Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mumsnet posts which drive me mad

633 replies

Ilovecleaning · 25/02/2024 21:20

Anyone hate these posts?

  • really really really long posts
  • long posts with NO paragraphs
  • posts which start ‘ I have a friend, let’s call her Jane; her DH, let’s call him Sam… you can’t bloody well follow the post. Much easier just to say Friend and DH.
Any others? 😊
OP posts:
Thepeopleversuswork · 02/03/2024 13:11

DerekFaker · 26/02/2024 10:38

There's a lot of promotion of disordered eating on here, and I wish Mumsnet would clamp down on it. It's actually dangerous.

From competitive under- eating posts to 'advice' like: try eating just 500 calories a day or fasting, and people claiming they feel HUGE at a size 12. Really grim.

I agree these are genuinely disturbing. Threads dominated by what are basically pro Ana comments. I have no idea why they don’t get deleted. I think people who enjoy making others feel bad about their calorie intake need calling out for their own sake.

ToWhitToWhoo · 02/03/2024 12:46

crumbledog · 02/03/2024 10:29

Is it’s an actual birthday phobia, as in I’m scared of cakes and cards, or is it I don’t want a huge fuss with balloons and party poppers in the works canteen ?
The latter I can understand, but I’m talking about a simple acknowledgment from your nearest and dearest, that an unusually high number of posters on here dismiss as unnecessary and childish. I would be quite hurt if I was ‘ forgotten’ about on my birthday, by close friends and family and I don’t think I’m unusual outside of mumsnet in that respect.

I'm not phobic of cards or cakes as such; I'm phobic of people making a fuss of my new age. I don't think I hated birthdays QUITE as much before the current emphasis (which I do think is fairly recent) on 'big' 'milestone' birthdays.

And I find it even more upsetting if I've told people that I want my birthday to be ignored, and they disregard my wishes. I understand that people, who do celebrate their birthday, will feel similarly upset if others ignore it. So maybe we aren't really so very different; we both want others to consider us as individuals, and to respect our wishes!

MasterBeth · 02/03/2024 12:38

crumbledog · 02/03/2024 11:47

Well it is. People are generally responding to a question somewhere in the thread, if not the op and the same thing applies, that poster has likely long since departed.
If you want to ask a question, start a new thread.
Using the pub conversation analogy, it’s like wandering in 2 hours after everyone has moved on and trying to resurrect a conversation, people are bored and have exhausted the topic.

No, I think many contributions are just adding to a discussion that sits online permanently and the original poster's initial question is relevant only because it's provoked the subsequent discussion.

You could read this discussion now or in two years' time and it would be equally (ir)relevant.

ToWhitToWhoo · 02/03/2024 12:36

crumbledog · 02/03/2024 00:31

@ToWhitToWhoo I would think you would feel at home here, I have never met anyone on real life that has a birthday phobia.
I am with the other poster, mumsnet seems have a large volume of people that seem to think that a poster wanting some kind of acknowledgement of their birthday is childish and entitled.

While I am probably rather extreme in my birthday-hatred, I certainly know other people who are birthday-phobic in real life. The thing is, that if you don't know people extremely well, you probably won't know that they are birthday-phobic, because they won't make it known when their birthday is.

I think there are a certain number of people on MN who are judgemental of others who don't 'do' their birthdays in the same way as themselves, and this happens in both directions. I have certainly come across the 'childish and entitled' comments; but I've also come across posts where people who dislike their birthdays are accused of being 'miserable curmudgeons', anti-social, ungrateful, or insincere; and where dislike of ageing is seen as simply vanity.

StockpotSoup · 02/03/2024 12:15

People who “correct” you by laughing at how stupid you are, rather than just saying “actually, that’s not quite right…” or similar. The irony is, the ones who are rude and mocking are usually wrong! (Yes, lumps of human porridge who laughingly told me there’s no such thing as “grounds for divorce” in the UK, I’m looking at you.)

