Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think now is not the right time for tax cuts

146 replies

jm9138 · 28/02/2024 07:22

So Hunt wants to cut NI having already cut it last Autumn. The total costs of these cuts will be £13.5 bn. To put that in perspective, this would more than cover the £9bn real terms cut in the education budget since 2010 and with the total NHS dentistry bill being £3bn he could double that and cover the education budget fall with £1.5bn left. Maybe with that he could, I don’t know, fund some private operations to reduce some of the NHS waiting times. AIBU to think that maybe there are other things to focus on now than tax cuts?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Newbutoldfather · 28/02/2024 17:38

Passive income and active income is a bit of a false distinction. They should be taxed the same, which means paying CGT at one’s top rate of income tax.

If you have saved and invested, you have made those investments out of taxed income, so to tax the earnings on that at a punitive rate is unfair. Also, if you run a business, you shouldn’t care what element you draw as salary and what as dividends.

Redlarge · 28/02/2024 16:47

Absolutely not when our debt has increased so much in last 5 years.

user1494050295 · 28/02/2024 16:28

PingvsPong · 28/02/2024 10:09

Wrong.
Unless the majority of your borough's income comes from Council Tax the funding hole in various councils is due to a lack of central government funding PLUS a lack of other revenue sources, e.g. business rates.

Areas with the highest council tax are some of the most deprived like Burnley.
https://www.taxpayersalliance.com/britains_council_tax_burdens_2023

A deprived area has the double burden of many being exempted, so not paying in the first place and usually a lack of commerce that reduces the take in business rates, you can whack the c.tax as high as you want but the issue is not the 'well-off' paying loads it's the number of people not paying.

That's why central funding is a leveller but the gov has withdrawn a lot and blamed it on councils. Sure there's been mismanagement but this ius also the cause. The areas most in need of funding are the least likely to be able to generate it.

Edited

My borough gets less from central govt because it is a wealthy area. So I guess most people pay full or close to full council tax. And people in areas where less pay c tax rely more on c govt?

ruby1957 · 28/02/2024 16:26

sleepyscientist · 28/02/2024 14:48

I'm all for giving more money to education but I also don't want to pay more tax and would happily accept a tax cut. The less money we have coming in the less we spend so the less VAT etc government gets.

Maybe they need to redraw the entire budget around core priorities and what is left funds the benefit state. Pensions is an area that should be cut, we pay into a private pension to actually fund our retirement yet we also pay NI for a state pensions we don't need

Throughout my working life of 40 years I paid NI which was understood then to ensure that I received unemployment benefit if I lost my job (which was unlikely) to pay for the NHS and to ensure that I was eligible for the state pension.

This was all valid and understandable.

Since then so many 'workers' get NI credits and UC is far more generous than Unemployment benefit that its meaning has been eroded since if someone has not paid the required years or none at all they get pension credit anyway.

Good for you - you don't need the state pension (which is potentially taxable if you have other income in retirement) but not everyone has good private pensions.

It should be scrapped and added to tax so everyone pays more - including the wealthy 6 figure earners.

user1494050295 · 28/02/2024 16:21

GasPanic · 28/02/2024 09:53

Can you tell us where this is please ?

Twickenham

jm9138 · 28/02/2024 16:18

taxguru · 28/02/2024 16:08

I think the big issue is that tax on earned income, i.e. workers, is higher.

It's counter intuitive that people working, producing things, etc., are taxed higher than people with passive income.

Back in the 70s, it was the opposite with eye wateringly high extra taxed on "unearned" income.

I think it should be the same. If someone earns £50k from wages, they should be paying the same tax (all taxes) as someone with income of £50k from pensions, property letting, interest/dividends, etc.

Not sure it should be the same for passive and earned income. I think there is quite a strong economic and moral argument that passive income should be taxed more. Having said that, there is no argument that it should be lower for passive income and making it equal would at least be a start.

