Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Making kids choose 'teams' for PE - assumed this was an old fashioned thing?

240 replies

Devicey · 28/02/2024 16:45

But told today that it happens every week at DCs primary.

Honestly thought this was something I have just seen on films and assumed wasn't done anymore?

Always similar kids left to the last couple that no one wants on their team.

AIBU or are there far better ways to divide up a class of kids for PE?

OP posts:
Phoebefail · 29/02/2024 07:28

Again! Must look after our snowflakes, and another way of nagging a teacher in the same post.
Just tell them to get a grip and get on with whatever is in front of them. Life is unbalanced. Cope.

x2boys · 29/02/2024 07:01

wherearemywellingtons · 28/02/2024 21:56

I’m a teacher and we do this, with a different team leader each week to give all children a chance to pick. I firmly believe this is the correct decision.

Let me guess you were good at sports at school 🫢 yes all children may have a chance at picking but for every other week how do you imagine that child who.is always picked last feels?
Do think it's good for a child's self esteem to be humiliated week after week? I'm 50.and still remember how awful PE lessons were as I was. Always picked last or second to last
If you want to foster a love of sport maybe have a little think about that .?

cariadlet · 29/02/2024 06:05

I remember studying Kes for O level English back in the 80s. At one point the class are choosing teams for PE and nobody wants Billy.

Our English teacher said that if Billy had been popular then he would have been chosen even if he wasn't very good at sport.

That really made me feel like shit. I was always last or almost last to be chosen because everyone knew how rubbish I was at PE.

I've been teaching primary for 30+ years and have never had 2 children picking teams.

LostittoBostik · 29/02/2024 06:01

This brought back horrific memories. Ugh.

greenacrylicpaint · 29/02/2024 06:00

to only do it is not right.
dc school do a mix of teacher choses, other methods (ability, playing cards, dice) or children chosing.

Breakingpoint1961 · 29/02/2024 05:47

I remember when kids chose their teams (early 60s here) but I don't remember in what order I was picked. However, in primary I was bullied by two girls, and they made sure if the team I was on won (and they weren't in it) I would pay, so I prayed I'd be on their teamSad

Children/young adults will choose their mates and the 'best' at the sport, no doubt about that.

This is seriously outdated and will slaughter an 'unpopular' child's self esteem to be in their boots.

Bullying at a very high 'subtle' level.

LightSwerve · 29/02/2024 05:33

Naptrappedmummy · 28/02/2024 19:58

Seems we talk a lot about resilience but don’t want any of the kids to actually develop it.

This is not how you foster resilience.

You've misunderstood resilience I think.

LightSwerve · 29/02/2024 05:28

wherearemywellingtons · 28/02/2024 21:56

I’m a teacher and we do this, with a different team leader each week to give all children a chance to pick. I firmly believe this is the correct decision.

Shockingly bad practice! Kids picking teams went out with the ark, it is extremely poor.

To any parent dealing with crap like this: complain complain complain. I'd refuse to allow mine to do PE with this practice, it's not the 1980s anymore.

circlesand · 29/02/2024 05:11

wherearemywellingtons · 28/02/2024 21:56

I’m a teacher and we do this, with a different team leader each week to give all children a chance to pick. I firmly believe this is the correct decision.

Please can you explain why you firmly believe it is the correct decision, given the other comments on this thread about how horrible it can be for children?

circlesand · 29/02/2024 05:09

TheSnowyOwl · 28/02/2024 17:05

Agree that it can be a good way to look at who is chosen and whether there is low level bullying going on. It should be different people picking each week.

Maybe, but I don't think this makes up for the fact that it's emotionally damaging for lots of children - which we can see simply by looking through this thread and the adults who remember it.

There are many, many other ways to notice bullying and class dynamics which don't involve putting kids through this archaic routine.

ShareTheDuvet · 29/02/2024 02:43

wherearemywellingtons · 28/02/2024 21:56

I’m a teacher and we do this, with a different team leader each week to give all children a chance to pick. I firmly believe this is the correct decision.

I’ve been the child picked last (due to bullying for many years) and I was a teacher. You’re totally wrong. It’s not the correct decision - it’s a shit, horrible thing to do to your kids. Please stop.

JustDiscoveredBueno · 29/02/2024 01:09

Surprised they still do this. Why do that? When they pick the teams in the Apprentice at the end, it reminds me of the cringiness of school PE team picking. People felt pressured to choose friends, embarrassed to explain to friends after if they didn't choose friends, humiliated if weren't chosen until near the end, those regularly chosen at end were often pitied or became targets.

Don't tell me they still rip the towels off you to check that you've showered / noted down when your period was / make you do PE in your underwear?! PE...so many opportunities to help people engage with sport, put often used to put people off sport at school.

Kittybythelighthouse · 29/02/2024 00:46

wherearemywellingtons · 28/02/2024 21:56

I’m a teacher and we do this, with a different team leader each week to give all children a chance to pick. I firmly believe this is the correct decision.

Why? I’m an adult that experienced this as a child and it was hellish whether I was picking or not. The anxiety over upcoming PE classes overshadowed the rest of my school day, my other lessons, and I was a very bright child who otherwise excelled in school. I would be in tears the night before a PE day every single week. I was also physical - a very strong swimmer but we never went swimming. I wasn’t lazy or anything else. I wasn’t picked for team sports because I had moved from a different school in another town mid year. I didn’t have friends yet so I wasn’t picked. The public ritual humiliation made it even harder to make new friends. It’s a stupid and cruel method. There is no need.

Kittybythelighthouse · 29/02/2024 00:30

Why should we only encourage “resilience” to the kids who are shy or disabled or simply not good at sports? Are we also “teaching resilience” in this way by publicly humiliating those who are good at sports but terrible at say, art, music, English, every single week? Surely you’d want the sporty or popular kids to learn “resilience” also?

Kittybythelighthouse · 29/02/2024 00:25

ThursdayTomorrow · 28/02/2024 18:39

The PE teacher chooses the captains- different ones each time. The captains choose 2/3 each the. The PE teacher allocates the rest to balance the groups.
i can’t see the problem but of course people just like to bash teachers whatever they do.

Edited

Measured criticism of something that is very easy to change, has no tangible benefit, is impractical as it stands, not to mention very hurtful and damaging to many kids, is not “bashing teachers” ffs. If only the poor teachers you’re imagining had skin as thick as the literal children who are being publicly humiliated every week.

QueenBodicea · 29/02/2024 00:24

The Tich Miller poem says it all. How impactful.

My son had SEN but was quite good at football so fortunately didn't have to suffer this ritual humiliation in games. He did however have some bad experiences in the classroom though with academic work. Sometimes teachers would ask pupils to get into groups for tasks and none of the groups wanted him. Broke my heart when he told me. How is that inclusive?
The parents on this thread saying it makes you resilient to be picked last clearly don't have children with SEN.

Kittybythelighthouse · 29/02/2024 00:17

midgetastic · 28/02/2024 17:27

Yes it's upsetting ( I was always 4th from last)

But it was also fair in that better children got chosen first and teaches you that skill and capabilities matter in the real world - so it's not a shock when you get turned down for promotion

Not really. No one is making kids pick teams every week in maths or art class. Many of the children who don’t ever get picked will be extremely good at something else which is not used to teach a similar lesson. It just ruins the self confidence of kids who aren’t sporty, but are excellent musicians, artists, scientists etc while constantly elevating some who are only good at sports or popular. Deeply unfair and totally unnecessary.

BogRollBOGOF · 28/02/2024 23:28

Ahh the joys of PE lessons; it does stand for Practical Exclusion doesn't it?

There was certainly no exercise involved other than getting changed into unsuitable clothing (gym knickers and skirts in all weathers) and traipsing over to a court/ field. Standing there waiting for the inevitable shoulder slump when the teacher's pet calculated how many people were left and that she'd be left with Bogroll on her team, then being allocated to be substitute if there were enough players to get away with it or allocated the least desirable position like Wing Defense if playing couldn't be avoided. All the not-so-subtle digs and bitchy comments. "Team" sports were a bully's haven.

Being shit in your first PE lesson in y7 guarenteed that every other PE lesson was a waste of time and you'd still be shit in your final ever lesson because there was no scope to practice and improve. There was also a lack of decent equipment such as fully inflated balls. My elbows weren't sharp enough to get the experience that it does actually help to have a ball that can bounce.

It was ritualised exclusion endorsed by the teachers who were often little better themselves.

Fortunately I did do something active out of school and that was the gateway to being a fit and active adult. Badly managed PE lessons often results in decades or even a lifetime of rejecting sport and activity. I can't think of any positive thing that I learned in year after year of enduring those "lessons".

My mobile phone taught me how to run both by feeling inspired by friends on social media taking up running, and by C25k which was the polar opposite of a PE teacher, gently encouraging and encouraging being slow rather than ridiculing.

There are many ways of organising teams without resorting to ritualised exclusion tactics.

saltrock123 · 28/02/2024 22:44

Detested games and P.E in the seventies, always picked last for netball which seemed to be the only sport played. Always the favorites were chosen to pick teams. Took great delight in last years of school to skive off and go awol for the afternoon and not be missed.

brunettemic · 28/02/2024 22:39

Meh, I don’t see the big deal. Classes still openly discuss how kids did in spelling tests or maths tests (my youngest does “morning maths” everyday) all the time. It’s no different.

SlumberDearMaid · 28/02/2024 22:28

Thanks to the pp who mentioned the Tich Miller poem. I’d never read this before.

@wherearemywellingtons and @Wisterical - thoughts?

https://www.aoifesnotes.com/junior-cycle/Paper-Two/docs/studied-poetry/Tich%20Miller%20by%20Wendy%20Cope.pdf

SlumberDearMaid · 28/02/2024 22:26

Wisterical · 28/02/2024 22:01

@wherearemywellingtons I agree with you. If everyone gets their turn to pick teams what's the problem? It's good to be able to choose teammates who you know you play well with.

Because the same kids will always be selected last?

It’s only the kids selected first who will change?

SlumberDearMaid · 28/02/2024 22:24

I’m 50, and I remember this. I was never bullied, but hated sport. I just remember silently praying that I wouldn’t be absolutely last. 2nd, 3rd to last - fine. Just not last.

Surely, it’s faster, simpler and kinder for the teacher to count off - 1, 2, 1, 2 ….?

Unless you’re a sadistic psychopath, how is getting two kids to pick teams the easier method from a teacher’s point of view….? Confused

I’m reminder of Ross, ‘sweetie, now I pick you…’

Making kids choose 'teams' for PE - assumed this was an old fashioned thing?
XelaM · 28/02/2024 22:15

I was always the last or second-to-last to be picked so absolutely hated this, but my daughter says she likes this system of choosing teams 🤷‍♀️but she's super sporty and wants to take PE GCSEs, so I guess it's a good system only for sporty kids and makes everyone else feel rubbish.

DGPP · 28/02/2024 22:06

I would complain heavily to any school that did this. I can’t believe there are teachers on here justifying it! The only fair way is for teachers (who hopefully aren’t bullies) to pick the teams and mix them up each week.
thankfully none of of my children’s schools do this