team. I only do solo activities.

In an age of obesity and the ensuing burden on the NHS and cost to public finances, not to mention all the misery that the infirmity obesity leads to as one ages, it is really, really, really stupid for school to be linking activity in kids brains, with them feeling crap about themselves in this way.

We should do physical activity in a way that encourages kids to enjoy it and see it as life affirming. School sports should not be a test as to whether you have the resilience to cope with being publicly marked out as unpopular and shit at sport, with no one wanting you on their side.

Wolfpa · 29/02/2024 08:19

@Bythefireside i can think of lots of other ways, all which come with their own problems.

sillysausage92 · 29/02/2024 08:15

God I still have awful memories of being the last one picked (I was terrible at sport to be fair) and at the time k always thought it was because people didn't like me. It was always a horrible crushing feeling when the PE teacher said right "popular girls pick your teams!"

broccolienthusiast · 29/02/2024 08:12

DecayedStrumpet · 29/02/2024 07:37

I'd be interested to know how many of the "I was always picked last and it never harmed me" crowd actually still do any exercise?

Me! I was shit at team sports but started running as an adult. I've done 6 marathons so far and I'm quite good at it

Naptrappedmummy · 29/02/2024 08:12

olympicsrock · 29/02/2024 08:08

I agree with you OP . It’s cruel and soul destroying for children. Asking people to get into pairs can also be difficult.
Horrible to be the child standing looking around at happy giggling pairs when no one wants you.
I wish teachers would just say - get into pairs with the person next to you starting here.

‘Soul destroying’? Being orphaned is soul destroying, living with painful chronic illness is soul destroying, being a child in Gaza/Ukraine/famine hit parts of Africa is soul destroying.

Should ‘not being picked first for a sports team in PE’ be added to that list, or should we all stop with the constant melodrama?

Josette77 · 29/02/2024 08:12

Actually I agree with the above. It was a relief in ways because there were no expectations of me.

When I was sent way out in the field for whatever sport I was much happier. Lol

Bythefireside · 29/02/2024 08:09

Wolfpa · 28/02/2024 22:08

How would you suggest that teams get picked?

Are you serious you literally can’t think of another way?!

Josette77 · 29/02/2024 08:09

I was picked last because I wasn't good at team sports.

I was on the track team and a dancer and gymnast. Athletic but no clue how to hit a ball.

I dreaded gym but not moreso than math class.

No adverse effects. I was a theater kid. I knew what I was good at and what I wasn't.

MumblesParty · 29/02/2024 08:09

Dazedandfrazzled · 29/02/2024 07:58

This is actually a fascinating thread. I was almost always picked last, I didn't think it actually affected me. But reading this, I do remember dreading it and basically feeling a bit shit. It also does make me think I never was interested in sports later probably because I thought I wouldn't be good at it anyway. Overall just interesting to think about and wonder if it really is necessary and is it really the best way to do it. Does it teach anything positive? It definitely does teach something negative to those who are picked last

it wasn't being picked last that made me unenthusiastic about sports. It was disliking sports. And being crap at it. In fact, being picked last took the pressure off, because it meant the team captains didn’t expect anything of me!

olympicsrock · 29/02/2024 08:08

I agree with you OP . It’s cruel and soul destroying for children. Asking people to get into pairs can also be difficult.
Horrible to be the child standing looking around at happy giggling pairs when no one wants you.
I wish teachers would just say - get into pairs with the person next to you starting here.

JustMarriedBecca · 29/02/2024 08:07

Yes. Happened twice at school here and I went in both times.

First time it was "pick your best friend" (so not even pick someone who is genuinely good at sport) so the last child picked has been marked as the child with no friends.

And second time, it was "pick someone who is sporty"

This isn't inclusive, kind of any of the drivel they spout as being important at primary school. Given how there is such a lack of focus at that age on academic success.

And as for learning resilience, given that we don't use the "Dunces Hat" or make kids do lines for being idiots / "working towards" why the hell should we penalise kids who struggle in other areas.

School were so apologetic when they realised what was going on (it was an external coach hired to run sports lessons).

I have one child who is always picked first, always team captain, always wins sports day / shields bla bla bla. And one who doesn't. I felt like I could therefore call it as bullshit.

shellyleppard · 29/02/2024 08:06

I was picked last as a teenagr in the 1980's......now 55 and no mental health side effects. I think there are more important things to worry about. Go to bed and try and sleep love

HesterRoon · 29/02/2024 08:05

Ha ha I remember those days of being the dud with the ball who no one wanted!I take it you’re being sarcastic when you say kids are scarred for life-if that’s the worst thing that will happen to them, they’ll lead a pretty charmed life!

ZebraDanios · 29/02/2024 08:03

Dazedandfrazzled · 29/02/2024 07:58

This is actually a fascinating thread. I was almost always picked last, I didn't think it actually affected me. But reading this, I do remember dreading it and basically feeling a bit shit. It also does make me think I never was interested in sports later probably because I thought I wouldn't be good at it anyway. Overall just interesting to think about and wonder if it really is necessary and is it really the best way to do it. Does it teach anything positive? It definitely does teach something negative to those who are picked last

Exactly this. Lots of things that happen in school are problematic, but either we don’t have a better alternative (eg exams) or they’re controversial because they also have advantages (eg setting).

Some people are unaffected by picking teams. Some people are put off exercise for life. For some it makes their time at school just that little bit more miserable.

Does it actually benefit anyone?

MumblesParty · 29/02/2024 08:01

Thinking back to school sports, I hated all the outdoor stuff. It was always bloody cold, and I was hopeless at all of it. The team-picking (where I was always last) was really only a very small insignificant part of the whole unpleasant experience, and until this thread I literally hadn’t thought about it for 40 years. Whereas I can still remember the horrors of seeing a hockey ball flying towards me across the frozen mud, and hating every second of it! Genuinely not fussed about being picked last.

tinofbeans · 29/02/2024 08:01

PE teacher here. I don't know any school that gets kids to do the 70s style picking teams until there's only one left. Totally counter productive.

My preferred method is 'sit with 1 or 2 people you want to be on a team with' then join those little groups together to make the desired team sizes. Also gives you as a teacher ways of differentiating groups to meet your lesson objectives.

coureur · 29/02/2024 07:59

I’m a sports coach for junior athletes. I always pick the teams. I let captains make tactical decisions, such as relay order, but they don’t get to pick the teams. This is absolutely standard practice in all junior sports coaching, and also in adult elite sport. I’m not surprised though that school PE teachers are massively out of date.

Swipe left for the next trending thread