Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed with book club and need advice!

41 replies

TeaAndBrie · 26/02/2024 16:28

I go to a local book club, it’s run at a local cake shop after hours by the owner and her daughter (grown up).
we have been doing this for about a year and there are normally 8-10 people attend.

One of the attendees always ends up going off topic and he always ends up talking about film versions instead of the book and then about tv and then actors completely unrelated. It’s getting really tiring.
Has anyone attended an enjoyable book club and can make some suggestions that I could politely bring up to try and make it more focused?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Globe22 · 26/02/2024 18:34

Gosh you seem to be taking it a bit too seriously! I go to a book club well wine club really and we chat about the book, go off tangent a bit. Then come back a bit. Nobody minds if someone hasn’t read the book and no one really objects to the ending being discussed. Chill your beans!

JinglingSpringbells · 26/02/2024 17:41

Jc2001 · 26/02/2024 17:34

Why should they have to do this? Just steer the topic away from, or say 'can we not discuss' the film when it's brought up. Job done.

Why are people so afraid of being direct? What do you think will happen?

Edited

Precisely.

You all seem a bit scared of Bob (or whatever he's called.)

Either interject, when he does it, or someone tells him right at the start of the meeting.

'We'll discuss the book, then any film versions later on.'

Not hard.

lottiegarbanzo · 26/02/2024 17:35

Well yes, can you say 'hang on Bob, let's give everyone who's read the book a chance to have their say before we get into that'.

JinglingSpringbells · 26/02/2024 17:34

Some books have 'book club questions' at the end and these can facilitate the discussion.

TBH all it needs is the organiser to say right at the start, 'Let's talk about the book then at the end if anyone wants to discuss a film version we can do so then.'

Jc2001 · 26/02/2024 17:34

caffelattetogo · 26/02/2024 16:41

Choose books where there's no film.

Why should they have to do this? Just steer the topic away from, or say 'can we not discuss' the film when it's brought up. Job done.

Why are people so afraid of being direct? What do you think will happen?

Pocketfullofdogtreats · 26/02/2024 17:33

Yes, there should be rules. Our book club talks about other stuff before the book (holidays etc) and afterwards. Tell Brian that he can talk about the film at the end. when everyone has said what they want to say about the book.

JinglingSpringbells · 26/02/2024 17:33

You seem to be making heavy weather of it.

I can see how it's annoying.

But can you not interject when he starts rabbiting on about the film and say 'Hey, John, let's talk about the book as film versions are always different'.

Or if there is a 'leader' they could ask that the chat is focused on the book and any films of it are discussed at the end of your discussion?

It shouldn't be that hard to control one person who's hijacking the discussion- just tell him!

lottiegarbanzo · 26/02/2024 17:31

May be worth suggesting that everyone gets a brief turn to offer their thoughts first, before the discussion expands to more general chat.

That prevents the discussion being completely hi-jjacked and diverted but also allows space for wider discussion.

I value hearing people's individual responses and having a chance to share mine. There's nothing more frustrating than having a particular thing to say that doesn't 'come up' in a more conversational style discussion - or the conversation moves on before you get a chance to contribute your point.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 26/02/2024 17:28

Also be blunt…

“Bob… we’re talking about the book not the film. Betty, in chapter 3 did you catch the line “blah blah blah” what did you think of it at the time and did your opinion change?”

Moonkittens · 26/02/2024 17:23

I was in a book club that met in a pub, all women and one man. The man used to love the sound of his own voice and seemed to think we were all fascinated by his lengthy opinions and tales of the bands he liked and car stuff. A few of us ended up creating our own book club instead and not inviting him...

saltinesandcoffeecups · 26/02/2024 17:23

I’ve always liked the idea of a book club but never joined one for this reason.

So take this as an outsiders view.

Can you suggest some ground rules along with some more stringent moderation from the leader as others have suggested. Then maybe a group moderation tactic. Such as members being able to give a phrase that indicates something has veered off topic for too long.

That last one is hard to explain… I’m thinking of more formal meetings run by robert’s rules of order where anyone can say ‘point of order’ for a rule infraction and that allows the chair to get back in front. Or in a way less formal setting at my extended family’s dinner table if a couple brought in an argument they were having to the conversation someone would shout ‘domestic’ and the couple knew to change subjects. The second was half lighthearted but also a good reminder and nudge that nobody else cared that one of the couple always leaves their socks on the bathroom floor.

commonground · 26/02/2024 17:16

^cross post!

commonground · 26/02/2024 17:15

Could you introduce 'prompts in a pot'. So think of some generic questions, eg:

'did the plot work for you'
'what was your favourite part of the book'
'what was unsuccessful?'
'Who was your favourite character and why.'
Would you read any more by this author?'

write them on pieces of paper and put them in a pot/cup and then pass the cup round. You have to talk a little about what you have pulled out. (You could even have the question 'who would you cast in the film version' if you wanted to give a little nod to the film lovers!)