OP posts:
GasPanic · 28/02/2024 16:11

jm9138 · 28/02/2024 15:53

I have never quite got why British people seem to be so much more upset about taxes on unearned income then taxes on earned income.

The rich have used it as a convenient loophole for years to avoid paying tax and the low earners don't realise it is happening, so all you get is the outrage of the rich and not the protests of the poor.

taxguru · 28/02/2024 16:08

jm9138 · 28/02/2024 15:53

I have never quite got why British people seem to be so much more upset about taxes on unearned income then taxes on earned income.

I think the big issue is that tax on earned income, i.e. workers, is higher.

It's counter intuitive that people working, producing things, etc., are taxed higher than people with passive income.

Back in the 70s, it was the opposite with eye wateringly high extra taxed on "unearned" income.

I think it should be the same. If someone earns £50k from wages, they should be paying the same tax (all taxes) as someone with income of £50k from pensions, property letting, interest/dividends, etc.

Vod · 28/02/2024 16:06

jm9138 · 28/02/2024 15:53

I have never quite got why British people seem to be so much more upset about taxes on unearned income then taxes on earned income.

This is part of the reason the proposed NI cut is progressive and refreshing.

jm9138 · 28/02/2024 15:53

I have never quite got why British people seem to be so much more upset about taxes on unearned income then taxes on earned income.

OP posts:
jm9138 · 28/02/2024 15:52

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 28/02/2024 15:40

Ok but they sell a house worth 500k and with the proceeds can only buy one worth 375k so effectively they have to reduce their standard of living.
it won’t incentivize anyone to downsize.

Well that is true if they did not manage to save any of the £380k less for the original house than the person next door paid.

I would not pretend that there would not be issues with CGT on houses. For some people they would be. But I would take that for being able to lower taxes on actual earned income and lower house prices overall. Things can be better without being perfect.

OP posts:
LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 28/02/2024 15:40

jm9138 · 28/02/2024 15:27

But why will that matter? So one person bought a house for £20k 20 years ago and it is now worth £500k. Another bought the neighbouring identical house for £400k also years ago and it is now worth £500k. They both sell on the same day and let's assume that they both have paid off their mortgage.

The person who bought the £20k house ended up with £480k of capital gain and with a 25% CGT (to keep the maths easy) would pay £120k CGT and have £380k left. The person next door you are will have a £25k CGT and so have £475K left. They both go to buy identical houses that cost £800k.

On the face of it this seems unfair, except when you work out that the person who bought the original home for £20k 20 years ago will have paid, for the two houses they have owned up to that point and less any capital gain and tax, £440k whilst the person next door who admitted had a much smaller CGT bill has had to pay £725k. And they both have owned for all intents and purposes the same property.

So no it really is not unfair. If you have done well on the property market you will still be in a better place than others who have not faired so well.

Ok but they sell a house worth 500k and with the proceeds can only buy one worth 375k so effectively they have to reduce their standard of living.
it won’t incentivize anyone to downsize.

jm9138 · 28/02/2024 15:27

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 28/02/2024 15:11

It won’t balance out though as everyone bought houses at different points so the amount that will need paying for cgt will vary massively by person

But why will that matter? So one person bought a house for £20k 20 years ago and it is now worth £500k. Another bought the neighbouring identical house for £400k also years ago and it is now worth £500k. They both sell on the same day and let's assume that they both have paid off their mortgage.

The person who bought the £20k house ended up with £480k of capital gain and with a 25% CGT (to keep the maths easy) would pay £120k CGT and have £380k left. The person next door you are will have a £25k CGT and so have £475K left. They both go to buy identical houses that cost £800k.

On the face of it this seems unfair, except when you work out that the person who bought the original home for £20k 20 years ago will have paid, for the two houses they have owned up to that point and less any capital gain and tax, £440k whilst the person next door who admitted had a much smaller CGT bill has had to pay £725k. And they both have owned for all intents and purposes the same property.

So no it really is not unfair. If you have done well on the property market you will still be in a better place than others who have not faired so well.

OP posts:
LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 28/02/2024 15:11

jm9138 · 28/02/2024 14:53

Yes but then everyone will have less to spend on the house and so everyone will have to lower the price they want. It should balance out.

There are no Pareto solutions to any tax changes really. Anything we change will likely make some people worse off. But that does not mean that those changes are wrong to do.

It won’t balance out though as everyone bought houses at different points so the amount that will need paying for cgt will vary massively by person

Newbutoldfather · 28/02/2024 15:05

@LiquoriceAllsorts2 ,

you are right that we don’t want to reduce liquidity, but if we reduced stamp duty a lot and added CGT, it might be neutral.

They could also make it deferrable if you couldn’t afford it (so it just got paid when you eventually traded down). If you also had an annual property tax, people would also trade down when they no longer needed a big family house.

The issue is that housing is a really economically inefficient investment, as well as the societal implications of amount of empty housing stock etc. The UK is pretty unique in the way we see ownership of residential property and it does need addressing.

Heatpumphero · 28/02/2024 14:56

jm9138 · 28/02/2024 14:53

Yes but then everyone will have less to spend on the house and so everyone will have to lower the price they want. It should balance out.

There are no Pareto solutions to any tax changes really. Anything we change will likely make some people worse off. But that does not mean that those changes are wrong to do.

Indeed. In the same way that scrapping stamp duty would mean that people have more money in their house purchasing budget so prices would rise accordingly, hence we would need to increase council tax at the same time as scrapping stamp duty to not only make up for the cost of scrappage, but also to dampen any resulting house price increases

jm9138 · 28/02/2024 14:55

sleepyscientist · 28/02/2024 14:48

I'm all for giving more money to education but I also don't want to pay more tax and would happily accept a tax cut. The less money we have coming in the less we spend so the less VAT etc government gets.

Maybe they need to redraw the entire budget around core priorities and what is left funds the benefit state. Pensions is an area that should be cut, we pay into a private pension to actually fund our retirement yet we also pay NI for a state pensions we don't need

I think a redrawing of priorities is a good idea and I think people could engage with. Just to be clear though - my OP was not about raising taxes but rather if the choice is between cutting taxes now or targeted spending on public services that are crippled where I think the priority should be.

OP posts:
jm9138 · 28/02/2024 14:53

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 28/02/2024 14:48

The other problem with capital gains tax is that normally when people sell a house they need to buy another. If you have to pay a large chunk of the price increase on tax you will not be able to afford a new house of comparable value which doesn’t seem fair. (Especially when you also factor in stamp duty which means you have that to some extent already)

Yes but then everyone will have less to spend on the house and so everyone will have to lower the price they want. It should balance out.

There are no Pareto solutions to any tax changes really. Anything we change will likely make some people worse off. But that does not mean that those changes are wrong to do.

OP posts:
LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 28/02/2024 14:48

The other problem with capital gains tax is that normally when people sell a house they need to buy another. If you have to pay a large chunk of the price increase on tax you will not be able to afford a new house of comparable value which doesn’t seem fair. (Especially when you also factor in stamp duty which means you have that to some extent already)

sleepyscientist · 28/02/2024 14:48

I'm all for giving more money to education but I also don't want to pay more tax and would happily accept a tax cut. The less money we have coming in the less we spend so the less VAT etc government gets.

Maybe they need to redraw the entire budget around core priorities and what is left funds the benefit state. Pensions is an area that should be cut, we pay into a private pension to actually fund our retirement yet we also pay NI for a state pensions we don't need

Heatpumphero · 28/02/2024 14:44

I think if you add CGT to peoples houses it would be unpopular and there is a danger that people would just sit tight in their properties until the politics change and the decision is reversed.

There are a lot of people making vast untaxed income from housing however.

jm9138 · 28/02/2024 14:20

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 28/02/2024 13:54

Ok but we are in a cost of living crisis, people are struggling. They could also do with having that additional money themselves to pay for food, energy, childcare etc.

The 13.5 isn’t something that is magically appearing, it is being paid by the people.

I think you make a valid point and I do see where you are coming from, but ultimately if we are going to long term get out of that crisis we have to start having a better educated and healthier society and that means investing in education (including early years and child care support) and in certain aspects of the NHS.

How about instead of my suggestions we use the money to insulate homes, or better subsidise child care and pay child care providers more? Or just take £2 bn of it and give £1000 to the poorest 2 million households as fuel payment vouchers?

Those most struggling are likely to see very little of this tax cut. If you earn £20k maybe you will be £2 a week better off. I am not sure that will make much of a dent into the cost of living.

OP posts:
jm9138 · 28/02/2024 14:13

Gatorpickle · 28/02/2024 13:44

I am saying that the situation is massively complex, involving millions of stakeholders, and unless you've got experience dealing with that level is complexity you won't understand how difficult it is. It's not like a household budget where you can say "Well, if we reduce the amount of money we spend on haircuts and days out we'll have more money to spend on electricity so therefore we can have the heating on longer".

It really is not massively complex. Whilst the government is not like a household (for many reasons, not least of which that it can instruct the BoE to print money) it still has revenue in and spending out. Is it more or less complicated when the Treasury just says to departments 'right, we are cutting (at least) 10% off your budget - go and find efficiencies' (like happened in the worst times of austerity). I suppose it could be argued it is less complex to cut taxes than increase spending but I would argue it is more complex and difficult to cut spending and Governments over the past 14 years have had no problem doing that.

It is like saying Microsoft have millions (billions?) of customers and so when faced with how to divvy up an unexpected profit it is just too difficult for them to choose to cut bills to customers, pay a bigger dividend or invest in new service provision. It might be more difficult to work out how to invest and easier to just pay a bigger dividend but lots of shareholders might think that really shows a lack of leadership at the top.

Yes I know that government is not a company either. But is your argument really that when faced with unexpectedly high tax revenues due to fiscal drag which - unless you change tax band thresholds - will continue and is not a one off windfall - the only choice the government has is to lower taxes because everything else is 'massively complex'. Seems a strange argument to me.

If your argument is they don't really have this £13.5 bn then I agree with you. The fact is though that they are at least pretending they do and they don't they will have to find it from somewhere, either borrowing or cutting services. But again, how is cutting services less 'massively complex' than increasing spending on them?

Or is your argument that they have to balance the tax cuts that benefit some of the millions of stakeholders (a strange term for society but maybe not the worse - and it would probably help if more people saw themselves as stakeholders) against public spending increases that may benefit a different set of stakeholders? Well that is self evident and the responsibility of government. I just think the balance this time should be towards beneficiaries of public services, but if you think it should be towards tax payers then fair enough. We disagree. But don't make out that public sector finances at a macro level are so ultra complex that only a select few could ever understand it or make decisions. If that was the case I think we need a better selection process for our MPs (actually, that is probably true anyway).

OP posts:
MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 28/02/2024 13:57

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 28/02/2024 13:54

Ok but we are in a cost of living crisis, people are struggling. They could also do with having that additional money themselves to pay for food, energy, childcare etc.

The 13.5 isn’t something that is magically appearing, it is being paid by the people.

So collect the tax and redistribute it to those who are actually struggling.

Lots of people can afford to pay the tax that they're currently paying. They might not like it, but they can afford it.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 28/02/2024 13:55

Gatorpickle · 28/02/2024 13:44

I am saying that the situation is massively complex, involving millions of stakeholders, and unless you've got experience dealing with that level is complexity you won't understand how difficult it is. It's not like a household budget where you can say "Well, if we reduce the amount of money we spend on haircuts and days out we'll have more money to spend on electricity so therefore we can have the heating on longer".

Well, the situation would usually be horribly complex, of course.

But it's actually pretty simple in this scenario. There is a general election coming up and the Tory right wing are baying for tax cuts. These will be prioritised.