Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tenants accepting (overdue) safety certificates- how to proceed

60 replies

DoubleShotEspresso · 27/02/2024 13:47

Hello,

Posting here as I cannot find another relevant category and figured traffic here may be better.

We are tenants, were provided all required safety certificates when we moved in, but these expired some (years) ago. Managing agent hurriedly arranged new inspections at the time we were being issued new contract (rent increase) and out property failed on both gas and electricity.

Recommended works were completed, but only some time after we signed a new tenancy agreement. We suspect the intention was perhaps to facilitate the possible use of a section 21 at some point in the next year but understand this is now not possible due to late issue of gas safety certificate. (After our new tenancy agreement was issued and signed).

So my questions here please:

-Is our landlord in breach for us not having had checks done for some years? If yes, what consequences could they face?
-Should we sign for an electrical certificate issued prior to signing new tenancy agreement even though the works are only being completed now? Can we/should we refuse?
-Can tenants seek compensation in situations such as this? (No intent here but interested to know the gravity here as being made to feel crazy whenever I raise a question on this)
-What consequences exist for landlords who fail to hold current gas safety certificates mid tenancy?

N.B No desire on my part for any conflict or at all to leave our home, but we do have some very real concerns as to the safety here but have no clue how to judge this.
Would be very pleased to hear from anyone kind enough to share some qualified wisdom! Thanks for reading.

OP posts:
DoubleShotEspresso · 27/02/2024 17:59

Thanks for this

OP posts:
DoubleShotEspresso · 27/02/2024 17:58

Cookiedefender · 27/02/2024 17:51

Yes you have but you re not a new tenant, the original cert and epc issued still count, this is my understanding as the docs have to provided BEFORE moving in, as you are already there, this can't be done.

The gas cert should be renewed yearly.

A gas cert is either signed off by the contractor or it will have AR or ID in the relevant tick box and the appliance disconnected & Repairs have to be made asap.
Is this your case?

This is helpful thanks. Gas cert has not been done for years.

No the certificate appears as if all is in good order, no references to the things which needed doing in order to pass. This and other wiring concerns are why we are worried and why I was seeking some advice. Nothing disconnected no.

OP posts:
DoubleShotEspresso · 27/02/2024 17:53

Cherrysoup · 27/02/2024 17:38

I rather think that if certificates are now in place, you have no recourse and can be sent a Section 21 if the ll has now complied with the law. You say you have safety concerns even though the certificates are now in place?

Right have searched this and the law is quite unclear, though the lateness of the gas one specifically seems to negate this/ Not sure tbh.
Yes the wiring is very old and the electrician identified it would be a "high code" on some of the recommendations he gave the landlord.

OP posts:
Cookiedefender · 27/02/2024 17:51

DoubleShotEspresso · 27/02/2024 17:36

We have a new tenancy agreement which cancels out the previous one. We id have all docs provided upon moving in but these expired .

So new contract means all should have been provided once again with all other relevant docs which is not the case.

It is the issue and very real pressure of needing to sign for these that I was querying hence the purpose of this thread. I cannot establish why this is needed and if in ding so, we are "accepting" that all is well when lit certainly is not yet.

Yes you have but you re not a new tenant, the original cert and epc issued still count, this is my understanding as the docs have to provided BEFORE moving in, as you are already there, this can't be done.

The gas cert should be renewed yearly.

A gas cert is either signed off by the contractor or it will have AR or ID in the relevant tick box and the appliance disconnected & Repairs have to be made asap.
Is this your case?

DoubleShotEspresso · 27/02/2024 17:49

Costacoffeeisbetterthanstarbucks · 27/02/2024 17:39

Do you live in Dorset? Sounds like you are going through the same as me. My agent is doing the same with the landlord living abroad. I know there are 2 other properties with the same landlord/letting agent. I am going through my local council. A notice from them stops revenge eviction

No but I would like to one day!
He has we think 20 or so properties, no idea where they all are though. Really wanted to avoid the council as we are happy here for now and are in no way "problem" tenants as inferred by an idiotic pp upthread. Live quietly, paid rent in full with no exceptions, never declined access for any works or similar, it's all so stressful and time consuming.

OP posts:
Costacoffeeisbetterthanstarbucks · 27/02/2024 17:39

DoubleShotEspresso · 27/02/2024 16:19

@Maryamlouise we have never met our landlord, he lives we think in another part of the country and all messaging is done (painfully) through the agent. Forgot to answer this bit sorry. The only contact details we have for him are the address provided on the agreement. No phone or anything to find out.

