Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tenants accepting (overdue) safety certificates- how to proceed

60 replies

DoubleShotEspresso · 27/02/2024 13:47

Hello,

Posting here as I cannot find another relevant category and figured traffic here may be better.

We are tenants, were provided all required safety certificates when we moved in, but these expired some (years) ago. Managing agent hurriedly arranged new inspections at the time we were being issued new contract (rent increase) and out property failed on both gas and electricity.

Recommended works were completed, but only some time after we signed a new tenancy agreement. We suspect the intention was perhaps to facilitate the possible use of a section 21 at some point in the next year but understand this is now not possible due to late issue of gas safety certificate. (After our new tenancy agreement was issued and signed).

So my questions here please:

-Is our landlord in breach for us not having had checks done for some years? If yes, what consequences could they face?
-Should we sign for an electrical certificate issued prior to signing new tenancy agreement even though the works are only being completed now? Can we/should we refuse?
-Can tenants seek compensation in situations such as this? (No intent here but interested to know the gravity here as being made to feel crazy whenever I raise a question on this)
-What consequences exist for landlords who fail to hold current gas safety certificates mid tenancy?

N.B No desire on my part for any conflict or at all to leave our home, but we do have some very real concerns as to the safety here but have no clue how to judge this.
Would be very pleased to hear from anyone kind enough to share some qualified wisdom! Thanks for reading.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 28/02/2024 22:55

Cookiedefender · 28/02/2024 08:10

EICR has a box for anyone present to sign in, it is just a little bit of cover if say the tenant said "your electrician didn't come here on that day" sort of thing.
It doesn't make an iota difference to the validity of the report.

@PrincessTeaSet If you mean you are the LL, then you are leaving your self wide open to a fine of up to £30,000, it has to be done BEFORE any tenancy starts, without it, a court may decide that you cannot enforce a sect 21 eviction.

I don't think that's what this is, OP said they're being asked to sign now in reciept of all the certs, including electrical that was issued before the tenancy was renewed, but before remedials were done - which are in progress.

But now OP says they don't have the EICR so I don't understand what it is they're signing for reciept of?!

Araminta1003 · 28/02/2024 09:27

The biggest risk for landlords is that the insurance would not be valid if it can be traced back to an issue highlighted in an EICR. As others have said, often it is things like a fuse box upgrade that is marked as a C1. It is not actually all that dangerous necessarily and a large amount of homeowners will have fuse boxes that may fail too. They should really make it compulsory for all homeowners including gas safety - but that would not be politically acceptable as people do not want to spend the money every year/every 5 years and upgrade their fuse boxes.
I think that may also be why there are enforcement issues.

In theory, if you make a small change to the exterior of a grade 2 listed building you can incur criminal charges and fines. In reality, not all councils prosecute or take this seriously. It is usually neighbours kicking up a fuss and forcing the council’s hands when something is actually enforced.

The question for the OP is whether the property is safe or not primarily. I would also check fire safety, smoke alarms, CO2 and make sure you know your escape routes in the event of fire. In reality, the most dangerous thing is leaving tumble dryers on and the fluff catching fire.

Cookiedefender · 28/02/2024 08:10

GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 28/02/2024 07:29

I really don't understand. If you don't have the EICR, what are you signing?

EICR has a box for anyone present to sign in, it is just a little bit of cover if say the tenant said "your electrician didn't come here on that day" sort of thing.
It doesn't make an iota difference to the validity of the report.

@PrincessTeaSet If you mean you are the LL, then you are leaving your self wide open to a fine of up to £30,000, it has to be done BEFORE any tenancy starts, without it, a court may decide that you cannot enforce a sect 21 eviction.

GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 28/02/2024 07:29

I really don't understand. If you don't have the EICR, what are you signing?

PrincessTeaSet · 27/02/2024 23:09

If they are not complying with the law, you signing something doesn't absolve them. What are the specific issues you are concerned about?

Gas safety is a 5 minute check of boiler and any other gas appliances, they don't actually do anything so if it's up to date now then you don't need to be concerned.

No idea about electrical safety as our rental property has never had one - I didn't know it was required until this thread

DoubleShotEspresso · 27/02/2024 21:51

caringcarer · 27/02/2024 20:25

Basically I get tenants to sign to cover myself. If they were to be troublesome tenants I can evict as I can then prove all documents were given not just at the beginning of tenancy as is required by law, but I reissue at beginning of each year if tenancy extended as rented for 1 year fixed term then extended for a further 1 year if tenants wish. I give smoke alarms in all bedrooms and first aid kit and fire blanket because I let my rental houses to families with DC and I want to be certain I've done everything I can to keep them safe.

Thanks, it was the purpose of signing that baffled us, your response here is what we suspected, we could not figure out why this was suddenly and so urgently required, this makes perfect sense thanks. We were a bit worried about assuming responsibility for the wiring in particular ... but seems this is not what it is all about.

OP posts:
caringcarer · 27/02/2024 20:25

DoubleShotEspresso · 27/02/2024 18:52

Please see my responses upthread re certificates.
Very good to read how you look after your tenants, in all the years I have rented I have never been given a first aid kit, but that's very kind of you ;-)

What is the purpose of you getting your tenants to sign for the docs please?

Basically I get tenants to sign to cover myself. If they were to be troublesome tenants I can evict as I can then prove all documents were given not just at the beginning of tenancy as is required by law, but I reissue at beginning of each year if tenancy extended as rented for 1 year fixed term then extended for a further 1 year if tenants wish. I give smoke alarms in all bedrooms and first aid kit and fire blanket because I let my rental houses to families with DC and I want to be certain I've done everything I can to keep them safe.

GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 27/02/2024 19:39

OP, the electrical certificate (EICR - Electrical Installation Condition Report) is the report. What is it you actually have? If you know what the needed works are, what are they written on?

laclochette · 27/02/2024 19:10

I am finding your thread very confusing.
Is the crux of the matter that you believe the certificates to have been issued fraudulently in some way ie when the situation is not one which would actually pass certification?
You can request copies from your agent so I would start there. Review them and then you know where you stand.

Containerhome · 27/02/2024 18:58

Why are you being asked to sign for the electrical certificate? We have a gas and electri safety inspection every year. The agents email me telling me when they will be coming and if that works for us. I agree. They attend and do what they need to do. There's no signing to do, even for an agreement for them to come... to be honest as long as its all up to date and is now done annually I would leave well alone. Its not easy to rent at the moment.

DoubleShotEspresso · 27/02/2024 18:54

Cookiedefender · 27/02/2024 18:48

@caringcarer An EPC is only required on a new tenancy or a house sale, they are valid for 10 years, after that you do not need a new one, there is zero requirement for a private owner to have one or any other checks other than on new work.
Eicr is every 5 years for tenant.

OP - You ve a right to have a copy of the EICR, in fact thats the law

Bear in mind, older wiring or an older CS do not mean anything is unsafe eg an older plastic consumer unit wouldn't comply with latest regs but it can still be safe.

That is interesting to note, we have asked for a copy earlier today, thanks for the other info, that is very reassuring and all was very unclear.

OP posts:
DoubleShotEspresso · 27/02/2024 18:52

caringcarer · 27/02/2024 18:38

You are not making much sense. Do you have a valid gas and electricity certificate or not? You can ask the agent to give you a copy. I issue a full pack for my tenants every 12 months. So I print out How to Rent documents from the government website every year, they are also given a copy of the new gas certificate every year and they are handed a valid electricity certificate which I photocopy every year and I print out the EPC every year for the tenants too. On the contract page I get them to sign to say that they have been given valid documents which are all listed. I get them to sign this every year. I also get them to sign to say they have working smoke alarms in every bedroom as well as on both floors also as working CM detectors next to boiler and gas hob. I take photos of CM detectors Insitu too. I provide fire blankets and a first aid kit too which tenant signs for.

Please see my responses upthread re certificates.
Very good to read how you look after your tenants, in all the years I have rented I have never been given a first aid kit, but that's very kind of you ;-)

What is the purpose of you getting your tenants to sign for the docs please?

OP posts:
Cookiedefender · 27/02/2024 18:48

@caringcarer An EPC is only required on a new tenancy or a house sale, they are valid for 10 years, after that you do not need a new one, there is zero requirement for a private owner to have one or any other checks other than on new work.
Eicr is every 5 years for tenant.

OP - You ve a right to have a copy of the EICR, in fact thats the law

Bear in mind, older wiring or an older CS do not mean anything is unsafe eg an older plastic consumer unit wouldn't comply with latest regs but it can still be safe.

caringcarer · 27/02/2024 18:38

DoubleShotEspresso · 27/02/2024 18:26

Not gas company no. They provided certificate after we signed contract as the corrective works took that long. Electrical works still happening and certificate issued before we signed, as above. I am not asking anybody, landlord included too risk their livelihood?

You are not making much sense. Do you have a valid gas and electricity certificate or not? You can ask the agent to give you a copy. I issue a full pack for my tenants every 12 months. So I print out How to Rent documents from the government website every year, they are also given a copy of the new gas certificate every year and they are handed a valid electricity certificate which I photocopy every year and I print out the EPC every year for the tenants too. On the contract page I get them to sign to say that they have been given valid documents which are all listed. I get them to sign this every year. I also get them to sign to say they have working smoke alarms in every bedroom as well as on both floors also as working CM detectors next to boiler and gas hob. I take photos of CM detectors Insitu too. I provide fire blankets and a first aid kit too which tenant signs for.

DoubleShotEspresso · 27/02/2024 18:26

Not gas company no. They provided certificate after we signed contract as the corrective works took that long. Electrical works still happening and certificate issued before we signed, as above. I am not asking anybody, landlord included too risk their livelihood?

OP posts:
caringcarer · 27/02/2024 18:24

Araminta1003 · 27/02/2024 17:04

The gas safety certificate needs to be renewed every year. However, note that home owners themselves never ever need to get a gas safety certificate.
The EICR needs to be completed every 5 years - if it fails, the failed aspects need sorting out. However, often electricians make lots of recommendations that are “advisable”. Again, most homeowners never do this in their own house.

The EPC needs to be carried out every 10 years but I think only on change of tenant. The EPC needs to at least be an E.

EICR and EPC are relatively new developments. There are more and more obligations on landlords along these lines. Homeowners do not do these so it is often more a technical issue than a safety issue.
Is the home actually unsafe? Do you have smoke and carbon monoxide alarms and do you test them regularly to check you are safe (rather than some technical breach by your landlord?)

If a property has tenants the ECP must be done every 5 years. It's only 10 years for private houses. There should be at least 1 smoke alarm on each floor. There should be a carbon monoxide alarm in every room with gas eg boiler or gas cooker. Optional extras include smoke alarm in all bedrooms, fire blanket in kitchen and first aid box provided.
OP if you had wanted to complain or report to claim compensation you would have needed to do so whilst LL was in breach. Gas certificate is every 12 months. Also LL can put rent up only once a year.

Thefirstonewastaken · 27/02/2024 18:22

DoubleShotEspresso · 27/02/2024 18:17

In a nutshell yes

So, you think an independent gas company and an independent electrician would risk their livelihoods so your landlord could save a few quid?

LauderSyme · 27/02/2024 18:19

Your LL has clearly been in breach of their legal responsibilities but in reality, if you don't wish to involve the authorities, you have no recourse.

DoubleShotEspresso · 27/02/2024 18:17

AlisonDonut · 27/02/2024 18:09

So you think the certificates are fake and the things certified can't be because they don't work?

In a nutshell yes

OP posts:
DoubleShotEspresso · 27/02/2024 18:17

Araminta1003 · 27/02/2024 18:08

OP Have you read the EICR in detail? Was it satisfactory or unsatisfactory overall? What were the code numbers? Code 1 for anything is dangerous. C2 potentially dangerous. Code 3 is just recommendations - which a good landlord would generally deal with. Once C1 or C2 rectified, I would then expect a new domestic electrical installation certificate if it was things like a dangerous consumer unit. I think if you read it in detail it is quite self explanatory? It is C1 and C2 you need to be concerned about.

Regarding EPC, it is generally a new tenant. Some differing opinions there too. People are not sure yet whether a new Labour Government might bring back a C from 2028.

We do not have a copy of the report so cannot say win relation to codes I am afraid.

OP posts:
DoubleShotEspresso · 27/02/2024 18:16

Cookiedefender · 27/02/2024 18:08

Did you get any C codes on the electrical report?

We have not seen the report-it went direct to our agent.

OP posts:
AlisonDonut · 27/02/2024 18:09

DoubleShotEspresso · 27/02/2024 17:37

Yes but suspect not validly issued.

Not yet no.

Not at all no.

So you think the certificates are fake and the things certified can't be because they don't work?

Araminta1003 · 27/02/2024 18:08

OP Have you read the EICR in detail? Was it satisfactory or unsatisfactory overall? What were the code numbers? Code 1 for anything is dangerous. C2 potentially dangerous. Code 3 is just recommendations - which a good landlord would generally deal with. Once C1 or C2 rectified, I would then expect a new domestic electrical installation certificate if it was things like a dangerous consumer unit. I think if you read it in detail it is quite self explanatory? It is C1 and C2 you need to be concerned about.

Regarding EPC, it is generally a new tenant. Some differing opinions there too. People are not sure yet whether a new Labour Government might bring back a C from 2028.

Cookiedefender · 27/02/2024 18:08

Did you get any C codes on the electrical report?