Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To use local optician for eye test & Specsavers for glasses

39 replies

MrsQuince · 27/02/2024 18:41

I have an appointment booked with my local optician and suspect I will be told I need new specs. While I always try to support indie businesses, I feel torn as this particular opticians stocks only really expensive designer frames.

So I am considering taking the prescription and buying the glasses elsewhere - either Specsavers or an online company.

Are there any potential downsides to this approach?

And what about the ethics of it - will the local optician still make a profit on my test (I get a free NHS test but pay a bit extra for OCT scan) or is the margin really just in the sale of frames?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Almostwelsh · 28/02/2024 12:43

@Roselilly36 it still means that it's likely a local optician has invested into the business and actually works at the store.

suki1964 · 28/02/2024 08:58

Specsavers, vision direct etc vary dramatically so of course peoples experiences will vary

Where I used to live, I wouldn't touch Specsavers because I had a bad experience there and chose Vision Direct

Now where I live I have been using the same Specsavers branch for 20 years and have seen the same 1 or 2 optometrists throughout that time. I get excellent CS there

Only one time have I had a problem with a prescription where they had changed the brand of lens they used, the partner tracked down my old lens brand and I got replacements within a week

I have never experienced "hard sell'. I take a basket and walk around the displays and pick whatever frames I think I like, then take them back and sit with an advisor and try them on and this can easily take a couple of hours, back and forth. I have a complex prescription, I have to wear glasses to see anything, so the frames are something I have to really love but it doesn't matter if I pay £49 or £149 and indeed I came out with two pairs this week, one pair from each end of the price bracket. Its the cost of my prescription that pushes up the price to "do I need to remortgage the house " level

FenellaBestwick · 28/02/2024 08:36

I ditched my local independent optician after he charged me £100 for an eye test. He was taking the piss.

anythinginapinch · 28/02/2024 08:32

Indi opticians all the way for me. They fix a broken "arm", do stuff to make glasses for perfectly again, know le personally and know my eyesight and I trust them to see any problems in my eyes. Why not pay for that? It's one of the few "shops" on a high street where that old fashioned "personal customer service" remains strong.

Nannyfannybanny · 28/02/2024 08:29

I had problems at 2 separate branches of Specsavers, I had a new pair of specs, driving the following day, suddenly felt nauseous, when I got to the shop, the right lense had fallen out! They didn't want to know! Boots have me completely the wrong script.3rd Specsavers, sent by GP for scanning. She told me to use blephasol and eyes permanently. Went to Asda,eye test 3 hours, lovely guy thought it might be a detached retina. Told me...use the products a couple of months,then break, because otherwise you get a knock on effect, like too many painkillers giving you a headache. Have now gone there 10 years. Glasses from glassesdirect for over 20 years, never had a problem. The last Specsavers wanted to sell me contact lenses, I am mildly short sighted. They put them in free trial, got in the car, couldn't see the instruments. I could see miles away, but not close up,had a hell of a job removing them.

Roselilly36 · 28/02/2024 08:20

@Almostwelsh specsavers are not a franchise, they are run as joint venture, which is different to a franchised business model.

Roselilly36 · 28/02/2024 08:17

I would book both the sight tests and specs from the same place tbh. Often prescriptions with different optometrists will vary, so if you need a re test, assuming specs made up and you couldn’t tolerate the prescription, that may be easier with the same practice. Specsavers have a very good policy on this. IMHO you wont necessarily get a better service from an independent, and you won’t be supporting them by having a sight tests, only by ordering specs, this is where they make their money.

Almostwelsh · 28/02/2024 08:06

The opticians at Specsavers are local opticians. Specsavers is a franchise and its likely that your particular franchise is operated by a local optician who has invested into the franchise and also works at the store.

sashh · 28/02/2024 07:58

Why don't you buy the frames you want from wherever and then take them with you for the eye test and ask the optician to fit the new lenses.

My local optician has designer frames but also cheaper ones. They always hand over the prescription.

THey also don't sell contact lenses, they will do the annual check, or if you are new to contacts the initial fitting, but they say you can get them cheaper online.

If you are taking the prescription away with you ask them to measure your 'pupil distance' it's not on the standard script but you need it to get the lenses right.

Priminister · 28/02/2024 06:19

I do the same thing. The indie is really, really good but very expensive. They also still insist on face masks and I refuse to try on multiple pairs of pricey frames while having to wear gloves and mask.

Toddlerteaplease · 28/02/2024 02:54

ashiningbeaconinspace · 27/02/2024 20:28

I had eyes tested and bought specs in Specsavers. Specs didn't feel right so went back and they rechecked and changed the lenses. Still didn't feel right. Went back and was told they were fine! Went to local independent opticians armed with prescription and specs. My correct prescription was different from both what was in the glasses and what was written on the prescription. The glasses and the prescription didn't match either. Got new glasses from independent optician (which were fine). Granted my prescription is complicated - short sight and astigmatism - but was seriously unimpressed with Specsavers and have never gone back.

I had similar issues, with them.,

Toddlerteaplease · 28/02/2024 02:53

Of course you can do that. I always shop around. You just say that you can't see anything you like, and they'll give you a copy of the prescription.

amberedover1 · 28/02/2024 02:45

I had exactly the same question , same circumstances @MrsQuince .
In the end I went to Specsavers for test and glasses.
It was ok but I struggled with the hard sell for expensive frames
I've previously got glasses from Asda and next time will go back there for test and glasses. Cheaper than Specsavers and nicer staff.

Meadowfinch · 28/02/2024 02:31

You can choose to buy from wherever you wish.

My only comment is that the two occasions when I've bought from Specsavers, the glasses have come apart within weeks and I've then spent ages looking for the tiny screws and reassembling them. Total pain.

I haven't had the same issue with Vision Express or on-line

HazelWicker · 28/02/2024 02:24

Optom business models mean they usually make a loss on a sight test. Benchmarking suggest NHS sight tests cost about £50 to perform. Not sure about private in comparison but could well be similar. Having a sight test then buying elsewhere probably costs them money. I'd say don't do it if you want to support them, they make their money on the frames.

HoneyWogan · 28/02/2024 01:37

MassageForLife · 27/02/2024 21:23

Indeed. But op is

a) trying to support her independent optician and
b) going in with full knowledge that, even if new glasses are needed, they will be bought elsewhere

I do agree with you that it's selling the glasses that will make their business profitable, and I personally would feel very cheeky indeed (I know everybody has the absolute right to do so) to have my NHS eye test done at my local indie optician and then take the form away with me so that I can look for glasses elsewhere at a cheaper price.

Do people do this openly, or do they fudge some kind of excuse about making do with their current ones for now or needing to save up before getting new ones - and then coming back in next time their test is due, wearing new(ish) glasses clearly bought from somewhere else?

I used to work with somebody who, whenever he needed new tyres etc. for his car, would phone around all the different companies, back and forth playing them off against each other. He would spend a whole afternoon (all on work time) doing this, ending up saving little more than a few pounds in the end.

I recall that he was always complaining that every garage he used had long waiting lists before they could ever fit him in; whereas my own garage that I've used for 25+ years (professional, highly competent, friendly, trustworthy and usually among the cheapest anyway) will always fit me in at very short notice if something urgent comes up. I wonder why that might be........

Digimoor · 27/02/2024 21:38

I do the opposite - test at specsavers and if they don't have any glasses I like I shop elsewhere

DollyPartonsBeard · 27/02/2024 21:34

I had mine tested at Specsavers and got their 2 for 1 offer (sunglasses and everyday glasses - varifocals so about £250 altogether). Crucially, they couldn't reglaze the (also expensive) ones I had from them two years ago because they no longer stock those frames.

Wise to their ruse I then decided to take a risk with Wherelight.com where I got 3 pairs of varifocals (all very funky, including 1x sunglasses) for £129. They are absolutely perfect and I'm very happy. I don't think I will buy glasses from high street opticians again.

Londonrach1 · 27/02/2024 21:25

Surely that's what most people do...shop around..asda pretty good with glasses. Strange you have to ask. Just do it!

MassageForLife · 27/02/2024 21:23

HoneyWogan · 27/02/2024 21:05

Probably, if they have a way of knowing; but lots of people have their eyes tested and don't need glasses at all. Even people who do wear glasses will often not need new ones at every test.

Surely they can't just see all standard tests that don't lead to a sale with them as a waste of their time? I'm sure, like MoT garages, they hope there is extra money in it for them, but it's not like they do the actual test for nothing at all.

Indeed. But op is

a) trying to support her independent optician and
b) going in with full knowledge that, even if new glasses are needed, they will be bought elsewhere

IncognitoPanda · 27/02/2024 21:17

The amount the NHS pay for a sight test is a pittance and significantly below the cost to perform the test. Even by purchasing an extra test, the business is unlikely to make any money from your appointment. The prescribing and dispensing of glasses is closely linked - whilst not legally necessary it is always best to get this done in the place you intend to buy your glasses, particularly if you need varifocals or have a complex prescription.

HoneyWogan · 27/02/2024 21:05

MassageForLife · 27/02/2024 20:27

I suspect the independent optician would rather use the slot for someone that is going to buy glasses from them, as financially it makes much more sense.

Probably, if they have a way of knowing; but lots of people have their eyes tested and don't need glasses at all. Even people who do wear glasses will often not need new ones at every test.

Surely they can't just see all standard tests that don't lead to a sale with them as a waste of their time? I'm sure, like MoT garages, they hope there is extra money in it for them, but it's not like they do the actual test for nothing at all.

Spamfrit · 27/02/2024 20:45

Have your eyes tested where you want to buy the glasses. It’s much less complicated then if you have an issue with the glasses. Where you buy the glasses has an obligation to you not where you had your eyes tested.
The actual eye test is a loss at the prices they charge £30 etc.

purplecorkheart · 27/02/2024 20:41

I moved from Specsavers to my Local Opticians a number of years ago. They are happy to give you your prescription if you ask or even if you don't. They will also fit lens if you buy frames online as they say themselves they do not have frames that appeal to everyone. As long as the frames are not fake. I am lucky my local Opticians are very up to date in the technology they have. I was happy with the testing in Specsavers but left because I did not like the hardsell that was in the branch I used.

orangina3 · 27/02/2024 20:32

Hey OP,

It is totally fine to get your eye test in one store and to purchase glasses in another 😃

Purchasing online comes with its own risks- for example, part of dispensing glasses involves measuring the distance between eyes and also vertical heights in the specific frame. This is important for all glasses as if the measurement is incorrect you’ll be looking through the wrong part of the lens, and it’s especially important for high prescriptions, astigmatism and varifocals. Purchasing online means these measurements will likely be inaccurate.

hope this helps and hope you manage to get some nice new glasses you like! 👍🏻