Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think now is not the right time for tax cuts

146 replies

jm9138 · 28/02/2024 07:22

So Hunt wants to cut NI having already cut it last Autumn. The total costs of these cuts will be £13.5 bn. To put that in perspective, this would more than cover the £9bn real terms cut in the education budget since 2010 and with the total NHS dentistry bill being £3bn he could double that and cover the education budget fall with £1.5bn left. Maybe with that he could, I don’t know, fund some private operations to reduce some of the NHS waiting times. AIBU to think that maybe there are other things to focus on now than tax cuts?

OP posts:
LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 28/02/2024 13:54

jm9138 · 28/02/2024 13:39

If he has £13.5 bn to fund an NI cut because he has more tax revenue than expected, then he could use that £13.5 bn instead to increase funding to core services as I outlined in my original post. He has found some money on the magic money tree and he is choosing to spend it one way when others are available. Or am I missing something?

Ok but we are in a cost of living crisis, people are struggling. They could also do with having that additional money themselves to pay for food, energy, childcare etc.

The 13.5 isn’t something that is magically appearing, it is being paid by the people.

IpanemaCaipirinha · 28/02/2024 13:47

Wealth taxes do not work. Macron scrapped them in 2017

Not true, they were going to cut the social charges but kept them after Covid happened. This will continue until 2048 I think. France very much does have wealth taxes, we will pay the same income tax there, 45% same as here, but we will have to pay an extra 9 and 12% tax on our income, plus extra tax on my shares etc despite the double tax agreement with the U.K.

However this is worth it IMO for better public services, functional healthcare/dentistry, cheaper childcare, cheaper higher education costs etc.

Also France has high corporation tax but attracts the most foreign investment year on year.

Gatorpickle · 28/02/2024 13:44

I am saying that the situation is massively complex, involving millions of stakeholders, and unless you've got experience dealing with that level is complexity you won't understand how difficult it is. It's not like a household budget where you can say "Well, if we reduce the amount of money we spend on haircuts and days out we'll have more money to spend on electricity so therefore we can have the heating on longer".

jm9138 · 28/02/2024 13:41

Gatorpickle · 28/02/2024 13:41

Yes. You are missing something unless you are a budget holder responsible for managing billions of pounds of tax payer revenue.

I am sorry I really don't get what you are trying to say

OP posts:
Gatorpickle · 28/02/2024 13:41

Yes. You are missing something unless you are a budget holder responsible for managing billions of pounds of tax payer revenue.

jm9138 · 28/02/2024 13:40

Gatorpickle · 28/02/2024 13:37

And that would work how, exactly?

I seem to have responded to the wrong post in my post that you responded to by the way.

OP posts:
jm9138 · 28/02/2024 13:39

Gatorpickle · 28/02/2024 13:37

And that would work how, exactly?

If he has £13.5 bn to fund an NI cut because he has more tax revenue than expected, then he could use that £13.5 bn instead to increase funding to core services as I outlined in my original post. He has found some money on the magic money tree and he is choosing to spend it one way when others are available. Or am I missing something?

OP posts:
Gatorpickle · 28/02/2024 13:37

jm9138 · 28/02/2024 07:29

But this is not about asking you to pay more NI. Instead of paying less NI Hunt could instead choose you just pay the same but have significantly better services.

And that would work how, exactly?

Vod · 28/02/2024 13:05

SpinyNorma · 28/02/2024 12:58

NI is one of the crappest taxes going. It's baffling in this day and age that a tax exists which applies only to income from work but not other forms of income. Transitioning away from it with gradual cuts offset by freezing income tax bands is pretty progressive really.

True enough about NI. I'm not generally a fan of using fiscal drag to raise tax for practical purposes whilst not explaining that's what you're doing... but NI is an appalling system now. Erosion of it is progressive. Ideally it wouldn't exist as a separate thing at all and be incorporated into income tax. It's deranged as well as disgusting to have a separate tax in all but name, that only applies to people of certain ages and disproportionately on money earned through work.

