Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

BILs new girlfriend - how do I NBU?

211 replies

AppelationStation · 27/02/2024 22:37

Jeez. This turned out to be loooong.

I know I am being pretty unreasonable here. I guess I'm looking for suggestions to shift my thinking so I don't let myself down and act like a tw*t.

BIL (DHs brother) separated from his wife almost 2 years ago.

Prior to this, the four of us were close friends for a while, living near by, seeing each at least once a week. In more recent years both couples relocated and we saw each other less. We have kids of a similar age, who are also quite close, so whenever we did meet up it was lovely.

We knew things were a bit rocky but didn't see the separation coming. BIL immediately got together with another woman, who he'd previously been friends with. He was seeing his new GF after he and exSIL decided to split, but before they'd moved out of their house together. We met her during this period when they were supposedly just friends, but I had a gut feeling which proved to be right.

New GF is very nice. I can't fault her. She's never expressed a negative thought or opinion within ear shot of me, on anything. BILs kids love her, the family love her, she fits right in. Everyone is, rightly, happy for BIL. There's a bit of me that feels BILs ex of 20 odd years, their kids' mum and my former friend (my attempts to contact her have been met with a luke warm response, fair enough) has very quickly been replaced. Maybe because I'm an inlaw in their family and it makes me feel insecure.

Here's where i'm being a tw*t: I can't warm to her. I am someone who wears my faults on my sleave and I can see 0 chink in her armour. To quote Motherland, "Where is her secret sadness?!". I find it a bit spooky.

Also, BIL is very loved up and vocal about how he was so unhappy for so long because his ex just wasn't his person. Thanks to new GF he's apparently discovered sex is his "love language" (!) and he was missing that before. They're both incredibly fit, outdoorsy people who share their love of mountaineering and cycling. I'm aware there's nothing wrong with this. BUT...

I find myself wanting to scream "OF COURSE YOUR NEW GF IS ALL SEXY AND SKINNY AND HAS TIME FOR YOUR HOBBIES BIL, SHE IS 10 YRS YOUNGER AND HASN'T BEEN BRINGING UP YOUR 2 KIDS FOR THE LAST TEN YEARS!"

FYI, BIL is quite hard to live with I'd say, and was quite neglectful as a partner to his ex.

I feel like my feelings are rather telling about my own marriage, and their new relationship is tapping into my own, grossly unattractive, insecurities. But that doesn't make the feelings go away. I just find it all...icky.

We're all going on a family holiday together soon and I'm dreading it. So, acknowledging IABU, what do I need to tell myself to get me out of this negative thinking pattern, and survive a long weekend in close quarters?

Extra points for empathy.
Top points for a kind telling off.
Zero points for telling me what I already know about how much of a dreadful person I am (I'm on it, ta).

OP posts:
GuinnessBird · 28/02/2024 11:03

MayThe4th · 28/02/2024 10:56

Nobody knows what goes on in someone else’s marriage.

It’s easy to say that he was a twat/prick/difficult but unhappiness in a marriage is rarely that black and white.

Also it’s not a popular viewpoint on here, but if the marriage was unhappy and the BIL ended up leaving because of this woman it’s entirely possible that the kids love her. I know several people whose parents left for other partners and the children have had fantastic relationships with them, even going forward.

From your perspective it’s your DH’s family. And realistically while you don’t have to like this woman you’re also as much as an outsider as she is. How would you feel if your IL’s refused to accept you for instance? And yet you are upset that they accept the BIL’s GF.

It’s his life, not their’s. The IL’s could of course choose to remain in contact with the ex if she’d wanted that.But that doesn’t mean they should shun the new GF.

I agree, I'm not sure that BIL has done much wrong here.

Would posters rather he stayed in an unhappy marriage?

Marriages don't always work, it's a fact of life.

Allfur · 28/02/2024 11:00

Porfirio - useful input

MayThe4th · 28/02/2024 10:56

Nobody knows what goes on in someone else’s marriage.

It’s easy to say that he was a twat/prick/difficult but unhappiness in a marriage is rarely that black and white.

Also it’s not a popular viewpoint on here, but if the marriage was unhappy and the BIL ended up leaving because of this woman it’s entirely possible that the kids love her. I know several people whose parents left for other partners and the children have had fantastic relationships with them, even going forward.

From your perspective it’s your DH’s family. And realistically while you don’t have to like this woman you’re also as much as an outsider as she is. How would you feel if your IL’s refused to accept you for instance? And yet you are upset that they accept the BIL’s GF.

It’s his life, not their’s. The IL’s could of course choose to remain in contact with the ex if she’d wanted that.But that doesn’t mean they should shun the new GF.

SausageAndEggSandwich · 28/02/2024 10:51

Why would you let yourself be assigned as default childcare while DH, BIL and GF go for a non kid friendly hike? Why would you do that to yourself?

No. It's your holiday too! They need to go on a kid friendly hike or DGPs look after all the kids or THEY DON'T GO

You talk about your insecurities, which I won't say are entirely valid but at this point you are just reinforcing them. If you don't want DH to see you as dull, boring, mummy who doesn't hike then stop letting them assign you that role!

If you want to hike then DH has to facilitate it. He and you should go together and BIL and GF should look after the children. And then you swap so the next day BIL and GF go out. Stop letting them have everything their way.

p1ppyL0ngstocking · 28/02/2024 10:49

A family friend went through a very similar situation to the OP; she struggled to warm to the BILs OW (who became his partner) and was berated by her PIL and SIL for not being more accepting and welcoming of this woman into the family.

A few years later, the same OW had an affair with the SIL's H. The same reasons were given by the H "we've been unhappy for a while, OW is sporty & fun; SIL has become boring" (I.e. she'd been too busy raising the kids and doing the housework to suck his dick regularly).

All of a sudden the PIL and SIL thought the OW was the biggest bitch in the universe and that my friend would be the most awful person if she accepted OW and the H into her life.

As it was, the new couple moved away together so the friend wouldn't have seen them anyway. But it's surprising how exactly the same situation and people were viewed, depending on who was hurt.

Birch101 · 28/02/2024 10:48

I'm sure your ex SIL will be climbing mountains now she will have 50% kid free time.

I'd be gritting my teeth at BIL. But I suppose at least the children seem to have accepted the change which is key. Like others have said it may all change if they stay together for the long run and decide to have children themselves

Speak to your husband about your feelings and any insecurities and who knows maybe this woman may encourage you to climb some mountains too

taylorswift1989 · 28/02/2024 10:47

JCLV · 28/02/2024 10:38

Make sure you arrange a day on holiday going off by yourself doing something you enjoy. And inform DH BIL and SIL that they are looking after the kids.

No, this isn't the right approach. Don't treat it like a competition between you and DH. All that does is cement the separation between you and the other adults. I don't think DH spending more time with BIL and GF and less with you is a good idea at all.

Instead, make sure that you and DH get alone, kid-free time to do something together. Find something that will connect you and make you feel close and secure. Sex and conversation, laughter, a shared interest. Spend a day or evening just the two of you and make it a lovely, warm and happy time. Let him see that while BIL is having fun, he's not having more fun than the two of you are, and he doesn't have decades of friendship behind him to make the connection deep and significant the way you and DH do.

Whatever you do, don't set yourself against DH in this situation.

Porfirio · 28/02/2024 10:45

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Porfirio · 28/02/2024 10:44

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 28/02/2024 10:41

A very ex bf - like 30 years - married a younger woman. Had been friends with him and his ex-DW for a long time. I had a lot of trouble warming to her - there is something about seeing a contemporary replaced with a younger woman which is horrible. FWIW I got to know new wife better and she is lovely. But its ok to not like the trend of women being replaced with younger partners.

JCLV · 28/02/2024 10:38

Make sure you arrange a day on holiday going off by yourself doing something you enjoy. And inform DH BIL and SIL that they are looking after the kids.

cheddercherry · 28/02/2024 10:36

I don’t actually think you’re being unreasonable, you can’t help your thoughts we can’t control our reactions all of the time. You are aware it’s not her fault, but nor are you at fault for feeling uncomfortable. You’d be unreasonable to ACT or VOICE these issues to her, but you’re not at all in the wrong for internally feeling this way.

After all, she’s the living embodiment of married women’s secret nightmare waltzing out of the shadows of their insecurities: she’s the the younger, hotter, no strings attached, active, sexually adventurous, “cool girl”. She’s the reality women hope don’t befall their own marriages, she’s the woman husbands swear to their wives they aren’t looking at/ attracted to/ interested in… until they are. She’s the “it won’t happen to us” standing in front of you. No one likes to feel replaceable, and she’s the new model. So no, I don't think you’re unreasonable to not warm to her but nor is this her fault and maybe one day he’ll do it again to her.

There’s a lot of pressure to be the perfect antidote to a wife when you’re the young fun girlfriend, maybe she’ll come to realise that it’s just as hard living up to the “dream girl” as much as you find it jarring to see the dream girl up close.

CormorantStrikesBack · 28/02/2024 10:34

You don’t have to be friends with her just because she’s with your bil. But be polite and superficially friendly with her. You might find over time that you warm to her but ultimately you don’t have to be mates with the in laws.

all the stuff about how you feel your bil was neglectful to your ex SIL that’s between them two. Try not to give it head space

ForgivenessHope · 28/02/2024 10:33

@AppelationStation if you needed my advice, I would say, act confident, act as if you are not bothered by gf competition, be nice to her- that is what will keep your dh. trust me on this. get therapy to improve your confidence or go on hikes with dh instead of therapy- same difference.

act the opposite, and you will be here in 2 years about your dh. men don't like their women being jealous/ feeling threatened by a new woman. it is enough for your dh to go.

LolaSmiles · 28/02/2024 10:30

Doesn't everyone have loads of sex at the beginning of a relationship? Wonder how long it will continue to be his 'love language'.
It'll probably always be his love language because he can pout and sulk because she knew sex was his love language when they got together.

She's also probably aware that any lines he's fed her (going to guess here that it's the usual wife doesn't get me, we were unhappy, we never have sex, poor me without enough time to do cycling and hiking) means that she knows from the start that when she gets older, or if they have children and her priority isn't him, or she expects him to not put hobbies and sex first, he's the sort of man that would be happy to trade her in for a younger woman.

I agree with PP that she sounds nice and switched on so hopefully she realises she can do better.

saraclara · 28/02/2024 10:30

... And yes, I'd be asking when MIL and I get our free day without the kids. And that no, SIL doesn't get to come along when we do. It's her turn to babysit.

SmallBox · 28/02/2024 10:29

Were you invited on the hike? Or did they just assume you'd be happy to look after all the kids while they have a nice day out?

saraclara · 28/02/2024 10:27

If my BIL (or my SIL come to that) started telling me about their hot sex life I'd want to go and throw up somewhere. Ew.

Pocketfullofdogtreats · 28/02/2024 10:26

As for coping with her, treat her as you would any new woman you met - a new work colleague, for example. Just take each moment as it comes rather than letting yourself be coloured by the past. You might find you enjoy her company. What you aren't doing is being disrespectful to your ex-SIL by accepting her - that's on BIL. But you've all been put in this situation by him and it would be best for everyone if it works out.

Allfur · 28/02/2024 10:21

I'd go on that hike and get the lowdown on her

rookiemere · 28/02/2024 10:20

I'm not sure OP is really being allocated for childcare here.

The ILs seem like they could handle that themselves, so it's more about DH choosing to yomp up a mountain with his arsey DB and mspertbottom DGF than anything else.

I say just leave them to it, it will probably be the most enjoyable day of the holiday.The cousins get to be together without any conflicting loyalties about daddies new DGF and ILs can relax in their company. It must be hard for the ILs as well, deep down they will know that their DS is a bit of a selfish twit, so they are probably just relieved he has picked a decent DGF.

I suspect there may be attempts to force a foursome on you like a meal out without DCs. i would maybe just be honest with the DGF tell her she seems nice, but you're struggling a bit with the whole concept as you were close friends with ex-wife. She sounds smart - too smart to be with BIL - so I'm sure she will get it.

ForgivenessHope · 28/02/2024 10:19

I am still not convinced that his unhappiness and the unhappiness of his previous marriage should be 100% ignored.

or is he the first one to find the dipping in energy, attractiveness of ex spouse affect the marriage? or is it just abuse- financial or physical- laziness, not wanting to change jobs etc etc which are acceptable reasons?

I am not talking about op and her insecurities and projections which she has admitted. although maybe op wants to be honest and say her own marriage is also unhappy/is struggling?

Allfur · 28/02/2024 10:17

Doesn't everyone have loads of sex at the beginning of a relationship? Wonder how long it will continue to be his 'love language'.

TruthorDie · 28/02/2024 10:15

Why do you have to do the childcare? It’s your holiday as well

I can see why this has all unsettled you. When my SIL and BIL (my then husbands brother) split up then l saw an unpleasant side to how the whole family saw it. This was then replicated when my husband and l split up

Couldntgiveafunk · 28/02/2024 10:12

Can you get out with MIL to do something nice you both enjoy, and leave the kids with DH/BIL/the new partner so you get some down time too? Seems only fair if you do a whole day of childcare.

I also get where you are coming from OP. You aren’t a bad person. I promise it will get easier to feel ok about her. Similar situation here many years ago, and I am now good friends with the “new” woman and she’s a hoot. She was massively insecure about us all not accepting her, as it turns out. Don’t be too hard on yourself.