Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

son in law and social class

91 replies

highlandslady · 27/02/2024 20:26

Hello, I am posting for the first time and do realise I'm being silly about this, so I do feel.a bit embarrassed. Please be gentle !

My oldest daughter (30) has married and had a son with her DH, (44). She is the first of our three girls to get married and we adore our grandson, and like SIL very much too.

However I'm getting in a tizz about things and worrying. They are having a wedding party to celebrate their marriage (small family affair in Scotland which we encouraged). They just had a small registry office wedding after their son was born, so this is a chance to celebrate

Now however his family are getting involved , it's becoming bigger. They are much wealthier, posher, and higher educated than we are.
Even though my SIL has been nothing but kind, generous and thoughtful with us, I do feel strange about the difference between us.
He is obviously older than my daughter and people have made comments about her being a golddigger ( small village with gossips) . He brought us things like some lovely champagne as a present - he lives in France - and my sisters made a slightly sarcastic comment . Recently we had a village fundraiser for a charity appeal which he donated a significant sum to, meaning we reached our goal. He did this anonymously but it was easy to tell it was him, and afterwards he made a comment playing it down and suggesting it was nothing - well, it was months worth of mortgage payments and utilities to me. He also recently offered (via my daughter) to help my other daughter with childcare fees as she is really struggling. He did this very discreetly and politely but it made me feel like I can't provide for my family.

I also feel very intimidated by his parents who are quite cool, snobby and seem to look down on us. His father held a very, very senior position in his career.

My son in law is only a few years younger than me (so 'sil' sounds strange ) but has a very impressive career, beautiful house, top first class oxbridge degree.

I've always felt confident but for some reason all of this is shaking me.

OP posts:
saraclara · 27/02/2024 21:32

What kind of wedding does your daughter want? If she only wants a quiet wedding, then help her find the strength to stand up to his parents, it to convince him that's that is what she wants and to stand up to his own parents.

My daughter's ex was a similarly nice guy, CV with parents who were super confident ex pat wealthy types. My reserved DD (and me as a very ordinary widow) found them pretty terrifying.

I was sad that she and he split up (for unrelated reasons) but her present partner and his parents are so much more relaxing to be around. So I do understand how you feel.

Janehasamane · 27/02/2024 21:30

highlandslady · 27/02/2024 21:09

Yes - exactly this !
I had her at 20 so he is only a bit younger than me (and is much closer in age to me than her - so that's another thing because I've now got friends flirting with him, unhelpfully!)

It's so much easier for men.

This just gets worse. You’re all jealous and your friends hit on him? Poor bloke.

Maybeicanhelpyou · 27/02/2024 21:24

@GooseClues
thats not your call to make!

GooseClues · 27/02/2024 21:23

On one hand he sounds lovely but on the other, a man in his 40s who still can’t let go of his mommy’s skirt and is easily influenced by her (insisting on boarding schools?!!! Wtf?!!) is not exactly a catch, is he?

Meowandthen · 27/02/2024 21:21

highlandslady · 27/02/2024 21:09

Yes - exactly this !
I had her at 20 so he is only a bit younger than me (and is much closer in age to me than her - so that's another thing because I've now got friends flirting with him, unhelpfully!)

It's so much easier for men.

I hope you are joking about your friends flirting with you son-in-law. If not, that is hugely inappropriate and disrespectful.

They need to behave as do your other daughters if they are making comments.

If your daughter doesn’t want a big wedding, now is the time to speak up. Her in-laws don’t get any say in where her child goes to school.

Janehasamane · 27/02/2024 21:19

This is quite unpleasant, it is like you accept his generosity but resent it and are jealous. He’s your son in law. You just need to make nice and try to rein your families meanness in.

Yesyoucant · 27/02/2024 21:12

Misthios · 27/02/2024 20:40

Inverse snobbery in action.

How exactly?

