Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

BILs new girlfriend - how do I NBU?

211 replies

AppelationStation · 27/02/2024 22:37

Jeez. This turned out to be loooong.

I know I am being pretty unreasonable here. I guess I'm looking for suggestions to shift my thinking so I don't let myself down and act like a tw*t.

BIL (DHs brother) separated from his wife almost 2 years ago.

Prior to this, the four of us were close friends for a while, living near by, seeing each at least once a week. In more recent years both couples relocated and we saw each other less. We have kids of a similar age, who are also quite close, so whenever we did meet up it was lovely.

We knew things were a bit rocky but didn't see the separation coming. BIL immediately got together with another woman, who he'd previously been friends with. He was seeing his new GF after he and exSIL decided to split, but before they'd moved out of their house together. We met her during this period when they were supposedly just friends, but I had a gut feeling which proved to be right.

New GF is very nice. I can't fault her. She's never expressed a negative thought or opinion within ear shot of me, on anything. BILs kids love her, the family love her, she fits right in. Everyone is, rightly, happy for BIL. There's a bit of me that feels BILs ex of 20 odd years, their kids' mum and my former friend (my attempts to contact her have been met with a luke warm response, fair enough) has very quickly been replaced. Maybe because I'm an inlaw in their family and it makes me feel insecure.

Here's where i'm being a tw*t: I can't warm to her. I am someone who wears my faults on my sleave and I can see 0 chink in her armour. To quote Motherland, "Where is her secret sadness?!". I find it a bit spooky.

Also, BIL is very loved up and vocal about how he was so unhappy for so long because his ex just wasn't his person. Thanks to new GF he's apparently discovered sex is his "love language" (!) and he was missing that before. They're both incredibly fit, outdoorsy people who share their love of mountaineering and cycling. I'm aware there's nothing wrong with this. BUT...

I find myself wanting to scream "OF COURSE YOUR NEW GF IS ALL SEXY AND SKINNY AND HAS TIME FOR YOUR HOBBIES BIL, SHE IS 10 YRS YOUNGER AND HASN'T BEEN BRINGING UP YOUR 2 KIDS FOR THE LAST TEN YEARS!"

FYI, BIL is quite hard to live with I'd say, and was quite neglectful as a partner to his ex.

I feel like my feelings are rather telling about my own marriage, and their new relationship is tapping into my own, grossly unattractive, insecurities. But that doesn't make the feelings go away. I just find it all...icky.

We're all going on a family holiday together soon and I'm dreading it. So, acknowledging IABU, what do I need to tell myself to get me out of this negative thinking pattern, and survive a long weekend in close quarters?

Extra points for empathy.
Top points for a kind telling off.
Zero points for telling me what I already know about how much of a dreadful person I am (I'm on it, ta).

OP posts:
IntoTheMild · 28/02/2024 10:07

I would just tell him how it is OP! He need to hear it from someone and if no one else has said it you should. I think it’s terrible when men leave their wife for younger, child free women and blame their ex wife for not having time for sex/hobbies, not looking after herself etc - of course she doesn’t, she’s looking after YOUR children! He’s behaved appallingly and should know it.

why pander to his ego like everyone else?

TheWayBackHome · 28/02/2024 10:00

OP - I don't think you're being u reasonable feeling the way you do.

I would be very reluctant to be allocated childcare duties while they spent a day fell running or whatever they're doing. Whose idea was that? It's majorly disrespectful to assign you to childcare while they go and have fun - you would be well within your rights to kick off/refuse to do this.

BadSkiingMum · 28/02/2024 09:59

I honestly wouldn’t go on the holiday as the arrangement you have described really isn’t fair on you.

But if you really do have to go, consider taking yourself and your two children off for the day - somewhere great fun of course. Make sure that DH misses out on something rather than you just being there at home to welcome the heroes back from the hills. 🤔Oh and arrive back at the cottage after them too.

With the girlfriend, try not to let her rile you. It’s BIL who’s annoying you really, not her.

Get a really gripping book on the go.
Take evening baths and have early nights to avoid too much chit chat.
Noise cancelling earphones playing zen music.
Go on your own walks.

taylorswift1989 · 28/02/2024 09:51

I find myself wanting to scream "OF COURSE YOUR NEW GF IS ALL SEXY AND SKINNY AND HAS TIME FOR YOUR HOBBIES BIL, SHE IS 10 YRS YOUNGER AND HASN'T BEEN BRINGING UP YOUR 2 KIDS FOR THE LAST TEN YEARS!"

I don't think YANBU at all. Your BIL sounds like a total dick and I'm not surprised you can't warm to his GF under the circumstances.

I wouldn't be doing the babysitting while the young cool people are off having fun up a mountain. Let the men look after their own kids. Don't be 'allocated' a role in the family that you don't want.

You could suggest instead that you and DH have all the kids one day so BIL and GF can do something (climb a mountain or whatever), and then they have all the kids another day so you and DH can do something together - maybe just spend the day shagging and drinking champagne. Reconnect with your DH and let BIL and GF do their own thing.

YesThatsATurdOnTheRug · 28/02/2024 09:49

You identify with the ex so the comments about her and the abandonment of her are really chiming with you and feeling personal. That's so totally understandable and natural. Maybe this holiday will help as you can start to see the real person underneath the emotional structures the GF represents.

Of course she has pain and flaws and all of the usual shades of black and grey, you just haven't seen them yet. BIL is being a dick, just roll your eyes at his nonsense and let it slide past you.

Codlingmoths · 28/02/2024 09:46

Dh, I’ve realised I have always quite enjoyed holidays with your parents, they are low key and fun. Now they aren’t, because I’ve been reduced to the woman who gets allocated the childcare while you and your brother go off and have fun. Why is it you think I’m going to keep coming to these? When are you and your brother going to do all the childcare and I get time off? Think carefully before answering please.

SpeedyDrama · 28/02/2024 09:35

ForgivenessHope · 28/02/2024 09:26

op self-ware etc- well done!

but, why are all posters IGNORING that bil and ex sis in law WERE unhappy?? even OP said this in her op. had anyone unhappy in marriage come here, the first post is ltb, get your duck in row, life is too short etc etc. or was bil supposed to hook up with someone he barely knew, have a not so nice gf and you are all happy? I just find his past unhappiness being ignored as unfair.

op, I thought he was married to your sister or was somehow your brother- you wouldn't have this feeling if he was either of the two.

yes, your dh is likely to fancy similar- so focus all your efforts on that. talk to him. get therapy, go on some hike etc etc.

It’s ok to recognise that either party was unhappy in a relationship. However, it doesn’t take a huge leap to see that his ‘unhappiness’ was from being part of a typically ageing relationship - getting older, younger kids, looks and energy levels do dip during these years on both sides. The fact he has resorted to stereotype of men his age - finding new life with a much younger, childfree woman to regain his happiness and youth whilst the one he built a typical life with is shunted to the side like a ‘practice run’, no he doesn’t come off as someone who is owed a huge amount of compassion here.

I agree with others, he looks after his own kids on this holiday and gets to remember he is still a grown man with responsibilities outside his new found excitement.

skygradient · 28/02/2024 09:34

@ForgivenessHope you've glossed over the cheating bit though (assuming they actually did cheat as OP only insinuated it and didn't elaborate)

No way would I hang out with a 3rd party apart from in a very distanced civil manner

LolaSmiles · 28/02/2024 09:30

You are unreasonable not to like her because it's really your BIL's behaviour and comments that are the problem, but to be fair to you, you have said you know you're being unreasonable there.

I don't think you're unreasonable for disliking your BIL's comments about his ex wife. There's something unpleasant and full of male entitlement to leave a marriage, get a new girlfriend that's 10 years younger and then start being dickhead comparing your shiny new younger woman to your ex wife who is mother of your children and has been raising a family for years. The "ooh sex is my love language" gives me the ick too. Basically he's traded family life for a younger woman so he can have more sex and do his hobbies, which is up to him, but bragging about it, especially around people who know and respect his ex wife is unpleasant.

juniorspesh · 28/02/2024 09:28

In your original post you are almost deliberately coming across badly, probably because you don't like yourself very much. There's "owning it" and then there's aggravating it. Here's a reframed thought for you: it is extremely demeaning to yourself to put her in a position above you like this. If you keep doing this you will make it a reality.

iwafs · 28/02/2024 09:26

This is the real crux of it:

I find myself wanting to scream "OF COURSE YOUR NEW GF IS ALL SEXY AND SKINNY AND HAS TIME FOR YOUR HOBBIES BIL, SHE IS 10 YRS YOUNGER AND HASN'T BEEN BRINGING UP YOUR 2 KIDS FOR THE LAST TEN YEARS!"

No way would I be going on an extended family holiday with them. You and MIL have been designated as childcare whilst DH, BIL and new GF go off hiking - enjoying themselves, getting fresh air, getting more fit and athletic! How exactly is this a holiday for you? You ought to be getting paid for nannying services!

It'd be good if your shitty bil fell off a ridge.

ForgivenessHope · 28/02/2024 09:26

op self-ware etc- well done!

but, why are all posters IGNORING that bil and ex sis in law WERE unhappy?? even OP said this in her op. had anyone unhappy in marriage come here, the first post is ltb, get your duck in row, life is too short etc etc. or was bil supposed to hook up with someone he barely knew, have a not so nice gf and you are all happy? I just find his past unhappiness being ignored as unfair.

op, I thought he was married to your sister or was somehow your brother- you wouldn't have this feeling if he was either of the two.

yes, your dh is likely to fancy similar- so focus all your efforts on that. talk to him. get therapy, go on some hike etc etc.

Catsfrontbum · 28/02/2024 09:20

The hole on holiday would send me furious with rage!

Are you taking a day off for yourself and leaving all the children? I would.

Livelovebehappy · 28/02/2024 09:14

Yanbu. I’ve been in similar situation, and based my dislike of their relationship on there obviously being cross overs between the separation and getting together of the new couple. It all seems so seedy and disrespectful. Obviously the gf was complicit in the deceit of how she and your bil got together, so I would not want to spend time with someone with such a low moral compass. You probably can’t get out of the holiday now though without causing drama, so i would just be civil with her and just treat her as an acquaintance you’re spending time with and nothing more. You don’t have to compromise your own feelings just because others are.

TheCosySeal · 28/02/2024 09:04

AppelationStation · 28/02/2024 08:07

I am insecure! Here's a big fat flag to mark it for you! It's not attractive, I don't like it, I work on it, but there it is. Life can he a bit shit sometimes and we have wobbles. I don't think being a bit insecure at times (and owning it, and trying to do better, hence the post) is the biggest sin going myself.

FYI, I and MIL have already been allocated childcare for the day while BIL, GF and DH go on an all day hike together.

I quite like spending time with my kids on holiday. If I only had them 50% of the time, I'd try to enjoy them even more.

Refuse to have them then. I would.

Id be telling him straight that he doesn’t have his kids all the time now so I thought he would want to spend as much time with them as possible so you won’t be looking after them so he can go on a walk.

Then take your own kids out.

Id also be telling the PIL that you won’t be doing holidays all together anymore as your BIL is a dick.

skygradient · 28/02/2024 09:03

I'm being a bit nosy but how did you find out they met through cheating?

serin · 28/02/2024 09:03

To be honest, I'm not surprised your ex SIL is being a bit frosty. When a similar situation occurred in our family, we made sure that SIL was not "forgotten" or replaced by inviting her to everything. Why don't you and your kids plan a fun weekend with her and her kids.
I wouldn't be particularly keen to foster a relationship with the new replacement, what's the point? He'll have another in a few years.

skygradient · 28/02/2024 09:02

Can you not politely refuse to do their childcare?! It doesn't seem very nice of your DH either to dump you with all the children and go off on the hike with them.

SpeedyDrama · 28/02/2024 09:00

It seems to me that your dislike is of your BiL (quite rightly from some of what you’ve said) and you’re projecting that on to the new girlfriend. You’ll always have bil in your life, being your husband’s brother so to cause an uneasy relationship would have ill effect, so it’s easier to mirror his choices on to her.

The whole ‘sex is my love language’ is so blegh though, it reads to me as a stranger that his wife was perfectly fine to keep as the maker of his kids and the keeper of his home but not good enough to be seen as a woman who also wanted sex and affection because she was no longer an energetic younger person. It’s not the new GFs fault that she is those things but again, easy to reflect that you have changed through her. Can’t win, either we as women have to continue to be what we were 10/20 years ago to please a man or we can accept our life and ageing differences and be seen as less worthy to men like your BiL…

SaladIsShitAndWeAllKnowIt · 28/02/2024 08:56

OP - I don’t think you’re a terrible person at all. I do think you need to address any distance between you and your DH because I can’t see how this woman would be so unnerving if your marriage was secure.

Could you join them on the hike? I say this as someone who bloody loves this stuff and I realise it’s not for everyone, but it sorta sounds like you enjoy it too and by skipping it maybe you’re cutting off your nose to spite your face. Is your fitness up to stuff like this?

Regardless of the hike, my strategy here would be to actively try to be her best mate because it’s a win win.

Winterstormm · 28/02/2024 08:52

AppelationStation · 28/02/2024 08:29

@Winterstormm , it's not a kid friendly hike. We'll likely do one of those too (I like a good walk), but BIL, GF and DH will be scrambling over dodgy ridges and walking miles in all weathers for a good 6 hours. We've taken the kids up mountains on a fine day with snacks, but dragging them over slippery rocks atop a cloud drenched peak when you have to keep the pace up to get down before dark isn't fun.

They need to choose a child friendly hike then. Or a child friendly activity. Your DH and Bil are parents. They can go on a day trip together another day (not during a 'family' holiday).

Use your annual leave on a holiday with just you, DH and your DC. Doesn't sound like a holiday if you're used as unpaid childcare whilst the other adults your age can go off and do whatever they want.

Edit: Maybe your DH should go with his DC whilst you stay home. That sounds more relaxing for you. Then your DH and Bil will have to look after their DC.

ChihuahuasREvil · 28/02/2024 08:50

I don’t know the woman obviously, but he sounds pretty insufferable. I think if I had an issue with either then it would be him. ‘Sex is my love language’ indeed. Talk about being led by your dick. He sounds like one.

I’d probably feel more pity for her, TBH, and as for the ex, sounds like she’s well off out of it.

harriethoyle · 28/02/2024 08:50

You need to stop thinking so pejoratively about her. This post is dripping with it. She's not a "new girlfriend", she's an established partner of almost 2 years. She's clearly putting the children first or they wouldn't like her. PIL are probably delighted she's child focused.

You're also really mean about yourself, with descriptions of being a chunk, boring, etc. Work on your own insecurities, take practical steps about things like your weight if that bothers you and be nice to both yourself and BIL partner.

As for those drama llamas saying BIL is appalling for denigrating his ex: show me someone who says they haven’t slagged off their ex and I'll show you a liar. 🙄

p1ppyL0ngstocking · 28/02/2024 08:43

Why would you go on this holiday?

Tell DH he can go on a weekend away with his brother at some point and do their hiking etc together, but you want to use annual leave for your nuclear family to do stuff together.

If you're stuck in a villa with your PIL and four DC to watch, whilst your DH, DBIL and his GF disappear for 6 hours at a time on treacherous hikes (& then return knackered) what kind of holiday is that for you?

Easier not to go at all.

If DBIL and GF go on holiday just with the PIL he's actually going to have to do some parenting of his own kids and as they no longer live with him, it's really important that his children get to spend that quality time with him, rather than with you as a babysitter.

AppelationStation · 28/02/2024 08:29

@Winterstormm , it's not a kid friendly hike. We'll likely do one of those too (I like a good walk), but BIL, GF and DH will be scrambling over dodgy ridges and walking miles in all weathers for a good 6 hours. We've taken the kids up mountains on a fine day with snacks, but dragging them over slippery rocks atop a cloud drenched peak when you have to keep the pace up to get down before dark isn't fun.

OP posts: