Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

BILs new girlfriend - how do I NBU?

211 replies

AppelationStation · 27/02/2024 22:37

Jeez. This turned out to be loooong.

I know I am being pretty unreasonable here. I guess I'm looking for suggestions to shift my thinking so I don't let myself down and act like a tw*t.

BIL (DHs brother) separated from his wife almost 2 years ago.

Prior to this, the four of us were close friends for a while, living near by, seeing each at least once a week. In more recent years both couples relocated and we saw each other less. We have kids of a similar age, who are also quite close, so whenever we did meet up it was lovely.

We knew things were a bit rocky but didn't see the separation coming. BIL immediately got together with another woman, who he'd previously been friends with. He was seeing his new GF after he and exSIL decided to split, but before they'd moved out of their house together. We met her during this period when they were supposedly just friends, but I had a gut feeling which proved to be right.

New GF is very nice. I can't fault her. She's never expressed a negative thought or opinion within ear shot of me, on anything. BILs kids love her, the family love her, she fits right in. Everyone is, rightly, happy for BIL. There's a bit of me that feels BILs ex of 20 odd years, their kids' mum and my former friend (my attempts to contact her have been met with a luke warm response, fair enough) has very quickly been replaced. Maybe because I'm an inlaw in their family and it makes me feel insecure.

Here's where i'm being a tw*t: I can't warm to her. I am someone who wears my faults on my sleave and I can see 0 chink in her armour. To quote Motherland, "Where is her secret sadness?!". I find it a bit spooky.

Also, BIL is very loved up and vocal about how he was so unhappy for so long because his ex just wasn't his person. Thanks to new GF he's apparently discovered sex is his "love language" (!) and he was missing that before. They're both incredibly fit, outdoorsy people who share their love of mountaineering and cycling. I'm aware there's nothing wrong with this. BUT...

I find myself wanting to scream "OF COURSE YOUR NEW GF IS ALL SEXY AND SKINNY AND HAS TIME FOR YOUR HOBBIES BIL, SHE IS 10 YRS YOUNGER AND HASN'T BEEN BRINGING UP YOUR 2 KIDS FOR THE LAST TEN YEARS!"

FYI, BIL is quite hard to live with I'd say, and was quite neglectful as a partner to his ex.

I feel like my feelings are rather telling about my own marriage, and their new relationship is tapping into my own, grossly unattractive, insecurities. But that doesn't make the feelings go away. I just find it all...icky.

We're all going on a family holiday together soon and I'm dreading it. So, acknowledging IABU, what do I need to tell myself to get me out of this negative thinking pattern, and survive a long weekend in close quarters?

Extra points for empathy.
Top points for a kind telling off.
Zero points for telling me what I already know about how much of a dreadful person I am (I'm on it, ta).

OP posts:
PicaK · 28/02/2024 05:10

Like previous poster I immediately thought of The Weekend by Fay Weldon.

HotChocolateNotCocoa · 28/02/2024 05:10

Mummyoflittledragon · 28/02/2024 05:02

This. I am not surprised you’re fuming. Your bil sounds like an idiot. At some stage I think I’d be putting him back in his box and tell him exactly what I think about his behaviour and denigrating the mother of his children.

And why do you think he will care?

HotChocolateNotCocoa · 28/02/2024 05:09

WandaWonder · 28/02/2024 05:03

why on earth does the OP need support for? no one else is doing anything wrong excpet for the OP she is doing iis making herself insecure no one can fix that but her

Yep - some people just have to be the star in a drama when, in reality, they’re barely a supporting player.

HotChocolateNotCocoa · 28/02/2024 05:07

Here's where i'm being a twt: I can't warm to her. I am someone who wears my faults on my sleave and I can see 0 chink in her armour. To quote Motherland, "Where is her secret sadness?!". I find it a bit spooky.

You come across terribly in this situation. Why are you making it your business? It’s nothing to do with you.

