Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is anyone worried about their council going bust?

168 replies

PassingStranger · 28/02/2024 16:38

It was on the news this morning that alot of councils are very close to going bust.
Services are having to be cut again and council tax going up?

What would happen if your council went bust?
Is there a way to find out how your council is doing?
Anyone worried like me? Xx

OP posts:
Ineedwinenow · 28/02/2024 20:08

My council truly are cowboys so it might be beneficial for them to go bust. It doesn’t matter if Labour or Conservative are in power, they have always been shocking.

They decide when they can be arsed to empty bins, every road is undrivable, vital and non vital services have been cut, promises broken , street cleaning , planting and Christmas decorations haven’t happened for a couple of years and to be honest none of us actually know where our money or government funding is going, public buildings have all shut, support for vulnerable is difficult ( impossible ) to access so we definitely need a new council who don’t pay their bosses and minions hundreds of thousands yet provide a worse service year on year

Got2getout · 28/02/2024 20:08

Yep, I work for the council and things are bleak. Everything cut to the bone. There’s no cut backs that can be made at this stage without severely impacting provision.

Lots of noise about blaming the Tories, but Labour have been in charge of Wales for years and the situation here just as bad (or worse) than England.

Sadly we will pay for this for generations; the lack of investment in infrastructure, education, health, and social care, is causing deep rooted damage that will take decades to repair, and cost so much more in the long run.

It’s so much more than pot holes and wheelie bins.

DontBeAPrickDarren · 28/02/2024 20:01

Gatorpickle · 28/02/2024 19:26

But what about local oversight and local accountability?

I know that in a couple of cases, councils invested in ventures they hoped would bring in extra income but failed miserably.

Part of the problem is the govt changed the funding model of LAs to make them “revenue generating” without considering whether there was the necessary expertise to do so. Councils are not businesses. Statutory duties aren’t optional.

Barring profit-making companies from delivering social care would be a start. The cost of residential placements for looked after children is eye watering, as is the cost of specialist SEND placements. Yet councils can’t open new schools to meet need unless they can get an academy sponsor to come in and do it, and then they don’t get to use half the places because the authority down the way decides it will pay more. It’s a batshit system and the amount of money pouring out into private hands is appalling.

EmmaEmerald · 28/02/2024 19:57

hollyblueivy · 28/02/2024 19:55

Also you could have millions in reserves but realistically that may only be a few months worth of costs covered and once they are spent, there is no way of building the reserves back up again.

Even more reason not to let them pay out a fortune to consultants and architects.

it's the same as Johnson spending £60m to figure out if the Garden Bridge was a good idea - which it never was.

hollyblueivy · 28/02/2024 19:55

EmmaEmerald · 28/02/2024 19:26

@Hecate01 good point, wonder what rules are on reserves.

Also you could have millions in reserves but realistically that may only be a few months worth of costs covered and once they are spent, there is no way of building the reserves back up again.

EmmaEmerald · 28/02/2024 19:54

helpfulperson · 28/02/2024 19:43

Many of you are talking about how much council tax you pay and rises in council tax. If you look at the income of a council less than 25% comes from council tax. The cost of providing all the services a council does is 4 times the amount you pay in council tax.

I think most of us know that.
But that makes me even more puzzled why they won't put money from things like sale of assets into basic services.

I'm sorry it's a soundbite, but when the country doesn't want to get the basics right - like broken bones and bin collections - you have to ask why.

The constant vanity and nonsense projects will be a large part of the bill.

In my previous council, the consultation for closing the library was just a way to line the pockets of consultants. The consultation cost about 10 x the cost of the library per year.

We also had two consultations on revamping the high street. The first one was found to have broken rules so they ran it again. Total cost - £3million.

nothing was implemented (nobody wanted it) and the proposal to resite the bus garage was (quite rightly) rejected by TFL. They wanted to have a split site so buses going the same way would be divided so you couldn't just get on the first bus going where you wanted as you'd be in the wrong place.

How does that level of idiocy get a consultation in the first place?!

DancefloorAcrobatics · 28/02/2024 19:49

Ours already went butst.
To me, it looks like they have some investment in pothole farming.

The proceeds - when they come- will hopefully go into special educational needs provision. (Currently non existing, I know 3 children who have to travel to neighbouring councils. As local school is closed due to rack concrete.)
Council is also happy to give land (green spaces) away to anyone who has a lawnmower and enough funds for fencing.

But I'm I'm not worried, after all they are in alright Jack camp, after giving themselves a little pay raise due to colc.
So things can't really that bad, or can they?

hollyblueivy · 28/02/2024 19:47

MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 28/02/2024 17:25

Our local council has just cut funding for the entire arts programme

This is the other impact we are all going to see regardless of council tax banding and revenue - any provision which is not statutory will be considered for the cut.

Cut to the bone.

SoupDragon · 28/02/2024 19:46

My council already has. A year or so ago. I've not noticed a huge difference (other than a big hike in council tax)

hollyblueivy · 28/02/2024 19:45

hulloplod · 28/02/2024 17:18

I work in internal audit in a large local government.
Things are dire! Not so much for my council, but across most of the country.
It's the cost of social care placements in light of inflation which seems to have been the straw that broke the camels back.

You've hit the nail on the head.

The massive proportion and majority of the money the council has to spend per year is spent on social care, leaving peanuts to manage everything else.

The social demand is not going down and the budgets are not going up.

So it seems we are in a foreseeable and inevitable position.

helpfulperson · 28/02/2024 19:43

Many of you are talking about how much council tax you pay and rises in council tax. If you look at the income of a council less than 25% comes from council tax. The cost of providing all the services a council does is 4 times the amount you pay in council tax.