PingvsPong · 27/02/2024 21:10

highlandslady · 27/02/2024 21:06

Thank you- yes , I agree with their tastes taking precedence. He definitely wanted a nanny for their son already, but my daughter didn't and so they have compromised. But his parents are already putting them under pressure to get a place at boarding school etc ! And with the wedding - it's all 'this is the right way to do xyz' and it all costs so much more than anything I would be able to even consider in my wildest dreams.

I don't think 'ordinary' people understand it until they've interacted with people in such circles. It's much much different from a 'working class' person marrying a 'middle class' person I mean, a WC person could go to uni, get a good graduate job and earn well.

This kind of money , and attitude comes from inherited wealth. The difficulty is that the lifestyle is also tied to that wealth, her DH obviously is trying to please his parents because they hold the purse strings.

It's really not the same as any other 'normal family tension'. So people are wrong for just telling you to get over yourself.

highlandslady · 27/02/2024 21:10

HowDoYouSolveAProblemLikeMyRear · 27/02/2024 21:05

Yes, navigating relationships with people from very different social backgrounds is so much harder when it's family/in-laws than friends.

As a solidly middle-class woman whose two long term relationships were respectively with a minor aristocrat and a proudly working class man, I've given my family their share of challenges in this 🤣

He sounds lovely. With luck, in time you'll feel more comfortable and relaxed about him and his family, and his parents will be won over as they get to see your daughter making him happy over the years.

There are so often tensions and difficulties in two families coming together. But it really does sound like your daughter's chosen a good man who's trying to love her family as he would if they were his own.

Did you ever have any funny moments introducing either of your partners?

OP posts:
highlandslady · 27/02/2024 21:09

PingvsPong · 27/02/2024 21:04

They're 30 and 44. Not 19 and 33. Or 35 and 65.

She isn't young enough to be his daughter with a 14 year age gap (OP had her as a teen or very young I'm presuming if she's less than 2 decades older than her daughter). She has enough life experience at 30 to make her own decisions, people can shut the duck up. Think what they want, so small minded, just keep their traps shut.
Especially as.. so many immature men in their 30's stringing women along, refusing to commit etc.

Women can't win. Marry an older man you get called a gold-digger. Marry younger, a cougar. Strangely.. no words for the men who do the same thing.

Edited

Yes - exactly this !
I had her at 20 so he is only a bit younger than me (and is much closer in age to me than her - so that's another thing because I've now got friends flirting with him, unhelpfully!)

It's so much easier for men.

OP posts:
Spirallingdownwards · 27/02/2024 21:09

If she is having issues with his side of the family please don't end up making issues on her side too.

Your other daughters will need to get over themselves too.

highlandslady · 27/02/2024 21:06

PingvsPong · 27/02/2024 20:58

I don't think 'shared accounts' and the family wealth are quite the same thing. But many, many other women as you can see on this site have to deal with worse MILs without the benefit of a kind + generous husband, and his wealth.

Again, you have nothing to worry about really, you seem to have raised a sensible young woman who won't make the mistake of relying on family wealth. So what if his mother tries to 'fence her off'.

For me, when I have seen this situation usually it's that the wealthy side tend to dictate everything. Where the kids go to school, what they do, etc. Probably outing but a relative was dating a man from wealthy farming family, the sort that go to boarding school as a young child, own acres and acres of land, etc. Ultimately while he was extremely generous there was always that unspoken understanding that he would have the final say although he appeared outwardly collaborative. And that his/his family's wants and tastes would take precedence, as you can see with this change in wedding plans.

My relative is clever, beautiful and headstrong, she didn't want to be controlled. So she dumped him.

There are plenty of even celebs that have 'micro-weddings' or quiet weddings. There is no need to force them into a big do. Fair enough, if that's what he originally wanted and can now do with his family's financing along with your daughter. Not fair, if they'd both wanted a small wedding.

Your daughter has made her choice. Support her in the knowledge that she can always come back to you and speak freely.

Edited

Thank you- yes , I agree with their tastes taking precedence. He definitely wanted a nanny for their son already, but my daughter didn't and so they have compromised. But his parents are already putting them under pressure to get a place at boarding school etc ! And with the wedding - it's all 'this is the right way to do xyz' and it all costs so much more than anything I would be able to even consider in my wildest dreams.

OP posts:
HowDoYouSolveAProblemLikeMyRear · 27/02/2024 21:05

Yes, navigating relationships with people from very different social backgrounds is so much harder when it's family/in-laws than friends.

As a solidly middle-class woman whose two long term relationships were respectively with a minor aristocrat and a proudly working class man, I've given my family their share of challenges in this 🤣

He sounds lovely. With luck, in time you'll feel more comfortable and relaxed about him and his family, and his parents will be won over as they get to see your daughter making him happy over the years.

There are so often tensions and difficulties in two families coming together. But it really does sound like your daughter's chosen a good man who's trying to love her family as he would if they were his own.

PingvsPong · 27/02/2024 21:04

coldcallerbaiter · 27/02/2024 20:54

Let’s be honest, many people will be thinking that she married someone 14 years older partly due to his wealth. Is she his second wife at all?

They're 30 and 44. Not 19 and 33. Or 35 and 65.

She isn't young enough to be his daughter with a 14 year age gap (OP had her as a teen or very young I'm presuming if she's less than 2 decades older than her daughter). She has enough life experience at 30 to make her own decisions, people can shut the duck up. Think what they want, so small minded, just keep their traps shut.
Especially as.. so many immature men in their 30's stringing women along, refusing to commit etc.

Women can't win. Marry an older man you get called a gold-digger. Marry younger, a cougar. Strangely.. no words for the men who do the same thing.

ItsVeryHyacinthBucket · 27/02/2024 21:03

KateLizAn · 27/02/2024 20:31

He sounds like a thoughtful generous person.

I think your inferiority complex sounds like the issue rather than him or his family.

Absolutely this. It’s your issue. Don’t fuck things up for your daughter. Sort this inverse snobbery out now (maybe go for some therapy to work out where it’s coming from?

highlandslady · 27/02/2024 20:59

coldcallerbaiter · 27/02/2024 20:54

Let’s be honest, many people will be thinking that she married someone 14 years older partly due to his wealth. Is she his second wife at all?

She is his second wife, yes. They have attracted comments and they've managed this together. I find it very hard as her mother - she has been upset at times, people implying she has married him for money or because he just wants a baby
People can be nasty and judgemental.

OP posts:
PingvsPong · 27/02/2024 20:58

Maybeicanhelpyou · 27/02/2024 20:52

You were quite happy with your life before he came along, so really nothing has changed.
You can’t change the situation, but you can change how you are reacting to it.
Hold your head up high, you brought up a wonderful daughter who he fell in love with. He chose her, be proud, accept him for who he is. Your daughter has.

I don't think 'shared accounts' and the family wealth are quite the same thing. But many, many other women as you can see on this site have to deal with worse MILs without the benefit of a kind + generous husband, and his wealth.

Again, you have nothing to worry about really, you seem to have raised a sensible young woman who won't make the mistake of relying on family wealth. So what if his mother tries to 'fence her off'.

For me, when I have seen this situation usually it's that the wealthy side tend to dictate everything. Where the kids go to school, what they do, etc. Probably outing but a relative was dating a man from wealthy farming family, the sort that go to boarding school as a young child, own acres and acres of land, etc. Ultimately while he was extremely generous there was always that unspoken understanding that he would have the final say although he appeared outwardly collaborative. And that his/his family's wants and tastes would take precedence, as you can see with this change in wedding plans.

My relative is clever, beautiful and headstrong, she didn't want to be controlled. So she dumped him.

There are plenty of even celebs that have 'micro-weddings' or quiet weddings. There is no need to force them into a big do. Fair enough, if that's what he originally wanted and can now do with his family's financing along with your daughter. Not fair, if they'd both wanted a small wedding.

Your daughter has made her choice. Support her in the knowledge that she can always come back to you and speak freely.

Littlecaf · 27/02/2024 20:57

It’s possible to decide they are not your kind of people AND be perfectly nice and pleasant. You do you, let them do them, keep it light and friendly for your DD and family.

coldcallerbaiter · 27/02/2024 20:54

Let’s be honest, many people will be thinking that she married someone 14 years older partly due to his wealth. Is she his second wife at all?

MCOut · 27/02/2024 20:53

I’ve said YANBU because everything you have said, makes it really clear that you know this is your issue. We all have our moments when we feel a bit small and unsure about things. You sound like, you’re the kind of person who is going to do your best to overcome these feelings, and that is all anyone can ask of you

highlandslady · 27/02/2024 20:53

Thank you very much for the comments so far.

Has anyone else found difficulties in navigating a relationship with people from different social backgrounds?

OP posts:
Maybeicanhelpyou · 27/02/2024 20:52

You were quite happy with your life before he came along, so really nothing has changed.
You can’t change the situation, but you can change how you are reacting to it.
Hold your head up high, you brought up a wonderful daughter who he fell in love with. He chose her, be proud, accept him for who he is. Your daughter has.

highlandslady · 27/02/2024 20:50

PingvsPong · 27/02/2024 20:41

Well OP if he isn't standing up to his parents r.e. small wedding I'd be worried too. Everyone else's jealousy, comments etc are irrelevant.
He married your daughter after she'd had his child - which is the right thing to do. But why didn't he do so before... how long have they been dating? how well do they know each other really?

On the surface he seems kind and generous but donating so much to charity, offering to pay someone else's expenses I can see why it sort of gets people's backs up. it's like he's trying to make a good impression with the money. It is a wee bit overstepping to offer to help with childcare fees but did your daughter accept?

I'm not one to judge, we're not posh but earn well for our age. I do think that throwing money around, that seems little to you but a lot to others can get their backs up. While I also agree that people shouldn't make judgy comments.

Support your daughter, also make sure she's financially watertight because I guarantee you a posh family like that will have good lawyers to make sure that she doesn't inherit too much of the 'family wealth' if she divorces him.

Also I don't understand you saying 'he lives in France'? Surely, as they have a child together. He and your daughter both live in France?

Edited

Hello - yes, I think he is finding it hard to stand up to his parents, and he does share their tastes in some ways.

I Don't feel he is trying to splash the cash in a showy way but it does just make me feel slightly inferior, even though I know I'm from a line of hard working decent people.

And yes - his mother has made it very clear she wants to fence everything off from my daughter. But he has not stood for this and they share accounts etc. My daughter feels embarrassed about how she is perceived and tries to pay her way - she doesn't want to be seen as a trophy wife.

They do really love each other, you can just tell, they are so happy in each other's company. She met him when she was 26 but they didn't get together until a bit later.
It's a bit quicker as a relationship because they both wanted a child together (br already has children)

OP posts:
PingvsPong · 27/02/2024 20:49

Misthios · 27/02/2024 20:45

You ARE being judgemental!! They're "not like us", they're better educated, they're cold and aloof.

You have decided you do not like these people without even giving them a chance, and despite of their son being lovely. Purely because they have money.

Wrong. It's her DAUGHTER who finds them cold and aloof. Not the OP.
Surely she knows. They are her in-laws after all.

It's not wrong for OP to feel a bit insecure, as long as she doesn't influence her daughter. We can't help our feelings borne of a lifetime of experiences.

Everyone else should shut up, reject his help if they don't want it but really...

WandaWonder · 27/02/2024 20:49

highlandslady · 27/02/2024 20:40

Yes - but it's hard because I do care about my family and I think jealousy can be natural
We are in a small community so these things do have an impact

For calm normal rational people jealousy is not normal it appears he nor his family is the one with the issues