Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My therapist called my boyfriend 'pathological liar'. AIBU to consider breaking up over this?

130 replies

Benji92 · 28/02/2024 18:41

I met my boyfriend just over a year ago. Initially he lied to me about certain things and got caught. He told me it was because his family were so suspicious of everything he did and used to punish him so badly. He developed this defence mechanism of lying to protect himself. He said he was trying so hard to change this habit.

His lies were never so big or dodgy. He'd lie about things like 'I make XX amount of money' (turns out he makes 2k less annually) or 'I weigh XX stones' (when he clearly weighs more than that). Inconsequential but still annoying.

We're both in our 30s and I'm desperate to start a family and have kids. I always wanted it. But despite loving him so much I'm not sure if I can do this with a man like that.

Although I haven't caught a lie for months, my brain picks up random things and I hate it. For instance he'd disappear saying he's working out, I'd go to his house the next day to find his workout equipment dusty, clearly untouched for days. Or he'd meet me later than usual saying he had to clean his bathroom and when I go to his a couple of days later I'd find it unclean (not disgusting, but clearly not cleaned 2 days ago).

I started therapy last week. This week on our second session my therapist called him a 'pathological liar'. She said that he isn't someone that operates with integrity. It sort of freaked me out as it does sound very alarming.

AIBU to consider ending things over this if everything else is great?

OP posts:
Benji92 · 28/02/2024 19:36

It is exhausting and stressful to look out for the next lie. Just to clear a few things up:

-I didn't seek therapy because of my relationship. It was grief related and nothing to do with my boyfriend. I was really taken aback when she called him that blatantly.

-There was a big lie as well that I forgot to mention. Still inconsequential. He told me he lived in X city when we met. Turns out he doesn't. We didn't start off anything serious so I understand if he didn't want to disclose everything but my therapist says as soon as he figured he wants more from/with you, he should've come clean. Instead he told me he'd moved to his current city early on whilst we're still talking and acted like he just started living in his house a couple of months in when I was finally comfortable enough to go to his house.

Now after reading comments, I'm confused whether to ditch the boyfriend or the therapist!

OP posts:
iwafs · 28/02/2024 19:36

And worse, what if your offspring is the same - a tricky liar. Genetics plays a big part in who we are.

iwafs · 28/02/2024 19:35

This man would make an utterly rubbish father.

mjf981 · 28/02/2024 19:28

I work with a liar currently. It’s exhausting and I hate it.
Everyday a new big lie. Last week it was ‘I’ve had a UTI for over a year, it got so bad last year they had to remove one of my kidneys and they still haven’t cured the infection.’ It’s just not true (she was travelling through SE Asia at the time, or so she claimed..) and the lies are getting bigger.
Get out. It will drain you.

FirstTimeMum897 · 28/02/2024 19:24

I cannot stress this enough: deciding who to have children with is one of the biggest, if not the biggest, decision of your life. Once you have a child with someone, they will be in your life for the next 18 years, at the very least. It will affect everything, and I mean everything in your life. Men are not just sperm donors.

A good one will give you a wonderful life and family and together you can have the happiness you deserve. A bad one will suck the life out of you and make your life miserable.

You need to be able to trust your partner, implicitly. You can never ever trust someone who you know is a liar.

Aprilrosesews · 28/02/2024 19:22

Also just to add, so he’s saying ‘I was busy doing X & Y so I couldn’t see you’. But you know that was a lie……what was he actually doing then? I would guess if you found out what, that would end your relationship anyway

Aprilrosesews · 28/02/2024 19:20

Please for the love of god do not have a child with him. From the child of a pathological liar who has fucked me up mentally for life

BobbyBiscuits · 28/02/2024 19:14

The therapist is saying that but you already knew he was a liar. They should be focussing on you, not telling you what you already know about your BF.
If you can't handle the idea he uses white lies as a coping mechanism, (most couldn't, it's vey childish) I guess try and say gently, 'I know you didn't do x...why not just tell the truth you went to burger king, not the gym? I don't care either way but it makes you look untrustworthy.' If he can't mend his ways then leave him. Therapist doesn't sound so hot though.

AcrossthePond55 · 28/02/2024 19:07

Don't let your desire for a child blind you.

He may not be 'pathological' but he IS a liar. And liars rarely make good parents or good partners.

I'd end it.

StarlightLime · 28/02/2024 19:03

I'd leave anyone who was late meeting because they had to clean the bathroom - even if they weren't lying!

Lurkingandlearning · 28/02/2024 19:03

I was also surprised that your therapist said that, especially so quickly.

Bottom line, choosing a partner and father for your children, I think, should be based on shared values. If you value integrity and honesty he’s not the man for you.

