Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To finally lose my temper and tell him to F off?!

63 replies

cathusa · 26/02/2024 03:03

Thankfully, this 'relationship' didn't last long. I am child-free and 33.

I stupidly made an exception for a single Dad because we clicked on so many other aspects. I'm 33 (female), so I suppose a lot of my 'pool' consists of a lot of parents. Certainly if they are older - which he is. He is 45.

This guy told me his co-parenting with his ex was cordial and in a good place. Total BS. He told me his kids didn't 'drop in' on the days he didn't have them, despite them being somewhat close by. Total BS.

Every date was interrupted with incessant calls. The mother would want to dump the kids onto him at a moment's notice, so nights in were quickly shut down - and because I had yet to formally meet them, I would have to leave the house before they entered. There was no formal arrangement regarding when the kids would be with the Mom/Dad, despite him saying otherwise. Plus, if he wasn't at home, he'd be at the Mom's house playing happy families. He even still thought he could take family (domestic and Intl) trips together - and they apparently still wanted to have that 'family setup'.

It was beyond insulting. Worst of all, I kept doubting myself and feeling like the worst person in the world for wanting a dinner where the phone didn't ring throughout - and so to 'keep the peace' - I would say nothing. But when I did speak up (and even that was kindly), I felt like a horrible person and like I was being 'needy' or 'competing' for attention.

But the truth is, because I'm such an independent person by nature, I let many things slide as I'm more than ok with my own company. But in the end, I was compromising too much. When I ended things, I was very polite and he thanked me for being understanding and said many lovely things etc... there was no drama within the break up and no shouting or anything like that. No blowup.

Of course, children should be a priority. I totally understand that, but he was trying to have this happy family setup in one home and thinking he could have this relationship with me on the side - where I couldn't even get my basic needs met. I hated feeling like I was 'asking for scraps of attention' - as that's so far from who I am as a person.

He admitted that he thought he could have both - and that there were no boundaries between him and his ex - and admitted that she still very much wanted this setup to continue too, more than he apparently did (but that could be BS - who knows). I suspect he just wanted to be the 'fun' and 'available' Dad - which I sort of get. They were still very much in each others' pockets. But in that case, there's sadly no room for another relationship - which is why I (respectfully and kindly) walked away.

Looking back now, I don't even know if his divorce had been finalized. He did admit his situation was 'difficult' for a CF person, but to be totally blunt, seeing him jump whenever his ex said 'jump' - just made me lose all respect for him. But I also understand that he's being present for his children, which is obviously no bad thing.

A few days later, he came back trying to plead his 'case' and list all the 'advantages' and how his kids don't demand a lot of attention and will be 'out the house soon'.

Hearing that didn't make me feel good as there shouldn't be a countdown as to when they 'leave'. Also, parenting is a job for life. So his 'case pleading' fell on deaf ears. I shut it down.

He's since come back again and suggested a break/vacation together. Whilst I appreciate the thought/efforts - I also feel like I'm not being heard - as what would that solve?! We are simply not compatible. Full stop.

I think because I ended things so amicably and kindly (which he would also agree with) - he still feels like he can have some swaying power. But now I am just beyond angry. I handled a situation well because I wanted what was best for their family - and yes, also for myself, but I feel like he's now asking me to put all of my needs aside for him.

Am I being unreasonable here in feeling as angry as I do? Once again, I feel like a terrible uncompromising person.

OP posts:
Nicebloomers · 26/02/2024 10:08

He’s probably realised that this situation would be even more complicated with a woman who also has a shared custody situation. Imagine the chaos. He could have made adjustments to accommodate a new partner but he didn’t. He wanted his cake and to eat it.

You gave it a go, it didn’t work out and he needs to respect your decision to break up. I’d block him tbh.

Goinggreymammy · 26/02/2024 10:01

You were completely right. I once went on a coffee date with a man who took 3 phone calls from children/ex partner during our date. I read his newspaper while he was on the phone. Needless to say there was no second date (I said we weren't compatible).

JonVoightBaddyWhoGrowls · 26/02/2024 09:45

Personally, I think he's still married. And if you were at his place, it's his little shag pad that his wife and DC know nothing about.

Dodged a bullet there.

FasterthanaButteredOtter · 26/02/2024 09:26

Agree with @Oblomov24 and @dimllaishebiaith

He's trying to have his cake and eat it and you deserve more and better than this.

Thank you NEXT!

dimllaishebiaith · 26/02/2024 09:16

HotChocolateNotCocoa · 26/02/2024 05:04

It sounds to me like you made a situation that’s nothing to do with you all about you. Maybe find someone without any ties who will always make YOU the star of the show.

Edited

Of course, because a women cant expect any aspect of a relationship to be about her if there is the opportunity for her to subjugate her needs to others

There is nothing wrong in the OP realising that her needs cannot be met in this relationship. There is nothing wrong in the ex putting the needs of his children first.

The issue is that he cannot seem to understand that his putting the children needs first to this extent means that he is not in the best position to be dating. Instead he, expects the OP to put up with having her needs ignored.

Alongside that he caused the problem in the first place by misrepresenting his situation to the OP and not giving her chance to make an informed decision at the start.

ArchetypalBusyMum · 26/02/2024 08:56

Well said op (latest update).

Mothership4two · 26/02/2024 08:52

Having read your latest update, you were wise to move on OP. He should have been shutting her down not indulging in long non-essential phone calls when he was on a date with you. If sounds more and more like she was doing it deliberately.

OrionStridesIn · 26/02/2024 08:16

You're a couple of years younger than me OP and I wouldn't date a man in his mid 40s!

Seriously, you're young, find someone younger, with or without kids most importantly with a far less messy set up!

cathusa · 26/02/2024 08:15

Toenailz · 26/02/2024 07:58

Find yourself someone child free, OP. Absolutely no need to put yourself through this.

I also agree it's not an on-off switch, but this is bizarre/OTT. The problem is it starts to get extremely tedious for the child-free person in the relationship if boundaries aren't set.

I dare say him being a father isn't the issue here, it's her.

@Toenailz I agree wholeheartedly. Even with kids, it was more just about boundaries. It become very apparent - very quickly - that the setup was a totally enmeshed one... which was in no way similar to what he said it was.

In many ways, I was weirdly pleased - because it made me happy that the children can have lots of quality time with each parent.

But it got old fast. The phone would ring incessantly every single time we were together - for no valid reason. But because the kid/ex was calling for a simple chat, I felt even worse for feeling bad about it.

All too often, I'd be sitting alone in a restaurant while he'd be outside talking on the phone for 20+ mins. Initially, I was concerned for him as I thought something was seriously wrong (as in an emergency) but no.

Even when the kids would randomly show up (obviously having been driven over), I would have to duck out before they arrived. I would have a 5/10 minute warning as the parents live close to each other. It was insane.

...and those are just a few examples.

I let it all slide for too long as I'm very conflict averse - and even when I (respectfully) ended things, he acknowledged the situation was messy, thanked me for being understanding etc... and said some very nice things etc... I was happy to leave quietly and nicely.

But this constant backtracking is now irritating me - and I feel like I'm being cornered. But as many other posters have said; it might be time to just be firm (again) and/or block.

I think it's great that he's a present father - especially in a world where there are so many awful parents/neglected children. I still wish him well, but from afar.

OP posts:
SignoraVolpe · 26/02/2024 08:09

Doubt he was going to pay for an extra bedroom when holidaying with an ‘ex.’

He thought because your younger and no dc he could present his dubious status as good co parenting. Personally I don’t think him and his ex have finished properly.

Block him.

cathusa · 26/02/2024 08:03

iamjustwinginglife · 26/02/2024 05:14

Maybe what he told you about the set up was right when he told you but the ex has decided to sabotage his new relationship by constantly calling him while he's with you?

