Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To get fed up when people put downer comments on lighthearted posts?

161 replies

Queenconsult · 26/02/2024 20:58

Fully expecting those Debbie downers to get funny about this.

It happens so often on here, someone posts a semi light hearted post usually about things your husband has done that have annoyed you, straw that broke the camels back, things that gave you the ick or the family ones - what made you realize your childhood was a bit weird etc.

Most people get it’s a bit of fun then you always get the Debbie downers that put ‘I got the ick when he raped me after I came out of the shower’ or ‘I knew my childhood was not normal when I realised no one else slept naked with their grandparents’

key example is earlier on the DD made to hug her grandad post, of course on the first page there is someone telling their life story of the uncle who molested them, no one asked, no one cares, it’s also not relevant.

It’s just so unnecessary and a bit attention seeking tbh. It’s just annoying seeing some funny posts be hijacked by the depressing ones as people can’t read a room.

OP posts:
Queenconsult · 27/02/2024 12:27

SirenSays · 27/02/2024 11:37

I think they're the same awkward people who overshare and trauma dump irl.
It pisses me off, I can't fix their trauma and lighthearted threads certainly aren't where I want to be reminded of mine.

Definitely, the biggest thing my mum ever drove home to me was to ask key questions before sharing anything personal;

Does this person need to know the information/is this the right forum for sharing this issue?
Does adding this information add to the conversation at hand?
Will the person you are speaking to care about the information you want to give?

if any of those are a no, then don’t share it!

OP posts:
TheFreaksShallInheritTheEarth · 27/02/2024 12:25

DerekFaker · 27/02/2024 12:16

Found one.

Nobody is forcing you to post on ANY thread, but you could quite easily find or start one with the tone and content that suits you, instead of arrogantly changing an existing one.

YANBU OP. Some people are very self centred. It's a form of derailing too.

Exactly. You can't police others' posts, but it would be annoying and selfish for a poster to start banging on about books on a thread about TV programmes; just as it is annoying for posters to go all 'woe is me' on a fun thread.

Just start your own thread if you want advice or sympathy.

Polkergheist · 27/02/2024 12:25

Unknown25 · 27/02/2024 11:38

I agree op. You wouldn’t go on a post about someone’s trauma and start joking around so why is it appropriate the other way around?

That's a good point. I hadn't thought about it that way.

YuleDragon · 27/02/2024 12:24

Can't believe people are actually trying to justify people doing this kind of stuff. Like, really?

DerekFaker · 27/02/2024 12:16

Thepeopleversuswork · 26/02/2024 21:19

I hate the "lighthearted" tag because I hate being told how to respond or what to find funny/not funny and I hate toxic positivity.

As a PP has said, its not your thread and you don't get to police other people's reactions.

If you can't deal with a robust response, don't put yourself on the line. It's not your internet.

Oh and "Debbie Downer" is a load of patronising tripe.

Found one.

Nobody is forcing you to post on ANY thread, but you could quite easily find or start one with the tone and content that suits you, instead of arrogantly changing an existing one.

YANBU OP. Some people are very self centred. It's a form of derailing too.

PlacidPenelope · 27/02/2024 12:13

The Dressing Gown of Doom threads used to be a funny, light hearted, gentle ribbing distraction now you can guarantee when one is started you get posters coming on telling everyone they are mean and nasty and their husband/partner died, how very dare they find the antics of their other half amusing and post about it. Thread killers, just want everyone to wallow in misery like they do.

SmileyClare · 27/02/2024 11:56

I think it pays to have a little empathy for people who are essentially trauma dumping on social media and the reasons why they might be doing so?

To be fair, it’s nearly always pulled up by posters on the “light hearted” thread and that poster is shut down.

In fact I think some posters get some glee from telling others they’re being inappropriate! Hmm

A lot of society are angry and disillusioned right now and that reflects in social media.

I must admit when I’ve been having a difficult time and I read a thread (light heartedly) moaning about diamond shoes being too tight, it’s tempting to think fuck me Get some perspective and see your privilege.

That’s a sign for me to get off mumsnet immediately.😂

On the flip side, I did once start a thread asking for support and advice during a difficult time and received great feedback from understanding posters.
Perhaps some people don’t have the confidence to do this or the capacity to see how clumsy their random post is.

I definitely think Social media is toxic and spectacularly bad for everyone’s mental health in general!

I dip in and out of MN.
When it starts to irritate you this much, step back a bit is my advice!

Unknown25 · 27/02/2024 11:38

I agree op. You wouldn’t go on a post about someone’s trauma and start joking around so why is it appropriate the other way around?

SirenSays · 27/02/2024 11:37

I think they're the same awkward people who overshare and trauma dump irl.
It pisses me off, I can't fix their trauma and lighthearted threads certainly aren't where I want to be reminded of mine.

Gobolina · 27/02/2024 11:31

HoneyWogan · 27/02/2024 11:24

I love a good lighthearted thread as much as anybody and I agree that not reading the room and trauma-dumping and misery-elevenerifing are often unhelpful on such a thread; but equally, I don't think you can state on a public forum that only what you consider to be in the acceptable bounds of lightheartedness is tacitly allowed.

None of us know how our level of privilege/education/mental and emotional intelligence/other circumstances might massively differ from those of other people who are really struggling. One person's deep trauma may be similar to another person's everyday life; and somebody's lighthearted experience might well equate to somebody else's scarring trauma. Look at the post on the current 'bad things you did as a child' thread, where an ostensibly funny story about a child pranking her DM into thinking she'd won a lot of money soon turned to huge upset.

I think we all agree that smugly pulling people up on their grammar or spelling mistakes makes you quite the arse; so is it really that different when we're berating people for being 'too lighthearted' or 'not lighthearted enough'? Also, we've had quite a few threads in the past where people have indeed 'complied' and related their 'lighthearted, hilarious' experiences - kidnapping a barky dog and driving to dump it 50 miles away from its home springs straight to mind.

I also thought it was extremely callous to declare that "no one cares" about a poster who has suffered sexual abuse. Fine to express that it's possibly not the appropriate place to discuss it, but "no one cares" is just nasty.

Maybe people should ask themselves will my post add to the discussion? Is my post in keeping with the tone of the thread? before they post.

The same way you are saying everyone has to right to feel what they feel, other posters also have a right to have a funny lighthearted thread without a trauma dump or it being brought down into misery.

It just smacks of I'm miserable so I'm going to make sure you are too. Nobody must laugh or joke or be happy because I'm miserable. Also the 'I'm going to be offended at nothing because you are happy', just scream I've got nothing else to bitch about so I'll be offended.

claudiawinklemansfringetrimmer · 27/02/2024 11:26

LightSwerve · 27/02/2024 10:42

Not everyone is as tidy and perfect as you @claudiawinklemansfringetrimmer

Humans are messy. This is not news and it's not going to change just because you don't want to read about other people's traumas.

I feel like your bar for perfect is very low

HoneyWogan · 27/02/2024 11:24

I love a good lighthearted thread as much as anybody and I agree that not reading the room and trauma-dumping and misery-elevenerifing are often unhelpful on such a thread; but equally, I don't think you can state on a public forum that only what you consider to be in the acceptable bounds of lightheartedness is tacitly allowed.

None of us know how our level of privilege/education/mental and emotional intelligence/other circumstances might massively differ from those of other people who are really struggling. One person's deep trauma may be similar to another person's everyday life; and somebody's lighthearted experience might well equate to somebody else's scarring trauma. Look at the post on the current 'bad things you did as a child' thread, where an ostensibly funny story about a child pranking her DM into thinking she'd won a lot of money soon turned to huge upset.

I think we all agree that smugly pulling people up on their grammar or spelling mistakes makes you quite the arse; so is it really that different when we're berating people for being 'too lighthearted' or 'not lighthearted enough'? Also, we've had quite a few threads in the past where people have indeed 'complied' and related their 'lighthearted, hilarious' experiences - kidnapping a barky dog and driving to dump it 50 miles away from its home springs straight to mind.

I also thought it was extremely callous to declare that "no one cares" about a poster who has suffered sexual abuse. Fine to express that it's possibly not the appropriate place to discuss it, but "no one cares" is just nasty.

Gobolina · 27/02/2024 11:23

Its funny how the people that do this are mostly the ones that scream for trigger warnings left, right and centre but they then do this trauma dumping where its unexpected, unwanted, and with no warning.