That way the evening is more focused and the discussion is more structured. And everyone gets a turn to say something, rather than listen to film bore.

You can use the prompts for any book. You don't have to do them the whole session but if it's getting a bit off track you could introduce them.

CharmedCult · 26/02/2024 17:10

Slanabhaile · 26/02/2024 16:57

I'm in a book club and one of our members regularly doesn't finish the book. The first time she did this and announced that we couldn't talk about the ending she was told very clearly that that's not OK. If she didn't read the whole book, fine, but the rest of us did and were going to talk about it.

I’m in a book club with one member who did this, it was my first time attending about a year ago and I blurted out “I don’t want to come to a book club where we can’t even discuss the book properly because someone hasn’t finished it!”

Everyone then chimed in that actually they agreed with me. Turns out she did it frequently but nobody had the balls to call her out and tell her it was tough luck.

I don’t think she likes me. Grin

As to your problem OP, the lady who runs my book club usually brings a set of questions along to prompt discussion and the last question is usually “would you/have you watched the film”, but I guess it’s going to take a strong character to cut this guy off from blathering on only about what he wants to talk about.

mondaytosunday · 26/02/2024 17:05

There should be rules! Everyone must finish the book! No talking about the film/TV adaptation if possible.
In the one book club I was a member we were all female and did only female writers. I think I astonished the group at my first time they made me start (bit mean of them actually), so I discussed the lead character and their growth and the issues I had with some plot points. I don't think they'd analysed a book in quite that in depth and I'd never been to a club so didn't know the form.
But they did like what I said and we had some good discussions about what we'd read.
It's fine to go to general chat but 75-80% should be about the book.

LovelyTheresa · 26/02/2024 17:05

Needmorelego · 26/02/2024 16:55

Are book clubs really just about talking about books? I always thought they were just an opportunity for people with similar interests to socialise - not like a GCSE English Lit class.
To me talking about a film/tv version of a book doesn't sound odd.

The one I go to is, yes. It isn't for talking about fluff. We also don't have any 'junk' books, chick lit, anything like that.

TeaAndBrie · 26/02/2024 17:03

Needmorelego · 26/02/2024 16:55

Are book clubs really just about talking about books? I always thought they were just an opportunity for people with similar interests to socialise - not like a GCSE English Lit class.
To me talking about a film/tv version of a book doesn't sound odd.

I agree that it should be relaxed and the conversation should be able to flow and other interests can be discussed. However with this individual everything has to be related to a film. So for example we did ‘the girl on the train’ and we were talking about the importance of the setting and the glimpse of the house from the train. They kept talking about the big gardens and houses and several of us had to keep saying that the book was set in London but the film is very different as it’s in America. Despite that he kept talking about the film version

OP posts:
snoopyfanaccountant · 26/02/2024 16:59

A friend's daughter was in a book club that met in the local pub. Friend asked daughter what book they were currently reading and the reply was that they didn't actually read any books; they just called it a book club to justify going to the pub.😂

ion08 · 26/02/2024 16:57

do you get the idea that the other 8/10 people are frustrated too?

Slanabhaile · 26/02/2024 16:57

TeaAndBrie · 26/02/2024 16:46

This is so annoying, we had it recently that people hadn’t finished so we couldn’t discuss the ending!
I wonder if you’re right, I will stop going if it stays annoying so May as well speak now or forever hold my peace!

I'm in a book club and one of our members regularly doesn't finish the book. The first time she did this and announced that we couldn't talk about the ending she was told very clearly that that's not OK. If she didn't read the whole book, fine, but the rest of us did and were going to talk about it.

TeaAndBrie · 26/02/2024 16:55

ion08 · 26/02/2024 16:53

are you friends with anyone in the group outside book club?

Not directly, one of the women’s husbands is friends with my husband but no one that we socialise with

OP posts:
Needmorelego · 26/02/2024 16:55

Are book clubs really just about talking about books? I always thought they were just an opportunity for people with similar interests to socialise - not like a GCSE English Lit class.
To me talking about a film/tv version of a book doesn't sound odd.

TeaAndBrie · 26/02/2024 16:54

TeaAndBrie · 26/02/2024 16:51

YES! This would be amazing!
i wish I had the balls to do that 😂

I am actually quite blunt and last time I chaired I suggested quite loudly that perhaps he could start a spin off film club instead. Unfortunately he just laughed and started talking about Fight club😳

OP posts:
ion08 · 26/02/2024 16:53

are you friends with anyone in the group outside book club?

TeaAndBrie · 26/02/2024 16:51

CheerfulBardo · 26/02/2024 16:49

Your job as chair is to shut up the monologuers, though, and open out the discussion from one irrelevant topic. Or whoever is chair at that session could hold up a card printed with Mr Bennet’s immortal line from Pride and Prejudice:

YOU HAVE DELIGHTED US LONG ENOUGH.

YES! This would be amazing!
i wish I had the balls to do that 😂

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread