Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Making kids choose 'teams' for PE - assumed this was an old fashioned thing?

240 replies

Devicey · 28/02/2024 16:45

But told today that it happens every week at DCs primary.

Honestly thought this was something I have just seen on films and assumed wasn't done anymore?

Always similar kids left to the last couple that no one wants on their team.

AIBU or are there far better ways to divide up a class of kids for PE?

OP posts:
Twilight7777 · 29/02/2024 19:59

I’m amazed they still do this knowing how much impact it can have on children's mental health! Was always picked last and it sucked.

Treaclewell · 29/02/2024 19:54

Phoebefail · 29/02/2024 19:36

If they are training for a game like basketball or soccer they should not be playing a game. They should be practicing exercises in ball handling or other techniques.

In primary schools not training. The team practices take place outside class lessons,which are for all the children's physical fitness. That we have adulrs over 79 on here still resenting what was done to them un PE shows how it has failed.

SlumberDearMaid · 29/02/2024 19:51

iwiporangi · 29/02/2024 09:38

@SoupDragon I want the published peer-reviewed studies of the psychological effect on children.

I want published, peer-reviewed studies that this approach to selecting teams in PE is underpinned by evidence and effective pedagogy - i.e. that it engages learners and improves learning outcomes in PE.

SlumberDearMaid · 29/02/2024 19:45

Phoebefail · 29/02/2024 15:36

Team games with players picked at random regardless of skill are pointless. Give the captain the responsibility of picking the best.
Surely Team games are a small part of PE so it matters little.

PE isn’t about winning? It’s about learning about health and physical education.

And all students in the class are expected to learn tbis….?

Treaclewell · 29/02/2024 19:44

It depends on the purpose of the game. Not all are games like football or netball. Some are for developing a particular skill, say throwing and catching, involving all children repeatedly, and there is no point in having tthe elite in one team and the others failing all the time. Funny how you can tell the winners here.
I developed a strategy at secondary. Get myself in the team with good forwards at hockey (field). Take the left back. place. Then make sure that the teacher always saw me between the ball and the goal. Nevwe had to develop any ball skills!

PaperSheet · 29/02/2024 19:38

I was always picked last. I was bullied at school generally. Not sporty at all. Being better at academic subjects didn't stop that feeling of humiliation once a week when teams were needed. Especially the day when I was the last one and should have gone to team A. The team captain said to team B "well we don't want her on our team you take her" to which B responded "no way we don't want her either! She's yours!"
All this said in front of the teacher who did nothing other than say to team A "well to make up numbers she needs to be on your team so it's tough luck".
I ended up getting signed off PE permanently not long after that. (My mum was very understanding as was my doctor who gave me the note).
I honestly hoped schools had stopped this awful way of choosing teams. Whether it's for PE or groups in lessons. It humiliates the non popular/friendless children.

Phoebefail · 29/02/2024 19:36

If they are training for a game like basketball or soccer they should not be playing a game. They should be practicing exercises in ball handling or other techniques.

Treaclewell · 29/02/2024 19:25

Of any group of teachers faced with a games class, most will not have been picked last in their own school days, so will not have thought about it, and I don't recall it being taught in college. No college now, and PE advisors are from the pickers group, so not aware.
I did not use picking, having been the tail end myself. Began with running about to watm up. Blew the whistle, told them to make groups of two, repeat for three, and four. (Depending on numbers that day). Pick one group to line up as the leaders. Make the others ;ine up behind them. Result - friendship groups split across the teams.. Occasionally one team would be worse than all they others. Swap them round to make it fairer. There was quite a bir of cooperation. I tended not to choose the alphas as the leaders.
But I couldn't influence other staff. I xouldn;t even convince them not to line up boys and girls at the end of break and compete on behaviour. (Used desk numbers.) Things have always been done as they have always been done......

LanaL · 29/02/2024 19:20

Devicey · 28/02/2024 16:45

But told today that it happens every week at DCs primary.

Honestly thought this was something I have just seen on films and assumed wasn't done anymore?

Always similar kids left to the last couple that no one wants on their team.

AIBU or are there far better ways to divide up a class of kids for PE?

I’m a teacher . I never , ever do this . I hate it . I was always the last to be picked in PE and it was a horrible feeling . When I was training , I was in a school where the teacher did this and I saw a whole team make a big show of being so disappointed when they had to have the last child left on their team and it was bloody heartbreaking !

I will decide how many teams we need and if , for eg , it’s 4 then children get numbered 1/2/3/4 and I do it in the order they’re stood in . I would never put a child through that and I think it’s disgusting that it’s still done

LightSwerve · 29/02/2024 18:40

Phoebefail · 29/02/2024 15:36

Team games with players picked at random regardless of skill are pointless. Give the captain the responsibility of picking the best.
Surely Team games are a small part of PE so it matters little.

What happens in PE lessons and what happens in sports clubs should not be the same.

PE lessons should be about healthy exercise and teamwork, not winning and competition.

Team games with players picked at random are the correct way to go in PE lessons. Learning to treat people with respect is more important than winning.

JustDiscoveredBueno · 29/02/2024 18:21

Not done at kid's school thankfully

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 29/02/2024 17:07

Phoebefail · 29/02/2024 15:36

Team games with players picked at random regardless of skill are pointless. Give the captain the responsibility of picking the best.
Surely Team games are a small part of PE so it matters little.

I’m all for celebrating the best and developing leadership skills. So maybe do this in situations where you can pick 2 top teams and then the rest of the class be split at random. Just don’t put any child in a position where they are having to choose, or repeatedly being chosen, between the second worst and the worst.

ManchesterLu · 29/02/2024 16:49

If you're going to do this, you should make sure the captains always change. But to be honest, I think it should be done at random - maybe using coloured balls and pulling one out each. I was always the one left until last, and it sucked. It didn't build my character in the slightest.

changergranger · 29/02/2024 16:38

I think it seems old fashioned too. I never did it as a teacher. But I don't think it's about bullying and I don't think that switching who picks teams will help.

I was bullied at school but aside from that I was absolutely terrible at all sports. I could barely throw or catch and would run in the opposite direction of the ball. I had absolutely no coordination. I was always picked last because most people at least somewhat want to win the game they're playing which made picking me an absolutely terrible idea. The only time I would be picked would be if my 1-2 friends were picking and even then they definitely only picked me because they had to. All of the other 24 students would definitely not pick me because why would they pick someone terrible?

I know it's nothing to do with me being bullied because one day we tried one of the "boys" sports that we never did and I showed a tiny flicker of talent at it (although short-lived) and then when it came to picking teams I was picked.

While I get while I wasn't picked and think it was completely separate to bullying, it was really humiliating. It would have been much kinder for the teachers just to do some kind of random picking.

iwiporangi · 29/02/2024 16:32

@takemeawayagain I have a life

TabbyM · 29/02/2024 16:09

Solidarity with all the 80s kids who hated PE for this reason (and showers and sadistic teachers) who found out later in life that not all exercise is bad!

Dixiechickonhols · 29/02/2024 15:46

I can’t believe they do that in 2024. I vividly remember it and hated it. Only reason I wasn’t last was I was useless but tall. Zoe and Jayne were always last at primary and secondary (useless and short)

takemeawayagain · 29/02/2024 15:42

iwiporangi · 29/02/2024 09:38

@SoupDragon I want the published peer-reviewed studies of the psychological effect on children.

You sound like a dick, I really hope you're not a teacher.

I see the peer reviewed studies have shut you up though.

Ahugga · 29/02/2024 15:40

Phoebefail · 29/02/2024 15:36

Team games with players picked at random regardless of skill are pointless. Give the captain the responsibility of picking the best.
Surely Team games are a small part of PE so it matters little.

Team games was all we ever did in PE.
What has being the "best" (in the opinion of another child) got to do with learning about sports and physical activity? The point of a PE lesson is not to win.

Phoebefail · 29/02/2024 15:36

Team games with players picked at random regardless of skill are pointless. Give the captain the responsibility of picking the best.
Surely Team games are a small part of PE so it matters little.

Borborygmus · 29/02/2024 14:02

This was how teams were always picked when I was at school a very long time ago. I was always one of the last picked, and I can't say it bothered me in the slightest. Until reading this thread I would have assumed it was still done this way.

JustDiscoveredBueno · 29/02/2024 11:41

So many things done past and present in the names of kids' resilience, despite many saying it had the opposite effect. I often think of TV shows where you'll have an old fashioned dad knocking seven bells out of his kids physically or mentally to toughen them up - not sure that helps more than self-belief. The kid who is poor at sport doesn't need a fake medal, but also doesn't need regular humiliation - at least not if resilience/appreciation of sport is the goal.

If I wanted to foster a love of reading, I wouldn't apply team picking for groups in the way it's done for sport. If I wanted to help a kid get to grips with a subject, I wouldn't stick them in a corner with a dunce hat on when they got a question wrong. If I wanted to improve mental health, I wouldn't encourage spreading illnesses that affect the brain.

PE is one (maybe only one) of subjects where kids that are great at a sport done at school can genuinely challenge themselves in school (and those that struggle are kind of ignored). If you're naturally good at other subjects, there is more of a 'waiting', sometimes for years, whilst schools concentrate on ensuring others reach curriculum target level.

Brexile · 29/02/2024 10:28

Naptrappedmummy · 28/02/2024 21:29

Then what would/did? If not fairly minor disappointments?

Weekly public humiliation isn't a "minor disappointment". A minor disappointment that helped me build resilience was twice getting only 99% in the annual spelling test (still the best in ths school by a long way). Now imagine that this spelling test, instead of being once a year, non-competitive, and basically never mentioned again, had been a weekly team event along American spelling bee lines. Imagine that I and the runner up, as the best spellers, got to pick teams. The dyslexic kids would always be chosen last and would be jeered at, with the teacher's encouragement. Imagine how "resilient" those last-picked kids would then feel! There's nothing intrinsically competitive about physical exercise, and there's nothing intrinsically uncompetitive about academic subjects. (A pp mentioned maths; thank God we didn't pick teams for that, as it would have gone about as well for me as PE did. But you get the picture.) Schools would do well to stop using PE as a humiliation tactic / popularity contest.

Leypt1 · 29/02/2024 10:08

Got me on my soapbox now, but here goes:

Based on my experience of PE (late 90s up to late 2000s) - and, it seems, the experiences of many others - the whole system is crap and needs reforming.

Splitting kids into those that are inherently "good" at sport and inherently "bad" from a very young age doesn't improve resilience - it just creates a lasting impression that you are crap at sports and shouldn't bother trying. The many small ways in which this is manifested and enforced, including picking teams, reinforces this by associating sports with deep-seated feelings of humiliation, which are shown to be the type of feelings that stick with people the longest.

This can and does have long-lasting impacts on people's willingness to try new things and work at improvement, i.e. the very opposite of resilience.

There are behavioural studies that demonstrate this phenomenon at work in a range of other contexts. What these studies show is that the most important thing for encouraging ongoing effort is rewarding the behaviour of trying hard and working to get better, not rewarding the characteristic of being "good", which only encourages resting on your laurels.

Brexile · 29/02/2024 10:07

@Lorac23 I'd read that! Bonus points if some of the sporty bullies were morbidly obese by their early twenties, while their victim was fit and looked great.