Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think now is not the right time for tax cuts

146 replies

jm9138 · 28/02/2024 07:22

So Hunt wants to cut NI having already cut it last Autumn. The total costs of these cuts will be £13.5 bn. To put that in perspective, this would more than cover the £9bn real terms cut in the education budget since 2010 and with the total NHS dentistry bill being £3bn he could double that and cover the education budget fall with £1.5bn left. Maybe with that he could, I don’t know, fund some private operations to reduce some of the NHS waiting times. AIBU to think that maybe there are other things to focus on now than tax cuts?

OP posts:
caringcarer · 28/02/2024 10:22

Yes as a lower percentage of income will go on rent and heating.

Heatpumphero · 28/02/2024 10:18

At least NI us one thing that the Scottish government cannot control. So an NI cut is actually a tax cut for Scot’s. But now they have ramped up income tax even more to compensate so we only got to enjoy a cut from Jan - March.

And I know people talk of fiscal drag but the higher tax rate starts at £43k here and is 41% not 40%.

And the SNP MPs are talking about walking out of Westminster today like the stroppy teenagers they are. Yes the Tory party are a bunch of corrupt idiots, but I would actually prefer that to the intellectually challenged 5 year olds that comprise the SNP.

rant over

Hollowgast · 28/02/2024 10:10

jm9138 · 28/02/2024 10:05

But if he cuts the NI then this is, in theory, money he could have spent on these things. In all reality he will cut taxes when we don't have the capacity to do so and let the next Government fix the mess.

Theoretically yes, but there's no sign of any desire to do so. Cutting taxes will just make stuff worse, they'll have to further underfund things ☹️

PingvsPong · 28/02/2024 10:09

user1494050295 · 28/02/2024 07:25

To add, I live in a borough with high council tax. Excellent amenities and schools and hospitals. You get what you pay for

Wrong.
Unless the majority of your borough's income comes from Council Tax the funding hole in various councils is due to a lack of central government funding PLUS a lack of other revenue sources, e.g. business rates.

Areas with the highest council tax are some of the most deprived like Burnley.
https://www.taxpayersalliance.com/britains_council_tax_burdens_2023

A deprived area has the double burden of many being exempted, so not paying in the first place and usually a lack of commerce that reduces the take in business rates, you can whack the c.tax as high as you want but the issue is not the 'well-off' paying loads it's the number of people not paying.

That's why central funding is a leveller but the gov has withdrawn a lot and blamed it on councils. Sure there's been mismanagement but this ius also the cause. The areas most in need of funding are the least likely to be able to generate it.

Britain’s council tax burdens

This research compares average band D council tax for the year 2023-24 against house prices and median gross pay in the local authority areas of Great Britain. Many of the trends identified in an earlier TPA study in 2021 have continued, with far highe...

https://www.taxpayersalliance.com/britains_council_tax_burdens_2023

jm9138 · 28/02/2024 10:05

Hollowgast · 28/02/2024 10:02

I don't think that cancelling the tax cuts will allow for the things you mentioned. We desperately need those things right now, with our current tax level. We'd have to increase taxes by the same amount if we wanted to fund those (frankly excellent) ideas.

But if he cuts the NI then this is, in theory, money he could have spent on these things. In all reality he will cut taxes when we don't have the capacity to do so and let the next Government fix the mess.

OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 28/02/2024 10:05

Heatpumphero
That's very interesting and sad to hear. It's not an area I know much about.
Many many years ago I considered whether moving to Scotland would be something for us to consider because it seemed so much better from what I'd heard, but then friends said that having taught in both systems the Scottish system has much lower academic standards.
The last few years of SNP politics have put me off consider it any time soon.

jm9138 · 28/02/2024 10:03

LolaSmiles · 28/02/2024 09:54

The problem with taxes for the last decade is that it's not been spent properly on delivering good public services. A lot of the money is being given to private companies, often with links to those in power, to run public services on private contracts. There's a difference between the two.
For an organisation to be making profit running public services, not all taxpayer's money is being spent on the service. It isn't average people who are benefitting from this arrangement.

Just looking at education as an example, there's some MAT CEOs who are paid hundreds of thousands of pounds and are giving themselves £9,000-10,000 pay increases when schools have teachers paying for glue sticks and resources out their own pocket.

I don't necessarily think that private companies delivering public services is always a bad thing. But they don't need to be everywhere and the way they are managed is pretty appalling on the whole - and this includes allowing management to award themselves massive pay rises when performance is poor.