SpinyNorma · 28/02/2024 12:58

NI is one of the crappest taxes going. It's baffling in this day and age that a tax exists which applies only to income from work but not other forms of income. Transitioning away from it with gradual cuts offset by freezing income tax bands is pretty progressive really.

LaCouleurDeMonCiel · 28/02/2024 12:29

user1494050295 · 28/02/2024 07:25

To add, I live in a borough with high council tax. Excellent amenities and schools and hospitals. You get what you pay for

I live in Wandsworth, one of the lowest council tax in the country, and great council services:

  • several outstanding schools
  • bins collected weekly
  • prompt reaction from the council when reporting fly tipping or pot holes.
  • several libraries at walking distance, one refurbished last year, open at the weekend
and the list goes on!
jm9138 · 28/02/2024 12:27

Newbutoldfather · 28/02/2024 11:51

We should abolish NI and just roll it into general income tax.

It was, in the old days, effectively what it said on the packet. You paid in NI and this was insurance for using the NHS and a basic pension (and maybe some other stuff which I forget). That is why you don’t pay it on retirement, as you have already fully bought your pension.

It used to be, at least theoretically, ring fenced. Then, a while ago, they removed the ring fence and it just became a weird extra non-progressive tax for the government to play around with in our overly complex tax system.

And the government should also look at CGT on people’s primary residence. It is a tough one, as you want a mobile population, but maybe this could be done and stamp duty drastically reduced. Again, this would discourage people leveraging up and using their home as a tax efficient investment vehicle and maybe invest more in our stock market and, thus, increase productivity.

We don’t need less tax, we need a far simpler, fairer tax system, which encourages hard work and investment and not expensive houses and share buy backs (which help top rate tax payers vs disadvantaging ordinary pensioners).

Excellent post. Thank you. Agree with all your points.

OP posts:
jm9138 · 28/02/2024 12:26

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 28/02/2024 11:48

The point is that if there is inflation but no increases in tax bands then there is actually a tax rise. You can then call something a cut without it actually being cut.

Well yes but you have the choice of what to do with that money - you could also increase spending and say 'I am increasing spending'. I get what you are saying that overall taxes have risen with inflation but I am arguing what I think should happen with that money, not how it got there.

OP posts:
Newbutoldfather · 28/02/2024 11:51

We should abolish NI and just roll it into general income tax.

It was, in the old days, effectively what it said on the packet. You paid in NI and this was insurance for using the NHS and a basic pension (and maybe some other stuff which I forget). That is why you don’t pay it on retirement, as you have already fully bought your pension.

It used to be, at least theoretically, ring fenced. Then, a while ago, they removed the ring fence and it just became a weird extra non-progressive tax for the government to play around with in our overly complex tax system.

And the government should also look at CGT on people’s primary residence. It is a tough one, as you want a mobile population, but maybe this could be done and stamp duty drastically reduced. Again, this would discourage people leveraging up and using their home as a tax efficient investment vehicle and maybe invest more in our stock market and, thus, increase productivity.

We don’t need less tax, we need a far simpler, fairer tax system, which encourages hard work and investment and not expensive houses and share buy backs (which help top rate tax payers vs disadvantaging ordinary pensioners).

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 28/02/2024 11:48

jm9138 · 28/02/2024 11:43

If they have more tax revenue because of inflation then they have a choice as to whether to use this revenue to actually get funding levels for services back to what they need to be or give some of it back. I think they should use it to better fund public services that have been cut so much there isn't, in some instances, any service still available.

The point is that if there is inflation but no increases in tax bands then there is actually a tax rise. You can then call something a cut without it actually being cut.

jm9138 · 28/02/2024 11:43

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 28/02/2024 11:14

Due to inflation tax has actually increased due to a lack of increase in the tax bands. Therefore they can introduce a tax cut without it actually cutting taxes.

If they have more tax revenue because of inflation then they have a choice as to whether to use this revenue to actually get funding levels for services back to what they need to be or give some of it back. I think they should use it to better fund public services that have been cut so much there isn't, in some instances, any service still available.

OP posts:
LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 28/02/2024 11:14

Due to inflation tax has actually increased due to a lack of increase in the tax bands. Therefore they can introduce a tax cut without it actually cutting taxes.

Heatpumphero · 28/02/2024 10:53

If I were making changes to tax I would:

Make nil rate bands, childcare free hours and child benefit universal, and drop the VAT registration threshold to £10k to get rid of the marginal tax rate disincentives to earn more at the same time as increasing each income tax band by a percent or so to offset this.

Ditch stamp duty and increase council tax to offset this, incentivising people to live in a house that meets their needs best.

Some long term investment in health initiatives to get the long term sick off benefits, and as above the investment in more social housing would help reduce costs to this country in the long term too.

GasPanic · 28/02/2024 10:52

PAYE are just the cash cow. Both parties milk it because it is an easy target.

If Labour were serious about taxing the rich and wealth inequality they will implement a wealth tax. But I can pretty much guarantee you there will be absolutely zero about doing that in their manifesto.

You have a choice. Tories high PAYE tax, crap services or Labour high PAYE tax, crap services.

lemmefinish · 28/02/2024 10:46

Anything to get more people working, and people working more is a good thing when we have severe staff/skills shortages in so many areas. We have too many people who could work but don't and who could work more hours/days, but don't. We need to chip away at the reasons why that is.

i work p/t, f/t would mean i’m in the 55-60k bracket. Factor in additional childcare, transport costs & impact to my time after tax it’s not worth it.

I know lots of people who overpay pension or reduce hours to keep under 100k to get free hours.

Child benefit should be universal.

It's time to look at the bigger picture rather than constantly increasing tax on the easy target of workers under PAYE!

Agree

bingoitsadingo · 28/02/2024 10:44

At least it’s NI they’re suggesting cutting, a tax which disproportionately affects young people, low earners and people with inconsistent incomes. personally I’d bin NI entirely and just roll it into income tax rates, but cutting NI is at least befitting the right people

CasperGutman · 28/02/2024 10:35

YANBU. Public services are on their knees. I grew up in a deprived industrial town in the 1980s. There were concert halls, art galleries, museums, leisure centres, swimming pools, theatres and manicured public parks. They're all under threat now, if not already closed.

If we could afford all these coming out of the 1970s, why are we choosing to allow them to fail now?

Education, social care, housing and health services are all getting worse too, while need is increasing.

Civilisation is in decline in the UK.

Diefrausagtnein · 28/02/2024 10:35

@taxguru what’s your opinion on the low wage economy ? That most are on benefits precisely because they aren’t paid enough…..

Diefrausagtnein · 28/02/2024 10:33

user1494050295 · 28/02/2024 07:25

To add, I live in a borough with high council tax. Excellent amenities and schools and hospitals. You get what you pay for

Are your ‘excellent services and amenities’ precisely that because you live in an affluent area where there are not as many demands for social care and other council spending etc ? We live in a borough where many of our libraries and council leisure centres have been shut or use restricted because of financial constraints, it’s an area with a lot of economic deprivation and low quality housing. The council is struggling to meet statutory requirements.
I don’t agree with lowering taxes either btw.

taxguru · 28/02/2024 10:30

Anything to get more people working, and people working more is a good thing when we have severe staff/skills shortages in so many areas. We have too many people who could work but don't and who could work more hours/days, but don't. We need to chip away at the reasons why that is. Some of the bigger reasons are the tax cliff edges, the way benefits reduce if you earn a little more, the earnings level where marginal tax (deductions) are over 60/70%, etc. There needs to be fewer disincentives for people to sit on their arses. An NIC cut is one small step, just as raising the tax free allowance and aligning the NIC threshold with tax threshold have been small steps.

Holding the £50k higher rate threshold, whilst cutting NIC, WILL help workers but it won't help those who don't have wages but otherwise have enjoyed relative low tax levels for a couple of decades, i.e. higher income pensioners, buy to let investors, etc. This latter group have had it good for a long time and it's time that tax changes started to impact them more than workers.

Getting more people working, and people working more will do far more good for the country than squeezing workers more!! It grows the economy, fills job vacancies, and those people working and working more will be paying more tax in to fund better public services. It's time to look at the bigger picture rather than constantly increasing tax on the easy target of workers under PAYE!