Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how you remain composed? I'm going to lose my job at 11am.

189 replies

AbsolutelyCrushed · 28/02/2024 10:39

My manager has invited me to a "next steps" meeting with HR.

I'm one week away from completing probation today, and they have to give me one weeks' notice. The timing won't be a coincidence.

Essentially, I've freelanced for them for years, but they said last year they'd have to stop giving me work due to IR35 unless I accepted a full-time job. I was nervous, but did - but the project they gave me changed, and turned out to not be my skill set. I've done a fine job, the client is really happy, but it's not what I want to do. I had a chat with a director a while back and he said they think I'm great and would find me something else, and just wanted me to be happy. We agreed I'd suggest and then train up a replacement for this project, and they'd find me work closer to what I usually do, and am good at.

I've done that. Replacement is in place. Everyone is happy (client has asked if I can stay in some capacity, but all is fine). Manager last week asked me "off the record" if I'd like to go back to freelancing - I said I hadn't thought about it but enjoyed being employed. To be honest, as they made me stop all freelancing when I signed my contract with them, I don't have the clients anymore. He said he wasn't aware of any other opportunities coming up in the next 2 months but would ask around.

He's now put a meeting in for 11am with HR and I can't stop crying. I'm the breadwinner, DH can't work due to a disability, and we have a toddler who has just settled into nursery. I'm so upset. I also feel really stupid. How do I get through this without crying?

OP posts:
LadyEloise1 · 29/02/2024 14:35

Onwards and upwards @AbsolutelyCrushed
Their loss.

SquareCrumpets · 29/02/2024 10:07

You are not a failure; you tried something new, and did not find it a comfortable fit with your skillset. They value you enough to give you a month's gardening leave, and they want you to work for them again.

Anyone who does contract or consultancy work knows that work comes and goes, but your network of contacts is extremely important, because that's where you get your next job. So maintain good relations with them, because you will probably be working with them (either the company, or individuals that you have met there) again. You now have an expanded CV, and can use this as an opportunity to get some good references from them. You have a month paid to look for more work; I don't know what you do, but in my industry this is the best time of year to start looking.

IR35 is shit, though. You can jump through all the hoops, supply your own equipment, have multiple clients, work off site to your own hours, have substitute staff, etc, but (especially government-funded organisations) won't accept that you are a independent. So you end up paying more tax than permanent employees for none of the benefits. And with the fear that you can be back-taxed for arrangements that were perfectly within the rules at the time.

Nonewclothes2024 · 29/02/2024 07:11

You are not a failure, if they didn't want you they wouldn't have offered you freelance work

The RSD is horrible isn't it.

FreeRider · 29/02/2024 00:18

Ahh the old 'training your replacement' bollocks. Had that happen to me when I was just 21...been working for the company for 3 years, helped steer it through a really difficult time when it changed hands...most of the original staff were let go, we went from 6 running the office to just 2.

The new owners then decided to move to a city 30 miles away. At that time I didn't drive, and couldn't afford to learn as I'd just got married and bought a house (when interest rates were at 15%!). I could barely afford to buy clothes... I ended up with an hour long train journey with a two mile walk to a bloody awful industrial estate at the end of it.

4 months after the move they'd sacked my colleague and I was the only original member of staff left. They hired a 'assistant' for me who lived locally, I trained her up for two months and they then promptly sacked me. Like you, all I got was 1 month's pay.

That was 34 years ago and I still remember how upset I was the day I was let go. For me the worst part was the being lied to, being told that the new member of staff was 'there to help me' when in fact it turned out she'd known from the minute she was hired she would be replacing me (someone who also worked there told me so afterwards).

In your situation, I would never work for them in any capacity ever again.

skygradient · 29/02/2024 00:03

pjani · 28/02/2024 10:45

Maybe accept that you might cry but that's completely understandable.

Firstly, be open to the idea that they might have ideas about keeping you on. Hold onto some hope. Alternatively, they could and should pay you out.

I would write some notes down, about what you'd like to say, and say them through your tears. For example:

'I have done years of good work for you. I had faith in you as an employer. I lost my other clients by agreeing to work full-time with you. I think it is your responsibility not to destroy my life - given my DH who can't work due to disability and my toddler - to pay me out/ contract with me for 35 hours a week tapering off over time so I can find other clients.'

Try and go in with some fixed asks in mind. They don't want to be 'those people' and it's probably not that impossible for them as an organisation to throw £10K your way, or whatever.

Edited

I was reading and nodding along until "I think it is your responsibility not to destroy my life" jesus Christ lol you're not in primary school anymore

skygradient · 29/02/2024 00:00

"To be honest, as they made me stop all freelancing when I signed my contract with them, I don't have the clients anymore. He said he wasn't aware of any other opportunities coming up in the next 2 months but would ask around."

Can you not communicate this to him professionally?

Superduper02 · 28/02/2024 23:17

Wish you all the best OP!

ThreeLocusts · 28/02/2024 22:58

OP I have no advice that hasn't already been given, just want to add to the chorus: it's not you, it's them!

They've behaved appallingly and I hope someone there has the decency to be embarrassed. If so, milk it for all it's worth.

ICouldHaveCheckedFirst · 28/02/2024 22:07

You're right to be angry. (Been made redundant twice, though never been freelance.) Do what you need to do to get through the next few days - prepare a counter proposal as suggested above.
Also, informally, can you lean on those who praised you to introduce you to new contacts for roles where your strengths lie? Especially anyone who is feeling guilty about how they've treated you / the impact on your family life.
As has already been noted, you have united MN, so you can do anything!!

Echobelly · 28/02/2024 21:44

I hope you are OK OP.

I get made redundant tomorrow. It's a bit unsettling as last time I was made redundant it took me ages to get another job so I'm a bit nervous. Especially as DH isn't bringing in any money at the moment now as he's working on launching his own product.

This time around at least I have got experience that opens up a lot more jobs and just in time a couple of external roles have asked me to interviews (and one internal one)

I felt calm when I got the news last month, I knew my industry was having a wobbly time and that this might happen, especially as I'd only been in role 18 months and was less 'essential' than some other positions. I found the thing that set me off feeling a bit tearful was other colleagues being so helpful and supportive!

I hope things work out all right for you.🍀

OrlandointheWilderness · 28/02/2024 21:43

Hope you are having a very large glass of wine @AbsolutelyCrushed

takemeawayagain · 28/02/2024 21:37

Have they got you to train someone who will cost them a lot less than you do so they can get rid of you and save money? What a bunch of wankers. You are way too good for them.

Teenagehorrorbag · 28/02/2024 21:22

Sorry - late to the chat but IR35 was to stop 'self employed' people working for a single employer (so technically being employed but claiming all the S/E benefits).

If you were working with other clients before they took you on, then citing IR35 is bollocks! Presumably they must have had a specific job they wanted you for? Otherwise I can't understand their rationale at all?

Either way they have treated you appallingly - and I'm sorry you're so upset. But as PPs have said, use the garden leave to your benefit, and get back out there. You are obviously brilliant at what you do.

It's not you, it's them!!!

Papyrophile · 28/02/2024 21:17

It's a long time ago, and the circumstances (and tax rules) were different then but when I went freelance I only worked freelance. It was before IR35, and I worked projects that rarely exceeded 6-8 weeks; 10-12 weeks would be a huge job, first time round on a multi-year contract -- perhaps. If I got busy for a spell, I upped my rates to choke off demand. If it was slack, I dropped them a small amount. If I didn't want the work, I doubled the rate and gritted my teeth if I got it anyway.

Pricing yourself out of the picture works a treat, and never makes you a failure. You are never a fail if you are too rich for the client's budget. They find more money to pay you, or they settle for a budget option that's not what they want.

DuckDuck1234 · 28/02/2024 21:05

Sorry you're feeling down, OP. My advice would be to give yourself the rest of the week to cry/sleep/let off steam. Then come Monday, take stock. Do you want to go back to freelancing or would you prefer to look for another employee position? What are the job opportunities in your area? What do your savings look like? Once you have those answers, you can start deciding on your next steps.
Wishing you all the best.

Ger1atricMillennial · 28/02/2024 21:01

Hi OP.

If you are still reading, I hope you have had a big cry and an even bigger doughnut/shots of tequilia etc!!

Panic over your circumstances is normal but it sounds like you are extremely skilled and employable/

This is the way companies work, no-one is a family it's all about productivity. They have been strategic to do this before your probation is up. It's how it works. HR- is human resources... emphasis on the resources part and less on the human part

The option are what is best for you. You said you liked being employed, would you consider approaching competitors as the income security in your situation would be good?

Oh an any further work you do with this company will be at 3x your normal rate

Hibernatalie · 28/02/2024 20:46

Everything is going to be ok xx

YankeeDad · 28/02/2024 20:44

To me it sounds as though you have not failed at anything, and they have had a management failure in that they did not organise themselves to cope with regulatory changes while keeping you on board in the way they wanted to. They overpromised by hiring you full time when they wanted to keep access to your services, and then you did the right thing for them by training your replacement when the work that they had was not suitable for you, and now they are probably just embarrassed.

The only failure is theirs.

If “gardening leave” means you are still paid, use the time to reconnect with a broader range of clients again, and go back to freelance where you are also not so dependent on whether one particular manager at one place handles things in an effective way.

PrincessOlga · 28/02/2024 20:17

"To ask how you remain composed?"

This is not expert advice, by any means, but it is what I do.

I don't try and look on the bright side. I do the exact opposite. I get everything out of my system by imagining the very worst scenarios, like no income at all, being thrown out onto the streets, bank accounts frozen. Then, no matter what happens, it is never as bad as you think. I think we suffer from mood swings a lot, so get into that "trough" now and you will come out the other side.

Fingers crossed for you, my dear. You might be wrong, you know (oh, I hope that it is so!).

... oh, and if the worse comes to the worst, come back on here for a bit of a sob among your virtual online friends. xxx

Blanketpolicy · 28/02/2024 20:11

Those meetings are horrible, they would have done it before and seen tears before. We had 200+ redundancies at our work, in my mid 40s and worked there for 24 years, terrified of going elsewhere. We all had to apply for any jobs left (they had stripped many levels in a cost saving effort), I applied for one that I knew I could do with my eyes closed but I was too expensive for. Participated in interviews and wiped the floor with the rest of them.

The Managing director and woman from HR called me at my desk with no warning just over a week later and asked me to come to HR now. I knew it was to tell me I hadn't got it. Went in, they told me, I managed to squeeze out a "is that it? can I go now?" - must have lasted 2 mins - I went back to my office, picked up my stuff without talking to anyone, and left for the day, drove home sobbing.

Next morning, a Friday, I drove to work and couldn't bring myself to leave the carpark without crying! Texted boss and said I wasn't coming in and I'd see them on Monday.

I sent them an email the next day telling them I did not want any consultations or future meetings face to face, just email me as it was too difficult. I was fine working the 6 months before the redundancy kicked, just couldn't talk about it officially.

Embarrassing and cowardly, but it was the best way to leave feeling I had some dignity intact.

Hope things work out for you. They did for me, got another job and 10 years later I am earning over twice what I did at old place doing something much better. Should have left years before.

WuTangGran · 28/02/2024 19:53

Good luck. Training your replacement is a RED FLAG.

theduchessofspork · 28/02/2024 19:49

paintingvenice · 28/02/2024 18:39

You’ve managed to unite mumsnet. You can do anything 💐💐💐💐

Too true!!

I hope you are stuck into a glass of wine.

From all you’ve said you are very much a success, you just had a bit of bad luck.

I agree with PPs - ask for more gardening leave - ask for 3 months, you might not get it, but you might well get it up to 6 or 8 weeks as a compromise.

You want to word something terribly balanced that makes the point they’ve caused you to loose your freelance pipeline at a time when work isn’t abundant by not thinking their original offer through.

I’d write it in the morning, put a draft on here and you’ll get some good feedback.

Then take a long weekend off and do any crying you have left to do, then on Monday get onto contacting all your contacts.

6pence · 28/02/2024 19:28

You aren’t a failure. They lured you in under false pretences.

JaneKatSuttonGoals · 28/02/2024 19:09

You're not a failure OP, just trusting & they have treated you appallingly.
I would check your contract very carefully - how watertight is the compete clause? Would happy client be able to be your first new freelance client? Or at least endorse your work.

minipie · 28/02/2024 18:59

I’m not an expert but if you had various other active clients when you were freelancing for them, IR35 shouldn’t have been an issue? Isn’t IR35 about people who are really employees just dressed up as contractors (so usually have no other work)? Not your situation as a genuine multi client freelancer.

If I’m right then their pretext for wanting you as an employee was false. I am guessing the truth is more that it was less expensive for them to have you as an employee than pay freelance rates. This is supposed to be offset with greater job security, but obviously that hasn’t happened. How shitty of them.