Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Making kids choose 'teams' for PE - assumed this was an old fashioned thing?

240 replies

Devicey · 28/02/2024 16:45

But told today that it happens every week at DCs primary.

Honestly thought this was something I have just seen on films and assumed wasn't done anymore?

Always similar kids left to the last couple that no one wants on their team.

AIBU or are there far better ways to divide up a class of kids for PE?

OP posts:
emziecy · 01/03/2024 17:07

emziecy · 01/03/2024 17:00

I have done this on occasion to check the dynamics of the class but normally choose them myself to encourage inclusion.

To clarify, this isn't specifically for PE as I don't teach it, but for any other activity involving teams or groups.

emziecy · 01/03/2024 17:00

Devicey · 28/02/2024 16:45

But told today that it happens every week at DCs primary.

Honestly thought this was something I have just seen on films and assumed wasn't done anymore?

Always similar kids left to the last couple that no one wants on their team.

AIBU or are there far better ways to divide up a class of kids for PE?

I have done this on occasion to check the dynamics of the class but normally choose them myself to encourage inclusion.

Kittybythelighthouse · 01/03/2024 15:26

Helenb70 · 01/03/2024 15:12

The lesson for me (reasonably popular but crap at all sports) was, eventually, that PE is a totally unimportant undertaking that had zero impact on the rest of my life.

So, I chose to bunk off PE once I hit 15 or so and worked very hard at my O and A levels. I often ran into the sporty popular kids working in shops when I came home for the university holidays. Turns out some abilities are rather more important than others!

Quite. I left school very well equipped to succeed “in the real world” with all A’s at A level and prizes for drama and languages. Funny enough I’ve never had to put ritual humiliation experience on my CV or raise it at an interview. In fact, dare I say it, it didn’t help me “in the real world” at all. I don’t believe it helped the kids who were doing the bullying either, just for the record. Looks like we could have skipped it with no ill effects whatsoever but a net positive effect on the self esteem and comfort of thousands of children. Fancy that!

Helenb70 · 01/03/2024 15:12

HelenTherese2 · 01/03/2024 09:07

Good grounding for the real world where you will get chosen to do things based on your ability.

No wonder kids can’t cope with real life any more.

The lesson for me (reasonably popular but crap at all sports) was, eventually, that PE is a totally unimportant undertaking that had zero impact on the rest of my life.

So, I chose to bunk off PE once I hit 15 or so and worked very hard at my O and A levels. I often ran into the sporty popular kids working in shops when I came home for the university holidays. Turns out some abilities are rather more important than others!

Kittybythelighthouse · 01/03/2024 15:09

Treaclewell · 01/03/2024 13:11

Arguments based on the real world, teaching resilience etc are atrocious. I saw one in the Guardian once which said bullying was OK because it established the pecking order for adult life, and I've seen something like that above. Of course, we aren't chickens. Do you know what happens to the hen at the bottom of the pecking order? She has no feathers, been pecked out, can't eat enough, driven from the food, is no good to the farmer. It is not a thing to emulate, and those putting it forward as something to encourage aren't expecting to have to learn their place, and resilience themselves, They expect to be the rooster on the dunghill. Resilience is for others. Snowflakes as Phoebe called them.
Not chickens or snowflakes, but humans to be respected.

Edited

The reality is that in the real world the kids who are doing the picking and mocking at school are no more likely to be more resilient or successful in life. In my anecdotal experience it’s been the exact opposite! The quieter, ‘uncool’ kids from my school are by and large way more successful than the sporty/popular kids now. One of the worst bullies in my school (good at sport, loved the “pecking order”) has been in and out of prison ever since. The idea that any brand of school mandated exclusion, mocking, bullying, humiliation, are necessary or beneficial to any child, wherever they fall on the “pecking order” is obvious nonsense.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 01/03/2024 14:57

Chaotica · 28/02/2024 17:12

DS's school does this (secondary). The same people always get to choose and the same people are left out. It's a terrible system. Teams for any sport are just chosen by who can play football well and/or who is popular (which is, I'm told, often the same thing).

That’s terrible!

I honestly didn’t think this was still practiced nowadays! We didn’t even do that back in “my day”. (Except for primary school, actually. Now that I’m thinking about it!🤔🤔)

Kittybythelighthouse · 01/03/2024 14:55

Youcannotbeseriousreally · 01/03/2024 12:01

I’m tempted to agree. They don’t do this at our secondary school but I fail to find the energy to be bothered about it. Like, life is going to happen and you’re not always going to be picked first so I don’t understand why we’d go to great length to ‘protect’ kids from situations they will encounter - better to build their resilience I think.

SIGH. Again, why are we only “building resilience” in kids who are not good at sports? How are we “building resilience” in kids who are good at sports but shit at maths/art/english? Why do those kids not get to benefit from your completely unsupported nonsense idea that ritual humiliation “builds resilience”?

Kittybythelighthouse · 01/03/2024 14:48

HelenTherese2 · 01/03/2024 09:07

Good grounding for the real world where you will get chosen to do things based on your ability.

No wonder kids can’t cope with real life any more.

Would you tolerate, as an adult, being forced into an activity that you don’t enjoy just to be laughed at, excluded, and mocked every single week? I don’t expect you would. It’s in no way okay to do this to children who deserve to feel safe at school. They can compete and be picked or not be picked at activities they have an interest in. Anyway, you’re overlooking all the children who happen to be good at sports but perhaps not good at things one actually needs in a world of work. How shall we give those children the “good grounding” in ritual humiliation that you think they need based on no research or wisdom whatsoever?

Dontcallmescarface · 01/03/2024 14:24

I was always last to be picked. It got to the stage where I would mentally work out which team had the misfortune of being the one to have to pick me and just go and stand there as soon as the first name was called. I did get told by the teacher once not to do that but I replied with "what's the point? I'm only going to end up here anyway so I might as well pretend I was picked 1st". From then on the teacher would pick the teams.

PaperSheet · 01/03/2024 14:18

Youcannotbeseriousreally · 01/03/2024 12:01

I’m tempted to agree. They don’t do this at our secondary school but I fail to find the energy to be bothered about it. Like, life is going to happen and you’re not always going to be picked first so I don’t understand why we’d go to great length to ‘protect’ kids from situations they will encounter - better to build their resilience I think.

I didn't care about being picked first. I just wanted to not be actively and vocally UNWANTED every single week. No where in adult life should anyone be saying to another adult "we don't want her you take her".
Remember this isn't about choosing teams for professional games etc.
Say in adult life you go for a job interview and don't get it. You (should) get a letter or phone call explaining you were unsuccessful. It's normally very polite. That's fine. Things happen. You brush yourself and move on. What you don't get is the recruiter actively laughing in your face saying no way are we going to employ you! Then another random job department agreeing they don't want you either! While they both laugh back and forth with each other about how awful you are.
Same with trying out for a sports team as a child. You try out. You don't get picked. Usually the coach (or maybe your parent if they've been told first) will tell you kindly you didn't make it this time and maybe if you practice next time you will. You might be upset for a while but yes normally some failures explained kindly are to be expected in life.
Weekly humiliation and being laughed at is not something I think I benefitted from.

Julimia · 01/03/2024 13:54

Doesn't make much difference how they are divided up the socio mix still prevails. If you asked the so called left overs to to do the actual choosing that wouldnt been seen as 'right' either would it??!

Chaotica · 01/03/2024 13:52

@JustDiscoveredBueno From what I can tell from my DC, the changes are very patchy. Some teachers try to pass on skills and to explain, most seem to just leave the kids to it.

FWIW even the kids who were good at sport got no guidance or strategy (or were even told to join a specialist club etc). Whether we won or not seemed to be left up to fate or 'natural ability'. (Maybe some kids had interested parents and that helped them along, but I don't think that was the norm when I was younger.)

Baba197 · 01/03/2024 13:50

I hated pe at school for that reason, it’s cruel and really knocks confidence. My son is currently yr 1 and the teacher allocated them to a team, don’t know if this changes further up the school

Treaclewell · 01/03/2024 13:11

Arguments based on the real world, teaching resilience etc are atrocious. I saw one in the Guardian once which said bullying was OK because it established the pecking order for adult life, and I've seen something like that above. Of course, we aren't chickens. Do you know what happens to the hen at the bottom of the pecking order? She has no feathers, been pecked out, can't eat enough, driven from the food, is no good to the farmer. It is not a thing to emulate, and those putting it forward as something to encourage aren't expecting to have to learn their place, and resilience themselves, They expect to be the rooster on the dunghill. Resilience is for others. Snowflakes as Phoebe called them.
Not chickens or snowflakes, but humans to be respected.

SocksMcR · 01/03/2024 12:51

I'm torn on this. On the one hand, I was always one of the last picks so I get that it can be hurtful. But it did always make for evenly balanced teams, and I learned not to out my self worth on being chosen. I just wasn't that good at PE. It wasn't the end of the world.

x2boys · 01/03/2024 12:29

Youcannotbeseriousreally · 01/03/2024 12:19

I was often the last picked but I didn’t care. It wasn’t important to me, why would it be? It’s just PE. There is so much more to life than being picked in PE. Thats what we should be teaching our kids.

I bet teachers just use it as a fast way to get organised. There is too much overthinking.

I was alwas picked last too.and it did bother me ,no I'm not still scarred by it
But it's a lazy and unnecessary teaching method if teachers want it to be quick the 1/2 method is much quicker and doesn't humiliate a child

Youcannotbeseriousreally · 01/03/2024 12:19

x2boys · 01/03/2024 12:13

You think its fair that the same kids are picked last every week and those that are night also be unpopular and might not be academic either
How much resilience do.you think they need ?
In the real-world people, are not publicly humiliated. at work on a weekly basis
I assume you can't find the energy to be bothered about it because it never happened to you

Edited

I was often the last picked but I didn’t care. It wasn’t important to me, why would it be? It’s just PE. There is so much more to life than being picked in PE. Thats what we should be teaching our kids.

I bet teachers just use it as a fast way to get organised. There is too much overthinking.

x2boys · 01/03/2024 12:13

Youcannotbeseriousreally · 01/03/2024 12:01

I’m tempted to agree. They don’t do this at our secondary school but I fail to find the energy to be bothered about it. Like, life is going to happen and you’re not always going to be picked first so I don’t understand why we’d go to great length to ‘protect’ kids from situations they will encounter - better to build their resilience I think.

You think its fair that the same kids are picked last every week and those that are night also be unpopular and might not be academic either
How much resilience do.you think they need ?
In the real-world people, are not publicly humiliated. at work on a weekly basis
I assume you can't find the energy to be bothered about it because it never happened to you

Victoria3010 · 01/03/2024 12:13

Also those saying its a good grounding for life is nonsense- when does anyone at the local pool, gym, running club pick teams or rank their members as most or least fit - never, bar the pdd fun competition! Most people as adults interact in a fun, local, "join up even if you've never played" way or they do solo sports at clubs where anyone can join and everyone is welcome - most cycling or running clubs absolutely pride themselves on this and most gyms work crazy hard to try and encourage people to join, make them feel welcome and not feel like they don't belong. It's mad to me, I'd never do any sports if it was like pe at school!! I know there are the few people who do very competitive football/running/cycling where they do want good times or want to make a team but most of us are just doing our best, making new friends, trying a new sport and desperately attempting to fit into our jeans! Imagine joining a walking football team for the over 50s to try and get fit and the first step being picked last to be part of a team - they'd not keep their new members!

Victoria3010 · 01/03/2024 12:06

This is horrid and super old fashioned. I think PE is one of those areas where it can be a bit like that, my son has dyspraxia which massively impacts in PE and we had to pull him out until the school put extra measures in place after the pe teacher they had made them all race 1 on 1 until he could "rank" them and my 6 yr old literally tried to escape school and had a total breakdown at being "worst" in the class. You'd never teach spelling or maths like this, they don't all pick the best readers for their reading team, or best multipliers for maths. It's hard because sports are competitive by their nature but I'd like my kids to grow up feeling they can be fit, healthy and try anything, rather than that sports is for exclusively "good" people. Surely the message should be that anyone can try anything and that sports and fitness is fun and good for everyone! Whilst I wouldn't say I was scarred from being bad at PE I've grown up thinking I'm "not sporty", being intimidated by gym types and as a result it took until 35 to get into a proper fitness regime with a PT I trust, that's not how I should've been left feeling about something that's so important for my health.

Youcannotbeseriousreally · 01/03/2024 12:01

HelenTherese2 · 01/03/2024 09:07

Good grounding for the real world where you will get chosen to do things based on your ability.

No wonder kids can’t cope with real life any more.

I’m tempted to agree. They don’t do this at our secondary school but I fail to find the energy to be bothered about it. Like, life is going to happen and you’re not always going to be picked first so I don’t understand why we’d go to great length to ‘protect’ kids from situations they will encounter - better to build their resilience I think.

Hollbeach · 01/03/2024 11:57

My daughter's school assigned everyone a different colour at the beginning of the year, they wear that colour PE T-shirt and that is their team

SoupDragon · 01/03/2024 10:48

Another reason that it's stupid is that it is a popularity completion rather than purely skill based

JustDiscoveredBueno · 01/03/2024 10:43

@Chaotica hopefully things have changed, but we were literally shown a few types of pass and that was it for games. We weren't even told the basic rules or what positions did what or any strategies. Also remember teacher shouting at the slower kids to hurry up, not because they were messing around or taking their time for the sake of it, but because they were just slower. Imagine doing that when kids are reading aloud in class. Kids were shown exasperation, rather than encouragement. It's so weird, yet was so commonplace.

Chaotica · 01/03/2024 10:11

HelenTherese2 · 01/03/2024 09:07

Good grounding for the real world where you will get chosen to do things based on your ability.

No wonder kids can’t cope with real life any more.

Another reason that this is a daft comment, aside from those above, is that PE lessons are supposed to teach sport. Students who aren't picked might just be those who can't play that particular sport yet because they've not tried it or learned the techniques, but they are not going to improve if they are put off before they start. They may have plenty of ability which is not yet obvious.

Don't get me started on PE teachers not telling people that they shouldn't just pass to their mates too... My DC had one who did that - they still remember her fondly.