OP posts:
Hollowgast · 28/02/2024 10:02

jm9138 · 28/02/2024 07:22

So Hunt wants to cut NI having already cut it last Autumn. The total costs of these cuts will be £13.5 bn. To put that in perspective, this would more than cover the £9bn real terms cut in the education budget since 2010 and with the total NHS dentistry bill being £3bn he could double that and cover the education budget fall with £1.5bn left. Maybe with that he could, I don’t know, fund some private operations to reduce some of the NHS waiting times. AIBU to think that maybe there are other things to focus on now than tax cuts?

I don't think that cancelling the tax cuts will allow for the things you mentioned. We desperately need those things right now, with our current tax level. We'd have to increase taxes by the same amount if we wanted to fund those (frankly excellent) ideas.

Heatpumphero · 28/02/2024 10:02

Scotland here. Just a reminder that it’s possible to pay sky high taxes and have diabolical public services. We pay circa £700 extra in income tax a month in our household, and we paid double the stamp duty we would have had in England. The education system has dropped like a stone in the international league tables. The waiting list for CAMHS is over 3 years, the number of university places is being hacked at every year to reduce costs (and you cannot even ask to pay tuition fees like the do in England, leading to English kids getting into my local uni while Scot’s with better grades being barred!!!).

You cannot book a holiday on an island in the summer without having real fears that there won’t be a ferry to take you, and one of the most obese countries in Europe is shutting leisure centres at a time when the first minister is sending government money to terrorists in Gaza.

And yet all that we get from those in charge here is Gaza, Gaza, Gaza. Like we don’t have any other problems to worry about.

and yes we are looking to move.

ThreeFeetTall · 28/02/2024 10:00

If people having a bit more money to spend stimulates the economy then would this also be the case is energy bills and rents were lower?

jm9138 · 28/02/2024 09:57

caringcarer · 28/02/2024 09:36

Cutting taxes stimulates the economy for growth. People have a little bit more money to spend. As the economy grows wages rise and people pay more tax. Revenue paid in taxes pays for Hospital, schools etc.

Ah the old virtuous circle and/or where are we on the Laffer curve. It entirely depends on what people spend the money on, propensities to consume, whether the tax cuts just fuel inflation. Let's hope you are right. Funnily enough this was/is broadly central to Liz Truss's ideas as well.

Just one point not necessarily related to your post but to a PP and the highest tax rate since the Second World War. Most public services are luxury goods - the more we earn the more we want to spend on these services as a proportion of our income (Health and education etc). So it would be entirely reasonable to assume that as the country gets richer tax would make up a bigger proportion of GDP.

OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 28/02/2024 09:54

The problem with taxes for the last decade is that it's not been spent properly on delivering good public services. A lot of the money is being given to private companies, often with links to those in power, to run public services on private contracts. There's a difference between the two.
For an organisation to be making profit running public services, not all taxpayer's money is being spent on the service. It isn't average people who are benefitting from this arrangement.

Just looking at education as an example, there's some MAT CEOs who are paid hundreds of thousands of pounds and are giving themselves £9,000-10,000 pay increases when schools have teachers paying for glue sticks and resources out their own pocket.

GasPanic · 28/02/2024 09:53

user1494050295 · 28/02/2024 07:25

To add, I live in a borough with high council tax. Excellent amenities and schools and hospitals. You get what you pay for

Can you tell us where this is please ?

Lifeinlists · 28/02/2024 09:49

user1494050295 · 28/02/2024 07:25

To add, I live in a borough with high council tax. Excellent amenities and schools and hospitals. You get what you pay for

You don't get what you pay for if you live in Birmingham, that's for sure, and that's with a 20% CTax rise in the next 2 years. Lucky you having such a well run council. Not all of us are so fortunate but I get your general point.

Barleypilaf · 28/02/2024 09:48

ZebraPensAreLife · 28/02/2024 07:34

Higher earners (on PAYE at least) already pay enough. We need to tax wealth rather than income. Agree the Tories won’t do that, though, because they won’t upset their mates.

This. Income tax is very high, but wealth is very low.

jm9138 · 28/02/2024 09:45

kirbykirby · 28/02/2024 09:32

Well, they can cut public sector pensions and welfare. It's unsustainable for them to be going up by 5/10% per year regardless of productivity whilst the private sector (which pays for it all) either has no pay increases or small amounts. The future unfunded public sector pensions bill is running into the trillions now. How is that going to be paid? By the younger generations who will pay more tax and get less services?

And people will vote with their feet when it comes to paying more tax, they will simply either stop working and jump on the bandwagon or reduce their hours to part time so they don't breach the tax threshold. I know a few people who have got so fed up they have already done this. Very few martyrs who want to pay more tax for less in return.

The ratio of those who pay tax to those who don't is already completely screwed. It's unsustainable whether you like it or not.

I think we are conflating things here. There is nothing to stop several things happening at the same time. Public sector services can be underfunded and collapsing, welfare bills and taxes can be too high, the balance of tax and from who it is drawn can need rebalancing and causing collapse in the private sector. Of all the things that need to happen though choosing to cut taxes when your public services are collapsing does not seem - to me - the right choice.

OP posts:
lemmefinish · 28/02/2024 09:42

wasn’t 20% VAT meant to be temporary?

GasPanic · 28/02/2024 09:40

They can cut the council tax any time they want.

The services we get for the money we pay are appalling. So better off paying less.

Not to mention the fines when the slightest thing is done wrong.

It's like paying someone to punch you in the face.

caringcarer · 28/02/2024 09:39

Hereyoume · 28/02/2024 08:19

True.

But more importantly, people should demand that money (our money) is spent on things that actually benefit us. Because a huge amount of money is being wasted, and our public services could be so much better. The money is there, it's just not used in the most appropriate way.

We literally gave away 7 Billion last year on foreign aid. That would have paid for an extra 175,000 police officers or nurses.

This year it will be over 8 billion pounds that we literally give away.

How can the government claim poverty when they literally give away tens of billions of pounds to other countries.

And don't give me the "it's the law" bollocks, they can change the law.

We are all being taken for fools.

I think we give away far too much for a country with so much debt borrowing.

lemmefinish · 28/02/2024 09:38

@Newbutoldfather I would include property taxes in general wealth taxes

caringcarer · 28/02/2024 09:36

Cutting taxes stimulates the economy for growth. People have a little bit more money to spend. As the economy grows wages rise and people pay more tax. Revenue paid in taxes pays for Hospital, schools etc.

kirbykirby · 28/02/2024 09:34

Alcyoneus · 28/02/2024 08:33

Is is ALWAYS the right time for tax cuts. Taxes have never been higher (since WW2 anyway) Public services have never had more money. And never performed worse than they do today. It is lazy thinking to keep throwing more taxed, borrowed and printed money at corrupt incompetent government departments.

The real problem is why 10 million working age people are not working. And we keep importing cheap labour and adding to the pool of net recipients in the economy. All thanks to 25 years of economic mismanagement.

Perhaps think beyond the soundbites and ask questions other than how to throw other people’s money at this problem.

Totally agree!

Cattenberg · 28/02/2024 09:33

YANBU. It’s as though the Tories are on a different planet. I’ve never known public services to be in such a dire state and after 14 years in power, the government needs to stop trying to blame Labour.

kirbykirby · 28/02/2024 09:32

jm9138 · 28/02/2024 08:17

Ah well first good laugh of the morning. I agree we should shift the tax burden to unearned income, but we have had 14 years of 'reducing waste'. Looking at the state of public services I think we moved past 'waste' some time ago and have stopped even pretending we even stock the fridge for several years.

Inefficiencies can be found anywhere - but that cuts both ways. You can be inefficient because you fail to dedicate enough resources to actually meet the minimum outcomes you need from a service.

Well, they can cut public sector pensions and welfare. It's unsustainable for them to be going up by 5/10% per year regardless of productivity whilst the private sector (which pays for it all) either has no pay increases or small amounts. The future unfunded public sector pensions bill is running into the trillions now. How is that going to be paid? By the younger generations who will pay more tax and get less services?

And people will vote with their feet when it comes to paying more tax, they will simply either stop working and jump on the bandwagon or reduce their hours to part time so they don't breach the tax threshold. I know a few people who have got so fed up they have already done this. Very few martyrs who want to pay more tax for less in return.

The ratio of those who pay tax to those who don't is already completely screwed. It's unsustainable whether you like it or not.

jm9138 · 28/02/2024 09:27

If they also want to address why so many people leave work and retire early, there needs to be legislation that makes it possible to ease out of work more gently as you get to that age. At the moment it's still mostly a choice betwene full time or no time - but the right to reduce hours down as you get older would help keep people who wanted to work but can no longer face or do a 40 hour week. Plus, age discrimination is still rife. This might also help the pension shortages because more people could still earn something if they wanted to.

A good point. I am afraid ideas are something all parties seem to be short of at the moment.

OP posts: