Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is anyone worried about their council going bust?

168 replies

PassingStranger · 28/02/2024 16:38

It was on the news this morning that alot of councils are very close to going bust.
Services are having to be cut again and council tax going up?

What would happen if your council went bust?
Is there a way to find out how your council is doing?
Anyone worried like me? Xx

OP posts:
TiredCatLady · 29/02/2024 08:07

I don’t think anyone would notice if our council went bust. They’re utterly useless. The council tax is eyewatering, I don’t know of a single property, even flats, that are below Band D. We just about get the bins emptied if we’re lucky.

They’re one with a very high amount of debt already so it’s a distinct possibility that they will collapse in the next year or so.

NoTouch · 29/02/2024 08:00

caringcarer · 28/02/2024 21:22

Birmingham has already gone bust and in local newspapers it was reported they have to pay a 10 percent rise in council tax this year and another 10 percent next year. I'm in Staffordshire and we've been told 5 percent. Birmingham not only has many cycle lanes they have signs that light up to say how many cyclist have been cycling along a road in one day. It's such a waste of money. Adult care sucks all the funds up. I do think once people reach 50 they should have to pay additional tax to pay towards social care should they need it. 50 would be a good age to introduce it as DC would be growing up.

There are two periods when dc are the most expensive, the nursery years when full time childcare is needed and the uni years (when many parents are around 50).

Plus everyone pays towards all social care evenly through their working lives.

Morph22010 · 29/02/2024 08:00

Our council is one of the lowest funded in the country so they pretty much already cut all the non statutory services over the past 13 years, our council run libraries went years ago although we do still have physical libraries they are now run by volunteer groups and are often attached to something like a village or community hall which can generate funds by being rented out for parties etc.

Where our council seems to go wrong is thst they don’t seem to take into account the knock on effects, either in a different council department or in a few years down the line.

So school transport has been mentioned as a problem. School transport is expensive as kids end up in special schools miles from home as they’ve been shoe horned in as it’s the only place suitable and available. Yet these same children a few years before were perhaps in mainstream and the la said they were ok in mainstream without any support/didn’t need an ehcp as it’s all about cost cutting in that area too. Had that child had. 1-1 ta for at least some of the time early on then they may have been ok in mainstream and never needed to go to a specialist independent school costing £80k a year in fees plus transport at prob another £50k a year. Instead by the time an ehcp and 1-1 is given in mainstream things have deteriorated to such a level and child has got into a negative cycle with school thst it’s too little too late. Also transport in our la is a diff department and no consideration is made when deciding on school placement so only the cost of the placement comes into it so a child could end up at a cheaper school miles away costing more in transport than it would to go to a more expensive specialist on doorstep

Orangeandgold · 29/02/2024 03:29

I’m tired of councils mismanaging the money they do have - sometimes it’s hard to tell that they are on tight budgets. It’s ridiculous when you find out what they prioritise and invest in. No wonder they are going bust. I’ve worked on a few council projects and a common theme is appointing the wrong people and contractors. Putting so much money into new shiny ideas nobody asked for or really needed instead of bettering existing services. And it just seems like the decision makers (in some councils) are out of touch with the daily needs of people. Many are also at the mercy of developers and other private organisations which screws up their perception/influences choices.

It’s worrying. I’m in London and as we have so many boroughs it’s interesting to see how differently each work and which are for their people and those that just don’t care.

Kimchie · 29/02/2024 00:42

DontBeAPrickDarren · Yesterday 23:03

@Kimchie over 55s are very hard to make redundant as it’s so expensive as well (assuming they have long service)! I have a friend who is desperate to go but has twice been told between redundancy and pension it’s too costly to agree it.

Of course, offering voluntary redundancy must cost a fortune when you have to pay out massive packages.
I’d take a guess about 25% of the people I work with day to day have over 15 years service, some are nearing 30 years.
Most of them are major assets, loads of experience, passionate, bloody good at their jobs, a wealth of knowledge that I couldn’t have learned how to do my job without, a couple who retired recently who are very missed.
Others are just hanging on way past time and it’s draining time and money out of the service and also blocking new blood coming in which is desperately needed.
It’s against rules to even hint at retirement to these people.
No signs of redundancies yet, we are still recruiting but only short contracts which then get renewed periodically which makes sense.
Im guessing if/when redundancies are necessary it will be voluntary to start with?
I hope so, imagine some could afford to take vol redundancy as early retirement and be happy to go.

Diamondshmiamond · 29/02/2024 00:28

justasking111 · 28/02/2024 22:12

It's our young here suffering the most as well as a 15% reduction in education, the paddling pools never opened last summer, tennis courts closed. This year could be libraries. More public loos closed.

Carers for the elderly here should be means tested. Two houses in our cul de sac, elderly couple had carers up to four times a day when the neighbours couldn't help her because of intimate health issues.

Another elderly lady had two carers four times a day. We begged her son to look for a residential home, he refused .

All three had excellent pensions, a lot of investments. They deserved better care but the offspring wanted to protect their inheritances. Some people are wicked.

Social care for the elderly is means tested isn't it? Threshold is £23k in savings and if there's someone living in the home so it can't be sold yet. Anyone with more will pay.

Dm had carers x4 per day and all had to be paid by her.

Diamondshmiamond · 29/02/2024 00:21

EllieQ · 28/02/2024 20:20

It’s a rule that applies to all councils @EmmaEmerald - this document from the Local Government Association (written for councillors) explains the rules of council finance in more detail:

Local Gov Finance

I work for my local council, and we are not in danger of going bankrupt, but have had to raise council tax and cut some budgets/ services to balance the books. It’s a fairly affluent, tourist area so the high street is still busy and I’d guess there a lot of houses in the higher council tax bands.

Like others have said, it’s the cost of adult social care that is rising steeply, but most people just think about bins, roads, libraries, and perhaps schools. I often wonder how many people who complain about council tax rises also think you shouldn’t have to sell your house to pay for care - who do they think will pay for it?

Edited

We have council tax rises AND my dm is having to sell her house to pay for a care home.
I know it's a shares pot but feel we're contributing a lot for less in return.

MohairTortoise · 29/02/2024 00:13

Wrt the SEN transportation, parents who are able to can transport their children, and my council pays 45p per mile. However, the parent has to transport for an entire term in advance, then apply for the funding, get the school to fill out forms to verify attendance and wait up to 28 days for funding to be paid.
For some parents, they cannot afford to wait this long, so while I agree that checks need to be made, the long wait times mean its not viable for many parents to transport their children, even if they have access to a vehicle and the time to do it. Those children will be provided with a taxi at an eye-watering cost. I wonder if the taxi firm have to wait months to be paid?
Once my council have agreed on a start date for SEN transport via taxi, usually the first date of the term, they have one month to put a taxi outside your door. It quite often takes a month to physically see a taxi outside your door, so parents either have to keep their children home or take them themselves. If the parent transports during this time, there are no funds available to help the parent with this cost, because the council have agreed on paper to provide a taxi. Apparently its completely irrelevant that the taxi isn't physically there!
Policies such as these don't foster any trust between parents and the council so parents are even more reluctant to help out, which is a shame because a journey of just 5 miles for example can cost the council upwards of £400 a week as opposed to £22.50 a week if the parent does it.
It makes financial sense to make it easier for the parent to transport, not the taxi firms, but many SEN parents can't cope with an added round of pressure and council policy.
Another issue is that the taxi firm will only be paid if they drop the child off at their home address. This doesn't work for working parents whose children use childcare.

AnneElliott · 28/02/2024 23:36

helpfulperson · 28/02/2024 19:43

Many of you are talking about how much council tax you pay and rises in council tax. If you look at the income of a council less than 25% comes from council tax. The cost of providing all the services a council does is 4 times the amount you pay in council tax.

I'm not sure that's right. Council tax has been making up an increasing proportion of core spending power over the last few years.

The class of local authorities I engage with on average get 60% of their income from council tax and some of them it's nearly topping 70% of income from council tax.

Even policing which traditionally received proportionally less funding from council tax than other classes of authorities gets 33% of their funding by raising council tax.

DontBeAPrickDarren · 28/02/2024 23:33

fuckssaaaaake · 28/02/2024 23:24

If they go bust, what happens to business rates debt? Asking for a friend 😜

I would assume they’d double down on recovering any and all debts to plug gaps in the budget.

AnneElliott · 28/02/2024 23:32

EmmaEmerald · 28/02/2024 19:22

My council says it's okay for two years but that's why bills have to go up - they don't think they'll be okay without the rise.

I'm wondering how citizens can object to a particular rule - which I think most councils have...all advice welcome.

Mine has just made a lot of money from a land sale. They say they are "not allowed" to spend this money on services and that council receipts from such a thing can only be spent on capital expenditure projects. They are on a mission to expand the local market, which is a huge waste of money when we have issues with basic service provision....and there's no physical space to expand the market anyway! And it's not well attended.

I was wondering how this insane rule can be challenged. I suspect it can't, because a capex project means more money into the pockets of their mates.

In general yes it's the case that capital receipts can only be spent on other capital items. But the council can ask DLUHC for a 'capitalisation direction' which would allow them to spend it on revenue costs (ie running costs). You should e quite if they've asked about this - it's often the first thing DLUHc offer when a council is facing financial issues.

fuckssaaaaake · 28/02/2024 23:24

If they go bust, what happens to business rates debt? Asking for a friend 😜

platinumplus · 28/02/2024 23:23

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 28/02/2024 23:01

There is a lot of waste, a lot of time wasting, it’s hard/almost impossible to get rid of useless lazy people, everything takes ages.

I have a horrible feeling that’s the case for every single council in the UK.

Oh it is. And government agencies - I worked for one and it would take 15 people people to do the job of one person. Infuriating wastes of time all over the place.

platinumplus · 28/02/2024 23:21

Kimchie · 28/02/2024 22:41

I work for my local council in library services so very worried, we are ok for next year and possibly the year after but then reserves will be gone.
The council in general and particularly the department libraries comes under are an aging work force which brings its own challenges and pressures, lots of sickness, lots of people over the age of retirement, in some cases so old they can’t actually do the basics of the job let alone add value to the service, still being paid a full wage, full pension contributions, up to 6 months full sick pay a year, it is not allowed to even hint that these people should retire.
Very stuck in the ways of old and not able to adapt change or modernise their thinking.
Of course when redundancies come the same people will be raking it in.
That’s my main hope is that people with long service will take the voluntary redundancies and leave some jobs for the rest of us.
There is a lot of waste, a lot of time wasting, it’s hard/almost impossible to get rid of useless lazy people, everything takes ages.
From application to onboarding for my job took over 2 months, that is not normal at all in the private sector industry I moved from.
I love my job and I’m passionate about the work we do, I truly believe you cannot call yourself a civilised society without free access to libraries for all, it’s so important and the service is increasingly a lifeline for so many vulnerable people I dread to think what would happen to some of them if we couldn’t open our doors every day.

100% agree with everything you've said here.

Babyroobs · 28/02/2024 23:09

I am a little concerned as both our local city and county councils are on the verge of bankrupcy. I work for a charity and these councils seem to have cut all their provision for helping vulnerable people and told them all to come to our charity for help. For example - an elderly person needs to make a claim for housing benefit or a blue badge and can't do it online, they ask the council for help and they won't even send them a paper form and just signpost to our charity to help. We are struggling to survive, have 3 advisors for the whole city and county and are completely overwhelmed. At one time the local authorities would be dishing out funding to charities to take on the work, now we are expected to do it for nothing. I worry about vulnerable people, our waiting lists are now 3 weeks for an initial phone call back and if a benefit can't be backdated then they just miss out on money.

DontBeAPrickDarren · 28/02/2024 23:03

@Kimchie over 55s are very hard to make redundant as it’s so expensive as well (assuming they have long service)! I have a friend who is desperate to go but has twice been told between redundancy and pension it’s too costly to agree it.

Manyandyoucanwalkover · 28/02/2024 23:03

It’s already happening here!

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 28/02/2024 23:01

There is a lot of waste, a lot of time wasting, it’s hard/almost impossible to get rid of useless lazy people, everything takes ages.

I have a horrible feeling that’s the case for every single council in the UK.

DontBeAPrickDarren · 28/02/2024 23:01

justasking111 · 28/02/2024 22:36

Maximum payment for carers means tested is £100 per week in our council. I don't know how much in neighbouring councils

The means test is set nationally. Broadly, if they have income/savings/capital over £23,500 they’ll be paying the cost of care themselves in full. Councils simply don’t have the funds to cap contributions at £100/week. That’s assuming you’re in England though.

Kimchie · 28/02/2024 22:41

I work for my local council in library services so very worried, we are ok for next year and possibly the year after but then reserves will be gone.
The council in general and particularly the department libraries comes under are an aging work force which brings its own challenges and pressures, lots of sickness, lots of people over the age of retirement, in some cases so old they can’t actually do the basics of the job let alone add value to the service, still being paid a full wage, full pension contributions, up to 6 months full sick pay a year, it is not allowed to even hint that these people should retire.
Very stuck in the ways of old and not able to adapt change or modernise their thinking.
Of course when redundancies come the same people will be raking it in.
That’s my main hope is that people with long service will take the voluntary redundancies and leave some jobs for the rest of us.
There is a lot of waste, a lot of time wasting, it’s hard/almost impossible to get rid of useless lazy people, everything takes ages.
From application to onboarding for my job took over 2 months, that is not normal at all in the private sector industry I moved from.
I love my job and I’m passionate about the work we do, I truly believe you cannot call yourself a civilised society without free access to libraries for all, it’s so important and the service is increasingly a lifeline for so many vulnerable people I dread to think what would happen to some of them if we couldn’t open our doors every day.

justasking111 · 28/02/2024 22:40

I'm fed up with the roadworks related to creating cycle lanes, while the potholes increase. But I think the lanes come out of the central government purse

LightSpeeds · 28/02/2024 22:37

Slanketblanket · 28/02/2024 16:57

Ours just put up car parking every week it seems. Now to pop to the city centre it will cost you £5000 an hour. Long term it's not a good strategy as people just drive off to the free out of town shopping centre 40 mins away leaving the city centre empty.

Same with ours. And, yes, I am worried about them going bust (although bizarrely they have a bottomless pit of money for cycle lanes)!

justasking111 · 28/02/2024 22:36

DontBeAPrickDarren · 28/02/2024 22:17

It is means tested. Four double up calls a day is still likely to be cheaper than residential care and many people are better off in their own homes.

Maximum payment for carers means tested is £100 per week in our council. I don't know how much in neighbouring councils

XenoBitch · 28/02/2024 22:19

Djfjrjc2022 · 28/02/2024 22:01

After our council merged with others to form Somerset Council, our council tax is going up by 23% (from memory!). Could be worse- next town across is increasing by 163%- yes there's was lower but it's an area of deprivation and either way, crazy amount to go up by!)

Christ, that is terrifying!

DontBeAPrickDarren · 28/02/2024 22:18

CormorantStrikesBack · 28/02/2024 22:15

I mean it’s bad if the gov cancelling hs2 has caused this but why does a council need to spend £11 million on a report preparing for hs2? Am I missing something? Surely the govt would be doing all the spending of hs2 is their project?

From memory I think they had to bid to have a hub station in the area, perhaps it was that? At the time likely an “invest to save” situation thinking the hub would bring a return and then some.