Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that emailing your colleagues from hols is a toxic behaviour

130 replies

Isthatrue · 26/02/2024 15:37

I have a couple of people in my team (Managers) who are unable to switch off when on leave and constantly email and send message on Teams even when on leave. I am not talking about 1 follow up on an important matter but more of a proper back and forth on stuff that can easily wait and doesn’t need them to be involved. I can’t stand it! I think it’s a) sad to see they are unable to switch off from work and relax and b) creates a toxic culture for which some people think it is expected to be connected even if technically on leave.

Am I the only one to feel p.ss.d off about this?

OP posts:
Purplefrock · 26/02/2024 18:28

If a team is managed properly it runs itself and no one really notices when the manager is missing. All those lazy managers who appear to do nothing all day are actually really good at their jobs

ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees · 26/02/2024 18:16

cathyj77 · 26/02/2024 18:04

Or @ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees there is a sixth option:

people whose working lives would be so difficult and unpleasant when they got back from holiday if they had ‘totally switched off’ that they prefer to check in for ten mins a day for peace of mind.

that’s certainly the category I - and most other senior people I know - fall into.

I'm senior too and used to think like that but I refuse to do it anymore.

I think that if the team around me are sufficiently trained and experienced, they can cope without my input for two weeks. If I died or was seriously ill, they would have to manage.

If there's a problem, then there's a real issue with succession planning,contingency plans etc that the company should address.

My work also isn't truely valued if I supplement others while I'm away. My contribution taken for granted etc. It's important to me that others see what's difficult when I'm not there.

Work get 100% of me while I'm at work, often more but if I'm away then I deserve to be away. Switching off fully is just as important.

I wouldn't work somewhere where I was never expected or permitted to switch off during annual leave. That's not healthy and my private life will always be more important than my professional life.

MandyRiceDavies · 26/02/2024 18:16

Magnastorm · 26/02/2024 17:31

I think it's more than ok to point out when someone is being an overbearing arse, yes.

Managers "checking in" when they are on holiday just sends a hugely negative message of "I don't trust you plebs to do your jobs" and it's incredibly irritating at best.

I think we must be imagining very different scenarios here, or at least I hope so. Ignoring your boss emailing you about a work thing while you are at work- and worse, insulting them first- would certainly get you sacked in my industry (at least if you did it more than once). And I'm not sure how you'd decide they're just being an "overbearing arse" if you're ignoring them. You're at work- do your work.

The way to deal with poor management is by raising it (for example, as 360 feedback or to HR or whatever the system is where you work) not by behaving like a brat and ignoring work-related emails.

neonjumper · 26/02/2024 18:10

I'm not even going to read the posts but I can tell you that it would be deemed toxic . This has come up in a work tribunal before and it was noted as unacceptable in the recommendations along with emails being sent after other team members working hours ... even if you are not expecting them to action them ... they should be on schedule sends .

In my workplace when someone is on holiday their out of office is on , they have already completed an adequate handover and it is deemed unacceptable to message those on holiday or those on holiday to message teams in offices .

cathyj77 · 26/02/2024 18:04

Or @ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees there is a sixth option:

people whose working lives would be so difficult and unpleasant when they got back from holiday if they had ‘totally switched off’ that they prefer to check in for ten mins a day for peace of mind.

that’s certainly the category I - and most other senior people I know - fall into.

LakieLady · 26/02/2024 18:00

WinchSparkle80 · 26/02/2024 15:56

It is expected in my company that you respond to teams on weekends and time off and it annoys me hugely.

I think that's bloody outrageous. Everyone needs downtime.

When I'm off, I put my out of office and voicemail on and tell anyone with a pressingly urgent issue how to get in touch with one of my colleagues.

The only times anyone's bothered my colleagues, it wasn't urgent and they just needed reassuring that whatever needed doing could wait for me to get back.

Abouttoblow · 26/02/2024 18:00

Our internal system and Teams is set up only to work with a UK IP address. If anyone attempts to login from outside the UK it disabled their accounts.
Much better for everyone as no one then feels pressured to be "present" if they're on holiday.

ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees · 26/02/2024 17:58

My phone is diverted to whoever is covering for me and my email out of office contains their contact details also.

Any aattempt to contact to me inspire of that is met with a pay rise request on my return. If a company cannot manage without me for 2 weeks, then I need to be paid more.

I think it's usually a sign of or a combination of.

  1. Control freaks
  2. People who aren't up to their job & try to hide it as much as possible - afraid someone will discover this why they are away
  3. Stressed people & genuinely cannot which off
  4. Unhappily married people who want an excuse to not enjoy a family holiday
  5. People who haven't enough going on in their life

Often hard to tell the exact cause.

tolerable · 26/02/2024 17:56

aw-back in the day-i remember my mam actual volley'd my dads mobile phone into the sea(yes i know not very eco-but i dont know the ozone layer was on her mind).I never saw him laugh as much(cos he was workaholic and knew every phone number so coulda used hotel phone)thing is.he didnt.he kinda got a bit -itchy to.but he didnt.its real hard for some people to switch right off.

Abitboring · 26/02/2024 17:49

It's weird. My boss does a version of this. In my view there's no reason he couldn't take a normal holiday. Recently he took a day off without telling anyone and I was waiting for something from him. When he sent it he said that he's actually off but didn't want to burden me with this piece of work.

I felt guilt tripped. Firstly, I felt like I was a reason he didn't take the full day and secondly, I feel it's weak that he cannot say to his team 'right, I'll be off, can we just see how we are going to distribute xyz amongst the team ?' so he somehow comes out as the martyr and doesn't realise the effect this has on others.

I get that he'd have to check his phone for emergencies etc, but even so he could easily appoint a deputy to deal with these things.

Mylittlepea · 26/02/2024 17:47

Jeez, WTH - who are the 24% voting YABU ?

People need to switch off & take the holiday to recharge batteries, regardless of seniority. Plan accordingly when taking leave and share responsibility with remaining team members - it’s developmental to learn to manage issues in senior managers absence.

Very bad culture indeed

Magnastorm · 26/02/2024 17:31

MandyRiceDavies · 26/02/2024 16:30

You think it's ok to ignore your manager when they are on holiday but you are at work?

I've worked for a number of different employers, private and public sector. Nowhere would this have been ok.

I think it's more than ok to point out when someone is being an overbearing arse, yes.

Managers "checking in" when they are on holiday just sends a hugely negative message of "I don't trust you plebs to do your jobs" and it's incredibly irritating at best.

cathyj77 · 26/02/2024 17:04

I agree with those saying that it's fine, as long as it is made very clear that the same isn't expected of other employees.

It's also absolutely impossible for anyone on this thread to answer whether it is or isn't okay in other people's businesses without knowing the specificities of those businesses, and what roles people do within them.

There are many advantages to being senior (higher pay being the obvious one) but the disadvantage is that the buck really does stop with you, and sometimes, a decision going one way or the other can make a difference of many thousands (or sometimes hundreds of thousands) of pounds, or indeed a risk to your job if things go badly.

I manage a team of over 50, and I do as others have said they do: log in once a day on holiday for 10 minutes. I only reply to truly essential things and I make it very clear to my staff that I don't expect the same from them. But I'd give short shrift to anyone who told me stop - let them try doing my job for a bit and they'd fully understand why I do it!

Schoolhelp23 · 26/02/2024 17:02

I recently saw an OOO autoresponse of a colleague which stated 'I am on annual leave until X and will be deleting all emails recieved during this time. If your email requires a response, please resend after this date'.

Amazed they were allowed to do this!

tulippa · 26/02/2024 17:00

Doesn't anyone reply back saying 'Aren't you on leave?'

I'll check in on my emails every so often while on leave so I can hit the ground running when I return. If I see something that I can help someone out with by sending a very quick response or anything catastrophic I'll reply but anything else is left for when I get back.

Dacadactyl · 26/02/2024 16:56

sweetpickle2 · 26/02/2024 16:42

It's incredibly toxic- bully for everyone on this thread saying it wouldn't make them want to work on their leave, but for junior staff or people who are new to the company they may well see managers and leaders messaging from their holidays and think that's the expectation.

They'd have to TELL me that was the expectation before I'd even vaguely consider it.

And as soon as those words left their mouth I'd be off to another job like a shot.

BobbyBiscuits · 26/02/2024 16:47

I think the rule has to be that emails do not get answered or generated by people who are on leave. If someone else needs to take over that person's work when they are away then by all means copy the absent one in but they are not responding.
I'd say have a gentle word to the boss. If they are a workaholic they probably can't stop working when on leave themselves, but that's their choice. It's their business. The expectation should be made clear, that there is no expectation.
Unless of course it's literally a business emergency but no one person surely could solve that type issue from their sun lounger if it was that gravely serious? Except the boss perhaps.

TellySavalashairbrush · 26/02/2024 16:43

One thing is a very senior (and highly paid) manager or owner of a business answering a couple of emails while on holiday, another is an expectation that lower graded staff will do the same during theirs.

sweetpickle2 · 26/02/2024 16:42

It's incredibly toxic- bully for everyone on this thread saying it wouldn't make them want to work on their leave, but for junior staff or people who are new to the company they may well see managers and leaders messaging from their holidays and think that's the expectation.

mynameiscalypso · 26/02/2024 16:40

I don't really switch off from work. My emails and teams are on my phone. I will always reply to quick questions directed to me - it takes me a couple of minutes and might save them a long time. I leave longer emails or pieces of work until I'm back. I'm also selective who I respond to and don't sent anything lengthy or directive to my team although will have much longer and more detailed correspondence with my boss.

I like to know what's going on and it helps me relax on holiday to keep an eye on things. Sure, I don't need to and my team are very capable but I hate coming back to work and spending the first day catching up on everything and getting a few surprises!

KimberleyClark · 26/02/2024 16:39

It’s virtual presenteeism and it is toxic.

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 26/02/2024 16:39

If they are managers they are setting a poor example and contributing to unhealthy company culture.

BeaRF75 · 26/02/2024 16:37

But why are you looking at your work email when you're on holiday? I expect to get emails while I'm away, but everyone will know that they won't get a response until I'm back as they will get my out of office message.
Don't look at your emails, OP, and hide all notifications. Sorted.

crumbledog · 26/02/2024 16:37

Used to have a manager like this, it’s was just really irritating.
She thought she was indispensable, most people just found her inefficient and stressful to be around.
Her choice, but seems like a fast way to make yourself unwell and I don’t think anyone is genuinely impressed by it.

TheTripThatWasnt · 26/02/2024 16:34

I have a senior role in a small company. My email app and teams app are removed from my phone (a work-provided phone which I also use for personal use) before I go on holiday. And I don't check my emails on the Sunday night before the first Monday back either. No way. Holiday time is precious.

If there was anything which really needed me, then my colleages know they could whatsapp me to ask, and I would of course reply. But as for engaging in 'stuff' that's happening on my projects - no way.

If a client phoned me on holiday, I would let it go to voicemail, then listen to the message and whatsapp the relevant person in the office and ask them to deal with it. My email out of office gives contact details for someone else so no-one is left wondering.

I would hate for more junior members of the team to feel there was some kind of expectation of engagement in work matters when on holiday.