Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Making kids choose 'teams' for PE - assumed this was an old fashioned thing?

240 replies

Devicey · 28/02/2024 16:45

But told today that it happens every week at DCs primary.

Honestly thought this was something I have just seen on films and assumed wasn't done anymore?

Always similar kids left to the last couple that no one wants on their team.

AIBU or are there far better ways to divide up a class of kids for PE?

OP posts:
LittlePinkLampshade · 02/03/2024 11:53

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Chaotica · 02/03/2024 11:51

Josienpaul · 01/03/2024 20:39

I’m a teacher of ten years and I’ve never done it and never seen anyone do it but had it done at secondary. Don’t think I’ve ever thought about it since. You have to be made of harder stuff if this type of thing gets to you.
also, typically, she’s taking her kid’s word for it. Never wise.
Finally, that’s how sport works in RL - the best get chosen.

Obviously, DC are not accurate reporters of everything which goes on in school but when it's a reliable 16 year old telling you that this has been going on once or twice a week for years, that's a good indicator of accuracy.

It's also not how sport works in real life because my last-picked DS is perceived as being bad at sport by the other kids rather than actually bad at it. (He was classed as gifted and talented for PE in primary, trains and competes regularly and is really fit.) If someone were picking on talents or potential, and had been since Y7, he'd have been included but that's not how other children pick. He's not one of the popular kids and doesn't make a big deal about his own sporting achievements in school. That said, he would also stand up for the rights of his mates who get picked last because they aren't good at sports to be picked fairly too.

Jomtie · 02/03/2024 10:48

I was always picked last for anything that wasn't netball. It was utterly humiliating! I got picked earlier for netball because I was tall and was good at goal defence!

0xyg7554n · 02/03/2024 09:39

For which they’d be rated inadequate by Ofsted. I don’t get the lack of giving a shit Ofsted have as regards providing quality PE provision for all. Particularly so when you consider current obesity rates. PE provision is clearly failing.

Ahugga · 02/03/2024 09:34

0xyg7554n · 02/03/2024 09:28

Exactly and half the time those who struggle are picked to field yards away and end up standing doing nothing to improve skills. In maths or Eng lessons those who struggle get support to improve skills in a kind empathetic way. Teachers are judged on progress. PE teachers seem to be allowed to do what they want and entirely ignore the very set of pupils who need help the most.

It's the equivalent of an English teacher sitting all the less able kids at the back, and expecting them to write an essay on a book they've never read. Humiliating them and setting them up for failure.

0xyg7554n · 02/03/2024 09:28

Ahugga · 02/03/2024 09:24

Picking teams ought to be a much smaller part of PE anyway. How much is anyone really learning from endless half hearted games of rounders and dodgeball.

Exactly and half the time those who struggle are picked to field yards away and end up standing doing nothing to improve skills. In maths or Eng lessons those who struggle get support to improve skills in a kind empathetic way. Teachers are judged on progress. PE teachers seem to be allowed to do what they want and entirely ignore the very set of pupils who need help the most.

Ahugga · 02/03/2024 09:24

x2boys · 02/03/2024 09:14

Well yeah but in real.life its people who enjoy sport and has a aptitude for it that join sports teams
We don't force people to try out for the England football team even though they hate football and have no interest in it then humiliate them when they are inevitably hopeless. do we
PE is part of the national curriculum everyone HAS to do it regardless of ability there are fairer ways of picking teams hen humiliating kids.

Picking teams ought to be a much smaller part of PE anyway. How much is anyone really learning from endless half hearted games of rounders and dodgeball.

x2boys · 02/03/2024 09:14

Josienpaul · 01/03/2024 20:39

I’m a teacher of ten years and I’ve never done it and never seen anyone do it but had it done at secondary. Don’t think I’ve ever thought about it since. You have to be made of harder stuff if this type of thing gets to you.
also, typically, she’s taking her kid’s word for it. Never wise.
Finally, that’s how sport works in RL - the best get chosen.

Well yeah but in real.life its people who enjoy sport and has a aptitude for it that join sports teams
We don't force people to try out for the England football team even though they hate football and have no interest in it then humiliate them when they are inevitably hopeless. do we
PE is part of the national curriculum everyone HAS to do it regardless of ability there are fairer ways of picking teams hen humiliating kids.

0xyg7554n · 02/03/2024 09:12

PE peer group picking and non differentiation in lessons by lazy PE teachers helped cause my daughters severe Anorexia. She had severe dyspraxia and hypermobility and was always the last picked that nobody wanted, was sniggered at standing alone waiting, had to listen to the comments etc. Also shouted at for not trying harder by peers and teachers. She developed a phobia of any sport and during lockdown when all her friends were trying to get fit by running she turned to dieting instead as felt all sport wasn’t for her. The impact of PE lessons has been noted by psychs during her EHCP process.

She has just developed the courage to start swimming completely alone now. 😊

Differentiation and non peer group team picking should be happening by default imvho alongside a bigger proportion of PE lessons given to individual sports.

Lindy2 · 02/03/2024 09:09

My junior school did this. I was always one of the last ones. I was actually OK at sport, not bullied at all and I had a great little group of friends. It was never one of my friends that got to pick though. Even my little group of friends always got picked before me.

Almost 40 years later though I still remember it and the cringing embarrassment I felt of pretty much always being in the last 2 or 3.

I was quite shocked when DD13 mentioned the other day how she hates how her PE teacher does this to pick teams. I honestly thought no one would seriously still be doing this when there are so many easy, non humiliating, options to divide a class.

All I can think is the PE teachers were never the last to be picked, so they don't understand and all talk about inclusiveness has gone somewhat over their heads.

Treaclewell · 02/03/2024 08:45

It's interesting to compare with other subjects. Poor language development? Special needs group. Poor numeracy skills? TA 1-1 support. But PE. Nope.It's your fault, don't practice enough, are lazy. Where are special needs for PE? Much more useful. It doesn't have to be full blown dyspraxia to need it. Hand eye coordination, balance skills, lifting things safely, everyone needs to know how to use their body well.
Got to use a ladder later, with care for that hip joint I couldn't have hurt because I came last. (I shouldn't bear ill will to a long dead nasty woman, but when it twinges, I do.)

Loubelle70 · 02/03/2024 06:46

I actually complained to my daughters school about this (granted was 20 years ago)...i said it's segregating for those kids who are least 'popular' and also encourages and perpetuates bullying...and facilitates any bullying that exists. Completely ignored.
It angers me this is still happening

Nofilteritwonthelp · 02/03/2024 06:29

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

👏👏👏

chrisfromcardiff · 02/03/2024 00:58

Devicey · 28/02/2024 16:45

But told today that it happens every week at DCs primary.

Honestly thought this was something I have just seen on films and assumed wasn't done anymore?

Always similar kids left to the last couple that no one wants on their team.

AIBU or are there far better ways to divide up a class of kids for PE?

Oh! How I hated this. I was not an athletic child. I was surrounded by classmates (all girl school) who were stronger, taller and def athletic. I was always the one to be picked last. That was about 50+ years ago and I still remember the humiliation. Arg.

SlumberDearMaid · 02/03/2024 00:43

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Kittybythelighthouse · 02/03/2024 00:37

midgetastic · 28/02/2024 17:27

Yes it's upsetting ( I was always 4th from last)

But it was also fair in that better children got chosen first and teaches you that skill and capabilities matter in the real world - so it's not a shock when you get turned down for promotion

I was always picked last. I’ve never been turned down for a promotion though. Probably because I don’t apply for promotions as a professional sportswoman. Do you? It seems like you think this crazily rare career path is super common!

“Better” at team sports means just that and only that. It literally has no value or impact on anything else in life, least of all a child’s future promotion prospects (?!) yes skills and capabilities matter in the real world. But those useful real world skills and capabilities that employers value are hardly ever about sport! Be for real! Certainly I’ve never once had call to use any P.E ‘skills’ in the workplace. The reality is that we all choose which direction in life to pursue based on our individual skills and capabilities and 99% of the time those directions aren’t sports related, but of course you do actually know this. No one is asking any adult to score a goal at a job interview, unless trying out for Man Utd.

In my case one of the girls who was “better” at sports - in fact she was the best, she should be prime minister now by your reckoning - ended up in prison at 19/20 and has been in and out ever since. I don’t think allowing kids to be bullied by her or condoning her to bully them helped anybody, least of all her. I think the real world was a shock for her actually, much more than for us kids who had talents elsewhere other than sports and have done alright thanks very much.

Fizbosshoes · 01/03/2024 22:12

It's one of my worst memories from school and I've never done a team sport since I left.

Kittybythelighthouse · 01/03/2024 21:57

PaperSheet · 01/03/2024 20:50

No how sport works in real life is people who are interested in playing a sport practice it then try out for a team. If they're not good enough the coach will explain that and the person will either go back to practicing or just playing for fun.
No where in real life sport would i be forced to stand at try outs for a game I have zero interest in and don't even know how to play. And other team members would not be forced to have me on their team.
If the teacher had at any point said to me "Actually you're not very interested in playing this are you? And also not that good. Would you prefer to go to an extra maths lesson?" I would have jumped at the chance.
I did not want to be there. Others did not want me there. Yet I was forced to be there. That is not how real life sport works.

Exactly! People like @Josienpaul acting like “real life” requires every adult to try out for sports teams constantly. Have they experienced real life? 😂 The reality is that in real life you don’t have to ever play a sport unless you fancy it and if you do you’re either pro level anyway or chances are you’ll be made to feel welcome and certainly not mocked, excluded, and ridiculed every week for months on end.

On the other hand, in real life, you probably will need to use some of the skills you learn in other subjects which don’t require the public ritual humiliation of children. It’s such a sincerely stupid argument. Depressing to see a teacher making it.

Kittybythelighthouse · 01/03/2024 21:46

@Josienpaul

“You have to be made of harder stuff if this type of thing gets to you.” - School shouldn’t require children to be made of “harder stuff”. It’s not the military. Or prison. It is really okay for some kids to be sensitive and not tough as nails. We don’t need to be churning out mini Kray Brothers thanks.

“Finally, that’s how sport works in RL - the best get chosen.” - And? The best are chosen for whatever they put themselves forward for “in RL”. We don’t get forced to put ourselves forward for things we don’t enjoy or don’t like. We typically don’t get ridiculed and mocked publicly either “in RL”. Do you think we should be forcing the sporty kids who are crap at other subjects to be publicly humiliated for their own good too? Is it just the kids who aren’t sporty that get this remarkable ‘privilege’ which is, by the way, completely unsupported by any scientific research?

Depressing to see so many “teachers” 🤡 on this thread who don’t give a fuck about the mental health of children ffs.

PaperSheet · 01/03/2024 20:53

In fact, I would have preferred to just sit on the edge and watch than be forced onto a team that didn't want me. I wouldn't actually have minded if the teacher said "would you rather sit this game out seeing as you don't like it?"
Being left out through a choice is much preferable to being humiliated.

PaperSheet · 01/03/2024 20:50

Josienpaul · 01/03/2024 20:39

I’m a teacher of ten years and I’ve never done it and never seen anyone do it but had it done at secondary. Don’t think I’ve ever thought about it since. You have to be made of harder stuff if this type of thing gets to you.
also, typically, she’s taking her kid’s word for it. Never wise.
Finally, that’s how sport works in RL - the best get chosen.

No how sport works in real life is people who are interested in playing a sport practice it then try out for a team. If they're not good enough the coach will explain that and the person will either go back to practicing or just playing for fun.
No where in real life sport would i be forced to stand at try outs for a game I have zero interest in and don't even know how to play. And other team members would not be forced to have me on their team.
If the teacher had at any point said to me "Actually you're not very interested in playing this are you? And also not that good. Would you prefer to go to an extra maths lesson?" I would have jumped at the chance.
I did not want to be there. Others did not want me there. Yet I was forced to be there. That is not how real life sport works.

sleekcat · 01/03/2024 20:45

I work in primary schools and have seen it happen at some but not others. I remember when I was at school the same children were always left until last and must have felt horrible.
I think the best method is when the teacher goes down the line and just gives everyone a number and that's what team they are in. Although sometimes all the best just end up on the same team by coincidence so that's not perfect either.

Rewis · 01/03/2024 20:45

I was very athletic in school ans was always the first or second pick. It sucked even when I was in that role. I coach kids and adults in few different activities and that is never how I make up a team even with adults.

My goto is have everyone go in a line based on something. Alphabetical order based on middle name, height, second number of birthday etc. Something random. Then divide the teams somewhat equally (either 1-2 method or splitting in half or some variation). Appears random as it is to some extend but can still control that they are equal or separate those who should be separated.

Josienpaul · 01/03/2024 20:39

Chaotica · 28/02/2024 17:12

DS's school does this (secondary). The same people always get to choose and the same people are left out. It's a terrible system. Teams for any sport are just chosen by who can play football well and/or who is popular (which is, I'm told, often the same thing).

I’m a teacher of ten years and I’ve never done it and never seen anyone do it but had it done at secondary. Don’t think I’ve ever thought about it since. You have to be made of harder stuff if this type of thing gets to you.
also, typically, she’s taking her kid’s word for it. Never wise.
Finally, that’s how sport works in RL - the best get chosen.

Wannabedisneyprincess · 01/03/2024 20:30

At my kids primary, they are placed in a house (diff colours) before they even start school and that’s their sports teams for the whole of primary and also grouping for different experiments etc in the classrooms

reading etc is done split into ability groups they have different for them