Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To get fed up when people put downer comments on lighthearted posts?

161 replies

Queenconsult · 26/02/2024 20:58

Fully expecting those Debbie downers to get funny about this.

It happens so often on here, someone posts a semi light hearted post usually about things your husband has done that have annoyed you, straw that broke the camels back, things that gave you the ick or the family ones - what made you realize your childhood was a bit weird etc.

Most people get it’s a bit of fun then you always get the Debbie downers that put ‘I got the ick when he raped me after I came out of the shower’ or ‘I knew my childhood was not normal when I realised no one else slept naked with their grandparents’

key example is earlier on the DD made to hug her grandad post, of course on the first page there is someone telling their life story of the uncle who molested them, no one asked, no one cares, it’s also not relevant.

It’s just so unnecessary and a bit attention seeking tbh. It’s just annoying seeing some funny posts be hijacked by the depressing ones as people can’t read a room.

OP posts:
HemlockSoup · 27/02/2024 20:57

Naptrappedmummy · 27/02/2024 19:02

And this will be one of those threads where the subject matter means nobody will dare put their head above the parapet to agree with you, they’ll vote instead because it’s anonymous.

oh, yeah no one will dare!

<looks at thread and sees all the people who've dared>

SmileyClare · 27/02/2024 20:39

Naptrappedmummy · 27/02/2024 19:02

And this will be one of those threads where the subject matter means nobody will dare put their head above the parapet to agree with you, they’ll vote instead because it’s anonymous.

Confused I mean loads of posters on this thread have literally started their comment with “I agree with you op” so I’m not sure what you mean there!

I honestly think if you’re getting irritated with threads to the point that you start your own just to vent about other posters, then it’s time to step away and have a break.

On any SM platform you’ll always have people posting for a reaction, trolls, clumsy misjudged comments and people with opinions or attitudes offensive to you. That won’t change unfortunately.

Let’s remember that you’ll encounter a far higher number of people with mental health issues online than you’d encounter in your real life.

I don’t know what the answer is but I agree with posters pointing out that a “fun” thread can’t be enforced by other users.

I must admit I rarely see a thread completely de-railed by “doom merchants” it usually recovers itself.

It’s certainly not that bothersome to me if a jokey thread moaning about your partner has a sober comment from a grieving widow who wishes she still had her husband with her. Yeah it’s uncomfortable to read but understandable.

Naptrappedmummy · 27/02/2024 19:02

And this will be one of those threads where the subject matter means nobody will dare put their head above the parapet to agree with you, they’ll vote instead because it’s anonymous.

Naptrappedmummy · 27/02/2024 19:00

I agree OP, I have a lot of skeletons in my closet but I don’t insist on dragging them out when it’s clearly inappropriate.

In fact I find having a laugh to be very therapeutic and become irritated myself when somebody else does it.

Zwellers · 27/02/2024 18:58

LightSwerve are you deliberately missing the point just to wind people up. Of course I sympathise with those who have been through something awful. Do l want to hear about it on a thread about favorite childhood toys. No it's inappropriate. Why do they get to spread doom and despair at will. No one would pop on a thread about a sad bearvement for example to talk about mr frosty.

YuleDragon · 27/02/2024 18:08

LightSwerve · 27/02/2024 17:05

I think they're free to post what they want, so long as within the talk guidelines.

People post loads of things I don't like, but that's an open forum.

I don't really know what I think of the word 'entitled' here, the talk guidelines would suggest they are entitled to post off subject or in a different tone.

Why do you feel the need to defend/justify people trauma dumping on fun threads?

Do you do it?

Zyq · 27/02/2024 17:55

Thepeopleversuswork · 26/02/2024 21:19

I hate the "lighthearted" tag because I hate being told how to respond or what to find funny/not funny and I hate toxic positivity.

As a PP has said, its not your thread and you don't get to police other people's reactions.

If you can't deal with a robust response, don't put yourself on the line. It's not your internet.

Oh and "Debbie Downer" is a load of patronising tripe.

Given that OP hasn't claimed any right to police other people's reactions or responses, this totally misses the mark.

DerekFaker · 27/02/2024 17:42

And we don't want a safe space - total misuse of thar term. We want a fun space. And there's nothing wrong with that!

DerekFaker · 27/02/2024 17:35

LightSwerve · 27/02/2024 16:42

I didn't say it was 'appropriate' I said it was normal.

If you want a safe space you need to post somewhere private.

Surely you know by now that humans are all different.

No, it really isn't normal.

Verv · 27/02/2024 17:16

I dont see the issue with Debbie Downer.
It's no different to Kevin the teenager, Billy no mates, or not my Nigel.
All used to instantly describe a type.

Nopeandno · 27/02/2024 17:08

loropianalover · 26/02/2024 21:18

Have to say I agree with you, it’s really stomach churning to have those comments everywhere. It seems those people are crying out for help and possibly have no one to talk to in their lives but it’s extremely inappropriate.

I think there are a lot of mumsnet users who have v little support/real life friends- and so the opinions you see expressed on here are often quite negative and polarising. The sample is very skewed. Very few people I know actually use mumsnet

I know that I tend to use it when I feel down. When I’m busy and socialising, I’m not on here!

LightSwerve · 27/02/2024 17:05

Gobolina · 27/02/2024 17:03

I think that's what people are intimating by posting 'lighthearted' ie keep your miserable shit off my thread, but people still do it 🤷‍♀️

These people aren't entitled to go around spreading doom and bringing everyone else down. Anyone can start a thread on here, how about they start their own pity parties elsewhere, and leave the people having a normal chat alone?

I think they're free to post what they want, so long as within the talk guidelines.

People post loads of things I don't like, but that's an open forum.

I don't really know what I think of the word 'entitled' here, the talk guidelines would suggest they are entitled to post off subject or in a different tone.

Gobolina · 27/02/2024 17:03

LightSwerve · 27/02/2024 16:42

I didn't say it was 'appropriate' I said it was normal.

If you want a safe space you need to post somewhere private.

Surely you know by now that humans are all different.

I think that's what people are intimating by posting 'lighthearted' ie keep your miserable shit off my thread, but people still do it 🤷‍♀️

These people aren't entitled to go around spreading doom and bringing everyone else down. Anyone can start a thread on here, how about they start their own pity parties elsewhere, and leave the people having a normal chat alone?

LightSwerve · 27/02/2024 16:47

claudiawinklemansfringetrimmer · 27/02/2024 11:26

I feel like your bar for perfect is very low

It's very easy to judge others but it doesn't really move the judger forwards.

LightSwerve · 27/02/2024 16:42

Gobolina · 27/02/2024 10:48

Why do you think its appropriate though?

Say if someone started a thread, ahhh look what my little cherub did, aren't they cute etc and 2 posts later someone is recounting how they were raped, the resulitng baby practically died in the womb and they had to give birth then watch the child die so OP should hug their child tighter.

That thread is not the place for that, why should the thread be brought down like that? Its not those peoples right to do that. There are boards for that on here. Its selfish and attention seekking and yeah, no one in that scenario does really care. They were trying to have a nice cute conversation.

I didn't say it was 'appropriate' I said it was normal.

If you want a safe space you need to post somewhere private.

Surely you know by now that humans are all different.

Queenconsult · 27/02/2024 13:38

OfficerChurlish · 27/02/2024 13:31

If people need to vent their frustrations here - and obviously some do - then overall I'd rather they do it on a lighthearted post (where the OP is probably half expecting backlash and the stakes are low) than on a post where someone in apparent distress is looking for perspective or advice.

Maybe MN needs a diary topic

Where the people who enjoy offloading on here can write to their hearts content

OP posts:
OfficerChurlish · 27/02/2024 13:31

If people need to vent their frustrations here - and obviously some do - then overall I'd rather they do it on a lighthearted post (where the OP is probably half expecting backlash and the stakes are low) than on a post where someone in apparent distress is looking for perspective or advice.

Orangeandgold · 27/02/2024 13:21

It’s an anonymous forum and it will attract people having a hard time I guess.

My issue are the ones that take the post so literal they end up steering away from the original post and derailing everyone into a pessimistic dark rabbit hole.

If it was a positive derail I wouldn’t mind but it completely kills the virtual mood.

PlacidPenelope · 27/02/2024 13:17

CurlewKate · 27/02/2024 13:09

@PlacidPenelope "The Dressing Gown of Doom threads used to be a funny, light hearted, gentle ribbing distraction now you can guarantee when one is started you get posters coming on telling everyone they are mean and nasty and their husband/partner died,"

I agree that's entirely inappropriate, and no help to anyone. I didn't realise that's what this thread was about. I thought it was about women posting about how their partners don't support them and find excuses not to contribute to family life and for some reason we're supposed to find that funny.

It what I thought the OP was referring to those type of light hearted threads.

I thought it was about women posting about how their partners don't support them and find excuses not to contribute to family life and for some reason we're supposed to find that funny.

I agree with you there.

CurlewKate · 27/02/2024 13:09

@PlacidPenelope "The Dressing Gown of Doom threads used to be a funny, light hearted, gentle ribbing distraction now you can guarantee when one is started you get posters coming on telling everyone they are mean and nasty and their husband/partner died,"

I agree that's entirely inappropriate, and no help to anyone. I didn't realise that's what this thread was about. I thought it was about women posting about how their partners don't support them and find excuses not to contribute to family life and for some reason we're supposed to find that funny.

SmileyClare · 27/02/2024 13:07

There was a comedy about vampires on iPlayer a while ago which featured Colin the energy vampire. This reminds me of that! Someone who can single handedly suck any positive energy from a room 😂

I do think in RL, it pays to have a bit of compassion, or at least try to acknowledge someone’s misery and then move on?

Social media is awash with lonely people desperate for acknowledgment and validation, so I can see why posting something left field and “explosive” on an innocuous thread gains the attention they crave.
That probably should be pitied.

I enjoy looking at MN but I find most of it annoying to be fair 🤣

DerekFaker · 27/02/2024 12:58

I think it pays to have a little empathy for people who are essentially trauma dumping on social media and the reasons why they might be doing so?

I think the best thing to do is direct them, kindly, to a different thread or board. Dealing with it in a lighthearted thread just derails the thread.

As a PP said, other people have sufferered trauma or are going through a bad time too, and want to have a break from the bad thoughts etc and have a laugh. They are just as valid and important as the trauma dumpers.

ancienticecream · 27/02/2024 12:56

YANBU, OP!

SameSameButDeliverance · 27/02/2024 12:55

MississippiAF · 27/02/2024 06:16

Yes! We have one at work. Everyone can be chatting together about something innocuous/mundane/lighthearted or shock horror - funny - and colleague chimes in with a doom story.

Riiiiight.. conversation is over, awkward silence and everyone turns round and gets back to work in silence. How can these people not notice?!

Edited

They do notice but from the POV of a victim:

’See!! I told everyone my trauma and they turned their backs on me! I KNEW they were uncaring and have forgotten #bekind. They’re all awful and don’t understand meeeeee!’

It just plays into their ‘poor me’ mentality.

Queenconsult · 27/02/2024 12:31

SmileyClare · 27/02/2024 11:56

I think it pays to have a little empathy for people who are essentially trauma dumping on social media and the reasons why they might be doing so?

To be fair, it’s nearly always pulled up by posters on the “light hearted” thread and that poster is shut down.

In fact I think some posters get some glee from telling others they’re being inappropriate! Hmm

A lot of society are angry and disillusioned right now and that reflects in social media.

I must admit when I’ve been having a difficult time and I read a thread (light heartedly) moaning about diamond shoes being too tight, it’s tempting to think fuck me Get some perspective and see your privilege.

That’s a sign for me to get off mumsnet immediately.😂

On the flip side, I did once start a thread asking for support and advice during a difficult time and received great feedback from understanding posters.
Perhaps some people don’t have the confidence to do this or the capacity to see how clumsy their random post is.

I definitely think Social media is toxic and spectacularly bad for everyone’s mental health in general!

I dip in and out of MN.
When it starts to irritate you this much, step back a bit is my advice!

Ah see I’ve never seen them pulled up

Either they’ll get loads of sympathy and then it will change the thread to more people telling sob stories

Or those who previously posted will come on and say how bad they feel having said that when people have gone through x, y or Z (as seen on the worst pain thread, people who posted in jest then came on to offer condolences to the poster whose daughter died and then said how ashamed they felt at moaning about stepping on a plug!)

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread