Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think now is not the right time for tax cuts

146 replies

jm9138 · 28/02/2024 07:22

So Hunt wants to cut NI having already cut it last Autumn. The total costs of these cuts will be £13.5 bn. To put that in perspective, this would more than cover the £9bn real terms cut in the education budget since 2010 and with the total NHS dentistry bill being £3bn he could double that and cover the education budget fall with £1.5bn left. Maybe with that he could, I don’t know, fund some private operations to reduce some of the NHS waiting times. AIBU to think that maybe there are other things to focus on now than tax cuts?

OP posts:
jm9138 · 28/02/2024 09:24

Iwishicouldflyhigh · 28/02/2024 09:23

I wonder why they don't make it more attractive for companies/staff to offer their staff free private healthcare including dentistry. Ie don't tax it as a benefit and allow companies to offset against tax - it would simultaneously improve the survival rate and take the burden off of the NHS.

It seems so simple to me that there must be a reason that they don't do it.

Good idea actually. A healthy (and educated) workforce is a productive workforce. I don't think the government got the memo.

OP posts:
jm9138 · 28/02/2024 09:23

Jaydenia · 28/02/2024 09:16

A question, we were surprised when my partner started getting their state pension that they no longer had to pay NI contributions - they are still in full time employment.

If that was changed would it make much difference?

Once you reach retirement age you no longer pay NI. So they just got a 9% tax cut (or whatever the rate currently is).

OP posts:
Iwishicouldflyhigh · 28/02/2024 09:23

I wonder why they don't make it more attractive for companies/staff to offer their staff free private healthcare including dentistry. Ie don't tax it as a benefit and allow companies to offset against tax - it would simultaneously improve the survival rate and take the burden off of the NHS.

It seems so simple to me that there must be a reason that they don't do it.

TheDowagerDoughnut · 28/02/2024 09:20

Tax cuts are meaningless and forgotten almost immediately.

If they must do something about taxes (and I think they must), I'd far rather they tackle the problem of fiscal drag - both for now and the future.

Tax cut offs should raise each year with inflation.

If they also want to address why so many people leave work and retire early, there needs to be legislation that makes it possible to ease out of work more gently as you get to that age. At the moment it's still mostly a choice betwene full time or no time - but the right to reduce hours down as you get older would help keep people who wanted to work but can no longer face or do a 40 hour week. Plus, age discrimination is still rife. This might also help the pension shortages because more people could still earn something if they wanted to.

Jaydenia · 28/02/2024 09:16

A question, we were surprised when my partner started getting their state pension that they no longer had to pay NI contributions - they are still in full time employment.

If that was changed would it make much difference?

L1ttledrummergirl · 28/02/2024 09:11

lemmefinish · 28/02/2024 08:36

The real problem is why 10 million working age people are not working. And we keep importing cheap labour and adding to the pool of net recipients in the economy. All thanks to 25 years of economic mismanagement.

Its 9.2m & the recent increase is largely due to the silver exodus of 500k mainly due to health.

The people I know who don't work are either:
out of work because it's unsafe in the workplace due to disabilities, bullying, being unable to advocate for themselves.
Bedbound and on a hospital list for years without treatment.
Stay at home parent as childcare is more expensive than minimum wage salary.

Essentially government mismanagement.

jm9138 · 28/02/2024 09:09

Alcyoneus · 28/02/2024 08:55

Your anecdotes about your local school should not form the basis of tax policy. The inputs are way more complex.

Oh dear. So what about the real terms cuts in education and dentistry - are they not facts?

Have you had your head in the sand about access to NHS dentistry?

As about my anecdotes - yes you are right they are anecdotes. Does not stop them being true. But just specifically on music have a read of this (from 6 years ago and do you think things have improved?):

https://www.sussex.ac.uk/broadcast/read/46367

I don't read the Guardian. I don't read the Mail, Express or Telegraph either. I would not call myself a socialist and the left wing people I know definitely wouldn't. I think everyone should contribute something whatever they earn and would be happy with a single flat tax rate so those that earn more pay more but not proportionally more. I think the majority of things should be kept out of Government control. But I also think some things have to be delivered by Government and if there is money to throw around and those things that should be delivered are not being because of lack of funds I will question whether government priorities are right.

Your comment on wealth tax. You do know the French still have a wealth tax don't you? It is just based on property value now. I would still go for something like this, but acknowledge it can be complicated. I think the bigger fairness issue is the failure to adequately tax unearned income in the same way as earned income.

Music education at significant risk of disappearing as a sustained curriculum offer no longer the norm in secondary

New research shows an increasing number of schools have reduced or completely removed music in the curriculum for lower secondary school students.

https://www.sussex.ac.uk/broadcast/read/46367

OP posts:
Whatafustercluck · 28/02/2024 09:08

Well, there's a general election around the corner, op, and the Tories are desperate to cling on to power - did you seriously expect any different from them? They have form for the Great Pre Election Taxation Reduction Bribary. So yabu to expect any different.

To be serious for a moment though, the easiest taxes to reduce are the most visible ones - NI and income tax. When those get reduced, the electorate notice it, and sometimes vote accordingly. Add the cost of living crisis, and on the face of it, it's a really welcome relief.

Only when they need the NHS or education, or other public services, will they realise how short sighted it is. Tories are amazing at stealth taxes. Look up local council tax gearing effect. Since 2010 they've systematically reduced central funding for local authorities, with the result that council tax levy has increased and the public picks up the bill through increased local taxation. The LA gets the blame, the government largely gets away with it because they can blame the LAs for not spending money wisely enough. Fewer NHS dentists? Denplan. That's enforced privatisation - another form of taxation, except it's 'optional'. But if you don't pay it, and you can't find an NHS dentist then you're fucked. Fewer police? Raise council tax.

NI contributions pay for the state pension of course. But cuts won't affect today's pensioners (who are more traditionally, born out with statistics, Conservative voters), it will affect those who need a state pension in a few decades. So the can is kicked down the road in favour of a quick fix today, in the Great Pre Election Tax Reduction Bribary.

Newbutoldfather · 28/02/2024 09:08

@lemmefinish ,

General wealth taxes don’t as they hit the moderately wealthy, whereas the truly wealthy duck them.

Property taxes do work and have worked. If you scaled up the old ‘rates’ to today’s values, that would be a significant tax contribution. And they are fair, the owner of the property has to pay the tax, no issues of residency etc.

Notonthestairs · 28/02/2024 09:01

"The real problem is why 10 million working age people are not working. "

That's a soundbite. .

To think now is not the right time for tax cuts
MiltonNorthern · 28/02/2024 09:01

Isn't this the same stupid policy proposal that tanked the mortgage market last year?

lemmefinish · 28/02/2024 09:00

Wealth taxes do not work. Macron scrapped them in 2017 after coming to power because saw that the actions of his socialist predecessor had led to reduced tax take from the rich as they were leaving the country. He roles back taxes, calling France ‘Cuba without the sun’

Taxes in general are pretty different in France

KimberleyClark · 28/02/2024 08:57

Of course not. Just voter bribes.

TheGoogleMum · 28/02/2024 08:57

Yes instead of cutting taxes use the money to improve services! Everyone knows the nhs is on its knees. Schools and police are underfunded. Birmingham council has gone bust they're going to close most of their libraries. And yet there was a surplus in January and they want to cut taxes....

Newbutoldfather · 28/02/2024 08:56

@jm9138 ,

‘I think they are so terrified that the monied would leave the country they dare not do this. Oh sorry, did I say monied - 'wealth generators' is the term isn't it. Given you don't pay any tax on wealth I don't really care where they go’

The wealthy always try to appeal to be taxed at a low rate by saying that they will leave if not. But they don’t, bar a tiny minority.

The bankers and hedgies played that bluff with the 50% top rate. A few hedgies decamped to Geneva and came back with their tails between their legs when it was lowered to 45%. People have families here, schools, friends….

lemmefinish · 28/02/2024 08:55

I think they are so terrified that the monied would leave the country they dare not do this. Oh sorry, did I say monied - 'wealth generators' is the term isn't it.

The wealth generators tend to be mobile already. It’s the older population with a property that’s increased massively, potentially a BTL or holiday home. I think 1 in 7 over 70s has a 2nd home. That’s the core vote though & so they won’t upset them. There are also more over 65s now than under 15s.

Disclaimer: Not bashing boomers, realise they aren’t all rich, blah blah blah.

Alcyoneus · 28/02/2024 08:55

jm9138 · 28/02/2024 08:52

So which of the things did I state were not facts? Your facts are also true and I would agree we need to broaden the net of where we get tax.

Your anecdotes about your local school should not form the basis of tax policy. The inputs are way more complex.

Soozikinzii · 28/02/2024 08:54

I also agree .That money is needed for basics like education and dentistry. They've completely lost the plot and think its OK for us to live like it's a third world country. While spraying money around interfering in other countries business like were still some Victorian superpower !

Alcyoneus · 28/02/2024 08:54

jm9138 · 28/02/2024 08:50

Completely agree.

I think they are so terrified that the monied would leave the country they dare not do this. Oh sorry, did I say monied - 'wealth generators' is the term isn't it. Given you don't pay any tax on wealth I don't really care where they go.

Oh dear. Do you actually have any objective facts or knowledge to back what you say or just regurgitating whatever you read in Guardian.

Wealth taxes do not work. Macron scrapped them in 2017 after coming to power because saw that the actions of his socialist predecessor had led to reduced tax take from the rich as they were leaving the country. He roles back taxes, calling France ‘Cuba without the sun’

jm9138 · 28/02/2024 08:53

lemmefinish · 28/02/2024 08:49

Why don’t we invest massively in social housing. Long term it would stop tax for housing benefit ending up in private hands, better standard of homes can improve health outcomes. Housing is the root of so much of our economic problems.

I couldn't agree more. Somehow social housing became a dirty concept.

OP posts:
jm9138 · 28/02/2024 08:52

Alcyoneus · 28/02/2024 08:50

Only facts are true. Everything else is just an opinion.

Facts are that the tax take has not been higher since WW2 and proportion of net contributors is now below 50%.

Edited

So which of the things did I state were not facts? Your facts are also true and I would agree we need to broaden the net of where we get tax.

OP posts:
lemmefinish · 28/02/2024 08:51

or Kier.

lemmefinish · 28/02/2024 08:51

Our net tax is already one of the lowest in G7.

But the burden is unequal which is a problem. Look at the % tax Rishi paid.

jm9138 · 28/02/2024 08:50

Newbutoldfather · 28/02/2024 08:43

Two of the single best tax reforms he could do are:

A proper property tax. As this would be paid on property, you couldn’t dodge it by the owner being a Cayman Island SPV etc. You own a £5mio property, you pay a decent annual tax on it. This would raise significant revenue, and cause absentee owners to think carefully about holding empty property.

CGT should be paid at your personal highest tax rate. Again, this would raise decent revenue and stop things like share but backs in favour of decent dividends. Again, this is clearly both efficient and fair. Of course, they should also bring back indexation, as it is unfair to pay CGT on inflation.

For some reason, no one is keen on either of the above, probably because the majority of MPs would pay more tax.

Completely agree.

I think they are so terrified that the monied would leave the country they dare not do this. Oh sorry, did I say monied - 'wealth generators' is the term isn't it. Given you don't pay any tax on wealth I don't really care where they go.

OP posts:
Alcyoneus · 28/02/2024 08:50

jm9138 · 28/02/2024 08:45

Several things can be true at the same time. It is true that their will be some level of incompetence (although I think the corruption is at a higher level than the civil service), it is true that we need to help more people into work and it is true that we have had economic mismanagement for a good while now. It is true we would all love to pay lower taxes and it is true that the tax burned is increasingly falling on middle income earners whilst those with the most often contribute the least. But it is also true that the education budget is 9% lower in real terms than 2010 and the dental budget I think is 50% lower in real terms.

It is true that this means that the curriculum has been paired back in schools to the point where my local high school has no out of school options at all - no sports teams, no school band, no school plays. They cannot even afford a specialist language teacher and the building from the 50s has needed replacing for at least 10 years. It is true that the dental cuts mean that vast swathes of the country have no access to NHS dentistry and that the nearest NHS dentist to my market town is 70 miles away and the nearest anyone can actually register with over 100 miles away.

Only facts are true. Everything else is just an opinion.

Facts are that the tax take has not been higher since WW2 and proportion of net contributors is now below 50%.

Swipe left for the next trending thread