Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think going public with a lottery win is bonkers?

167 replies

WhataPlank · 26/02/2024 12:19

Just watched a little YT documentary following the lives of lottery winners and I was blown away by how many people reach out to lottery winners to beg money; not just friends and family, ex-colleagues or even ex-friends, but complete strangers with sob stories (both genuine and fake).

Is there some kind of incentive offered by the lottery people to go public? It's obviously in the organiser's interest as its all publicity, but surely there's nothing in it for the winner but absolute misery?
There must be some kind of bonus for announcing it, because why would you want everyone to know!?

OP posts:
ALongHardWinter · 26/02/2024 21:38

I've always wondered what the reasoning was behind lottery winners going public. After hearing so many stories about winners receiving endless begging letters,I've always thought why put yourself in that position? Crazy.

LindaHamilton · 26/02/2024 21:22

tttigress · 26/02/2024 20:39

I guess most people just get swept up with it, plus the lottery probably put on subtle pressure giving reasons why it would be better to get it over with.

Realistically with some if the absolutely massive Euro Millions wins now it would be almost impossible to avoid people finding out.

It would almost be worth winning a few million, it might then be easier to transition to a nicer house, new car, etc. etc. without turning your life upside down and turning your back on everything you have ever known (which is a sure fire way to make you crazy l).

There is a difference between people finding out though and broadcasting it at a national level. So when winners say they went public as they didn't want to hide it from their friends I just think well you didn't have to tell the nation and beyond to do that...

In fairness if I heard any of my friends or family won the EuroMillions I'd honestly expect nothing off them especially friends nor would I be asking and I am in no way rich . I'd be like 'well done' but I cannot fathom expecting them to fund my life or throw me any big sums really. It's their money.

The only people I'd expect something from would be my parents if they were still here but that's different and really I'd expect any parents who won a big sum to want to help all their kids....

tttigress · 26/02/2024 20:39

I guess most people just get swept up with it, plus the lottery probably put on subtle pressure giving reasons why it would be better to get it over with.

Realistically with some if the absolutely massive Euro Millions wins now it would be almost impossible to avoid people finding out.

It would almost be worth winning a few million, it might then be easier to transition to a nicer house, new car, etc. etc. without turning your life upside down and turning your back on everything you have ever known (which is a sure fire way to make you crazy l).

swayingpalmtree · 26/02/2024 20:25

Yes the other myth is ''all lottery winners go broke''

I hate the way they report that too- it's always with some snidey 'SEE?- look at them all miserable!- AND their marriage broke up" as if they deserve to be miserable or something, typical British press - build them up so you can knock them down later on.

I imagine there must be lots of people who have won the lottery who are happy as Larry but that doesnt make a very interesting story I guess and people would then say they were "bragging" so you really cant win either way

CharmedCult · 26/02/2024 20:14

Yes the other myth is ''all lottery winners go broke''

Ofcourse there are a handful of horror stories we all heard but these are only a tiny minority

Exactly. The stories of the no doubt countless number of lottery winners who have invested wisely, live off of the interest, regularly donate to charity, and are enjoying a very nice lifestyle with no drama wouldn’t sell papers.

LindaHamilton · 26/02/2024 20:08

swayingpalmtree · 26/02/2024 19:50

The press wouldn't be allowed to report the story either. The press know so much stuff about celebrities and so on that they aren't allowed to report. Unless you go public the press cannot do it. I don't know where that myth comes from

Yes- exactly. Plus the whole appeal of a public lottery win is interviewing them, them telling everyone what they'll do with the money, what they did to celebrate, what their family think of it, photos of them with a huge cheque and champagne corks flying etc

I cant imagine a more boring or uninspiring story than "we think Mr Smith from Edinburgh has won the lottery but he said "no comment" when we asked him and we cannot confirm it's true either. He has however started shopping at Waitrose though instead of Tescos, we'll keep you informed of any further developments" 😂

Yes the other myth is ''all lottery winners go broke'', considering the vast majority remain anonymous or stay out of the limelight even if they go public/have to go public like in USA then that 'fact' is nonsense.