Gobolina · 27/02/2024 11:06

Queenconsult · 27/02/2024 10:54

Those doing it for attention I think that would definitely put an end to it.

Those who are just socially inept maybe not

It might teach them where and when is appropriate though 😂

Queenconsult · 27/02/2024 10:54

Gobolina · 27/02/2024 10:52

If they don't get pandered to and fawned over, they might stop doing it.

Those doing it for attention I think that would definitely put an end to it.

Those who are just socially inept maybe not

OP posts:
Gobolina · 27/02/2024 10:52

If they don't get pandered to and fawned over, they might stop doing it.

Gobolina · 27/02/2024 10:50

Maybe everyttime we see this shit we should post a stock phrase, like I'm sorry for your trauma but please take it elsewhere, this is not the thread for this.

MississippiAF · 27/02/2024 10:49

Agree with PP; people have gone from not talking about mental health and trauma to talking about it ALL THE TIME.

I have to wonder if that’s even any better than keeping it all down. Surely a happy medium.

Gobolina · 27/02/2024 10:48

LightSwerve · 27/02/2024 10:42

Not everyone is as tidy and perfect as you @claudiawinklemansfringetrimmer

Humans are messy. This is not news and it's not going to change just because you don't want to read about other people's traumas.

Why do you think its appropriate though?

Say if someone started a thread, ahhh look what my little cherub did, aren't they cute etc and 2 posts later someone is recounting how they were raped, the resulitng baby practically died in the womb and they had to give birth then watch the child die so OP should hug their child tighter.

That thread is not the place for that, why should the thread be brought down like that? Its not those peoples right to do that. There are boards for that on here. Its selfish and attention seekking and yeah, no one in that scenario does really care. They were trying to have a nice cute conversation.

Queenconsult · 27/02/2024 10:48

LightSwerve · 27/02/2024 10:42

Not everyone is as tidy and perfect as you @claudiawinklemansfringetrimmer

Humans are messy. This is not news and it's not going to change just because you don't want to read about other people's traumas.

We can still be annoyed about the mess though.

Humans who can’t read the room have been around since day one most likely, doesn’t make it any less annoying though

OP posts:
MississippiAF · 27/02/2024 10:46

LightSwerve · 27/02/2024 10:42

Not everyone is as tidy and perfect as you @claudiawinklemansfringetrimmer

Humans are messy. This is not news and it's not going to change just because you don't want to read about other people's traumas.

No one is denying that. They’re just asking why people have to dump their mess on lighthearted threads that people are using as an escape from everyday life.

Sometimes it smacks of - I’m miserable, so why the fuck should you be laughing and happy

LightSwerve · 27/02/2024 10:42

claudiawinklemansfringetrimmer · 27/02/2024 09:38

Look, I’ve been through plenty of abuse and trauma, do you know where I bring it up? In therapy. Sometimes to my husband or a close friend. Very occasionally in a relevant internet thread (ask me about EMDR, I will sing it’s praises!) Not on a jokey thread about “the biggest mistake your parents ever made” or whatever. There’s a time and a place!

Also I don’t actually want to read about other people’s traumas myself when I’m on something lighthearted

Not everyone is as tidy and perfect as you @claudiawinklemansfringetrimmer

Humans are messy. This is not news and it's not going to change just because you don't want to read about other people's traumas.

CurlewKate · 27/02/2024 10:38

I'll tell you what I don't like. I don't like women accepting being treated appallingly by men. "I had to clean shit off the loo again today! Third time this week-what are they like!" "Oh, I can so relate! They just can't help it, can they? Never mind, he's agreed to babysit for an hour on Saturday so I can go to the gym. I'm so lucky"
#DebbyDownerAndProud

Queenconsult · 27/02/2024 10:34

HemlockSoup · 27/02/2024 10:24

I was going to say Yanbu but after reading your post in full I’ve changed my mind.

It’s one thing to think ‘yeah, maybe this isn’t the right thread for that poster’s horrific trauma’ but for you to say ‘here is someone telling their life story of the uncle who molested them, no one asked, no one cares, makes you sound like the coldest bitch.

Might be cold but it’s true

Its a bit weird to post about your childhood trauma on someone’s post when it’s not asked for

OP posts:
Onl · 27/02/2024 10:30

YANBU People are strange.

Swipe left for the next trending thread