BIWI · 02/03/2024 12:05

The other reason zombie threads are disliked is because they're often resurrected by spammers or trolls. So the actual thread (and any questions therein) are totally irrelevant. It's just for them to get into Active Discussions.

And aren't there enough current/topical threads to discuss, without the need for the old ones?!

crumbledog · 02/03/2024 11:47

MasterBeth · 02/03/2024 11:31

Again, that supposes that the only reason for the forums on Mumsnet is to answer a question set by the original poster. I don't think that's the case.

Well it is. People are generally responding to a question somewhere in the thread, if not the op and the same thing applies, that poster has likely long since departed.
If you want to ask a question, start a new thread.
Using the pub conversation analogy, it’s like wandering in 2 hours after everyone has moved on and trying to resurrect a conversation, people are bored and have exhausted the topic.

MasterBeth · 02/03/2024 11:31

crumbledog · 02/03/2024 11:28

People then start responding to the op, who has likely long since departed.

Again, that supposes that the only reason for the forums on Mumsnet is to answer a question set by the original poster. I don't think that's the case.

crumbledog · 02/03/2024 11:28

MasterBeth · 02/03/2024 11:18

Also, anyone who posts to say "Zombie thread!!!!" like you're going to catch a disease off it.

Why does it matter if you're reading or posting on an older thread?

People then start responding to the op, who has likely long since departed.

MasterBeth · 02/03/2024 11:26

NecessaryNC24 · 02/03/2024 11:25

I'm pretty sure it's because it's a waste of everyone's time if the poster left the building about 3 years ago and the problem is over.

That assumes that Mumsnet is some personal problem-solving service, when really it's just a timeless pub chat.

MasterBeth · 02/03/2024 11:25

SerafinasGoose · 02/03/2024 11:22

I can see how that happens. No one really checks the date of every thread they post on, but occasionally a list of 'threads similar to this one' comes up at the bottom of the desktop app, and people click on them and respond as though they are new.

There are some longstanding threads where groups of posters follow the progress of the OP - and that's fine and I think invaluable for support reasons. But surely it isn't beyond technological capability to automatically instigate the closure of a thread once no one has posted on it for, say, three months?

I'd say this one was less user error than software limitations.

I know why it happens but I don't understand why it's a problem that someone responds on an older thread.

Would this thread be any different/better/worse if it was added to over six hours or six months?

NecessaryNC24 · 02/03/2024 11:25

MasterBeth · 02/03/2024 11:18

Also, anyone who posts to say "Zombie thread!!!!" like you're going to catch a disease off it.

Why does it matter if you're reading or posting on an older thread?

I'm pretty sure it's because it's a waste of everyone's time if the poster left the building about 3 years ago and the problem is over.

SerafinasGoose · 02/03/2024 11:22

MasterBeth · 02/03/2024 11:18

Also, anyone who posts to say "Zombie thread!!!!" like you're going to catch a disease off it.

Why does it matter if you're reading or posting on an older thread?

I can see how that happens. No one really checks the date of every thread they post on, but occasionally a list of 'threads similar to this one' comes up at the bottom of the desktop app, and people click on them and respond as though they are new.

There are some longstanding threads where groups of posters follow the progress of the OP - and that's fine and I think invaluable for support reasons. But surely it isn't beyond technological capability to automatically instigate the closure of a thread once no one has posted on it for, say, three months?

I'd say this one was less user error than software limitations.

SerafinasGoose · 02/03/2024 11:20

Mothership4two · 28/02/2024 22:15

@LindaHamilton

How do you know for certain though?

Because they cocked up and accidently posted under their original (OP) names.

It doesn't really drive me mad, but it is a bit baffling

It's known as sock puppeting(!) Apparently it's a common enough problem that it's against talk guidelines, and if reported MNHQ can and do pull the posts that engage in it.

It does beg the question of who in the hell would be tragic enough to do this? Quite as opposed to irritating, I find it so pathetic as to be hilarious!

MasterBeth · 02/03/2024 11:18

Also, anyone who posts to say "Zombie thread!!!!" like you're going to catch a disease off it.

Why does it matter if you're reading or posting on an older thread?

MasterBeth · 02/03/2024 11:16

Posters who can't think beyond their own circumstances or experiences. This can manifest in various ways, the most annoying being:

  1. Can't believe anyone could actually earn £100k or £10k and has to be lying about it.

  2. Thinks "but then, I live in London" means they live a completely life to anyone else, and demands double the salary.

  3. Reads a pretty generic AIBU story ("My boss is mean to me", "My hairdresser is mean to me") and think they can pinpoint exactly who it is ("Are they called Darren?", "Is this in Kent, OP?")

SaveMeTheLabelOfThatPerfumeOnTheTable · 02/03/2024 10:58

crumbledog · 02/03/2024 10:29

Is it’s an actual birthday phobia, as in I’m scared of cakes and cards, or is it I don’t want a huge fuss with balloons and party poppers in the works canteen ?
The latter I can understand, but I’m talking about a simple acknowledgment from your nearest and dearest, that an unusually high number of posters on here dismiss as unnecessary and childish. I would be quite hurt if I was ‘ forgotten’ about on my birthday, by close friends and family and I don’t think I’m unusual outside of mumsnet in that respect.

I wouldn't use phobia to describe it but I become very anxious in the run up to it, I don't have any cards or presents, I find the whole thing very uncomfortable and quite stressful. I accept that people who know will say Happy Birthday but I'd feel more comfortable if they didn't 🤷🏻‍♀️

I wouldn't describe someone who wanted to celebrate as childish but I think some people's expectations are OTT.

crumbledog · 02/03/2024 10:29

SaveMeTheLabelOfThatPerfumeOnTheTable · 02/03/2024 10:19

You wouldn't necessarily know that. We don't generally announce it because that would draw attention to it.

At my workplace, we acknowledge staff birthdays. I've been in my work place for 4 years. Mine's never been announced and no one has ever questioned it because no one has noticed. And thats just the way I like it.

I'm sure all of those people would say they don't know anyone who doesn't celebrate their birthday.

Is it’s an actual birthday phobia, as in I’m scared of cakes and cards, or is it I don’t want a huge fuss with balloons and party poppers in the works canteen ?
The latter I can understand, but I’m talking about a simple acknowledgment from your nearest and dearest, that an unusually high number of posters on here dismiss as unnecessary and childish. I would be quite hurt if I was ‘ forgotten’ about on my birthday, by close friends and family and I don’t think I’m unusual outside of mumsnet in that respect.

SaveMeTheLabelOfThatPerfumeOnTheTable · 02/03/2024 10:19

crumbledog · 02/03/2024 00:31

@ToWhitToWhoo I would think you would feel at home here, I have never met anyone on real life that has a birthday phobia.
I am with the other poster, mumsnet seems have a large volume of people that seem to think that a poster wanting some kind of acknowledgement of their birthday is childish and entitled.

You wouldn't necessarily know that. We don't generally announce it because that would draw attention to it.

At my workplace, we acknowledge staff birthdays. I've been in my work place for 4 years. Mine's never been announced and no one has ever questioned it because no one has noticed. And thats just the way I like it.

I'm sure all of those people would say they don't know anyone who doesn't celebrate their birthday.

SaveMeTheLabelOfThatPerfumeOnTheTable · 02/03/2024 10:13

ToWhitToWhoo · 01/03/2024 15:36

I have a pet peeve that's the reverse side of that! I am absolutely birthday-phobic (my own, not anyone else's) and it's very important for me never to be reminded in any way of the loathsome occasion, and especially of any age-milestones. That doesn't mean that I think that people who do wish to celebrate their birthdays are childish or entitled: but I find it really annoying when people can't understand that some of us really don't like birthdays. and that it doesn't mean that we must be miserable, stingy, ungrateful, or playing some sort of dishonest game in order to get more birthday attention. I also hate the expression 'you should be glad to get older; some people don't have the privilege'. I know all too well that some people die young; nevertheless, the older I get, the nearer I am to death, and, before that, to increasing health problems on top of my existing ones.

I'm the same.

I don't celebrate my birthday either. My lockdown birthdays were the least stressful ones I've had in years.

The year of my 40th was the worst and my 50th is coming up in the next year. Dreading all the "What are you doing for your 50th?" conversations.

I do celebrate others' birthdays though if they choose to.

crumbledog · 02/03/2024 00:31

@ToWhitToWhoo I would think you would feel at home here, I have never met anyone on real life that has a birthday phobia.
I am with the other poster, mumsnet seems have a large volume of people that seem to think that a poster wanting some kind of acknowledgement of their birthday is childish and entitled.

ToWhitToWhoo · 01/03/2024 15:36

SoundTheSirens · 01/03/2024 07:32

Oh I’ve thought of another one: posters who consider anyone who enjoys having even a tiny bit of consideration shown to them on their birthday completely unreasonable. “How old are you OP [with the inference they must be a child to still care about birthdays]?” or “he’s not a mind reader / why do you care so much about a cheap piece of cardboard / he probably has more important things to think about” when the OP’s partner hasn’t so much as bothered with a card, or simply the withering “grow up / why are you making such a fuss / are you usually this entitled, OP?” type replies.

I appreciate we all have different experiences, but in 50-mumble years on this planet I’ve never encountered such dismissive attitudes to birthdays, or that the idea that to want your partner / parents / closest friends to remember and wish you happy birthday and maybe be available to go for a pizza at the weekend or whatever is wildly “entitled”, as I have on MN.

I have a pet peeve that's the reverse side of that! I am absolutely birthday-phobic (my own, not anyone else's) and it's very important for me never to be reminded in any way of the loathsome occasion, and especially of any age-milestones. That doesn't mean that I think that people who do wish to celebrate their birthdays are childish or entitled: but I find it really annoying when people can't understand that some of us really don't like birthdays. and that it doesn't mean that we must be miserable, stingy, ungrateful, or playing some sort of dishonest game in order to get more birthday attention. I also hate the expression 'you should be glad to get older; some people don't have the privilege'. I know all too well that some people die young; nevertheless, the older I get, the nearer I am to death, and, before that, to increasing health problems on top of my existing ones.

IamaRevenant · 01/03/2024 15:09

Tatonka · 29/02/2024 01:33

The ones where a poster asks thoughts on a baby name, then people reply which alternate names that don't even closely resemble it

Yes this. Extra points when it's a massively long list that the poster clearly just copies and pastes of their own favourite names. Eg:

OP - I like American style, unisex girls' names. Current shortlist is Blair, Taylor and Regan. Any similar suggestions?

Annoying poster -
Penelope
Clementine
Liliana
Beatrice
Lettice
Pandora
Annabelle

And on, and on...

Februaryfeels · 01/03/2024 14:19

One popped up on another thread and I had forgotten how pissed off it made me

Any single person asking how to meet a partner, wondering if they're too old, why they can't find a partner, etc

Up pops a poster to say words to the effect of
"It'll happen when you least expect it" or "you'll meet the right man eventually"

Really unhelpful and guaranteed to make the single person feel even more inadequate when he doesn't actually come along

willWillSmithsmith · 01/03/2024 12:21

SoreAndTired1 · 29/02/2024 04:01

The lazy ignorant arseholes who take up a post and post one post with ( . )
Or 'placemarking'.

FFS, there is WATCH THREAD as a function for this very reason, to STOP all the 'placemarking' or posts with nothing but a full stop. Watch his thread can be found at BOTH the top AND the bottom of the thread, so no excuse not to use it!

I wondered what those full stop posts were. 👍

Swipe left for the next trending thread