Do you live in Dorset? Sounds like you are going through the same as me. My agent is doing the same with the landlord living abroad. I know there are 2 other properties with the same landlord/letting agent. I am going through my local council. A notice from them stops revenge eviction

Cherrysoup · 27/02/2024 17:38

I rather think that if certificates are now in place, you have no recourse and can be sent a Section 21 if the ll has now complied with the law. You say you have safety concerns even though the certificates are now in place?

DoubleShotEspresso · 27/02/2024 17:37

AlisonDonut · 27/02/2024 17:25

So you now have all certification and are safe and well and still living there?

So all the equipment works and is in good condition?

But you want some sort of compensation?

Yes but suspect not validly issued.

Not yet no.

Not at all no.

OP posts:
DoubleShotEspresso · 27/02/2024 17:36

Cookiedefender · 27/02/2024 17:18

So long as you were given the EPC and gas cert before moving in at the start of the tenancy (how would you prove this?) the sect 21 can be used (as long as the current gas safe cert is sent to the tenant first)

Any safety cert's can't be issued in lieu of safety work still to be done & the tenant doesn't sign for these either.

Changes to No Fault Evictions were dropped as were the EPC one, even the EPC E requirement is never enforced.

Disagree on LL's taking lessons, looking after a tenant in your own home is very basic, the problems arise due to a complete lack of enforcement.

I must admit i'm at a bit of a loss as to what this thread is about.

Edited

We have a new tenancy agreement which cancels out the previous one. We id have all docs provided upon moving in but these expired .

So new contract means all should have been provided once again with all other relevant docs which is not the case.

It is the issue and very real pressure of needing to sign for these that I was querying hence the purpose of this thread. I cannot establish why this is needed and if in ding so, we are "accepting" that all is well when lit certainly is not yet.

OP posts:
DoubleShotEspresso · 27/02/2024 17:31

telestrations · 27/02/2024 17:16

I would contact shelter and the council if you are still concerned about any outstanding inspections or works.

My understanding is that landlords can get into big trouble (fines or prison) if they are not up to date and if something dreadful happens. And can be threatened with fines for non-compliance. But to my knowledge ince done they are done, non-compliance is not retrospective or makes a tenant entitled to compensation like failure to put a deposit in a scheme is and does. It also cannot prevent rent increases or evictions.

You should have working smoke alarms, CO2 detectors and a heat alarm. Not sure how many of these are requirements or recommendations though would cost less then £100 for all.

Edited

First quote for corrective works came in at over £2k.

OP posts:
DoubleShotEspresso · 27/02/2024 17:29

GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 27/02/2024 17:16

Have you had a proper look at the whole electrical cert you are being asked to sign for, the one dated before the remedial works were done?

If it failed that inspection, a certificate will have been issued, but it will say that it has failed on it and list the needed works. Are you sure that's not what this certificate is? If it is, I can't see any issue in you signing that you've seen it.

If it says it passed, and it didn't, and the works are still not done, then that is very concerning.

Finally, somebody gets my main concern, thank-you. No the certificate issued states date of inspection and reads as if no concerns.

OP posts:
AlisonDonut · 27/02/2024 17:25

So you now have all certification and are safe and well and still living there?

So all the equipment works and is in good condition?

But you want some sort of compensation?

Cookiedefender · 27/02/2024 17:18

So long as you were given the EPC and gas cert before moving in at the start of the tenancy (how would you prove this?) the sect 21 can be used (as long as the current gas safe cert is sent to the tenant first)

Any safety cert's can't be issued in lieu of safety work still to be done & the tenant doesn't sign for these either.

Changes to No Fault Evictions were dropped as were the EPC one, even the EPC E requirement is never enforced.

Disagree on LL's taking lessons, looking after a tenant in your own home is very basic, the problems arise due to a complete lack of enforcement.

I must admit i'm at a bit of a loss as to what this thread is about.

telestrations · 27/02/2024 17:16

I would contact shelter and the council if you are still concerned about any outstanding inspections or works.

My understanding is that landlords can get into big trouble (fines or prison) if they are not up to date and if something dreadful happens. And can be threatened with fines for non-compliance. But to my knowledge ince done they are done, non-compliance is not retrospective or makes a tenant entitled to compensation like failure to put a deposit in a scheme is and does. It also cannot prevent rent increases or evictions.

You should have working smoke alarms, CO2 detectors and a heat alarm. Not sure how many of these are requirements or recommendations though would cost less then £100 for all.

GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 27/02/2024 17:16

Have you had a proper look at the whole electrical cert you are being asked to sign for, the one dated before the remedial works were done?

If it failed that inspection, a certificate will have been issued, but it will say that it has failed on it and list the needed works. Are you sure that's not what this certificate is? If it is, I can't see any issue in you signing that you've seen it.

If it says it passed, and it didn't, and the works are still not done, then that is very concerning.

Araminta1003 · 27/02/2024 17:09

“Please see this from my original OP, we just cannot understand why this business of signing its such a burning priority when absolutely nothing else ever has been. Came here to understand this not launch legal proceedings!”

Is there an estate agent and are they a listed business (listed on a stock exchange)? If so, you have your answer. They do not want properties on their books that do not comply with the technical letter of the law.

Araminta1003 · 27/02/2024 17:07

“This is not the point of the thread. I know, but it's threads in general about lacksadaisical landlords that make me fume .”

There are some terrible landlords out there who allow properties to disintegrate and be full of mould etc. However, in this instance this appears to be more of a problem tenant trying to find a technical fault. The more problem tenants who think they can get a landlord on a technicality, the more the landlords leave the market and the less property to rent. Right now rents are sky high because tax laws changed and you cannot deduct mortgage interest, landlords cannot pass on costs anymore and there is on the horizon a S21 to be abolished as well as all EPC to be C. No small time landlord will be left after that. Which is fine, but only if there is a plan for that housing to be taken over and rented out accordingly by big landlords/councils. If not, you just get more and more tenants chasing fewer properties and rents get even higher.

DoubleShotEspresso · 27/02/2024 17:05

Jabberwonky · 27/02/2024 16:47

This is not the point of the thread. I know, but it's threads in general about lacksadaisical landlords that make me fume .

There are far too many amateur landlords around and tenants are screwed over

Anyone who wishes to be a landlord should be forced to take lessons on how to be a good landlord and how to deal with all associated issues in a legal and timely manner.

OP I hope that you can get these issues sorted and that any insurances are valid.
Shelter is a good place to start.

Good luck.

Agree with much of your sentiment, it's just so hopelessly frustrating always having to be on guard and trying to do the guesswork on what stunt is about to be pulled next.
Landlord lessons would be a great start too.... so many just have no regard for the impact their decisions have upon family households.
Have been trying to get through to Shelter, will persevere thanks.

OP posts:
Araminta1003 · 27/02/2024 17:04

The gas safety certificate needs to be renewed every year. However, note that home owners themselves never ever need to get a gas safety certificate.
The EICR needs to be completed every 5 years - if it fails, the failed aspects need sorting out. However, often electricians make lots of recommendations that are “advisable”. Again, most homeowners never do this in their own house.

The EPC needs to be carried out every 10 years but I think only on change of tenant. The EPC needs to at least be an E.

EICR and EPC are relatively new developments. There are more and more obligations on landlords along these lines. Homeowners do not do these so it is often more a technical issue than a safety issue.
Is the home actually unsafe? Do you have smoke and carbon monoxide alarms and do you test them regularly to check you are safe (rather than some technical breach by your landlord?)

Jabberwonky · 27/02/2024 16:47

This is not the point of the thread. I know, but it's threads in general about lacksadaisical landlords that make me fume .

There are far too many amateur landlords around and tenants are screwed over

Anyone who wishes to be a landlord should be forced to take lessons on how to be a good landlord and how to deal with all associated issues in a legal and timely manner.

OP I hope that you can get these issues sorted and that any insurances are valid.
Shelter is a good place to start.

Good luck.

Ladyj84 · 27/02/2024 16:34

I very much recommend Rick Gannon on Facebook..his tips helped us get our whole house sorted after trying for years once we learnt the legal stuff

DoubleShotEspresso · 27/02/2024 16:32

Herdinggoats · 27/02/2024 16:25

I think if you want to avoid conflict or rent rises then pursuing your landlord for fines or compensation would be a bit short sighted. I think goodwill from a landlord is pretty priceless- there is of course what you are entitled to and to do, but I don’t think the pay off would make it worth your while

Please see this from my original OP, we just cannot understand why this business of signing its such a burning priority when absolutely nothing else ever has been. Came here to understand this not launch legal proceedings!

N.B No desire on my part for any conflict or at all to leave our home, but we do have some very real concerns as to the safety here but have no clue how to judge this.

OP posts:
Lindy2 · 27/02/2024 16:26

Yes the certificates should always be up to date so your agency/landlord are at fault here. However, they are now in place and the recommended work is being completed.

I've not heard of a landlord being criminally prosecuted for a past lapse that has been now been rectified. It's difficult to get criminals prosecuted for much worse offences so although technically a crime I don't think the Police will be interested.

Insist the works get completed in a timely manner. However, I wouldn't take it further unless you are happy to move to another property. It really isn't worth causing issues with your landlord.

Herdinggoats · 27/02/2024 16:25

I think if you want to avoid conflict or rent rises then pursuing your landlord for fines or compensation would be a bit short sighted. I think goodwill from a landlord is pretty priceless- there is of course what you are entitled to and to do, but I don’t think the pay off would make it worth your while

Swipe left for the next trending thread