Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is MIL right treating grandchildren different?

136 replies

Allthingsdreamy · 26/02/2024 22:38

Me and my partner have a 4 year old daughter together, I also have other children from a previous relationship. I currently dont work. Daughter has addition needs. Partner works 12 hour shifts, days and nights ,with a second job. Not usual for him to work 70 hour weeks. SIL has two children, youngest 6 years old. MIL has 6 yo all through school holidays (she sleeps over 6 night's a week, they live local so not like they have to travel far to get neice to nanas on a morning etc) picks her up afterschool and has her for a couple hours until parents finish work. SIL works 9am til 5pm, Mon to Fri. MIL has my daughter one night a week. I feel like the level of support she gives couldn't be any different. My daughter is autistic so doesn't communicate her feelings very well. If we go to MIL and she wants to stay she will cry. MIL will dismiss this and so we will bring her home with us. Niece is able to ask to stay etc and they usually let her. She has never taken my daughter out (although grandad does, he is very good with her) never collected her from school. She does majority of doctors and dentist appointments with SIL kids also. My partner has told them last week that in comparison to the time spent with niece and nephew, they don't really spend much time with our daughter. Again this was dismissed. They said its because they work (I don't as I don't have no one to rely on for childcare, also have to take daughters lunch to school everyday as she won't have packed lunch or school dinner). The longest they've had my daughter is for 2 nights, three times (because niece was staying)AIBU to want them to spend more time with my daughter? Regardless if I work or not? I don't expect the same level of support, but I don't think it would hurt to have her even a extra night in school holidays.

OP posts:
QueenOfHiraeth · 27/02/2024 19:27

I think the suggestion of having your niece come to yours for a playdate is a good one as it would please your daughter, strengthen the friendship between the 2 girls and give your MIL a break!

Farmwifefarmlife · 27/02/2024 18:46

MississippiAF · 27/02/2024 05:35

I honestly don’t understand why she has to have her even one day when you don’t do anything, and she is at school all day? What are you doing with your time?

Exactly her poor DH working 70 hours + you could go self employed as a cleaner to fit around school hours!

Azandme · 27/02/2024 18:42

Oh and both my parents, and my MIL are dead and my FIL is disabled. No grandparents having mine one night a week...

Azandme · 27/02/2024 18:39

You're comparing need and want.

The GP are meeting a NEED by providing childcare for your niece.

You WANT them to have your dd more, because your dd WANTS to stay more.

They already have her one night a week because they want to.

You really are being unreasonable to sdk them to do more, capacity is limited and need trumps want.

As for your comment about being a sahm being harder. Seriously? I do everything you do AND work 40+ hours a week, and I've been a SAHM - I was never flat out like I am now. But hey, you do three hours a day of school runs (after choosing to move) so it must be so much harder.

Give your head a wobble.

BritneyBookClubPresident · 27/02/2024 18:28

toomuchfaff · 27/02/2024 11:38

am I wrong to think it's unfair that she doesn't let me daughter stay and play with her cousin.

Have you ever offered to take the cousin to your house to continue the play when your child has expressed a want to stay? Easily solved; offer to have the cousins at your house with you looking after them all; the kids get to continue to play, GP gets a break. win/win

Offer to take all the kids out? Play date? Park? anywhere? somewhere not at GP house.

This

Make opportunities to get your DD together with family and cousins but with you hosting. That way the family cannot be worried they are "in charge", it's not affecting their existing responsibilities and your DD gets to play

Mememe9898 · 27/02/2024 18:27

Grandparents can’t win can they! If I was getting one day a week off I’d be over the moon. We get zero help and have to pay for all childcare.
Also, is it her daughter? If yes then she’s clearly going to be doing more for her own daughter. My in laws do a lot more for their daughter but we get zero help. They provided weekly childcare so she could go back to work but they do live a bit closer to them. She can’t afford childcare so they help and I totally respect that. My husband (her son) and I can afford childcare though but it would be great to have 1 day off every so often. The only time they helped was when I was in hospital giving birth to my youngest and we needed someone to stay with my eldest. Other than that they never help.

shivony263 · 27/02/2024 18:23

Being a SAHM cannot be harder than working 9-5. Working mums still have to do the same amount of cooking, cleaning and housework as a SAHM. Especially if your kids are in school and you don’t have them through the day. And you have 1 night a week childcare. That’s loads more than most people have!

brentwoods · 27/02/2024 18:18

RhiWrites · 27/02/2024 17:08

OP you say the way your daughter expresses that she’d like to stay is to cry. A lot of people think a wailing child is over tired and ready to go home. Have you tried using your words to say that you believe she’s crying because she’d like to stay and is that possible?

I also find your statement that she’s chilled out and easy to cater to sits oddly with the fact you’ve had to quit work to support her additional needs?

It might be that your MIL favours the other child or gets on better with her daughter but it might also be that your child isn’t that easy and since you don’t need childcare (as you’ve said repeatedly) offering to have her stay longer isn’t a priority.

Edited

YES. No one wants to have a child stay who is crying. If MIL doesn't understand that this is her way of expressing that she wants to stay, that's your fault.

Also, there's a big difference between caring for a 4 year old and a 6 year old, even without accounting for the additional needs of your 4 year old. I don't buy that she's "chilled and easy" when you say you quit your job to be her carer and being a SAHM to her is harder than a 9-5. You can't have it both ways.

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 27/02/2024 18:13

If your DD is non verbal, is there any chance that MIL doesn't feel able to look after her for longer? After all, your DD can't tell her if anything is wrong, has a very restricted diet, won't eat breakfast - I would have thought that looking after her for short periods of time would be enough for your MIL, just in case there is something wrong somewhere and DD can't tell her?

RunningThroughMyHead · 27/02/2024 17:55

Life isn't fair. That's the first lesson I was taught in life.

Yes, you get less support than your SIL. But in comparing, you're getting entitled. What you receive is still a lot more than many.

I find it surprising that the school won't warm up a homemade lunch for her? Id be focusing on that.

Ariona · 27/02/2024 17:49

Op the more you post about your dd, the higher her needs sound. I don't blame your mil for not wanting to have her more. She must be really exhausted taking care of her other gc, and taking care of a child with extra needs is harder. It really isn't a comparable situation. She's providing one night a week of a child with extra needs- she deserves a medal not extra nights. If you are financially comfortable, your dp can choose his additional hours then why don't you get some help at home ?

Zanatdy · 27/02/2024 17:45

Most mothers would prioritise helping their working daughter over non working daughter in law. Maybe it does seem unfair when your dd is crying to stay longer (if she can’t communicate that why don’t you tell MIL this is what’s wrong?). But you contradict yourself saying you’re a carer so can’t work yet then say DD is no harder than other kids. If that’s the case why do you need to get paid as a carer? Maybe she deliberately doesn’t help you more as you’re getting paid to care for your daughter and her daughter is working up to 40hrs a week. There is a distinction and I think you and your partner guilt tripping MIL is very unfair, she does a lot already and maybe your MIL thinks it’s your mums turn to help too. Honestly one night off a week when you don’t work is really good and you’re being very unfair to your MIL.

Zanatdy · 27/02/2024 17:31

I think it’s fair enough if you don’t work, they are helping out with childcare

CeciliaMars · 27/02/2024 17:30

There are a few things going on here. Your MIL might be closer to her daughter than her son - very common. Her daughter works - you don't need as much childcare. Your child has additional needs which the MIL may find harder to deal with - this is upsetting but understandable. Overall, I would say (and I speak as someone who doesn't have anyone to help with my 3 kids as a working parent) that you are very lucky to have one night a week's help with MIL! Be grateful for what you have.

NotThatWitty · 27/02/2024 17:29

I AM ASKING IS MY MIL RIGHT TO IGNORE MY CHILD WHEN SHE IS SHOWING SIGNS OF WANTING TO STAY A PLAY FOR A WHILE?

