Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is anyone worried about their council going bust?

168 replies

PassingStranger · 28/02/2024 16:38

It was on the news this morning that alot of councils are very close to going bust.
Services are having to be cut again and council tax going up?

What would happen if your council went bust?
Is there a way to find out how your council is doing?
Anyone worried like me? Xx

OP posts:
EllieQ · 28/02/2024 20:55

EmmaEmerald · 28/02/2024 20:29

@EllieQ Thanks, I thought it might apply to all councils but have they chosen to adopt it or was it forced on them? That's why I wondered if a campaign to someone other than the local MP might be in order.

i will at your links tomorrow.

Re things going out to tender - just like with NHS supplies - it's a corruption problem with all parties and it's so key to our rotten systems.

How do we find another George Lansbury?!

I expect the rule about use of capital funding for capital projects is set out in one of the Local Government Finance Acts of Parliament.

The Local Government Finance Act 1992 set up Council Tax as a replacement for the Poll Tax, for example:

1992 Act

Local Government Finance Act 1992

An Act to provide for certain local authorities to levy and collect a new tax, to be called council tax; to abolish community charges; to make further provision with respect to local government finance (including provision with respect to certain grant...

https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1992/14/contents

DdraigGoch · 28/02/2024 20:53

Treehuggingmutherfunkin · 28/02/2024 17:22

Whoever voted for brexit, tories, Sadiqque Khan the rest of the idiots is to blame. I can hold my head high and say I DIDNT

I'm pretty sure that the people who voted for Sadiq Khan are unlikely to have voted for Brexit or for the Tories.

justasking111 · 28/02/2024 20:53

Our council tax went up 10% last year going up 10% again in April. Our payment will be over 3.5k for the coming year.

Bins collection every four weeks have been for years.

Education cuts 10% last year, coming year another 5%. Big arguments in chambers about four day school week.

Councillors getting a pay rise in line with inflation.

Our shiny new council offices £45 million built a few years ago have been mostly empty since covid March 2020.

We've paid 500k for two electric bin wagons we can't use because they won't last the distance of any route.

Our pension payments are 🙈

Our social care for the elderly is what is breaking us more than anything. We sold off all the retirement homes to save money, it's still not enough.

DdraigGoch · 28/02/2024 20:50

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 28/02/2024 16:48

If the Tories stay in it will happen. They've publicly said they are against local authorities in the past-at least, Boris Johnson was open about it. Still, I suppose some of the services they consider basic will be provided by contractors, all tendered and organised fairly, of course!

It's not just the Tories. I live in Wales and my county council (well run, not at all wasteful) are having to hike council tax and cut the education budget because the Welsh Government's settlement is insufficient. Apparently the formula used in Wales (not sure how it would be calculated in England) gives extra weight to areas with larger proportions of young families. So the councils with aging populations not only find themselves landed with the cost of social care but they also have smaller government grants per capita.

platinumplus · 28/02/2024 20:49

Our council seems to spend vast VAST sums of money (billions) on completely unimportant vanity projects and then slices essential services such as education to the bone. It's time that councils were run like profit making businesses. Someone recently described working at the council as "feet up central" and I can't think of a better term. I've had the pleasure of dealing with various departments at a number of local authorities and the lack of/speed of work is astonishing.

MintTwirl · 28/02/2024 20:49

Yeah ours is in trouble. It’s an area with a lot of deprivation and they have already closed our sports centre and pool, the library in our town and the next are to shut and they they are shutting the registry office too. These are imo basic services that a large town should have.

StarDolphins · 28/02/2024 20:43

Our council has just spent 9million buying a near derelict shopping centre should probably.

byteme1011 · 28/02/2024 20:41

I worry and how will this be resolved or what can actually be done about it? Surely adult social care bill is only going to increase, same with SEN transport

Thighdentitycrisis · 28/02/2024 20:33

I might lose my job

EmmaEmerald · 28/02/2024 20:31

@mammaia "Not to mention the billions most councils spent buying and investing in huge commercial portfolios, oversaw by people who hadn't the faintest idea of commercial property . Portfolios which have now tanked in value and these repayments are massive. "

this most of Croydon's bankruptcy issue (Labour).

Judellie · 28/02/2024 20:30

Tangential but why are people from overseas allowed to buy property here - and then leave it empty. Loads of people need places to live.
Didn't Turkey or somewhere say that only Turkish residents could own property in Turkey - and took all the rest back for their own citizens.
Doubt that would actually happen here tho

DontBeAPrickDarren · 28/02/2024 20:30

I’m banging on about social care because it’s the area that my previous employer is about to go bust over.