He may have got into the habit of lying when he was a child and his parents doled out harsh discipline, but a lot of children go through phases of lying and grow out of it. If he’s continuing the habit as an adult, he’s unlikely to stop permanently because it comes easy to him and it seems he thinks it makes situations easier for him.

I n your shoes, I’d find someone who doesn’t need to do as much work on their character.

Elvis1956 · 28/02/2024 19:01

My sil is like this stupid pointless lies most of the time...like she bought the last real tree in the supermarket and won't be getting more in. On Dec 4th.

However some of her lies are dangerous or hurtful or plain vindictive. Mil likes Wetherspoons. Sil told her it's full of drug dealers. Mil in her 90s is now worried about going at 4 in the afternoon. Spoons isn't posh enough for sil. She doesn't want mil going as it might reflect on her!!

He lies for no good reason about the small things, things easy to be caught out on. Either he just lies and there are bigger lies or he wants to be caught as he doesn't feel he deserves a relationship (ie his family have undermined him that much). The fact remains that you are wasting so much time and energy that you will never be happy.

HomeTheatreSystem · 28/02/2024 18:54

How do you envisage a future life with him panning out when he might tell you the truth or he might lie? It might have serious consequences or it might not. You'll only ever find out after the fact. In short, he's a dyed in the wool liar. It means he is inherently unreliable and you will spend much of your life feeling like you're going crazy.

Vermin · 28/02/2024 18:52

Break up with the therapist. It’s highly unethical for them to diagnose someone they haven’t met. And of course going only on your word.

TreesWelliesKnees · 28/02/2024 18:52

AnnaMagnani · 28/02/2024 18:47

Leave and discuss with your therapist why you ignored so many red flags with him.

Therapist is fine, you discuss other people in therapy and yes, the therapist will make comments about them too.

Saying he is a pathological liar isn't so much making a diagnosis as making a factual comment based on the information given - he lies about shit all the time and you can never trust him.

The therapist shouldn't be making summative judgements about people and they also shouldn't lead the client. They are there to provide the space for the client to discover for themselves.

Neriah · 28/02/2024 18:51

vodkaredbullgirl · 28/02/2024 18:43

🤔leave

Possibly the boyfriend. Definitely the therapist. No therapist should be diagnosing someone they haven't met, not should they be telling a clientb what to do.

Oldandcobwebby · 28/02/2024 18:50

I get the impression that you only want validation to have a reason to leave him without feeling bad. Go for it. Liars are impossible to deal with. How can you ever trust someone about there big things when the can't evrn tell you the truth about cleaning the bog? Life's too short for this nonsense.

Rocknrolla21 · 28/02/2024 18:50

Eyesopenwideawake · 28/02/2024 18:43

I'd change your therapist instead. Anyone who diagnoses someone who isn't their client is not good news. Maybe find a better one and encourage him to consider therapy as well?

If what the op is saying is right, then the literal definition of what he’s doing is pathologically lying. No one needs to be with someone who they have to see a therapist with only a year in

HelloDarlingWhatAreYouDoingHere · 28/02/2024 18:49

I'm married to a liar - it never ends.

If it's part of his makeup then that's who he is. You'll never be able to trust him or believe anything he says.

SometimesIchangemyname · 28/02/2024 18:48

Well they’re not terrible lies. Just silly ones a teenager would resort to. I wouldn’t want to marry someone so immature though.

Rocknrolla21 · 28/02/2024 18:48

Do not have children with this man. Your actual therapist is warning you

AnnaMagnani · 28/02/2024 18:47

Leave and discuss with your therapist why you ignored so many red flags with him.

Therapist is fine, you discuss other people in therapy and yes, the therapist will make comments about them too.

Saying he is a pathological liar isn't so much making a diagnosis as making a factual comment based on the information given - he lies about shit all the time and you can never trust him.

TreesWelliesKnees · 28/02/2024 18:47

He seems like a massive risk to hang your future on. But your therapist shouldn't be calling anyone anything - it's completely unethical. Don't leave him because of what the therapist said. You need to come to your own conclusions. Find a better therapist in the first instance, and go from there.

Teaandcrumpets86 · 28/02/2024 18:47

It doesn’t sound like you can trust him, which means that you shouldn’t be in a relationship with him.
If he’s lying about little inconsequential things that are easily disproved then you’ll never know whether he’s lying about bigger things too.
It sounds like he had a tough upbringing but whatever his reasons for lying you shouldn’t be in a relationship with someone whose default is to be untruthful. You especially shouldn’t get married/share finances/have children with someone who you just don’t trust.
Cut your losses now and find someone that can be honest with you.

Onelifeonly · 28/02/2024 18:46

Listen to your gut but not the therapist who can't diagnosis and presumably hasn't met him.