Yes, your MiL is right. Ultimately, it is her house and time, and therefore up to her who she wants to stay over.
I will add, though, that when I was your DC age, I would also cry and sulk when I had to leave my grandparents, or my aunt's, etc (especially at my aunt's where my cousins were). Quite simply, I was having fun, and going home meant the boring stuff like dinner, then bath, and bed. Most children would choose to stay and to play with their cousins over the everyday mundane. The reality is though, my GPs could have let me stay for another half hour, or hour, and I would still have reacted the same when it was time to leave - it really didn't matter to me that I had already had the extra time, and an extended stay. Maybe your MiL just sees your DCs crying as something similar to that?

RhiWrites · 27/02/2024 17:08

OP you say the way your daughter expresses that she’d like to stay is to cry. A lot of people think a wailing child is over tired and ready to go home. Have you tried using your words to say that you believe she’s crying because she’d like to stay and is that possible?

I also find your statement that she’s chilled out and easy to cater to sits oddly with the fact you’ve had to quit work to support her additional needs?

It might be that your MIL favours the other child or gets on better with her daughter but it might also be that your child isn’t that easy and since you don’t need childcare (as you’ve said repeatedly) offering to have her stay longer isn’t a priority.

Devon23 · 27/02/2024 16:55

Your not being unreasonable however having a now 16 and 21 year whom both are autistic with complex needs i have learned not to rely on family for help. It's sad but like me you need to find your tribe. Look for local parent support groups for those with children with needs. If your exhausted you can ask for a social care assessment which may fund enablers in the holidays and overnight to give you some respite. I totally get hubby working hard one wage etc but could he reduce a little to support you more?

Flatdog · 27/02/2024 16:54

You say “I dont work no, I'm carer for my daughter, which can be hard work sometimes”, even though she is in school?
Then say “my daughter is really chilled and
really easy to look after”. Not adding up. Your MIL is amazing looking after your daughter overnight for one night a week .

Underestimated4 · 27/02/2024 16:51

My MIL treats mine differently we don’t get the same care or childcare that my SIL does.

LateAF · 27/02/2024 16:05

ChilliPanda · 27/02/2024 13:21

Yes and why not invite MIL over for dinner and a huge cup of tea to enjoy watching you play with them together ?

Exactly...because OP said it's not about childcare is it?! 😂

ChilliPanda · 27/02/2024 13:21

beAsensible1 · 27/02/2024 10:11

Why don’t you arrange some play dates with her cousin at your house.
That way DD gets more play time with her cousin that she is wanting and MIL gets a break

Yes and why not invite MIL over for dinner and a huge cup of tea to enjoy watching you play with them together ?

HollyKnight · 27/02/2024 13:21

I think what you're not getting is that, from MIL's point of view, this isn't about treating one child better or different from the other, this isn't about bonding/quality time with a grandchild, this is just about helping out her daughter. It doesn't matter whether you think SIL deserves this help or not - she thinks she needs it and her mother is happy to help. You've said yourself that you don't need help, hence why your daughter doesn't stay there as often.

LittleLittleRex · 27/02/2024 11:44

I think you are confusing the issues of your daughter not getting to mix with family so much with your opinion of SIL/MILs relationship (which you are viewing almost completely transactionally).

You say the hard part of being a SAHM is being isolated, so why don't you stay at MILs with DD, so she can play with her cousin and you can chat to MIL, why are you dropping her off?

The following is not under your control:
-what MIL does for SIL
-that SIL doesn't appear to be coping with DD
-that your perceived needs re childcare are less than SILs
-that MIL doesn't want to have all the children all the time

Another solution would be that you offer to have your niece, to give MIL a break and allow the cousins to play together? Then MIL might have more capacity to have both girls and they will get more used to being together.

Your solution is to get angry at the bits you can't control, this isn't going to do anything but alienate you and your DD. Try looking at it from a different angle.

toomuchfaff · 27/02/2024 11:38

am I wrong to think it's unfair that she doesn't let me daughter stay and play with her cousin.

Have you ever offered to take the cousin to your house to continue the play when your child has expressed a want to stay? Easily solved; offer to have the cousins at your house with you looking after them all; the kids get to continue to play, GP gets a break. win/win

Offer to take all the kids out? Play date? Park? anywhere? somewhere not at GP house.

Fairyliz · 27/02/2024 11:06

Poor mil. Looking after all her grandchildren and no one seems to appreciate her.
Id be advising her to go on holiday for a month and have a nice break.