Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To offer ticket to contentious friend

117 replies

Fireworkgrannyblanket · 27/02/2024 12:36

More of a WWYD really -

I'm going with a bunch of mates to see a band in a nearby city next month and DP can't come, so l've got a spare ticket. It's an hour or so on the train to get there, and we're going to get some food beforehand - so not a quick meet-at-the-venue-few-pints-and-home-again sort of do.

My issue is this - l've a friend who likes the band and would come if l offered her the ticket but who wouldn't gel with the rest of the people going. I've known her since we were kids and she's very good hearted but a bit Daily Mail in some of her opinions and the rest of the group are from my uni and far more woke. I don't want to spend the evening arguing but l feel bad not inviting her as l now have a spare ticket! I'm going round and round in my head over this so be brutal and help me!

OP posts:
Newchapterbeckons · 28/02/2024 13:28

Smoor · 28/02/2024 13:17

Who would have your back unless you needed time off work for stress/anxiety? Who would have your back unless you couldn't afford to buy a house (because clearly you're blowing your money on expensive coffees)?

Your beliefs are who you are. If the DM expresses and represents those beliefs, you are the reverse of a good person.

Is that really true?

Anyone that reads the daily Mail, mainly older people, I imagine are ALL the opposite of good?? That is a perfect illustration of entrenched biased thinking. Do you not seek to challenge such blinkered assumptions?

Fireworkgrannyblanket · 28/02/2024 13:27

Forget the Daily Mail reference!

I used it as shorthand for a particular type of single perspective, self-sufficient, small 'c' conservatism that l have trouble describing another way. Salt of the earth? No-nonsense common sense? Not arty-farty or airy-fairy? That sort of thing, anyhow. I don't read the DM so l don't actually know what's in it!

OP posts:
Newchapterbeckons · 28/02/2024 13:25

Fireworkgrannyblanket · 28/02/2024 13:14

@Newchapterbeckons Very! Old enough that l've amassed a lot of different friends from different activities - country dancing/shouty metal gigs/woodwork classes/uni/old mates from home/dark ages re-enactment/book club/work peeps ... They don't have much in common

Edited

And you can’t have a party and invite them?! You need to keep them in their pigeon holes unless they peck each others eyes out! I find that bizarre. Yes!! How can you live like this, when it’s hand bags at dawn about avocados and climate change 😄
My friends, all of them, are fully expected to be grown ups! I wouldn’t stand for shouty silliness, and quite frankly the whole point of gigs and get togethers is surely to have fun. I couldn’t deal with the level of intensity you describe, nor would I like friends that were so judgemental that they couldn’t even be trusted to be welcoming of one of my childhood friends. Not a good look.

You need new (grown up) friends op!

EdithStourton · 28/02/2024 13:20

Fireworkgrannyblanket · 28/02/2024 13:04

It's a done deal - the spare ticket's been sold.

I'm not trying to censor anyone.
I just don't think Old Friend would get on with UniFriends as their views on stuff differ fairly dramatically and l don't want to spend the meal waiting for things to kick off as both she and they are quite outspoken once they've had a few drinks.

She's not a knuckle-dragger - l wish l hadn't mentioned the Daily Mail now! She's had a hard life with lots of setbacks and has come through with courage and determination and sheer hard work. She's full of compassion for people but she sees everyone's life through the prism of her own so she feels that if she coped and didn't ask for special treatment they shouldn't need to either. It's a view that lots of posters on here echo.

I'm curious now though - do people really bung all their mates together and expect that they get on? I have lots of different groups and l'm a slightly different version of myself with all of them, so l wouldn't expect them to mix comfortably or have much in common. Don't other people do this too? I'm feeling a bit paranoid now!

To answer your question, yes, I do. I live in a small town/large village and you have to learn to deal with people. I have people I count as friends all the way from people who left school at 16 to bods with doctorates, and from serious left-wingers to ones I know vote Tory. Academic scientists and alternative hippy types. Under 10s and over 80s. Fling em all together for a party and everyone has a great night.

I've recently joined a local club. It didn't occur to me worry who I'd be mixing with. So long as they're not preachy and dictatorial, I like having friends who challenge my views, come from different generations, have expertise where I am ignorant, and so on.

Smoor · 28/02/2024 13:17

Ukholidaysaregreat · 28/02/2024 13:12

I think it's good to have a diverse friend based. Especially if you know they are a good person who would have your back. Many people seem to exist in echo chambers.

Who would have your back unless you needed time off work for stress/anxiety? Who would have your back unless you couldn't afford to buy a house (because clearly you're blowing your money on expensive coffees)?

Your beliefs are who you are. If the DM expresses and represents those beliefs, you are the reverse of a good person.

Fireworkgrannyblanket · 28/02/2024 13:14

@Newchapterbeckons Very! Old enough that l've amassed a lot of different friends from different activities - country dancing/shouty metal gigs/woodwork classes/uni/old mates from home/dark ages re-enactment/book club/work peeps ... They don't have much in common

OP posts:
Ukholidaysaregreat · 28/02/2024 13:12

I think it's good to have a diverse friend based. Especially if you know they are a good person who would have your back. Many people seem to exist in echo chambers.

Newchapterbeckons · 28/02/2024 13:08

Fireworkgrannyblanket · 28/02/2024 13:04

It's a done deal - the spare ticket's been sold.

I'm not trying to censor anyone.
I just don't think Old Friend would get on with UniFriends as their views on stuff differ fairly dramatically and l don't want to spend the meal waiting for things to kick off as both she and they are quite outspoken once they've had a few drinks.

She's not a knuckle-dragger - l wish l hadn't mentioned the Daily Mail now! She's had a hard life with lots of setbacks and has come through with courage and determination and sheer hard work. She's full of compassion for people but she sees everyone's life through the prism of her own so she feels that if she coped and didn't ask for special treatment they shouldn't need to either. It's a view that lots of posters on here echo.

I'm curious now though - do people really bung all their mates together and expect that they get on? I have lots of different groups and l'm a slightly different version of myself with all of them, so l wouldn't expect them to mix comfortably or have much in common. Don't other people do this too? I'm feeling a bit paranoid now!

How old are you op?

Fireworkgrannyblanket · 28/02/2024 13:04

It's a done deal - the spare ticket's been sold.

I'm not trying to censor anyone.
I just don't think Old Friend would get on with UniFriends as their views on stuff differ fairly dramatically and l don't want to spend the meal waiting for things to kick off as both she and they are quite outspoken once they've had a few drinks.

She's not a knuckle-dragger - l wish l hadn't mentioned the Daily Mail now! She's had a hard life with lots of setbacks and has come through with courage and determination and sheer hard work. She's full of compassion for people but she sees everyone's life through the prism of her own so she feels that if she coped and didn't ask for special treatment they shouldn't need to either. It's a view that lots of posters on here echo.

I'm curious now though - do people really bung all their mates together and expect that they get on? I have lots of different groups and l'm a slightly different version of myself with all of them, so l wouldn't expect them to mix comfortably or have much in common. Don't other people do this too? I'm feeling a bit paranoid now!

OP posts:
toastfiend · 28/02/2024 12:48

You know her, OP. It sounds from your description like she will, but is she going to rub everyone up the wrong way and spoil the evening for them? If so, then obviously don't invite her. You don't need to feel bad, she doesn't even know that you have a spare ticket and she'll be none the wiser. If she wanted to see the band that much she could have bought her own ticket.

Tbh, if I were going out for a specific event with a group of friends, I wouldn't be overwhelmed with joy if someone I didn't know at all was invited along without any consultation anyway. I'd be particularly annoyed if it then transpired that they were someone with fundamentally different views to the rest of the group who, instead of setting that aside and enjoying the night, spent the evening forcing their opinions on us and making us defend our own positions. I like a debate in the right setting but a sociable night out to see a band isn't that occasion.

rookiemere · 28/02/2024 12:38

Newhorizons8 · 28/02/2024 11:16

Assumedly, she tells you her opinions, as you are close friends but has enough social common sense not to discuss controversial views with people on the first meeting.

Why wince at her views rather then having a discussion? People can have opposing views and debate the topics respectfully.

But this is meant to be a fun night out catching up with old friends and watching a concert or similar together that everyone enjoys.

I know the type that OPs friend conjures up, and I'd be hugely annoyed if this relaxing social event turned into the equivalent of BBC question time due to some random interloper. It would put me off doing anything with OP in future just in case she turned up.

Newchapterbeckons · 28/02/2024 12:17

Foxblue · 28/02/2024 12:02

Ahh yes, the usual people who go:

'Very intolerant of you to not want hear different opinions'
'You can't have a good natured debate any more"
Have turned up on this thread.

The only time I've ever seen a good natured debate get derailed was because of the right winger getting agitated and either raising their voice or going in a huff saying 'ugh, can't say anything any more' OR the major one - someone going 'okay, interesting that you think that, so how does that match up with evidence A B and C that proves that isnt true' or 'interesting, what's your evidence for that opinion' and the person not being able to reference ANY or again, gets angry and defensive when someone VERY politely goes 'but xxx research has shown...'

If I've witnessed 10 debates between 'right and left' 9 times out of 10 the right winger gets upset at being asked what evidence they have used to base their opinions on. How is it a debate if you're just pulling an opinion out of your ass with no knowledge or research to back it up?!?

I'm sure others have different experiences - but that's just mine.

In real life I enjoy great discussions - different views and all with humour. Do you socialise offline? I find people generally are very measured on the whole. Certainly I don’t consider it when making plans or inviting friends over

Foxblue · 28/02/2024 12:02

Ahh yes, the usual people who go:

'Very intolerant of you to not want hear different opinions'
'You can't have a good natured debate any more"
Have turned up on this thread.

