Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we need to change how we treat Anorexia

88 replies

S3aH0use7337 · 25/02/2024 19:43

My dd has suffered from this disease since lockdown. It has had a catastrophic impact on her life. Part of the reason she has been ill for so long is that the traditional way of treatment relies on family therapy. My dd has autism and this style of approach with parents being in control just didn’t work for her and often doesn’t with autism. Research shows autism and Anorexia can often be linked. My DD’s Anorexia wasn’t picked apart and she wasn’t given any coping strategies that suited her or proper specialist support just FBT. CAMHS pulled back from FBT when it clearly wasn’t going to work but didn’t have any ideas of what else to do and just tried to make her focus on other things with the idea that real would make her suddenly decide to get well.🤔 No tools were given to do that .The anorexia got more and more imbedded . Because FBT is the default treatment they were too scared to take the bull by the horns and try anything else. Because beds in units were in very short supply she just ping ponged in and out of paed wards without specialist care and the disease was left to get more in control of her life. I saw so many other young people in the same situation with trauma and ptsd becoming common.

Under adult services she has tried a different style of treatment with some success. It’s hard though because she has been ill for so long. I don’t understand why it isn’t tried earlier under CAMHS.

In addition to this is the issue re how adult sufferers are accessing care. It’s shocking but the iller you get the less help you seem to get with some areas now discussing palliative care instead.I have added a link which explains the truly shocking state of play at the moment.

So AIBU in thinking the whole area needs a massive rethink starting with a look at the FBT or nothing approach for young children, links to autism and the shocking struggle to access treatment as adults?https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2024/feb/25/illness-worsens-scandal-eating-disorder-treatment-england

Your illness worsens – so care is cut off. This is the scandal playing out in eating disorder treatment | John Harris

Patients I’ve spoken to in the east of England were desperate for help, with dangerously low BMIs. On what possible grounds were they discharged?, asks Guardian columnist John Harris

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2024/feb/25/illness-worsens-scandal-eating-disorder-treatment-england

OP posts:
Softleftpowerstance · 25/02/2024 21:50

I’ve never heard of FBT. I had anorexia as a teen in the 90s when awareness and treatment was even worse than it is now. But reading about FBT now has made my blood run cold. I cannot begin to describe how detrimental it would have been in my family. If this really is the go to dogma then I find that terrifying.

S3aH0use7337 · 25/02/2024 21:44

Kielyflower · 25/02/2024 21:41

I agree with you. I think what @helpfulperson and I were trying to say is that some people do not really respond to any treatment for their anorexia or other mental health problems even with all the money and resources in the world. Just look at all the rich and famous who struggle with MH, ED and addiction etc.

Its a very hard thing to accept but not dissimilar to the fact that young, otherwise healthy people, do not always respond to eg chemotherapy. It’s all very sad.

But they won’t if oniy one style of treatment is tried for far too long leaving an ED to get imbedded. Many sufferers are not getting any treatment at all.

OP posts:
Kielyflower · 25/02/2024 21:41

S3aH0use7337 · 25/02/2024 21:23

No I expect services to try other types of treatment instead of just sticking to a default treatment known to not be that great for the very section of society most likely to get Anorexia.

Its lazy and causes a massive drain on paediatric wards.

I agree with you. I think what @helpfulperson and I were trying to say is that some people do not really respond to any treatment for their anorexia or other mental health problems even with all the money and resources in the world. Just look at all the rich and famous who struggle with MH, ED and addiction etc.

Its a very hard thing to accept but not dissimilar to the fact that young, otherwise healthy people, do not always respond to eg chemotherapy. It’s all very sad.

S3aH0use7337 · 25/02/2024 21:23

Kielyflower · 25/02/2024 21:19

I agree with this. Doesn’t just apply to anorexia but other mental health problems too.

No I expect services to try other types of treatment instead of just sticking to a default treatment known to not be that great for the very section of society most likely to get Anorexia.

Its lazy and causes a massive drain on paediatric wards.

OP posts:
ThatsNotHealthy · 25/02/2024 21:23

I had chronic severe anorexia for 18 years from the age of 11. FBT actively made it worse, for everyone not just me. And CBT at best was uselessly frustrating. I think the problem with anorexia is that there is no single treatment that’s going to work for everyone. Anorexia is borne out of a complex mixture of life circumstances and genetics to a degree. Getting better really is trial and error. It is possible to fully recover though so there is hope. I never used to believe that on my bleakest days but life on the other side is much better now.

Kielyflower · 25/02/2024 21:19

helpfulperson · 25/02/2024 20:22

I do think part of the issue is that we expect the professionals to have answers and treatments for everything and the challenging answer is that they don't. There is no magic wand that can be waved in many cases even if money and resources were no barrier.

I agree with this. Doesn’t just apply to anorexia but other mental health problems too.

JaneSeymourTheOnlyOneHeTrulyLoved · 25/02/2024 21:18

FBT hasn’t worked for us either. 3 years in and recently diagnosed with ASD and on yet another Paediatric admission. I’m hoping that now she has the ASD diagnosis, the anorexia will be approached from a different angle.

S3aH0use7337 · 25/02/2024 21:11

ameliapond · 25/02/2024 21:08

My eldest was diagnosed with anorexia back in 2018 I think at 14 years old.
We did the whole fbt and it didn't work for her either.
She's in her second year of uni, and has been under the adult services since 18, after camhs discharged her due to lack of engagement, and being able to maintain a lower end of normal weight despite many symptoms etc

Pretty sure she is also autistic, she pretty much fell apart when starting secondary school, leading to the anorexia in year 10.

Under the adult service, she was having an asd assessment but I don't know the outcome for that, she wouldn't tell me.
One thing that worked for her was that they didn't tell me a single thing unless they had no choice, and they always asked her if it was okay to share things with me.

She was transferred to the ED service where she goes to uni in Wales, and the difference has been huge. They've really helped her, she's closely monitored with weekly checks and frequent blood tests.
The adult service has done more for her than camhs ever did.

Now, I turned to fb support groups for support for myself and advice. They can be good however if you do have a child or young person for whom fbt doesn't work, you're then made to feel bad that you can't help your child, that fbt is the only thing that works, and the only thing they will advice on. If anyone dared to question it, they were basically jumped on and make you feel.like you're failing. You were told you weren't doing it right, that you had to fully focus on it despite having to work, or having to provide care of other siblings.

I hear you. That so sounds like our story.FBT is like a cult, people are blocked from Facebook support groups if they don’t fully chant the FBT cry or dare to voice that it just isn’t working.

I think it causes trauma in some cases. It has in ours for both my husband, myself and my daughter.

OP posts:
S3aH0use7337 · 25/02/2024 21:08

Fullrecoveryispossible · 25/02/2024 21:05

So sorry to hear these stories. I fully received from anorexia so please know it is possible! But certainly not under nhs treatment. It was through a book written by Tabitha Farrar. Can’t remember the name but it was life changing. I have no issues around body image, eating or exercise now.

My daughter has that book and says it’s good.

OP posts:
ameliapond · 25/02/2024 21:08

My eldest was diagnosed with anorexia back in 2018 I think at 14 years old.
We did the whole fbt and it didn't work for her either.
She's in her second year of uni, and has been under the adult services since 18, after camhs discharged her due to lack of engagement, and being able to maintain a lower end of normal weight despite many symptoms etc

Pretty sure she is also autistic, she pretty much fell apart when starting secondary school, leading to the anorexia in year 10.

Under the adult service, she was having an asd assessment but I don't know the outcome for that, she wouldn't tell me.
One thing that worked for her was that they didn't tell me a single thing unless they had no choice, and they always asked her if it was okay to share things with me.

She was transferred to the ED service where she goes to uni in Wales, and the difference has been huge. They've really helped her, she's closely monitored with weekly checks and frequent blood tests.
The adult service has done more for her than camhs ever did.

Now, I turned to fb support groups for support for myself and advice. They can be good however if you do have a child or young person for whom fbt doesn't work, you're then made to feel bad that you can't help your child, that fbt is the only thing that works, and the only thing they will advice on. If anyone dared to question it, they were basically jumped on and make you feel.like you're failing. You were told you weren't doing it right, that you had to fully focus on it despite having to work, or having to provide care of other siblings.

Cuff2 · 25/02/2024 21:06

S3aH0use7337 · 25/02/2024 20:46

My dd is doing MANTRA . We’re so not out of the woods yet and it’s not a miracle cure but it’s sooo much better than FBT and you don’t get it until under adult services. I don’t get why they can’t do a child version. After a year of unsuccessful FBT they should be looking at alternative treatments but they don’t. The longer the illness the less likelihood of a positive outcome. 3 bloody years we wasted doing FBT leaving the ED to get more imbedded.

Thank you so much. I'll look into that. Appreciate it. Sounds positive hope it goes well.

Fullrecoveryispossible · 25/02/2024 21:05

So sorry to hear these stories. I fully received from anorexia so please know it is possible! But certainly not under nhs treatment. It was through a book written by Tabitha Farrar. Can’t remember the name but it was life changing. I have no issues around body image, eating or exercise now.

S3aH0use7337 · 25/02/2024 20:55

Dogdilemma2000 · 25/02/2024 20:48

I was anorexic for 10 years and the lack of treatment available then was shocking. I had an amazing therapist as a teen who I really respected and listened to, but I went off to uni and was told by the mental health team there that I didn’t have any real problems and was discharged when my weight was at a critically low point.

More work needs to be done on the root cause of anorexia in the individual. In my opinion anorexia often develops as a poor coping mechanism, same as self injury, and if you don’t deal with the root of the issue all you’re doing is force feeding (which has a time and place, when you’re starved and malnourished you can not think straight at all).

Absolutely!

OP posts:
S3aH0use7337 · 25/02/2024 20:53

Kalevala · 25/02/2024 20:48

I 100% agree that the energy deficit needs correcting first, but my parents in control would never have worked for me, I would have fought back on principle. It also would have not worked for my parents who were independent at 15/16 and thought I should be too. It needed to be my decision.

That was exactly the same with my dd and CAMHS thought the same, so much so the psych actually said she needed to be in control and FBT needed to stop but they gave her nothing else. No investigation and picking apart of the cause of her ED or coping strategies. She’s done 1 year of MANTRA and made more progress than in 3 years of FBT. It’s nuts.

OP posts:
Kalevala · 25/02/2024 20:52

I agree about FBT, it is also almost impossible to operate with a lone parent and an older teen who is not entirely in your control and can leave the house/stay up all night to outwit you.

I'd have just walked out and would have been sleeping on the train with a return ticket riding back and forth. That was my go to for family fights.

S3aH0use7337 · 25/02/2024 20:50

Mmmm19 · 25/02/2024 20:40

I think you make a good point. Medical care can’t fix all diseases/disorders and psychiatry further behind than other fields in part due less research funding but mainly due to the complexity of the brain. Care for mental health and eating disorders would be better with more funding but it wouldn’t cure everyone (I work in the clinical and research field)

But all they do is push a traumatic crap treatment that doesn’t work for many patients particularly those with ASC. They don’t try anything else until it’s too late. The FBT obsession needs to end as does bumping adults off treatment if they become too unwell. It’s a scandal.

I’m still having therapy myself as a result of FBT and only just starting to rebuild my relationship with my daughter after FBT did so much damage.

OP posts:
Kalevala · 25/02/2024 20:48

PostItInABook · 25/02/2024 20:28

The main problem is professionals and parents setting target weights far too low, especially for pre teens / teens. It is a fundamentally biological illness. The medicine to treat it is food / calories and weight gain. No amount of therapy will help when the brain is too starved. The psychological symptoms are because the brain is starved. Those symptoms will not go away until adequate nourishment is achieved. If target weights are too low this doesn’t happen and the sufferer becomes a chronic case. Therapy/psychological intervention is for when adequate nutrition and weight gain is enough to show an improvement in symptoms. Then therapy to develop coping strategies to prevent relapse.

FBT is really, really hard on everyone, but the point of it is to get the medicine (I.e. food) in to achieve the necessary weight gain to a proper level before other treatments can be successful.

I 100% agree that the energy deficit needs correcting first, but my parents in control would never have worked for me, I would have fought back on principle. It also would have not worked for my parents who were independent at 15/16 and thought I should be too. It needed to be my decision.

Dogdilemma2000 · 25/02/2024 20:48

I was anorexic for 10 years and the lack of treatment available then was shocking. I had an amazing therapist as a teen who I really respected and listened to, but I went off to uni and was told by the mental health team there that I didn’t have any real problems and was discharged when my weight was at a critically low point.

More work needs to be done on the root cause of anorexia in the individual. In my opinion anorexia often develops as a poor coping mechanism, same as self injury, and if you don’t deal with the root of the issue all you’re doing is force feeding (which has a time and place, when you’re starved and malnourished you can not think straight at all).

ItsallIeverwanted · 25/02/2024 20:47

@annonymousse I'm so sorry. That's awful.

S3aH0use7337 · 25/02/2024 20:46

Cuff2 · 25/02/2024 20:38

@S3aH0use7337 would you mind sharing what treatment is hopefully working for your DD now. My DD had FBT for sometime and I agree it never attempts to unpick the actual issue.

My dd is doing MANTRA . We’re so not out of the woods yet and it’s not a miracle cure but it’s sooo much better than FBT and you don’t get it until under adult services. I don’t get why they can’t do a child version. After a year of unsuccessful FBT they should be looking at alternative treatments but they don’t. The longer the illness the less likelihood of a positive outcome. 3 bloody years we wasted doing FBT leaving the ED to get more imbedded.

OP posts:
annonymousse · 25/02/2024 20:46

TRIGGER WARNING -DEATH

My niece was diagnosed at age 15. We were told she was anorexic but nothing really happened and life went on. She went off to uni and was sent home after 6 months in a skeletal state. She was admitted to hospital for the first time for life saving treatment ie tube feeding and a telling off. This was the start of a cycle of admissions to general wards and specialist units where they would feed her up and send her home. They kept asking her what had triggered her anorexia and because she wasn't able or willing to tell them they would be exasperated with her. It felt like she was being passed from pillar to post. Finally after a suicide attempt they decided she had a personality disorder and sent her home for care at home. The care all the way through was just woeful. Tragically she died last year aged 32. Her whole adult life was just pain and suffering. It is such a horrible disease and so much more complicated than just starvation. I can't believe they still don't seem to have effective treatment.

LovelyTheresa · 25/02/2024 20:46

helpfulperson · 25/02/2024 20:22

I do think part of the issue is that we expect the professionals to have answers and treatments for everything and the challenging answer is that they don't. There is no magic wand that can be waved in many cases even if money and resources were no barrier.

That really isn't good enough, though. It isn't about 'finding answers' it is about working with what they have got, trial and error, seeing what's actually in front of them instead of just throwing their hands up when what they assume ought to work does not.

ItsallIeverwanted · 25/02/2024 20:45

I agree about FBT, it is also almost impossible to operate with a lone parent and an older teen who is not entirely in your control and can leave the house/stay up all night to outwit you.

In our case, I was convinced, and subsequently it's been the case, that it wasn't 'just' an eating disorder and so this idea we would hit the better weight and their thinking would get much better just never happened. I knew there were underlying MH issues that needed urgent attention, at the same time.

I would like my dd to have done CBT as well, but it just never happened. That said, so far, adult services are sensible and focused on safety and quite patient, and there isn't the parental telling-off thing constantly going on as in child services. We are also in long-term recovery after an ED that started later in teens.

Mmmm19 · 25/02/2024 20:40

helpfulperson · 25/02/2024 20:22

I do think part of the issue is that we expect the professionals to have answers and treatments for everything and the challenging answer is that they don't. There is no magic wand that can be waved in many cases even if money and resources were no barrier.

I think you make a good point. Medical care can’t fix all diseases/disorders and psychiatry further behind than other fields in part due less research funding but mainly due to the complexity of the brain. Care for mental health and eating disorders would be better with more funding but it wouldn’t cure everyone (I work in the clinical and research field)