Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

BILs new girlfriend - how do I NBU?

211 replies

AppelationStation · 27/02/2024 22:37

Jeez. This turned out to be loooong.

I know I am being pretty unreasonable here. I guess I'm looking for suggestions to shift my thinking so I don't let myself down and act like a tw*t.

BIL (DHs brother) separated from his wife almost 2 years ago.

Prior to this, the four of us were close friends for a while, living near by, seeing each at least once a week. In more recent years both couples relocated and we saw each other less. We have kids of a similar age, who are also quite close, so whenever we did meet up it was lovely.

We knew things were a bit rocky but didn't see the separation coming. BIL immediately got together with another woman, who he'd previously been friends with. He was seeing his new GF after he and exSIL decided to split, but before they'd moved out of their house together. We met her during this period when they were supposedly just friends, but I had a gut feeling which proved to be right.

New GF is very nice. I can't fault her. She's never expressed a negative thought or opinion within ear shot of me, on anything. BILs kids love her, the family love her, she fits right in. Everyone is, rightly, happy for BIL. There's a bit of me that feels BILs ex of 20 odd years, their kids' mum and my former friend (my attempts to contact her have been met with a luke warm response, fair enough) has very quickly been replaced. Maybe because I'm an inlaw in their family and it makes me feel insecure.

Here's where i'm being a tw*t: I can't warm to her. I am someone who wears my faults on my sleave and I can see 0 chink in her armour. To quote Motherland, "Where is her secret sadness?!". I find it a bit spooky.

Also, BIL is very loved up and vocal about how he was so unhappy for so long because his ex just wasn't his person. Thanks to new GF he's apparently discovered sex is his "love language" (!) and he was missing that before. They're both incredibly fit, outdoorsy people who share their love of mountaineering and cycling. I'm aware there's nothing wrong with this. BUT...

I find myself wanting to scream "OF COURSE YOUR NEW GF IS ALL SEXY AND SKINNY AND HAS TIME FOR YOUR HOBBIES BIL, SHE IS 10 YRS YOUNGER AND HASN'T BEEN BRINGING UP YOUR 2 KIDS FOR THE LAST TEN YEARS!"

FYI, BIL is quite hard to live with I'd say, and was quite neglectful as a partner to his ex.

I feel like my feelings are rather telling about my own marriage, and their new relationship is tapping into my own, grossly unattractive, insecurities. But that doesn't make the feelings go away. I just find it all...icky.

We're all going on a family holiday together soon and I'm dreading it. So, acknowledging IABU, what do I need to tell myself to get me out of this negative thinking pattern, and survive a long weekend in close quarters?

Extra points for empathy.
Top points for a kind telling off.
Zero points for telling me what I already know about how much of a dreadful person I am (I'm on it, ta).

OP posts:
Noicant · 29/02/2024 19:20

Codlingmoths · 28/02/2024 04:58

Can you talk to your dh, and say you’d appreciate a bit of emotional support to stop yourself screaming at his brother <exactly what you said- SHE’S TEN YEARS YOUNGER AND DIDNT GIVE BIRTH TO AND BRING UP YOUR KIDS SO OF BLOODY COURSE SHE HAS TIME AND ENERGY FOR SEX AND HOBBIES>, because I would expect my Dh to be totally on board with my emotions here, which I would feel pretty strongly . ‘Got the kids, drained the wife to a husk, so upgrading to younger sexy fit childfree model a man like me hasn’t yet drained’ is so classically male entitlement. Id have been full of snide comments I’m afraid - ‘mountain climbing! How nice- I hope Ella <his ex> gets a chance to take up hobbies like that now you are more hands on with parenting 😁

But a bit of support should be a big help in reigning in the resentment of the new gf.
I hear you on the in law awareness and how quickly they drop the exes.

Thats exactly how I would feel to be brutally honest. I’d be disgusted with my BIL if he did the same. Thing to remember is that the fault is with him and not her.

DreamingofManderley · 29/02/2024 19:17

I think that this is you projecting your own insecurities. The ex was replaced with a younger, more fun (in his eyes) model and the family have all accepted this with open arms.