WandaWonder · 28/02/2024 05:06

Mummyoflittledragon · 28/02/2024 05:04

A man denigrating the mother of his children is not fine.

But how is that making the OP insecure, sure he sounds like an moron but the new GF must like him for something, but women do that about fathers of their children on here all the time and of course in real life

and the OP is making that all about her

Mummyoflittledragon · 28/02/2024 05:04

WandaWonder · 28/02/2024 05:03

why on earth does the OP need support for? no one else is doing anything wrong excpet for the OP she is doing iis making herself insecure no one can fix that but her

A man denigrating the mother of his children is not fine.

WandaWonder · 28/02/2024 05:03

Codlingmoths · 28/02/2024 04:58

Can you talk to your dh, and say you’d appreciate a bit of emotional support to stop yourself screaming at his brother <exactly what you said- SHE’S TEN YEARS YOUNGER AND DIDNT GIVE BIRTH TO AND BRING UP YOUR KIDS SO OF BLOODY COURSE SHE HAS TIME AND ENERGY FOR SEX AND HOBBIES>, because I would expect my Dh to be totally on board with my emotions here, which I would feel pretty strongly . ‘Got the kids, drained the wife to a husk, so upgrading to younger sexy fit childfree model a man like me hasn’t yet drained’ is so classically male entitlement. Id have been full of snide comments I’m afraid - ‘mountain climbing! How nice- I hope Ella <his ex> gets a chance to take up hobbies like that now you are more hands on with parenting 😁

But a bit of support should be a big help in reigning in the resentment of the new gf.
I hear you on the in law awareness and how quickly they drop the exes.

why on earth does the OP need support for? no one else is doing anything wrong excpet for the OP she is doing iis making herself insecure no one can fix that but her

Mummyoflittledragon · 28/02/2024 05:02

Codlingmoths · 28/02/2024 04:58

Can you talk to your dh, and say you’d appreciate a bit of emotional support to stop yourself screaming at his brother <exactly what you said- SHE’S TEN YEARS YOUNGER AND DIDNT GIVE BIRTH TO AND BRING UP YOUR KIDS SO OF BLOODY COURSE SHE HAS TIME AND ENERGY FOR SEX AND HOBBIES>, because I would expect my Dh to be totally on board with my emotions here, which I would feel pretty strongly . ‘Got the kids, drained the wife to a husk, so upgrading to younger sexy fit childfree model a man like me hasn’t yet drained’ is so classically male entitlement. Id have been full of snide comments I’m afraid - ‘mountain climbing! How nice- I hope Ella <his ex> gets a chance to take up hobbies like that now you are more hands on with parenting 😁

But a bit of support should be a big help in reigning in the resentment of the new gf.
I hear you on the in law awareness and how quickly they drop the exes.

This. I am not surprised you’re fuming. Your bil sounds like an idiot. At some stage I think I’d be putting him back in his box and tell him exactly what I think about his behaviour and denigrating the mother of his children.

Codlingmoths · 28/02/2024 04:58

Can you talk to your dh, and say you’d appreciate a bit of emotional support to stop yourself screaming at his brother <exactly what you said- SHE’S TEN YEARS YOUNGER AND DIDNT GIVE BIRTH TO AND BRING UP YOUR KIDS SO OF BLOODY COURSE SHE HAS TIME AND ENERGY FOR SEX AND HOBBIES>, because I would expect my Dh to be totally on board with my emotions here, which I would feel pretty strongly . ‘Got the kids, drained the wife to a husk, so upgrading to younger sexy fit childfree model a man like me hasn’t yet drained’ is so classically male entitlement. Id have been full of snide comments I’m afraid - ‘mountain climbing! How nice- I hope Ella <his ex> gets a chance to take up hobbies like that now you are more hands on with parenting 😁

But a bit of support should be a big help in reigning in the resentment of the new gf.
I hear you on the in law awareness and how quickly they drop the exes.

ohdamnitjanet · 28/02/2024 04:56

Fizzadora · 27/02/2024 23:55

Well he's a cyclist ergo he is a knob.
I'm afraid I wouldn't have been able to resist bursting his smug bubble when he denigrated his wife.
You need to re-think this OP, you think it's the girlfriend that you don't like but actually it's BIL, isn't it.

Yup!

Autienotnaughtie · 28/02/2024 04:48

I'd say it's reasonable to feel irked at bil and his hot girlfriend enjoying a hassle free relationship with loads of great sex. Presumably you had that with your dh at some point too? But you also know this is temporary it lasts a couple of years max then normality sets in. They may want kids and will be back in the nappies stage when you guys are fairly child free.

Also I see why it's concerned to witness first hand how disposable in-laws can be. They love you and your part of the family as long as your dh loves you. It is always helpful to remember that their loyalty isn't with you.

You don't have to have a close relationship with this woman, it doesn't have to replicate your previous sil relationship. You need to find a new relationship with her technically she hasn't done anything wrong. I'd aim for polite and friendly but don't pressure yourself to be more than you are comfortable with.

Guavafish1 · 28/02/2024 02:36

Life is too short for this kind of nonsense.

Your BIL was unhappy in his marriage for multiple reasons and as was ex-wife.

I agree with others that your projecting and that you have be having the ick with your BIL.

Go with the flow, enjoy the holiday, enjoy the company and see if you learn something new for your BIL gf.

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 28/02/2024 02:27

Exactly who is going to be looking after your DNs while your DH hangs out with his DB? Prior to this, I'm sure you and your SIL hung out together and jointly cared for all the DC, so I suspect your Bail is expecting you to do all that childcare on your own I'm afraid. The GF is unlikely to be doing any of it. Or else they will expect that DGP to step in, knowing full well that it will then likely fall to you anyway.

Point out to your DH that you are not willing to carry the burden of childcare for all the DC so he is NOT to make plans with his DB for just the two of them. Lets see how exciting and fun DBIL finds life when HE has to actually take responsibility for childcare.

Rubbishconfession · 28/02/2024 01:33

YANBU, BIL sounds like a prick.

And I get the sense from your post that he may have been with his new GF even whilst married.

The good news is you’ve relocated away from each other so you can hopefully keep contact to a minimum.

I wouldn’t let them use you to form a foursome. Seems strange why he has chosen to come on this holiday when they don’t previously join.

skygradient · 28/02/2024 01:22

Who gets the kids? Can you not go on a family holiday with the ex and her kids too, as they're still your nieces and nephews?

I mean obviously not for the sake of just fitting in a holiday with them but just rotate every now and then.

Otherwise she sounds totally excluded/replaced from your circle which also explains some of your resentment towards the new woman

BruFord · 28/02/2024 01:05

@AppelationStation Don’t be hard on yourself, I rarely go on trips with DH’s family, I wave him goodbye (sometimes with one of our teens in tow, sometimes not) and let him go with them. I’ll do Christmas and other special occasions, but otherwise, I let him have a few days with his family and I relax at home. 😂 Perhaps you should do this next time someone suggests a long weekend away, he could take the children.

Fizzadora · 27/02/2024 23:55

Well he's a cyclist ergo he is a knob.
I'm afraid I wouldn't have been able to resist bursting his smug bubble when he denigrated his wife.
You need to re-think this OP, you think it's the girlfriend that you don't like but actually it's BIL, isn't it.

SleepingStandingUp · 27/02/2024 23:52

I think you need to try and see her as "Sarah" rather than "BILs fling who he keeps comparing unfairly to my friend". Could you suggest some girl time? An activity where the adult women get to hang out together without kids or men?

JimBeamCoke · 27/02/2024 23:44

Some of your other posts paint your DH as a bit of a dreamer so it might make sense you would be worried he might not see the reality of your BIL new relationship.
It is a shame you are all trying to recreate the couples relationship you had previously with this new woman. It is not going to be the same and you need to let your DH be aware of your concerns. E.g. you are happy to meet up with them but you have your reservations as this woman is much younger, not a mother, has different life experiences, so you are naturally not going to gel the same.

Dingbatbingo · 27/02/2024 23:41

I feel like my feelings are rather telling about my own marriage, and their new relationship is tapping into my own, grossly unattractive, insecurities. But that doesn't make the feelings go away. I just find it all...icky.

you are being very honest and I think the crux of it is as you and others have said upthread, this new relationship feels like a threat to you and your ‘old’ relationship and no doubt some righteous indignation on behalf of your ex sil.

this feeling towards the new sil is entirely understandable to those of us who might be older and feeling worn out etc but as you say, it’s not her fault.
can you talk to your husband about how it’s making you feel? If not him then a good and trusted honest friend or failing that, a therapist.
anyone who can help you look at the background to these feelings and help you to separate your emotions from their situation.
also this ‘new’ relationship has upset the status quo, you no longer have your familiar cosy foursome and seem to have lost a good friend.

so your brain is telling you that new sil is the cause of these unwelcome changes.

AppelationStation · 27/02/2024 23:39

We're going with PIL, as we have done for the last few years, and BIL + GF are coming along.

Breaks away with PIL are usually v low maintenance, easy an fun. I didn't know the other were coming until last week. It's great for DH as he gets to hang out with his brother, and the kids get to see their cousins. I could really do with a break and now feel it will be hard work. I know that makes me very selfish.

OP posts:
TwoWithCurls · 27/02/2024 23:36

Ewwww of course you don't like her! I'd have gone right off the BIL as well, if I were you! What a cliche! His poor kids.

AppelationStation · 27/02/2024 23:35

Hiddenvoice · 27/02/2024 22:46

I don’t think you’re a dreadful person but I do think you’re projecting your own insecurities onto this woman.

What bil decided to do with his life is his choice. It seems like the family have all accepted the girlfriend and most importantly the children. Really that’s all that matters here.
It’s a shame your ex sil doesn’t want to keep in touch but it’s fair enough, she needs to have a clean break away from everyone.

I think you’re worried your own dh might get some ideas and feel he will be happier elsewhere. That’s a completely normal worry to have, it’s a worry a lot of women have. We are working and raising children so don’t always have the time to have fun and feel relaxed. At the end of the day we sometimes just want our beds and a good night sleep. You’re worried that your dh will see what bil has and want it for himself.
Thats not this woman’s fault. That’s what you need to repeat to yourself. We can’t comment on how and when they got together but it’s working for them and that’s all that matters.

You need to give yourself a shake (no judgement) and remind yourself to focus on your own marriage. Focus on your relationship and if you’re feeling worried or unhappy then what can you do to change it?

You are quite correct. I am worried my DH will fancy a bit of the same.

Who wouldn't want to trade in me: The Tired Woman who, having relocated to his home town to have kids and then went through surgical menopause at 32 as a result of a disastrous birth, and is a therefore a grumpy chunk: with a fit nubile 30 something with no baggage and a lust for life?

I think my DH values me and mostly shares my view. He'd quite like it if I was more inclined to walk up mountains in my spare time. I like mountains, but with a demanding ft job and kids, it's not high on my list of priorities when I have a day off. I can't he arsed!

OP posts:
Daleksatemyshed · 27/02/2024 23:30

If you really can't cope then why agree to the holiday Op? It's going to be very difficult being stuck with them every day

BruFord · 27/02/2024 23:23

TheCosySeal · 27/02/2024 23:12

I wouldn’t of booked a holiday with them in the first place and I would distance myself to be honest.

I would also have to mention the remarks about kids etc if he kept saying about his love language.

i agree with @TheCosySeal, I don’t know why you’re going on holiday with them! As it’s already arranged, I’d plaster on a smile for this long weekend and then tell your DH that you’re not interested in going on any more such holidays. If your DH wants to go on holiday with his brother, great, but you don’t have to.

If your BIL starts on about his hobbies again, you can casually say that it must be easier to do his own thing when he hasn’t got the children.