Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Making kids choose 'teams' for PE - assumed this was an old fashioned thing?

240 replies

Devicey · 28/02/2024 16:45

But told today that it happens every week at DCs primary.

Honestly thought this was something I have just seen on films and assumed wasn't done anymore?

Always similar kids left to the last couple that no one wants on their team.

AIBU or are there far better ways to divide up a class of kids for PE?

OP posts:
SlumberDearMaid · 01/03/2024 10:03

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

NappiesAndBunFluff · 01/03/2024 10:00

I remember a girl throwing an absolute fit in secondary school because she didn't want me on her team.
Or school got turned into a specialist sports college after I started there. All the pe lessons were basically just for finding out who the talent were and coercing them to join the school sports teams to make the school look better.
It just made me hate exercise.
Found out later I had severe anaemia and that's why I was out of breath so quickly. Teachers didn't notice/ care, there was never much actual "education" in PE.

JustDiscoveredBueno · 01/03/2024 09:49

'Morning kids! It's Thursday, so time for our weekly maths quiz. Olivia and Zack are this week's captains. The rest of you stand up and go join your team when picked.'

I'm sure that will give the kids that are picked last every week a love of learning for maths, will motivate them to work harder rather than cement their view that they can't do maths. It can steady them for the real world (if they work in a fucked up organisation). Having their peers bear witness to their regular humiliation will do wonders. In the real world, you can find a job in a less toxic place - kids have no agency to do that with schools.

coureur · 01/03/2024 09:37

To be honest, I'm stunned by the number of parents and even teachers who are supporting this outmoded method of team selection. I wonder what sport (if any) their coaching qualifications are in? Because anyone who has coached at any level in the past 15 years would know that this is not acceptable in inclusive/all-ability youth sport. It's been proven to be counter-productive (see studies posted by PPs) and serves only to drive less immediately able participants out of sport and physical activity. I'm a national level 2 coach in my sport, focusing on youth athletes and if I saw anyone using this method I would be correcting them immediately.

BananaforScale · 01/03/2024 09:20

I was the fat kid, always picked 2nd to last (90s) and (this combined with repeated humiliation by bastard PE teachers) then didn't do any exercise for 20 years. By chance found a really inclusive, body positive sport and never looked back.

But secondary PE didn't make me resilient, it made me scared to exercise and contributed to disordered eating.

x2boys · 01/03/2024 09:20

HelenTherese2 · 01/03/2024 09:07

Good grounding for the real world where you will get chosen to do things based on your ability.

No wonder kids can’t cope with real life any more.

PE is part of the national curriculum children have no choice but to participate regardless of their ability
In real life if you have a natural aptitude for a particular sport you could CHOOSE to try out for a team the key word is CHOOSE.

JustDiscoveredBueno · 01/03/2024 09:16

HelenTherese2 · 01/03/2024 09:07

Good grounding for the real world where you will get chosen to do things based on your ability.

No wonder kids can’t cope with real life any more.

The equivalent of that would be auditioning for a school play or trying out for a sports team. How many situations in your real world are there where a couple of peers argue about who they don't want in front of all their colleagues? Why can't some people cope with acknowledging it's a shitty thing to do - wonder how they cope in the real world when people pull them up on their twisted ways.

SoupDragon · 01/03/2024 09:10

HelenTherese2 · 01/03/2024 09:07

Good grounding for the real world where you will get chosen to do things based on your ability.

No wonder kids can’t cope with real life any more.

Don't be ridiculous.

This is choosing teams in a PE lesson, not choosing teams for competitions. PE lessons should be enjoyable.

HelenTherese2 · 01/03/2024 09:07

Good grounding for the real world where you will get chosen to do things based on your ability.

No wonder kids can’t cope with real life any more.

PaperSheet · 01/03/2024 08:43

Imisssleep2 · 01/03/2024 08:29

If for a pe lesson then a 1 2 1 2 system would be nicer and fairer, if got a school team playing against other schools then you have to pick the ones that excel at the particular sports.
It's not just popular people that are picked to be team leaders, it just so happens that sporty people tend to be popular.

I used to be good at hockey, but average at netball, I nearly always played for the school hockey team, but rarely a first pick for netball, more a b team or sub, yes I was disappointed, but it gave me drive to try harder

I think the main problem is with the compulsory PE lessons. Obviously actual teams you choose the best people. But normally at least the people trying out to be on a team want to at least try and play even if they aren't very good. Plus actual teams that play competitively aren't chosen by the other players. The coach will choose who gets in.
I am not sporty. I am aware I am not sporty. I generally do not enjoy sports. So I would never put myself forward to be on an actual team nor would I expect to be chosen. This isn't what PE lessons are though.
You have no choice but to be on a team. You and everyone else knows you're shit at the sport so they don't want you on their team and make it well known to your face. If I'd have been given the choice at school to be humiliated every week in PE or go and do another maths lesson I'd have skipped off to maths. But I wasn't given that choice. I was forced to stand there while being laughed at and told I wasn't wanted in any team.

x2boys · 01/03/2024 08:39

Imisssleep2 · 01/03/2024 08:29

If for a pe lesson then a 1 2 1 2 system would be nicer and fairer, if got a school team playing against other schools then you have to pick the ones that excel at the particular sports.
It's not just popular people that are picked to be team leaders, it just so happens that sporty people tend to be popular.

I used to be good at hockey, but average at netball, I nearly always played for the school hockey team, but rarely a first pick for netball, more a b team or sub, yes I was disappointed, but it gave me drive to try harder

We are talking about PE lessons not school teams playing against each other
If you join team it would be voluntarily and obviously the best players are going to be picked that happens irl,too I imagine the Manager of England selects the players they think are the best and play well together
I don't suppose they get the players to publicly humiliate their team members before every game though.

Imisssleep2 · 01/03/2024 08:29

If for a pe lesson then a 1 2 1 2 system would be nicer and fairer, if got a school team playing against other schools then you have to pick the ones that excel at the particular sports.
It's not just popular people that are picked to be team leaders, it just so happens that sporty people tend to be popular.

I used to be good at hockey, but average at netball, I nearly always played for the school hockey team, but rarely a first pick for netball, more a b team or sub, yes I was disappointed, but it gave me drive to try harder

whiteroseredrose · 01/03/2024 07:02

In the primary schools I worked in I don't remember the children picking who they would sit with for numeracy, literacy etc. The teachers decided this based on ability and support needed. Why wouldn't the same apply to PE?

Ggttl · 01/03/2024 06:55

They shouldn’t and most of them will have been told not to when training to be teachers. A lot of sports teachers go for a system that appears totally random put also makes sure the teams are fairly balanced.

SlumberDearMaid · 01/03/2024 06:22

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Geordiebabe85 · 01/03/2024 05:46

I'm a teacher and I've never done this. I just I've all the kids a random number and if they move to try and get the same number as their mate I deliberately give a different number.

WiddlinDiddlin · 01/03/2024 04:24

Being chosen to do the picking to 'even things up' didn't help anyway.

Instead of the groaning at the end when each captain had to pick one of the two remaining fat/slow/clumsy/useless losers... we had the groaning and huffing at the start when us fat/slow/clumsy/useless losers were selected to do the picking!

Then the snarky bitchy comments as we picked, dragging feet, rolling eyes, laughing at others etc 'haha Fatty chose you' 'nee ner, Clumsy picked you'.. etc.

It is a lose-lose situation for those who are not good at sports, not popular or both. And by no means are those kids guaranteed to be the ones who excel at academic stuff, as if that were in any way equal in the minds of kids anyway!

These threads come around every so often and every single time, those who didn't care or indeed, were the sporty popular kids, say 'oh well it builds resilience' and 'it didn't scar anyone for life'... And yet every. single. time, the threads are full of people into their 60's, 70s and beyond, stating it absolutely fucking did.

scotsmum2015 · 01/03/2024 04:14

It’s unusual it’s still getting used . Thought it would have died out with the new mentality of everyone is winners and less competitive attitudes in schools.
definitely a cruel practice. Get on to school. Tell them its modelling a pecking order that is probably the same every week and after the first sporty 8 is probably ALL about popularity. It’s promoting bullying and exclusion. Which will fly against the motto they will have on their walls.

Kittybythelighthouse · 01/03/2024 00:53

Naptrappedmummy · 28/02/2024 21:29

Then what would/did? If not fairly minor disappointments?

Being publicly humiliated every week is not a “minor disappointment”. It’s not “disappointment” that’s the issue. It’s the sneering, the exclusion, the mocking, the bullying, that goes alongside this stupid practice. I bet there’s something you were shit at at school. Would you think it okay for teachers to have made you a laughing stock over it every single week? Would it be okay to do this to any child? It wouldn’t be tolerated in an adult workplace, why should it be okay in a school? There’s a reason this practice is not allowed in Scandinavian schools, for example. The research shows that it leads to poor outcomes for the targeted child and absolutely does not foster “resilience” at all.

Kittybythelighthouse · 01/03/2024 00:47

Phoebefail · 29/02/2024 07:28

Again! Must look after our snowflakes, and another way of nagging a teacher in the same post.
Just tell them to get a grip and get on with whatever is in front of them. Life is unbalanced. Cope.

“Snowflakes” 🥴 get a grip ffs. We are talking about children. Allowing children to learn without undermining their dignity and self esteem is the very fucking least we, as adults, can do. The teacher doesn’t need your help. She’s an adult.

Kittybythelighthouse · 01/03/2024 00:40

iwiporangi · 29/02/2024 09:38

@SoupDragon I want the published peer-reviewed studies of the psychological effect on children.

Now you’ve been given several published peer reviewed sources you’ve gone awfully quiet. Where are your published peer reviewed sources proving that humiliating children is in any way good, decent, effective?

SlumberDearMaid · 01/03/2024 00:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Kittybythelighthouse · 01/03/2024 00:31

iwiporangi · 29/02/2024 09:38

@SoupDragon I want the published peer-reviewed studies of the psychological effect on children.

The researchers and experts that ScienceNorway has talked to all agree that pupils should not be the ones picking teams for games in gym class. At stake is reduced self-esteem, unhappiness, poor social relationships and destructive class dynamics. In the worst case, more kids can end up skipping class.
Studies show that a performance-based learning environment increases the risk of poor mental health in school.”

https://www.sciencenorway.no/children-and-youth-health-psychology/should-children-be-allowed-to-choose-teams-in-gym-class/1578143

74Violette · 01/03/2024 00:13

I think this stuff scarred me for life. The PE teachers I had were absolute bullies and even back in the 80s when I was at school I couldn't understand why that cruel system was used to pick teams.
I was always one of the last to be picked, I had health problems and was pretty rubbish at sports. I can still hear the derision from the mean girl sporty kids when they had me land in their team from the last few rejects.
Yeah, just encourages bullying and confidence bashing. Any teacher that endorses this approach has either an evil streak or is super lazy.

SlumberDearMaid · 29/02/2024 20:02

ManchesterLu · 29/02/2024 16:49

If you're going to do this, you should make sure the captains always change. But to be honest, I think it should be done at random - maybe using coloured balls and pulling one out each. I was always the one left until last, and it sucked. It didn't build my character in the slightest.

Changing the captain only alters who’s picked first. It doesn’t alter who’s always picked last.

Agree with the last part of your post.

Swipe left for the next trending thread