Of course you’re going to wonder if they’d do the same with you. Honestly I’d do the same, I know I would. The only advice I could give is that if that is going to happen then it’ll happen no matter what. Worrying over something that might not happen is just going to drive you crazy.

You are loyal to your friend, but that does not mean you can’t like the new gf. As you say she hasn’t done anything wrong here, you don’t have to dislike her just because the ex might.

Mumof3confused · 29/02/2024 19:13

Sounds like your BIL is a bit of a twat and I know this type. He’s rewriting the story of his relationship with ex. Warning bells. New girlfriend is clearly very naive.

He might also have said something to his ex about you to stop your contact. Ie made something up that you’ve said or something. He wants her cut out completely.

CandiceBloor · 29/02/2024 18:48

I don’t think you are being unreasonable, in fact you are being very generous.

You are an in law in this family and you have seen how quickly you can be replaced. Of course that is making you feel uncomfortable! You are blaming the new girlfriend but it is the BIL really here who appears to be showing, and I know this is a bit harsh given we don’t know all the facts only they do, but it’s untrustworthy character. That is why you are feeling uneasy. It’s a bit like having your kid run free in a sweet shop and trying to find reasons to blame the sweets. We just can’t accept it’s our little darling. Truth is there usually will be always be some willing woman around, he’s chosen this.

You’ve reached out to ex Sil but she hasn’t responded warmly, fair enough given the situation like you said. There is every likelihood she is sad too to lose her friend because of exs choices but needs to move on. I’d be annoyed too and miss her. You had a good thing going by the sounds of it.

As others have said, stick to your own side of the road and keep it clean. It’s all you can do. However, I would also be taking note & probably giving more priority to my own friends, hobbies etc ready in case of facing this myself in future in light of knowing how easily the family accepted this. I suspect this would help the feelings & confidence generally so a win win.

It’s uncomfortable and none of us want to think about it but divorce is common as is shopping in the wife for a younger model. And it’s worth remembering there is no reason he won’t go shopping again once she gets older / he has kids with her and she can or longer climb mountains on a whim…

Im a bit biased though as my grandfather married three times in the end and no doubt girlfriends too. I heard every excuse for it from various family members not directly affected blaming the ‘new’ woman and always felt very sorry for my mum, aunt and uncle who suffered gratefully from it. The only reason he stopped was because he was so old his body wouldn’t let him anymore 😂

Ohhoho · 29/02/2024 18:32

I haven’t read all the e posts but a few of them have said how it wasn’t the new younger gf’s fault. Well if the affair started before they had broken up she does bear some responsibility. Women who take other peoples husbands are the pits. Especially if they have children. I wouldn't agree to a relationship with a married man until he had been living separately for at least six months. You just don’t do it. Men will get away with whatever they can. It’s a dreadful betrayal. It never happened to me but I have known three wives to whom this happened who felt so humiliated and in such grief one took her own life in two of the other cases had breakdowns. It should not be tolerated as though it was nothing.
OP your instincts are true and real. I’m sure you’ll do your best not to cause uproar but you’re right.

AgnesX · 29/02/2024 18:24

I don't think it's the g/friend that's the problem but the twattish-ness of your BIL.

"Love language is sex" 🙄 I wonder how long that idiocy will last for. That aside, it's not really for you to judge.

StockpotSoup · 29/02/2024 18:18

No, I am not “devoid of a moral compass” 🙄 But for me, parents have a moral duty to the people they brought into the world. That means sometimes accepting their choices, even if you disagree with them, and moving forward as best you can. Refusing to accept their new partner after TWO YEARS would frankly put you on a fast track to having zero relationship with them.

If you read what I’ve said properly, you’ll see I’ve agreed that it’s better to get along when there are children involved. And if you read what YOU said properly, your exact words were “Both of them deserve to be excluded from family events, to make way for your poor SIL”. So you were indeed advocating cutting him out.

Are you honestly saying you think it’s normal to be inviting your child’s former spouse to a family party instead of them? As well as them would be weird enough!

ttcat37 · 29/02/2024 16:31

StockpotSoup · 29/02/2024 12:04

This is utterly ridiculous. Who excluded their own child in favour of their former spouse? It just doesn’t happen - and indeed shouldn’t happen.

I find it bizarre how many people are criticising OP’s PILs for “abandoning” their former DIL or “erasing her from history”. What do you expect them to do? Build a shrine to her? Begin every family event with an announcement that they do not acknowledge their divorce and that, as far as they are concerned, former DIL is their son’s one true wife?

It’s nice if people can still get along with their former in-laws in the event of a divorce, especially when there are children involved. But really, that’s all it needs to be. Several people have told OP that she needn’t be anything more than basically civil to the “new” woman given they only have a relationship through BIL. Well, isn’t that equally true of his parents and his ex? Why would they stay close when they no longer have that connection?

Also, has it ever occurred to you (or anyone lamenting the former SIL’s “exclusion”) that maybe SHE isn’t interested in maintaining a relationship with her ex’s family? Maybe her “at best lukewarm” response to the OP’s attempts at contact is not because she’s terribly hurt that her former in-laws haven’t publicly shunned her ex’s new partner, but because she simply doesn’t want to be around people she associates with her ex? She presumably has parents, maybe siblings, of her own, plus friends. Perhaps she wants to spend her time with them.

Are you devoid of a moral compass?
Of course the parents would want to maintain a relationship with their DIL, so they maintain the best relationship possible with their grandchildren. Plus their son and DIL were married for over 20 years, and you propose that they’re not married anymore so they just cut her out? She plays a huge part of their family history.
And no, I wouldn’t suggest they cut their own son off for his behaviour- although I wouldn’t blame them- but if this was my son there is no chance he would be bringing the woman he most likely cheated with to play happy families.

Mrsjayy · 29/02/2024 15:24

Lisagreasa · 29/02/2024 12:35

Who the fuck says in public " sex is my love language?"

Don't go. You might murder him.

I mean I read that and I got the mythical .ICK and shuddered !

Lisagreasa · 29/02/2024 12:35

Who the fuck says in public " sex is my love language?"

Don't go. You might murder him.

LadyBird1973 · 29/02/2024 12:25

I wouldn't choose a dil over my own son, but if I felt he'd behaved badly, he'd definitely hear about it from me and I wouldn't tolerate him bad mouthing her, if she'd spent years raising my grandchildren while DS pleased himself.
I love my kids unconditionally but that doesn't mean accepting without criticism everything they do.

I suppose the problem here is that we are expected to view our in-laws as family, when we get married, but there really is a difference between those people who are 'ours' and those who are family only through marriage.

StockpotSoup · 29/02/2024 12:04

ttcat37 · 28/02/2024 17:57

YABU by being far too nice to the pair of them. They were clearly at it before your BIL abandoned his wife- you can see that can’t you?
And no wonder your efforts to keep peace with your SIL were met with a lukewarm response when you’ve welcomed this new woman into your family with open arms. What a fucking insult.
Both of them deserve to be excluded from family events, to make way for your poor SIL, not the rest of the family condoning his behaviour and making extra effort to make them feel welcome.

This is utterly ridiculous. Who excluded their own child in favour of their former spouse? It just doesn’t happen - and indeed shouldn’t happen.

I find it bizarre how many people are criticising OP’s PILs for “abandoning” their former DIL or “erasing her from history”. What do you expect them to do? Build a shrine to her? Begin every family event with an announcement that they do not acknowledge their divorce and that, as far as they are concerned, former DIL is their son’s one true wife?

It’s nice if people can still get along with their former in-laws in the event of a divorce, especially when there are children involved. But really, that’s all it needs to be. Several people have told OP that she needn’t be anything more than basically civil to the “new” woman given they only have a relationship through BIL. Well, isn’t that equally true of his parents and his ex? Why would they stay close when they no longer have that connection?

Also, has it ever occurred to you (or anyone lamenting the former SIL’s “exclusion”) that maybe SHE isn’t interested in maintaining a relationship with her ex’s family? Maybe her “at best lukewarm” response to the OP’s attempts at contact is not because she’s terribly hurt that her former in-laws haven’t publicly shunned her ex’s new partner, but because she simply doesn’t want to be around people she associates with her ex? She presumably has parents, maybe siblings, of her own, plus friends. Perhaps she wants to spend her time with them.

Vod · 29/02/2024 11:09

LolaSmiles · 29/02/2024 09:12

What a woman 10 years younger than a man leaving his wife and children for more sex sees in him is....baffling. I'd question her intelligence. She probably just feels really flattered she's got one up on another woman.
I think that's possibly a little unfair on her.From what the OP says the new girlfriend is quite nice.

I'm not sure so much she's flattered to have got one up on another woman in a spiteful way, more that she's likely a little naïve and has fallen into the common trap of an older man fancying her with all the scripts that come with it.

At the back of her mind, if she has any sense, will be the nagging awareness that the second she ages, or has children, or the honeymoon phase of lots of sex tails off, he's highly likely to start looking for a replacement. He's being very (far too) open with her and everyone that his priorities are himself, sex and being the cool man with lots of hobbies.

Agree.

AwfullyWeeBillyBigchin · 29/02/2024 10:34

Fizzadora · 27/02/2024 23:55

Well he's a cyclist ergo he is a knob.
I'm afraid I wouldn't have been able to resist bursting his smug bubble when he denigrated his wife.
You need to re-think this OP, you think it's the girlfriend that you don't like but actually it's BIL, isn't it.

You don't have to be a cyclist to be a knob. Clearly.

LadyBird1973 · 29/02/2024 10:25

It should be a red flag to a younger woman when a man has left his first wife because he's not getting enough sex or she wasn't 'fun' (because she was stuck with the kids). That is likely to be her in a few years, if she wants children!

DisappearingGirl · 29/02/2024 09:28

I wonder if the new GF will be on here in a few years' time, as we see variations on the below on here constantly:

"DH and I have two kids age 1 and 3, he wants to go out all day Saturday to do his [man hobby / cycling / mountain climbing]. But it's his day to have his two pre-teens. He's asked me to look after all four of them, but it's a lot of work especially when I've been up all night with the baby. Also I know he's going with a younger child-free woman he's friendly with which I'm finding hard, especially as he complains we don't have sex as much lately. Also I'm not sure sex is my love language anymore. AIBU?"

Rosestulips · 29/02/2024 09:25

Janehasamane · 29/02/2024 09:00

Feelings are neither right or wrong, they simply are. However in this instance it is nothing to do with the woman, who is perfectly nice and done nothing wrong. This is all about the op and her jealousy and insecurity.

as said, folks are now focusing on the hike like they are desperately trying to find something wrong and attack any one but the op. This is because she says she was “allocated childcare”.

op if you don’t wish to care for your own kids with your mil then speak to your husband and explain this. Use your words. Don’t agree then bitch behind his back. Simply say no I’m not willing to do that so you can’t go on the hike. However this is totally seperate to the fact you’re jealous of the bil new girlfriend and insecure about your relationship.

Where has she bitched about the hike? She’s explained that it’s not a hike for children? You must have read a different post to me.

And just because someone is ‘nice’ doesn’t necessarily mean they are going to get on with each other. Why be fake? I doubt she is going to be mean to her too

OP has admitted she in insecure, and is working on it.

Hankunamatata · 29/02/2024 09:22

I think I would struggle to keep my mouth closed when he started going on about his love language. Icky

bobbycock79 · 29/02/2024 09:13

I could have written this word for word about my own brother in law (in fact I did and asked similar advice about how to get over my feelings of anger towards him and OW) Nothing really helped , time meant I accepted her and my ex-SIL also distanced herself from our side of the family, we rarely see my niece and nephew now as they're older and have made the choice not to see much of their dad. His new relationship lasted a few years but reality set in and they split, he's now with someone even younger ! can't be on his own apparently. His socials are full of pics of wild nights out and city breaks (he's mid 40's) . I have no respect for him and I don't think DH does either. I used to feel very insecure because as you say , who wouldn't want to trade in a life of nonstop work/drudgery of childcare/ no money with exciting sex and freedom? However DH is still with me and recognises his brother's personality flaws and knows how his life has been very unstable and permeated with mental health issues since the divorce. Ultimately it's not a life to be envied.

