Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is MIL right treating grandchildren different?

136 replies

Allthingsdreamy · 26/02/2024 22:38

Me and my partner have a 4 year old daughter together, I also have other children from a previous relationship. I currently dont work. Daughter has addition needs. Partner works 12 hour shifts, days and nights ,with a second job. Not usual for him to work 70 hour weeks. SIL has two children, youngest 6 years old. MIL has 6 yo all through school holidays (she sleeps over 6 night's a week, they live local so not like they have to travel far to get neice to nanas on a morning etc) picks her up afterschool and has her for a couple hours until parents finish work. SIL works 9am til 5pm, Mon to Fri. MIL has my daughter one night a week. I feel like the level of support she gives couldn't be any different. My daughter is autistic so doesn't communicate her feelings very well. If we go to MIL and she wants to stay she will cry. MIL will dismiss this and so we will bring her home with us. Niece is able to ask to stay etc and they usually let her. She has never taken my daughter out (although grandad does, he is very good with her) never collected her from school. She does majority of doctors and dentist appointments with SIL kids also. My partner has told them last week that in comparison to the time spent with niece and nephew, they don't really spend much time with our daughter. Again this was dismissed. They said its because they work (I don't as I don't have no one to rely on for childcare, also have to take daughters lunch to school everyday as she won't have packed lunch or school dinner). The longest they've had my daughter is for 2 nights, three times (because niece was staying)AIBU to want them to spend more time with my daughter? Regardless if I work or not? I don't expect the same level of support, but I don't think it would hurt to have her even a extra night in school holidays.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Pheeeeebs · 02/03/2024 06:49

Yabu. You are a sahm. You are parenting your own child from a previous relationship anyway. Mil is helping her daughter by providing childcare, her son doesn’t need childcare, you are the sahp/childcare.

Nofilteritwonthelp · 02/03/2024 06:22

Sorry, but I can't believe your MIL has your daughter one night a week and you're complaining

PhoenixStarbeamer · 02/03/2024 01:32

Yabu you don't work and she does, it's completely different.

BeckiBoBecki · 02/03/2024 00:29

You're a Stay At Home Mom. They have her when you ask from what I gather......yeah. You're feeling rubbish because you're doing solo parenting due to your partner having to support that by working every hour God sends to provide for you and the kid you have that needs additional support.

I feel sorry for your partner - he must be exhausted.

lolacherricoke · 29/02/2024 19:04

Violetsnapdrgon76 · 29/02/2024 15:58

I don't think one extra night when one grandchild is already at the house during the hols is too much...it's not that much extra effort to cook two meals etc, come on! There is no complex medical needs or medication. So what if SIL is working or not: grandchildren should be treated equally during jols. Yes, during the week 9-5, she understands her SIL needs help but 6 days a week during hols is a bit much! She is only asking one extra night. l don't think that is too much to ask, helps with socialising and sharing too!

This is OP using a different name to defend herself?

The MIL has no obligation to look after any of these children and whether she chooses or not to have some children more than others dependent on what she believes their needs are is totally her prerogative!

OP should be offering to have all the children one day a week in the home to give her poor MIL (who is a saint) a break!!

If you have kids they are your responsibility! Not MILs

Violetsnapdrgon76 · 29/02/2024 15:58

I don't think one extra night when one grandchild is already at the house during the hols is too much...it's not that much extra effort to cook two meals etc, come on! There is no complex medical needs or medication. So what if SIL is working or not: grandchildren should be treated equally during jols. Yes, during the week 9-5, she understands her SIL needs help but 6 days a week during hols is a bit much! She is only asking one extra night. l don't think that is too much to ask, helps with socialising and sharing too!

nanamoo · 29/02/2024 11:29

Allthingsdreamy · 27/02/2024 09:10

3 hours a day goes straight onto school runs and pick ups. We dont live local to the school where children can walk. We are a family of 6, so always washing, cooking and cleaning to be done. Daughter has lots of appointments for her needs also. We do swimming and other activities. Other children do boxing and football, dancing, youth club, etc Partner also does activites and things he enjoys outside of work. I gave my activities up so he could do his. Other than seeing my sister for 2 hours a week i dont really see anyone. Just becasue i am a SAHM does not make me lazy, which it sounds like you are insinuating. I am far from it. I am very hands on with my children. Again you clearly haven't read my comments. If you did you would see I am not expecting her to provide childcare. At the minute I am not looking for work. I don't need to work. Even when i have worked we used a nursery and paid for our childcare. We are financially comfortable. I am very capable of looking after my children. You are very much missing my ppoint. I have never expected MIL to to 'babysit'. I am asking am I wrong to think it's unfair that she doesn't let me daughter stay and play with her cousin.

SIL is very lazy. Works 9-5. Lots of times when MIL has offered to clean her house, help with washing etc. SIL picks and chooses what appointments she can and can't do with children.

But you are happy to call your SIL lazy because she works and accepts the help that MIL OFFERS her. You sound jealous to me.

BlondeAussie · 29/02/2024 11:08

Redmat · 27/02/2024 21:33

The one person who deserves a break in all this is mother in law.

Agree - and possibly the husband who works 70 hours per week...

Azandme · 28/02/2024 18:19

Dragon3068 · 28/02/2024 17:47

I think yes its ok for you to be upset that your daughter doesn't get to stay and play with her cousin at their grandparents house. I also however understand why you feel the way you do about your sil and why your mil does so much for the grandchild. Your sil needs to buck up and parent better as her mother currently is definitely the main carer and the one raising her child. This is wrong and it puts a heavier burden on your mil.
Open a conversation up with your mil about all of this as quite frankly your daughter not being able to ask to stay longer is only a small bit of this problem. Your mil could end up literally raising that other grandchild unless your sil is forced to parent after work. Working 9-5 does not mean you can dump your parenting responsibilities on their grandma. Help is good but what your sil is doing is not just childcare but dumping her parental responsibilities on her mother and that's not on. Your mil is very likely knackered doing this but she will carry on untill her health fails her or her daughter bucks up. She can't ever treat her granddaughters the same while she has to do this.
So definitely be upset about how unfair this is as it is. Just make sure you direct it to the right place and where it firmly belongs.

You didn't read it properly did you...

The SIL does parent after work. The MIL has the niece overnight in school holidays, not all the time.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 28/02/2024 18:08

Dragon3068, OP has zero right to talk about mother in law's daughter to her. It's none of OP's business and could result in OP's child not having the time she does with her grandparents. I can't think of a quicker or more effective way than to bring about the end of a relationship or make it terribly strained.

The only thing that OP or her husband could do is perhaps mention that their daughter really enjoys her time with granny and cousins and there's no need - from OP's/husband's side - for daughter to rush off if granny would like her to stay.

Dragon3068 · 28/02/2024 17:47

I think yes its ok for you to be upset that your daughter doesn't get to stay and play with her cousin at their grandparents house. I also however understand why you feel the way you do about your sil and why your mil does so much for the grandchild. Your sil needs to buck up and parent better as her mother currently is definitely the main carer and the one raising her child. This is wrong and it puts a heavier burden on your mil.
Open a conversation up with your mil about all of this as quite frankly your daughter not being able to ask to stay longer is only a small bit of this problem. Your mil could end up literally raising that other grandchild unless your sil is forced to parent after work. Working 9-5 does not mean you can dump your parenting responsibilities on their grandma. Help is good but what your sil is doing is not just childcare but dumping her parental responsibilities on her mother and that's not on. Your mil is very likely knackered doing this but she will carry on untill her health fails her or her daughter bucks up. She can't ever treat her granddaughters the same while she has to do this.
So definitely be upset about how unfair this is as it is. Just make sure you direct it to the right place and where it firmly belongs.

BirdsofPrey1 · 28/02/2024 13:58

You don't work and your MiL has your DD nevertheless one night a week. I think you are being unreasonable.

I think this is a much higher level of support than most people get. Have you also considered the impact on your MIL of having your DD more often? In what way would it help you if DD spend more time with MIL? If you cannot cope, contact social services and push for a social care assessment to get respite. Bit I don't think this is on your MIL. Sorry

ProbablyNotMad · 28/02/2024 13:42

YABU. It is not unfair. The children are different and your MIL can do what she wants. Be grateful for the support you get and stop comparing. Comparison is the thief of joy.

BlondeAussie · 28/02/2024 13:26

NOBODY is entitled to have their mother or mother-in-law look after their children.

Whatever she does for her other granddaughter is irrelevant. It's an arrangement between her and her own daughter due to their family's needs.

YOUR daughter is YOUR and your husband's responsibility.

Appreciate the support you do have, put the green-eyed-monster to bed and move on.

BlondeAussie · 28/02/2024 13:22

Allthingsdreamy · 27/02/2024 08:29

Who said MIL had quit her job to look after children?

I think you may have misread "be a sensible 1"'s scenario.

When she says "Her mum has quit her job to ensure she can make her appointments, cooks and takes her lunch to school everyday."... the "mum" in this sentence is the OP.

GreyhoundGurl · 28/02/2024 11:28

Hi,

So you have 3 other children (you mention being a family of 6)? What was/is MIL's relationship with the others? You sound very lonely and stressed OP, if your only social time is 2 hours a week with your sister - is there no- one else in your family you can turn to? I wonder if that's really the issue? I agree MIL is spending a lot more time with your niece - but 6 year old are easier, and it sounds as though SIL has verbalise she needs help. Does MIL understand your DD wants to stay longer but can't communicate it? I do get your frustrated, but calling someone who works full time lazy was never going to help people to empathise with your situation.

Crazycrazylady · 28/02/2024 08:53

Honestly op, you sound a bit selfish and are changing your story when this thread hasn't gone the way you hoped.

  1. Relationship between mother and daughter is always going to be different to daughter in law.
2 you get a night off every week to go out with your husband. I pretty much know of no one with small kids who have that guaranteed each week. I certainly didn't when kids were small.
  1. You are a sahm who's kids are in school. You have that bit of free time each day that your sil doesn't have if you need to get your hair done or meet someone for coffee.

Op. You could be in real danger here I'd biting the hand that feeds you . Be very careful if I was sil and got wind of the fact that you were giving out about my mom who had been supportive to you. I'd be giving you a very short shift .

Harry12345 · 28/02/2024 00:25

Allthingsdreamy · 27/02/2024 09:30

I'm not complaining. I am explaing my day as others are insinuating that because I am a SAHM, that I don't do anything. I am also not asking for any help off MIL. Just wondering am I In the wrong to think she's been unfair to my daughter when she wants to play with cousin. Please read my other comments before you judge me.

When is this happening though? If beige is only there a couple of hours after school? Mil prob thinking it’s too much to have your daughter there when she is going to have her overnight at weekend? Your op was about mil spending more time with her and now you’re getting annoyed with people’s reactions to that and changed it to being about cousin

Harry12345 · 28/02/2024 00:17

Allthingsdreamy · 27/02/2024 09:10

3 hours a day goes straight onto school runs and pick ups. We dont live local to the school where children can walk. We are a family of 6, so always washing, cooking and cleaning to be done. Daughter has lots of appointments for her needs also. We do swimming and other activities. Other children do boxing and football, dancing, youth club, etc Partner also does activites and things he enjoys outside of work. I gave my activities up so he could do his. Other than seeing my sister for 2 hours a week i dont really see anyone. Just becasue i am a SAHM does not make me lazy, which it sounds like you are insinuating. I am far from it. I am very hands on with my children. Again you clearly haven't read my comments. If you did you would see I am not expecting her to provide childcare. At the minute I am not looking for work. I don't need to work. Even when i have worked we used a nursery and paid for our childcare. We are financially comfortable. I am very capable of looking after my children. You are very much missing my ppoint. I have never expected MIL to to 'babysit'. I am asking am I wrong to think it's unfair that she doesn't let me daughter stay and play with her cousin.

In your op you said you thought mil should spend more time with her and have her extra nights through holidays, now you’re saying it’s about time with her cousin.
i found being a sahm exhausting and thankless and my partner was resentful even though I did everything and his job meant I had no way of working. I understand the imbalance is rubbish but her situation with her own daughter is different and I would just be grateful you get a night off. Maybe mil is really overwhelmed and not saying and that’s why she doesn’t answer when your daughter wants to stay longer.

Fluffyted · 27/02/2024 23:28

Yes you are being unfair to your MIL. It’s her choice if she wants your daughter to stay & play LONGER with her cousin (as if the playing together they’ve done that day hasn’t been enough!). She isn’t being unfair or treating your daughter unfairly by not reading her signs to want to stay. Maybe she just wants an easier evening without your daughter being there.
it’s not up to you. It’s not up to your daughter - maybe start teaching her this. As she is in school she is able to learn, yes even with autism.

Or here’s an idea - INVITE YOUR NIECE OVER TO PLAY AT YOUR HOUSE.
then your daughter gets to play longer. You live within walking distance to your MIL so that would be an easy solution.
your a SAHM and you’ve stressed how much you do during the day so your house will be perfectly tidy with no household jobs left to do, so you’ll hardly be slaving away and can give your attention, as a hands on mum, to your daughter & niece.

Just be grateful your MIL spends quality time with your daughter. She has her plenty.

TheSilkLady · 27/02/2024 23:11

Have you explained to DGM that your DD is crying as she wants to stay and play a bit longer ?

could your neice not come and play at yours ?

my son is autistic could you explain to dd that crying isn’t working and explain how to ask to stay and practice it ?

Redmat · 27/02/2024 21:33

The one person who deserves a break in all this is mother in law.

Nevermind31 · 27/02/2024 19:53

Allthingsdreamy · 27/02/2024 07:54

Not sure people are reading properly what ive said. Partners second job is when it suits us, if we have no other commitments that day then he will go to work for a few hours. His main job is shift work so can't be off on a weekend, it's all year round. It was a joint decision for me to not work. Hubby has a Very well paid job. I enjoy working so that was one of the main factors when I did work as I think it's important emotionally and mentally to have time out. I DONT NEED CHILDCARE AS I OBVIOUSLY DONT WORK. I am asking people's thoughts on the having both grandchildren when my daughter would like to stay and play. This does not have to be overnight. We live very close so literally walking distance for me to collect her when needed. SIL is very lazy. Works 9-5. Lots of times when MIL has offered to clean her house, help with washing etc. SIL picks and chooses what appointments she can and can't do with children (usually none) children have trouble with teeth where SIL hasn't took them for regular check ups as "she doesn't like dentists". I could go on and on and on about her lack of responsibilities and her putting heavy loads on MIL, but i won't. AGAIN, I AM NOT ASKING FOR ANY CHILDCARE. JUST FOR THEM TO INCLUDE MY DAUGHTER MORE OFTEN. JUST BECUASE SHE CANT BE VOCAL ABOUT WHAT SHE WANTS DOES NOT MEAN SHE DOESNT UNDERSTAND.

a 4 year old is more work than a 6 year old. Add in the special needs - it sounds as if your mil doesn’t have the stamina to have your child for longer (and maybe auntie was helping nana out by taking the other children out). Why don’t you have niece over at yours so that they can play together?
auntie took children to play area - your child gets 1:1 time with Nana.
you have told pils that your child would like more time with them - they have told you they cannot do that. Accept their boundaries- it is not like they are not having your child at all/ not seeing them…

Gillarms · 27/02/2024 19:47

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 27/02/2024 08:43

My day sometimes starts at 4.30am, I usually wont get sat back down until about 9pm.
So you're expecting the grandparents to do this also? What horrendous tasks are you doing other than dropping off lunch in the school day that us lazy working parents aren't doing after work?

I've often wondered what SAHMs think working parents do when their working day has finished...Exactly the same as SAHMs but crammed into a few hours after working all day. Working parents are also full time parents, they've just got less time to themselves.

Gillarms · 27/02/2024 19:43

Allthingsdreamy · 27/02/2024 05:38

She has always had grandchildren 1 night per week. Her having SIL children, this came after I had to stop working as didn't have childcare. Also this isn't about me expecting her to have my daughter. I have already said I am grateful for the night I get each week. It is to do with her dismissing my daughter when she is showing signs of wanting to stay longer. Neice is able to ask outright to stay etc my daughter can't.

So, why don't you explain to your MiL that your DD wants to stay longer with her grandmother and to play with her cousin? I'm not sure what you mean when you say your MiL dismisses your DD?

Swipe left for the next trending thread