In his recent review of children’s social care Josh McAllister wrote eloquently about profiteering in the residential sector - see 129-130 here:
<a class="break-all" href="https://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ukgwa/20230308122535mp_/childrenssocialcare.independent-review.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/The-independent-review-of-childrens-social-care-Final-report.pdf" rel="nofollow" target="blank">https://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ukgwa/20230308122535mp/childrenssocialcare.independent-review.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/The-independent-review-of-childrens-social-care-Final-report.pdf

but I think the government pretty much ignored this in its response

https://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ukgwa/20230308122535mp_/https://childrenssocialcare.independent-review.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/The-independent-review-of-childrens-social-care-Final-report.pdf

EmmaEmerald · 28/02/2024 20:29

@EllieQ Thanks, I thought it might apply to all councils but have they chosen to adopt it or was it forced on them? That's why I wondered if a campaign to someone other than the local MP might be in order.

i will at your links tomorrow.

Re things going out to tender - just like with NHS supplies - it's a corruption problem with all parties and it's so key to our rotten systems.

How do we find another George Lansbury?!

TeenLifeMum · 28/02/2024 20:26

@mammaia i don’t disagree re mismanagement but we had successful district councils that were financially doing fine but the county council was in financial difficulty. Against public opinion, the conservatives (Robert Jenric) authorised a unitary authority and within 10 months they were saying they’re close to announcing a section 114, having absorbed all the district council money. They’re now cutting theatres, sports facilities and country parks plus many, many services that had all been run by the district councils very well. Funding has also dropped from central government and they’ve just received notice that rubbish collections need to return to 2 weekly collections from 3 weekly (which has been surprisingly fine - I say as a family of 5). They hadn’t budgeted for that announcement and it’ll cost £40m that they need to magically find.

mammaia · 28/02/2024 20:25

@DontBeAPrickDarren

Agreed. My post wasn't meant to say this was the only reason. Yes central government cuts have not helped, granted. However there are a lot of councils run by those who shouldn't really be in charge. They wouldn't be heading up a multi million private sector business, but he in again it's not their money they're throwing away!

Not to mention they're paid disgusting salaries to go with it despite she failure on their parts.

EllieQ · 28/02/2024 20:20

EmmaEmerald · 28/02/2024 19:22

My council says it's okay for two years but that's why bills have to go up - they don't think they'll be okay without the rise.

I'm wondering how citizens can object to a particular rule - which I think most councils have...all advice welcome.

Mine has just made a lot of money from a land sale. They say they are "not allowed" to spend this money on services and that council receipts from such a thing can only be spent on capital expenditure projects. They are on a mission to expand the local market, which is a huge waste of money when we have issues with basic service provision....and there's no physical space to expand the market anyway! And it's not well attended.

I was wondering how this insane rule can be challenged. I suspect it can't, because a capex project means more money into the pockets of their mates.

It’s a rule that applies to all councils @EmmaEmerald - this document from the Local Government Association (written for councillors) explains the rules of council finance in more detail:

Local Gov Finance

I work for my local council, and we are not in danger of going bankrupt, but have had to raise council tax and cut some budgets/ services to balance the books. It’s a fairly affluent, tourist area so the high street is still busy and I’d guess there a lot of houses in the higher council tax bands.

Like others have said, it’s the cost of adult social care that is rising steeply, but most people just think about bins, roads, libraries, and perhaps schools. I often wonder how many people who complain about council tax rises also think you shouldn’t have to sell your house to pay for care - who do they think will pay for it?

https://www.local.gov.uk/sites/default/files/documents/11.107%20A%20Councillor%27s%20Workbook%20on%20Local%20Government%20Finance_v02.pdf

BigDogEnergy · 28/02/2024 20:20

DyslexicPoster · 28/02/2024 17:14

I'm surprised mine wasn't the first to go bankrupt honestly.

Places like Medway I worry more for. There is a lot of poverty in Medway and parts of it are already quite grim. I can't see how they will cope long term without it getting more deprived. It's quite a contrast to Woking which feels all new and shiny.

I don't think anywhere is safe. Not enough investment in prevention of SC costs and expensive reactionary attitudes.

Like my ds 60k pa school. Zero interest in getting him pre school speech therapy as must hoard the pennies, well that paid off when he still couldn't talk at 7. Would he have been at cheaper if he had early intervention? I really think it would. Lots of the SEN costs are due to too little to late.

What will happen to kids in SEN schools, particularly those that are independent? We're in a similar situation and likely going to require an independent specialist I the next year or so

DontBeAPrickDarren · 28/02/2024 20:19

I agree with you to a degree @mammaia but that situation arose as a consequence of the Tories slashing central govt funding to local authorities year on year post-2010 and basically saying jog on and sort yourselves out.

TeenLifeMum · 28/02/2024 20:19

Yep - council tax going up and dh likely to lose his job. The people trying to sort it out are seemingly incompetent from the meetings I’ve over heard (dh is a civil servant and exec team is unimpressive).

mammaia · 28/02/2024 20:18

aquarimum · 28/02/2024 18:28

This is a direct result of Tory policy that drastically cut funding to local governments, safe in the knowledge its arms length from Westminster blame. Shame on them.

Oh give over,

This is the result of years of mis management, by people who were not qualified to be in charge of businesses. Throwing money for years on unnecessary crap

Not to mention the billions most councils spent buying and investing in huge commercial portfolios, oversaw by people who hadn't the faintest idea of commercial property . Portfolios which have now tanked in value and these repayments are massive.

Just saying.

EmmaEmerald · 28/02/2024 20:17

@DontBeAPrickDarren
That's really interesting re the funding models

So we're best advised directing these queries to local MPs, have I understood that correctly? Thank you.

i think Croydon Council went bust twice and then appointed their own mayor or something? Should be banned under corruption laws.

wombat15 · 28/02/2024 20:17

It's already happened to some councils.

DontBeAPrickDarren · 28/02/2024 20:15

From the CMA review of private providers in social care:

”Second, the prices and profits of the largest providers in the sector are materially higher than we would expect them to be if this market were working well. The evidence from our core data set, covering 15 large providers, shows that these providers have been earning significant profits over a sustained period. For the children’s homes providers in our data set we have seen steady operating profit margins averaging 22.6% from 2016 to 2020, with average prices increasing from £2,977 to £3,830 per week over the period, an average annual increase of 3.5%, after accounting for inflation. In fostering, prices have been steady at an average of £820 per week, and indeed have therefore declined in real terms, but profit margins of the largest IFAs appear consistently high at an average of 19.4%.

If this market were functioning well, we would expect to see existing profitable providers investing and expanding in the market and new providers entering. This would drive down prices as local authorities would have more choice of placements, meaning that less efficient providers would have to become more efficient or exit the market, and the profits of the largest providers would be reduced. Eventually, profits and prices should remain at a lower level as providers would know that if they raised their prices they would be unable to attract placements in the face of competition. The high profits of the largest providers therefore shows that competition is not working as well as it should be.

Third, we have concerns around the resilience of the market. Our concerns are not about businesses failing per se, but about the impact that failure can have on the children in their care. Were a private provider to exit this market in a disorderly manner – for instance by getting into financial trouble and closing its facilities – children in that provider’s care could suffer harm from the disruption, especially if local authorities were unable to find alternative appropriate placements for them. Given these potential negative effects on children’s lives, the current level of risk needs to be actively managed. This is less of a concern in the case of fostering, as foster carers should be able to transfer to a new agency with minimal impact on children. It is a greater concern in the case of children’s homes, where placements may be lost altogether.
We have seen very high levels of debt being carried by some of the largest private providers, with private equity-owned providers of children’s homes in our dataset having particularly high levels. This level of indebtedness, all else being equal, is likely to increase the risk of disorderly exit of firms from the market.”

CrispsandThings · 28/02/2024 20:12

My county council was the biggest employer in our town.
It has relocated and most staff wfh.

So not only has the largest employer gone, the staff no longer visit the town. Cue loads of shop closures.

It's a really tricky situation.
Our county is rural and so it's reliant on fruit/veg pickers who are mainly Eastern European and send their wages back home.
There aren't many graduate prospects ; a recent survey showed that our county had the largest number of commutees out of the county for jobs.

Therefore there's little spend in our county and a swollen wfh culture.

We also have an unusually high proportion of people who don't work and claim benefits.
We also have a large elderly population needing support.

How is a council supposed to support this?

cheerypip · 28/02/2024 20:09

Globules · 28/02/2024 18:29

R4 were discussing this matter this morning.

A LGA spokesman says 70%+ of council budgets were going on 4 things

Safeguarding children
Adult social care
Temporary housing
SEN costs of children, specifically the transportation costs to get them to and from school.

These 4 areas don't impact the majority of taxpayers. His words, they care about bins, potholes and libraries as they're the services they use.

My job means I have insight into 3 of those 4 areas. The costs, and the budgets available to these areas, staggers me. E.g. I arranged an SEN child, who isn't physically disabled, getting to and from school. The taxi fare was £25 total. Because I had to use LA approved transport, the cost was £110 total.

That can't be right. How are these tenders being accepted?

Re SEN transport. In my (rural) area there aren't enough taxis especially at peak school times, so you wouldn't have a chance of getting your £25 taxi ride at school times. So the cost goes up. Add the cost of an escort if needed and - you're right! - eye watering costs, especially if there aren't any other children travelling that way so the journey can't be shared.

If the parents are willing to provide the transport themselves, it's often much cheaper to pay their travel expenses, but of course that doesn't work for many families.

Swipe left for the next trending thread