The only time I've ever seen a good natured debate get derailed was because of the right winger getting agitated and either raising their voice or going in a huff saying 'ugh, can't say anything any more' OR the major one - someone going 'okay, interesting that you think that, so how does that match up with evidence A B and C that proves that isnt true' or 'interesting, what's your evidence for that opinion' and the person not being able to reference ANY or again, gets angry and defensive when someone VERY politely goes 'but xxx research has shown...'

If I've witnessed 10 debates between 'right and left' 9 times out of 10 the right winger gets upset at being asked what evidence they have used to base their opinions on. How is it a debate if you're just pulling an opinion out of your ass with no knowledge or research to back it up?!?

I'm sure others have different experiences - but that's just mine.

Newchapterbeckons · 28/02/2024 12:01

Maybe it’s my age, but I have friends of all political persuasions, none are aggressive, rigid or rude. I wouldn’t socialise at all with them if they were.

Our dinner table discussions are good natured, light and interesting.
Am I the only one left that doesn’t have a need to set up a safe space/moderator for a simple drink with mixed friends 😳 sometimes it feels like we live in a parallel universe. This wouldn’t even occur to me to preempt this situation, but then all of my friends are civil 🤷🏼‍♀️

Newchapterbeckons · 28/02/2024 11:38

YouTulip · 28/02/2024 11:34

It’s hard not to love that you see a Daily Mail reader and her aggressively dimwitted views of poverty and MH issue as key to the ‘intellectual integrity’ of the country.

No, not the mail reader per se but accepting differences is key to a tolerant society.

DisforDarkChocolate · 28/02/2024 11:36

You can't impose someone on a group who you know will offend them.

YouTulip · 28/02/2024 11:34

Newchapterbeckons · 28/02/2024 11:24

I fear for the intellectual integrity of this country, or even its ability to remain a democracy with such dogmatic entrenched mindsets with no capacity to listen to another view even at a relaxed social event.
How are they going to manage in the real world 🤷🏼‍♀️

It’s hard not to love that you see a Daily Mail reader and her aggressively dimwitted views of poverty and MH issue as key to the ‘intellectual integrity’ of the country.

WhereIsBebèsChambre · 28/02/2024 11:30

ShortRun · 28/02/2024 10:18

Haha I came on here to defend your friend , that she may not be racist but sheltered in her other views. On the flip side if she doesn't mingle with people from other backgrounds she will never get a 360 perspective. I appreciate it's not your job though and it's a difficult one as I would also be exhausted mentally from being on tippytoes all evening. Xxx

On the flip side, the friend has said/done absolutely nothing 'racist' but read a paper that's disapproved of by some.
Grow some gumption @Fireworkgrannyblanket tell your 'friend' she embarrasses you and you're ashamed she doesn't have the exact same opinion as other friends, so she knows you're not actually a 'friend'.

Beautiful3 · 28/02/2024 11:27

Is she argumentative though? If she'll be quiet and civil, then I'd bring her mind she argues alot with people, over different views then nope. My fil is one of those argumentative people, can't take him any where! Not the pub or for a meal, he ruins it every time!

Newchapterbeckons · 28/02/2024 11:24

I fear for the intellectual integrity of this country, or even its ability to remain a democracy with such dogmatic entrenched mindsets with no capacity to listen to another view even at a relaxed social event.
How are they going to manage in the real world 🤷🏼‍♀️

Newhorizons8 · 28/02/2024 11:16

Assumedly, she tells you her opinions, as you are close friends but has enough social common sense not to discuss controversial views with people on the first meeting.

Why wince at her views rather then having a discussion? People can have opposing views and debate the topics respectfully.

Newchapterbeckons · 28/02/2024 11:15

I see this woke herd approach in my teen dds social groups. It feels sinister because no one is allowed to express a different idea without being shot down as transphobic etc.

Newchapterbeckons · 28/02/2024 11:13

The issue is not with your ‘friend’ but with the crowd that can’t bear to have their fixed mindset challenged in any way! I come from a world where we encouraged and enjoyed differing views, and could consider other ways of thinking. A bunch of ‘woke’ people in your view all with identical views would terrify me! I have a legal background, and can’t be the only questioning this group think mentality.

Would you need to come up with a safe space for one of them potentially??

I think you are being a bit weak op, sorry.

ShortRun · 28/02/2024 10:18

Haha I came on here to defend your friend , that she may not be racist but sheltered in her other views. On the flip side if she doesn't mingle with people from other backgrounds she will never get a 360 perspective. I appreciate it's not your job though and it's a difficult one as I would also be exhausted mentally from being on tippytoes all evening. Xxx

Amberjane41 · 28/02/2024 09:43

im going to a concert soon with 3 friends I’d be pissed off if someone dropped out and someone else invited some random that we didn’t know. Especially as we too are going for drinks and stuff, even without the daily Mail stuff as it upsets the dynamic.