LolaSmiles · 29/02/2024 09:12

What a woman 10 years younger than a man leaving his wife and children for more sex sees in him is....baffling. I'd question her intelligence. She probably just feels really flattered she's got one up on another woman.
I think that's possibly a little unfair on her.From what the OP says the new girlfriend is quite nice.

I'm not sure so much she's flattered to have got one up on another woman in a spiteful way, more that she's likely a little naïve and has fallen into the common trap of an older man fancying her with all the scripts that come with it.

At the back of her mind, if she has any sense, will be the nagging awareness that the second she ages, or has children, or the honeymoon phase of lots of sex tails off, he's highly likely to start looking for a replacement. He's being very (far too) open with her and everyone that his priorities are himself, sex and being the cool man with lots of hobbies.

Janehasamane · 29/02/2024 09:00

Rosestulips · 29/02/2024 08:35

I don’t think there is anything wrong with feeling the way you are. And you don’t have to click with this woman, I’m sure you’ll be polite to her

You can feel sad because you have lost a relationship due to someone else’s decisions.

You’re fine OP and you will be, just be authentic

Feelings are neither right or wrong, they simply are. However in this instance it is nothing to do with the woman, who is perfectly nice and done nothing wrong. This is all about the op and her jealousy and insecurity.

as said, folks are now focusing on the hike like they are desperately trying to find something wrong and attack any one but the op. This is because she says she was “allocated childcare”.

op if you don’t wish to care for your own kids with your mil then speak to your husband and explain this. Use your words. Don’t agree then bitch behind his back. Simply say no I’m not willing to do that so you can’t go on the hike. However this is totally seperate to the fact you’re jealous of the bil new girlfriend and insecure about your relationship.

Rosestulips · 29/02/2024 08:35

I don’t think there is anything wrong with feeling the way you are. And you don’t have to click with this woman, I’m sure you’ll be polite to her

You can feel sad because you have lost a relationship due to someone else’s decisions.

You’re fine OP and you will be, just be authentic

Crumblespiesetc · 29/02/2024 08:05

You don't sound like a terrible person, rather an honest one! Every single person on this planet will have someone who taps into their insecurities. I suppose she represents a threat (represents rather than is).

Because you asked for advice on how to handle... and this is just a forum, my quick tips would be:

  1. Give it time. You don't have to be best buddies with her, I'm sure you'll manage to remain polite and nothing catastrophic will happen.
  1. Address the part of you that can't warm to her as just that - a part of you. It is not the whole of you. And it sounds like it is a part that is trying to protect you. Whether this part is right or wrong in its assessment of her and the situation, just thank it.
  1. You sound a bit overly reasonable if you ask me! Not a bad thing, but what if you let rip in a completely unreasonable letter to her/BIL/whoever (that you won't send)? One of the reasons I hate AIBU is because some people use it to enforce that feelings are somehow wrong and we shouldn't have them unless the situation meets a very specific set of criteria. That's not how feelings work. You can have feelings without letting them take over your rational brain. You sound very good at being rational, so I wouldn't worry about that.

And questions:

  1. Do you need some reassurance from your husband?
  1. Will DH and BIL be doing some childcare on the weekend so you can have some time to yourself?

Ps She probably does have baggage, even if she is only 30!

Pps And saying that sex is his love language? Ew!

FasterthanaButteredOtter · 29/02/2024 08:04

Codlingmoths · 28/02/2024 09:46

Dh, I’ve realised I have always quite enjoyed holidays with your parents, they are low key and fun. Now they aren’t, because I’ve been reduced to the woman who gets allocated the childcare while you and your brother go off and have fun. Why is it you think I’m going to keep coming to these? When are you and your brother going to do all the childcare and I get time off? Think carefully before answering please.

Yep

FasterthanaButteredOtter · 29/02/2024 08:01

FYI, I and MIL have already been allocated childcare for the day while BIL, GF and DH go on an all day hike together.

Fuck that. Who did the allocating? I'd be having a very sharp clear word about that! Nope!

Swipe left for the next trending thread