Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Young couple cannot afford a family on 100k per year!

229 replies

dottiedodah · 26/02/2024 17:36

All subjective of course.Young couple feel they are unable to afford a family ,With lots of expenses .YABU they should just save and keep going .YANBU if they want children then they would have to cut back .Apologies DM link!

OP posts:
BeaRF75 · 26/02/2024 22:12

To be fair, you also have to look at long term costs too eg private education, university fees. It's about wanting to do what you feel is best for any future child.

QueSyrahSyrah · 26/02/2024 22:11

Well it's relative isn't it. DH and I earn about £90k between us but we live in a place where an average family home is £800k and a decent 2 bedroom flat £500k. Childcare is over £100 a day. The supermarket choices we have are Co-op or Waitrose. I'm expecting our first and we'll be ok just about with budgeting and some flexible work but far from well off. We certainly can't afford an actual house with current mortgage rates.

We could of course leave and move to a much cheaper area, but then our salaries would probably fall by half, and we'd be in a similar boat.

allthemiddlechildrenoftheworld · 26/02/2024 22:11

@dottiedodah well they need to get rid of the avocado on toast and the starbucks coffee every morning and sell the expensive car and take the bus

Palindrone · 26/02/2024 22:06

Hilarious. My DH and I are raising our daughter on less than half that household income. She has everything she needs and more. Difference is, we have been willing to make sacrifices such as making do with a smaller home and not holidaying abroad in over 6 years. The wife looks as though she spends a considerable portion of her income at the aesthetics clinic.

Girlontherailreplacementbusservice · 26/02/2024 22:06

RealisticDreamer · 26/02/2024 21:40

£100k per couple goes nowhere unless you are up north. Anything south of the Midlands is expensive - houses, childcare, cost of living.

most of us don’t have the luxury of waiting to have a baby (biological clock and all that) so we wait as long as possible to earn enough, have financial security, have a house etc. A lot of us also don’t have the luxury of having family who can provide childcare, however much we would love it (through no fault of our own). But HOW DARE WE have created a career that provides before we procreate! Work hard, study, move location and then dare to have a child (or more). It’s our fault for succeeding and earning a reasonable salary but most don’t understand the ‘squeezed middle’. We look like we earn well, pay ridiculous tax and are entitled to
nothing from the government.

Then we get penalised for wanting to reduce hours as we have no family to pick up our children before we finish work. Breakfast clubs and after school clubs are oversubscribed, there are minimal reliable childminders so we have to pay more or we lose our jobs.

Some of us have to live within a certain radius of certain cities to do our jobs. We don’t like it and I would love to be a SAHM but we cannot afford to yet nursery fees are nearly £4K for two children.

so how about we recognise that we are all finding it hard, not living the lives we want, having the holidays we want, buying houses we want and just admit most of us are having a hard time and support each other.

Having a higher wage does not mean you are having a better time/easier life.

We managed in East Sussex on waaaay less than 100k in fact about a third of it when DC were born now about a half of it. We aren't several holidays a year, private school and brand new cars every two years wealthy but we are plenty comfortable (both putting 10+ per cent into pensions, both run cars, have a family holiday every year). Suggesting its impossible to raise a child on 100k in Sussex is a big fat clickbaity lie.

Notheninkynonk · 26/02/2024 22:00

If you copy and paste a Paywalled article link into archive.today you can read it without paying.

2under4 · 26/02/2024 21:58

dottiedodah · 26/02/2024 17:47

They are in East Sussex in a cottage that they have been renovating . So large expenses there .Also rightly worried about Nursery fees .They are only early 30s ,so time still .Just think there are probably lots similar ,but surely you make a choice ?

Not that much time, depending on how many they want...

LoftyTurtle · 26/02/2024 21:56

Surely it matters so much on where they live and what types of job you're doing? DH and I are on about 90k combined and we're comfortable. We have 1 baby and I don't think we'd struggle with a 2nd or 3rd. However we're fortunate in that:

  • We don't live in London. Our mortgage is ~200k. A fair chunk of money each month yes, but our house isn't/wasn't obscenely expensive
  • DH works very rigid set shifts, but I have a very flexible WFH job and a great boss. Therefore we only need 2 days of nursery a week which again, is a fair bit of money (about £600 per month), but not in the region of 3-4k you see some families paying). When our DC are in school I'll be able to change my job hours to do pick ups/drop offs around DH shifts
  • We live very close to our workplaces and nearby shops etc, so we don't have a 2nd car because we don't need it
  • Once/if we have a 2nd baby, our first will get some free hours. So our nursery bill will still increase, but it won't quite be double the cost
  • We're both homebodies and don't go out much just because we're not really that sort of couple (didn't really before kids either, just not our thing tbh)

Take away any of the above (well not so much the last point) and its easy to see why nearly 100k for someone else isn't the same as almost 100k for us

I was also very fortunate to get a lot of help with breastfeeding (Dbaby was in NICU) which has probably saved us a small fortune in formula costs to be honest. Sometimes when I look at the prices of formula at the shops I think, Jesus christ pity the families already struggling and having to deal with the insane costs of formula on top of it all

Awwlookatmybabyspider · 26/02/2024 21:55

So they have 2K per week coming in! Some people really don't know when they've got it good and easy!!!

PawsisShady · 26/02/2024 21:55

adriftinadenofvipers · 26/02/2024 18:21

Nw22 · Today 18:14

I think it’s much better than people who have a baby and don’t plan how to pay for it and just expect the government to support them. We earn a bit over 100k and we couldn’t afford a baby without big sacrifices due to things like Student loans and pension payment

So are you saying that low earners shouldn't have babies?

I mean it depends if you can afford them
If I got pregnant now I would have to terminate as no, I can't afford a child on min wage
That's the main reason why I've never had children as financially I couldn't afford childcare let alone anything else

blackcatsyeah · 26/02/2024 21:49

Emmacb82 · 26/02/2024 20:06

They want a family but they still want to have the same lifestyle they have now. They don’t want to miss out on their yearly holiday, and have spent a lot of money buying a big cottage which seems pointless if you have no plans to fill it with at least one child. Having a family means making sacrifices and becoming a lot less selfish and it sounds like they aren’t willing to make that compromise. And it’s probably the right decision for them if they are going to resent future children for denying them from living their wanted life!

Ah, the old ‘you can only have a big house if you plan to fill it with kids’ nonsense. As if childless people are required to live in shoeboxes.

KimberleyClark · 26/02/2024 21:48

They can afford a family, they just can’t afford a family and the lifestyle they want.

Orangeandgold · 26/02/2024 21:44

They just can’t be bothered to change their lifestyles. Clearly they don’t want children enough.

NonPlayerCharacter · 26/02/2024 21:43

so how about we recognise that we are all finding it hard, not living the lives we want, having the holidays we want, buying houses we want and just admit most of us are having a hard time and support each other.

Plenty of people aren't having a hard time and "hard time" is subjective anyway. I'm intrigued by the poster who has a family of four, soon to be five (she mentioned date nights so I assume she has a partner) and claims not to struggle on a household income of £30k. That kind of budgeting goes far beyond not having expensive holidays or meals out.

RealisticDreamer · 26/02/2024 21:40

£100k per couple goes nowhere unless you are up north. Anything south of the Midlands is expensive - houses, childcare, cost of living.

most of us don’t have the luxury of waiting to have a baby (biological clock and all that) so we wait as long as possible to earn enough, have financial security, have a house etc. A lot of us also don’t have the luxury of having family who can provide childcare, however much we would love it (through no fault of our own). But HOW DARE WE have created a career that provides before we procreate! Work hard, study, move location and then dare to have a child (or more). It’s our fault for succeeding and earning a reasonable salary but most don’t understand the ‘squeezed middle’. We look like we earn well, pay ridiculous tax and are entitled to
nothing from the government.

Then we get penalised for wanting to reduce hours as we have no family to pick up our children before we finish work. Breakfast clubs and after school clubs are oversubscribed, there are minimal reliable childminders so we have to pay more or we lose our jobs.

Some of us have to live within a certain radius of certain cities to do our jobs. We don’t like it and I would love to be a SAHM but we cannot afford to yet nursery fees are nearly £4K for two children.

so how about we recognise that we are all finding it hard, not living the lives we want, having the holidays we want, buying houses we want and just admit most of us are having a hard time and support each other.

Having a higher wage does not mean you are having a better time/easier life.

NonPlayerCharacter · 26/02/2024 21:39

strawberryswizzler · 26/02/2024 21:28

we live within our means - don’t take out finance, don’t jet off for fancy holidays or go for expensive date nights etc.

What do you pay for rent/mortgage, food and bills? Whereabouts in the country are you?

NeverDropYourMooncup · 26/02/2024 21:36

The cost of the botox and filler would have covered a few months' worth of nappies. But that's why the Mail has run the story - to get the clickbait comments, not because it's realistic.

ancienticecream · 26/02/2024 21:36

Voone · 26/02/2024 20:26

She said they take home £70k combined after tax.

She said "bills, mortgage, insurance and council tax — doubled from £1,400 a month to £2,800"

Commuting is around £160 a week

I missed the £70k after tax part.

In that case they'd have £890pcm spending money after all bills. That's manageable until the kid gets their 15/30 free hours.

selectiveparticipations · 26/02/2024 21:31

They don’t look young though (to start a family), quite the opposite.

MidnightPatrol · 26/02/2024 21:30

strawberryswizzler · 26/02/2024 21:28

we live within our means - don’t take out finance, don’t jet off for fancy holidays or go for expensive date nights etc.

Can you outline your outgoings?

A £30k salary after tax wouldn’t pay my nursery bill for one, so a lot of us have somewhat higher outgoings (!).

FirstTimeMum897 · 26/02/2024 21:29

While they look like idiots for going to the DM, I do get it and it is worth discussing. Yes you need to cut back but the current situation has nothing to do with prior generarations and their version of "cutting back".

My in laws had my DH at the age of 23. My FIL was an electrician and MIL a nurse and they had bought a 3 bedroom house already, with a small mortgage!! at 23! With no family help. The lack of secure housing will put a lot of people off, it's a disgrace that housing is so expensive and there is no option for secure tenancies either.

For what it's worth, I make a 6 figure salary. Once childcare for 2 kids is paid, some bills, and the mortgage, I'd have nothing left. Nothing for clothes etc. I'm pregnant now so will figure it out but I'm actually luckier than most and I still want to cry at the cost of childcare + mortgage (London).

Ruffpuff · 26/02/2024 21:28

Not me looking at this having £50 left per month after paying bills and buying basic ass food…

Single mother of 1, working 40-50hrs per week in a professional role.

Am I managing? Barely. 100k a year is nearly quadruple my income. Nevertheless, I have a higher education and I work my arse off. I’m fortunate that I have the opportunity to increase my income over time.

Do I have sympathy for them or want to hear about heir ‘struggles’? No.

I think people need to pick their moments better. The cost of living crisis is causing everyone to tighten their belts, but some people’s belts are on the last notch and are about to snap.

You have choices when you are on that kind of household income. Meanwhile some of us get a stomach ache when we realise our children need a new pair of shoes.

strawberryswizzler · 26/02/2024 21:28

lemmefinish · 26/02/2024 21:23

no - we don’t struggle at all.

So how do you afford it?

we live within our means - don’t take out finance, don’t jet off for fancy holidays or go for expensive date nights etc.

lemmefinish · 26/02/2024 21:23

no - we don’t struggle at all.

So how do you afford it?

strawberryswizzler · 26/02/2024 21:22

lemmefinish · 26/02/2024 21:15

it’s entirely down to lifestyle isn’t it. i have 2 kids and a third on the way with a household income of about 30k

Do you struggle to pay a mortgage & childcare?

no - we don’t struggle at all.

Swipe left for the next trending thread