EmmaEmerald · 28/02/2024 19:26

@Hecate01 good point, wonder what rules are on reserves.

Gatorpickle · 28/02/2024 19:26

But what about local oversight and local accountability?

I know that in a couple of cases, councils invested in ventures they hoped would bring in extra income but failed miserably.

EmmaEmerald · 28/02/2024 19:26

My sister's council went bust a few years ago and she claims she can't see a difference....I think she can't see it directly because the cuts don't affect her and she's in Central London six days a week.

But she wouldn't know about local education, potholes, leisure facilities, so she's annoyed by the higher bill but not affected by any changes.

When I visit, I can see how much more run down it is.

Hecate01 · 28/02/2024 19:25

Ours are pleading poverty but have millions in reserves. I don't think we'd notice the difference if they did go bust because they are corrupt and useless.

EmmaEmerald · 28/02/2024 19:22

My council says it's okay for two years but that's why bills have to go up - they don't think they'll be okay without the rise.

I'm wondering how citizens can object to a particular rule - which I think most councils have...all advice welcome.

Mine has just made a lot of money from a land sale. They say they are "not allowed" to spend this money on services and that council receipts from such a thing can only be spent on capital expenditure projects. They are on a mission to expand the local market, which is a huge waste of money when we have issues with basic service provision....and there's no physical space to expand the market anyway! And it's not well attended.

I was wondering how this insane rule can be challenged. I suspect it can't, because a capex project means more money into the pockets of their mates.

Pigglyplaystruant99 · 28/02/2024 19:21

I 💯 agree with you.

sleepyscientist · 28/02/2024 19:11

PassingStranger · 28/02/2024 17:32

Very interesting thanks.

Leisure Centres are so needed. People keep fit there and it's good for mental health too.
If they close people's fitness etc would suffer surely bringing another problem? Xx 😪

Our council run leisure centre is more expensive than the near by 5* hotel so no I don't think we need them. Even water babies have moved to a private pool it's so expensive using council services.

We are quite harsh me and DH has threshold of we will pay for a cleaner and gardener when we age. Anything else we won't be here so really begrudge paying nearly 3k for something we won't be using.

Realistically I would rather a lot less council tax but pay for our bins to be emptied when we want, have a for profit leisure centre and pay a school tax whilst DS is young. Oh yeah our estate isn't adopted either so we have that bill on top of council tax.

pixiesaresmall · 28/02/2024 19:09

I've just applied for an arts/markets type role in LA. Would I be mad to gamble and leave a 110@% secure role with around £500 less per year wage. This thread has made me think hard now that it really is a non essential role in the eyes of the public and our council tax is already going up 9.9% this year and we will still have a deficit across the borough.

makeanddo · 28/02/2024 19:08

In some cases this isn't due to the government,

Birmingham for example - massive equal pay claim which they fought and has bankrupted them.

Frankly having worked for a council there is still so much wastage and the old 'using up the budget before April' type stuff. The one I worked at was so poorly managed.

As per pp something needs to be done the transport costs for sen children. It's not sustainable and the taxpayer should not be funding this in the way it's currently done. Something has to give. There isn't enough money.

NotMeNoNo · 28/02/2024 19:08

As PP said the money is going on services most people don't see like SEN support, temporary housing, social care. The central government has cut funding to local authorities by about 80% since 2013. So yes they are raising council tax and cutting the non statutory services to attempt to close the gap.

Diamondcurtains · 28/02/2024 18:59

Our council is already bankrupt.

RheaRend · 28/02/2024 18:58

Nope as my council seem to have a nice little earner. They have taken 2 years worth of pension payments off teachers and not put them into their pension pots. About £3m per month earning interest for them! They have a nice little side line going on while all the teachers have no pension payments going in!

BoobyDazzler · 28/02/2024 18:56

CranfordScones · 28/02/2024 18:14

A lot of councils have been put under immense strain because of back-dated pay claims over supposedly unequal historic pay. Lots of workers are keen to compare themselves to refuse collectors (or whatever benchmark they used) with no thought as to why the latter may be paid more - it's just the nebulous concept of 'work of equal value'. Glasgow is a good example of that.

And then if you want more specifics: Nottingham Council illegally spent £18m of ring-fenced housing funding on things it wasn't allowed to.

Birmingham's leader seems to have done friendly deals with certain unions which turned out to breach equal pay legislation so it gave rise to yet more backdated claims. And much of their spending seemed to lack oversight.

Thurrock Council gambled away hundreds of millions of pounds on risky investments.

So, yeah, it's all the government's fault. But what about local oversight and local accountability?

One of my first jobs was working for a council run housing home. It was a lovely place to work but the staff there were one of the first tranch of claimants of “equal pay”, and yes they compared themselves to bin men, and why wouldn’t they? Being a bin man is a job anyone can do and involved little to no skill or experience yet they are paid handsomely for their admittedly dirty work, because they’re men. Caring is a vocation that few can do well, requires immense people skills, compassion and can be very dirty work; it also requires 24 hour working, yet carers have historically earned peanuts because they’re mostly women (although carers then earn more that carers now!)

What the council do in light of these claims? They closed the nursing homes, thousands and thousands of them. Pushing care in to the private sector lining the pockets of many private individuals and turning vulnerable people in to the cash cows. Who pays the bill for that? The councils. Who’s paying the price for that now? We all are.

Women deserved to be paid as much as men in a comparable role. Carers certainly deserved to be paid more than bin men.

Barbiefromtheblock · 28/02/2024 18:50

OneRingToRuleThemAll · 28/02/2024 16:52

Yes, because I work for them and my job is at risk if they do.

Same ☹️

Swipe left for the next trending thread