Even if you google the winners in the UK/USA who were known/went public there is hardly any information about them after the win so who knows what became of them? Ofcourse there are a handful of horror stories we all heard but these are only a tiny minority.

ReadtheReviews · 26/02/2024 19:51

They all look the same type of person physically which is what makes me laugh.
Wonder if AI would get it right inputting British Lottery Winner.

swayingpalmtree · 26/02/2024 19:50

The press wouldn't be allowed to report the story either. The press know so much stuff about celebrities and so on that they aren't allowed to report. Unless you go public the press cannot do it. I don't know where that myth comes from

Yes- exactly. Plus the whole appeal of a public lottery win is interviewing them, them telling everyone what they'll do with the money, what they did to celebrate, what their family think of it, photos of them with a huge cheque and champagne corks flying etc

I cant imagine a more boring or uninspiring story than "we think Mr Smith from Edinburgh has won the lottery but he said "no comment" when we asked him and we cannot confirm it's true either. He has however started shopping at Waitrose though instead of Tescos, we'll keep you informed of any further developments" 😂

LindaHamilton · 26/02/2024 19:42

swayingpalmtree · 26/02/2024 18:45

For the really big wins, the tabs actively try to track winners down

Nah- this really isnt true. Think about it- we only hear rare stories of massive winners who chose to go public. There have been hundreds and hundreds of very big winners before who remained anonymous and we never hear about them! I know this because I play euro millions fairly regularly and the jackpot frequently goes to say, 100 million one week and then it's down to 14 million the next. Someone must have been winning those amounts but you don't hear weekly about lottery winners so they stay anonymous.

A tabloid isnt going to be interested in a story where someone tells them- guess what?- my neighbour just moved to an expensive house, surely they MUST have won the lottery! If that were true then the tabs would be constantly knocking on the doors of everyone who lives in Knightsbridge or similarly expensive places all day long. I think people forget that there are a LOT of very rich people in the UK - but most people don't live in super expensive areas it feels rare. If you live in Belgravia, Kensington or Mayfair, being mega rich is just "normal" and not out of the ordinary at all.

The press wouldn't be allowed to report the story either. The press know so much stuff about celebrities and so on that they aren't allowed to report. Unless you go public the press cannot do it. I don't know where that myth comes from.

WhataPlank · 26/02/2024 19:40

I think I must live a very boring/antisocial life because I don't think enough people would give a stuff about my finances to gossip/speculate.
Combined with the fact that I've no interest in very flashy stuff (cars, watches, big houses etc) and don't post on SM so the things I would splurge on (holidays and experiences) wouldn't really be seen either - I reckon I could fly under the radar.

If the Universe is listening, I'd love to test the theory!

OP posts:
swayingpalmtree · 26/02/2024 18:45

For the really big wins, the tabs actively try to track winners down

Nah- this really isnt true. Think about it- we only hear rare stories of massive winners who chose to go public. There have been hundreds and hundreds of very big winners before who remained anonymous and we never hear about them! I know this because I play euro millions fairly regularly and the jackpot frequently goes to say, 100 million one week and then it's down to 14 million the next. Someone must have been winning those amounts but you don't hear weekly about lottery winners so they stay anonymous.

A tabloid isnt going to be interested in a story where someone tells them- guess what?- my neighbour just moved to an expensive house, surely they MUST have won the lottery! If that were true then the tabs would be constantly knocking on the doors of everyone who lives in Knightsbridge or similarly expensive places all day long. I think people forget that there are a LOT of very rich people in the UK - but most people don't live in super expensive areas it feels rare. If you live in Belgravia, Kensington or Mayfair, being mega rich is just "normal" and not out of the ordinary at all.

ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees · 26/02/2024 18:39

Not a chance would I go public.

I also would say absolutely nothing for at least 6 months to anyone, just collect it and sit on it. No changes at all, even continue working.

I would then lie and say I either one a much smaller amount or that I had a share in a syndicate & that I had signed an NDA where all the money was reclaimable by the other members if I leaked it or it was proven that the leak came from me.

LindaHamilton · 26/02/2024 18:27

MandyRiceDavies · 26/02/2024 12:35

Saw an interview with a lottery spokesman about this a while ago- they said it's not to do with financial advice (which all winners get, not just the ones who go public) but with managing the story.

  • Realistically, most winners are going to be unable to keep the win a secret due to lifestyle changes and people talking.
  • For the really big wins, the tabs actively try to track winners down.
  • Winners therefore have the choice of going public on their own terms or being "outed" as winners by the press.
  • Doing the first allows them more control of the story and to choose how to present themselves.

winners have never been outed by the press ever, it's not interesting enough for them.

janicegarvey · 26/02/2024 18:25

IvanaTinkles · 26/02/2024 18:19

Everyone who wins over a certain amount is definitely offered financial advice - the firm I work for is on the panel of companies that the national lottery refers people to. They normally get their initial meetings and advice at a discounted rate.

Personally, I would tell everyone I’d been offered a high paying contract to work in the Middle East for a year, and piss off travelling for that year as a cover, then say the amount I earned was enough to pay off the mortgage and buy a new car etc as an explanation. Not that I’ve fantasised about this extensively or anything 🤣

That's genius !! That's what ill do when I win 😂

minthybobs · 26/02/2024 18:20

Realistically, both my husband and I could say that the other came into money through work or an inheritance. There would be no need to say how much it was

This is what I’d do- be very vague and say it was an inheritance and not say how much. I’d also say it was tied up in a trust and I couldn’t access it all. I couldn’t give a toss if my neighbours saw me moving, people move all the time! I’ve never ever asked a neighbour how they could afford to move in my life (Or even where they’re moving to!) as I’ve never been super close to neighbours either and their finances are not my business. I also have a tiny family so it would be impossible for anyone to come out the woodwork as all my direct family have passed. For my close friends I’d use the inheritance story (they’re not money obsessed people anyway so wouldn’t hassle me). As for acquaintances I don’t talk about moving or what I’m buying on social media anyway so they’d never know as I don’t post pics of my house. For me it really wouldn’t be hard at all to keep it quiet as I’m very guarded on SM already. I imagine it would be harder if you have a huge family who regularly visit you though

IvanaTinkles · 26/02/2024 18:19

Everyone who wins over a certain amount is definitely offered financial advice - the firm I work for is on the panel of companies that the national lottery refers people to. They normally get their initial meetings and advice at a discounted rate.

Personally, I would tell everyone I’d been offered a high paying contract to work in the Middle East for a year, and piss off travelling for that year as a cover, then say the amount I earned was enough to pay off the mortgage and buy a new car etc as an explanation. Not that I’ve fantasised about this extensively or anything 🤣

CruCru · 26/02/2024 17:31

I think I’d keep it quiet. Perhaps I’d do the things I’d been putting off because they are boring and expensive (getting the car serviced, going to the dentist).

I don’t think I’d ever tell people I was flying first class on holiday.

Realistically, both my husband and I could say that the other came into money through work or an inheritance. There would be no need to say how much it was.

Beaverbridge · 26/02/2024 17:25

I'd stay quiet for couple of months. I'd go off to NYC for a month. If it was mega money, look at getting an apartment there. Whilst I was away I'd get a total house and garden renovation done. I'd stay in a hotel when I was away. Anyone who asked I'd tell them my partner had a reasonable win. He doesn't live with me. Don't have large family, 2 daughters, they'd get a bung.

HolidaySwears · 26/02/2024 17:18

I have never, ever in my life read a story in any of even the raggiest of shitrags about how a lottery winner was tracked down and outed by shonky journos? Even google is coming up empty?

Total scare mongering BS.

GnomeDePlume · 26/02/2024 17:16

Whether you can keep it secret will depend to a large extent on your current life. If you regularly chat with your neighbours, post on FB, don't holiday much or only holiday in the UK then people will notice and comment on changes:

  • unexpectedly putting the house on the market or moving out without explaining why
  • suddenly coming off FB
  • sporting a winter sun tan having said you were going to Rhyl

I have no doubt that the press have contacts in all sorts of places. Someone will blow the secret.

swayingpalmtree · 26/02/2024 16:40

I wouldn’t go public but even if you didn’t you’d get constant speculation like the above

Yes, you may get speculation but at the end of the day, noone really KNOWS so they cant say for sure and if you do things sensibly by gradually upscaling your lifestyle rather than buying a diamond rolex and a Ferrari the very next morning then people are less likely to catch on. I imagine that adapting slowly rather than going on mad spending sprees is probably better for you psychologically as well as financially anyway.

I'm not telling anyone when I win- not a damn soul apart from my DH! I wouldnt change my lifestyle for several months and I'd do it slowly. Noone is "owed" any explanations about my finances anyway - and if they asked I'd tell them it was private!

Herdinggoats · 26/02/2024 15:38

I’d be intrigued as how many people came crawling out the woodwork. “So sad we lost touch, what are you up to now…oh you won the lottery…I had no idea”. But agree it’s madness to tell the press

Greenpolkadot · 26/02/2024 15:22

A woman who lived near me won over £10 million. I heard from a mutual friend that she had taken all of her friends out for a meal but made them pay for themselves as she didnt want them to think she was being flashy..

I wonder what happens to all the begging letter? Do the winners read every one?

Antsinmypantsneedtodance · 26/02/2024 15:06

Jessforless · 26/02/2024 14:39

I have a friend I suspect won some money. They moved to a much more expensive house, both got new cars, took 3 or 4 holidays and posted themselves flying upper.

Every mutual friend always says ‘where on earth do they get their money!’

I wouldn’t go public but even if you didn’t you’d get constant speculation like the above.

This reminds me of an ex colleague of my husband. He's fb friends with them and noticed their regular holidays flying first and business class, taking family with them, buying a holiday home, decking out a home gym with peloton equipment etc.

He asked where do they get their money. But was more trying to work out how his colleuege who wasn't overly competent had got a role high up in their specialism for a large multi national company. But assumed he'd just got lucky.

He honestly didn't even think of a lottery win. It wasn't until I looked at it and their generic linkedin job titles they'd created and their previous roles not completely matching, I twigged that was probably what had happened. As costing their expenditure up doesn't really match their potential earnings

Others may know or suspect, but the cover is probably easy to keep as they come from a relatively high paying sector (60-120k pa wages). I mean there's a chance they didn't win but I find it unlikely they havent somehow come into some money, though looking at the house they've bought and other things i doubt its a euro millions level win. More like a few million. Oddly though i think the very british attitude of not discussing money shows as comments on posts are more subtle. No one asking outright about where their money comes from. Ther emust be quite a few winners per year winning 1 million plus. I doubt the press care too much about the small ones. So wait long enough and pretend to be one of the 1-2 million winners.

Buttercupmush · 26/02/2024 14:58

Soupsetanddefeated · 26/02/2024 14:24

@Buttercupmush this made me laugh out loud, the press can write whatever they want about whoever they want! It doesn't have to be true, just "from a source" i.e a sad face relative or acquaintance who has been paid a couple of grand to sell their story. They may approach the people and ask them for an interview for an exclusive, but if they decline they'll still write it anyway.

But to do that they must need some form of confirmation? Anyone can say anything to a newspaper just for a wind up ? I would imagine it would be from an anonymous source who phones the press ? The press then rock up on the doorstep and make believe they are from Lotto ? They are going to look idiots otherwise ?