@iamjustwinginglife True. A possibility indeed, but ultimately it doesn't change anything as that's still equally unappealing as I'm not looking for drama. To his credit, he fully acknowledged it was 'messy' with their setup - but only after I had ended things.

OP posts:
Toenailz · 26/02/2024 07:58

Find yourself someone child free, OP. Absolutely no need to put yourself through this.

I also agree it's not an on-off switch, but this is bizarre/OTT. The problem is it starts to get extremely tedious for the child-free person in the relationship if boundaries aren't set.

I dare say him being a father isn't the issue here, it's her.

ArchetypalBusyMum · 26/02/2024 07:21

You've been reasonable op.
He's trying to keep his foot in the door with you despite you saying it isn't working for you so you just need to be really clear you're done as he's not listening.
Of course his kids will always come first and good dad's don't turn being dad on and off, but his set up is pretty messy and it would appear they haven't really got their post split sorted properly so that things are predictable and clear all round.
Any new partner he finds will struggle to find a role in his life with what you describe.
You're well out of it.

theduchessofspork · 26/02/2024 06:35

KnowledgeableMomma · 26/02/2024 03:21

"It's not going to work out, for all the reasons I said in our previous conversations. I wish you nothing but the best. I won't be contacting you again." And block.

This

Mummyoflittledragon · 26/02/2024 05:57

Oblomov24 · 26/02/2024 05:41

"You are obviously suited to a man without kids. "

I disagree. You just want a man, (who may very well have kids) who has boundaries, and who considers your needs, and who has space for you and prioritises you. Not unreasonable.

I agree with this. It’s ok for family life to take precedent sometimes when the dcs are with the other parents. But not all the time. They both sound very enmeshed and haven’t truly moved on from the relationship.

Oblomov24 · 26/02/2024 05:41

"You are obviously suited to a man without kids. "

I disagree. You just want a man, (who may very well have kids) who has boundaries, and who considers your needs, and who has space for you and prioritises you. Not unreasonable.

Isthismyforever · 26/02/2024 05:29

HotChocolateNotCocoa · 26/02/2024 05:04

It sounds to me like you made a situation that’s nothing to do with you all about you. Maybe find someone without any ties who will always make YOU the star of the show.

Edited

I think that's very unfair on the OP. Sounds to me like she has been very understanding & tbh the guy is at fault for misrepresenting the set up to her. I don't think she has made it all about her at all! Quite the opposite.

thebestinterest · 26/02/2024 05:20

Plus he’s way too old for you, specially is you’re wanting children for your own. Next.

Shoxfordian · 26/02/2024 05:16

Tell him again that you're done and block him, sounds like you made the right choice

iamjustwinginglife · 26/02/2024 05:14

Maybe what he told you about the set up was right when he told you but the ex has decided to sabotage his new relationship by constantly calling him while he's with you?

fatphalange · 26/02/2024 05:06

Does he realise the relationship is over? He should leave you alone! You've dodged a complete nightmare here, I think.

HotChocolateNotCocoa · 26/02/2024 05:04

It sounds to me like you made a situation that’s nothing to do with you all about you. Maybe find someone without any ties who will always make YOU the star of the show.

Pinkfrlls · 26/02/2024 05:01

Life is short. Time is precious. Tell him to eff off and don't come back.

poetryandwine · 26/02/2024 04:47

I ended a ‘fling with potential’ for similar reasons, OP. I am glad I did, but part of that is that while I liked the guy a lot I couldn’t imagine falling head over heels for him.

It sounds like there may possibly be an element of this for you as well?

In any case I met DH which was a much more enthusiastic proposition from the outset a year later. That was quite a while ago!

Lurkingandlearning · 26/02/2024 04:35

I hardly ever think “just block them “ but that is what I think you should do. You’ve politely explained your position and he is refusing to accept it. There’s no reason for him to contact you again so make sure he can’t.