Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we need to change how we treat Anorexia

88 replies

S3aH0use7337 · 25/02/2024 19:43

My dd has suffered from this disease since lockdown. It has had a catastrophic impact on her life. Part of the reason she has been ill for so long is that the traditional way of treatment relies on family therapy. My dd has autism and this style of approach with parents being in control just didn’t work for her and often doesn’t with autism. Research shows autism and Anorexia can often be linked. My DD’s Anorexia wasn’t picked apart and she wasn’t given any coping strategies that suited her or proper specialist support just FBT. CAMHS pulled back from FBT when it clearly wasn’t going to work but didn’t have any ideas of what else to do and just tried to make her focus on other things with the idea that real would make her suddenly decide to get well.🤔 No tools were given to do that .The anorexia got more and more imbedded . Because FBT is the default treatment they were too scared to take the bull by the horns and try anything else. Because beds in units were in very short supply she just ping ponged in and out of paed wards without specialist care and the disease was left to get more in control of her life. I saw so many other young people in the same situation with trauma and ptsd becoming common.

Under adult services she has tried a different style of treatment with some success. It’s hard though because she has been ill for so long. I don’t understand why it isn’t tried earlier under CAMHS.

In addition to this is the issue re how adult sufferers are accessing care. It’s shocking but the iller you get the less help you seem to get with some areas now discussing palliative care instead.I have added a link which explains the truly shocking state of play at the moment.

So AIBU in thinking the whole area needs a massive rethink starting with a look at the FBT or nothing approach for young children, links to autism and the shocking struggle to access treatment as adults?https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2024/feb/25/illness-worsens-scandal-eating-disorder-treatment-england

Your illness worsens – so care is cut off. This is the scandal playing out in eating disorder treatment | John Harris

Patients I’ve spoken to in the east of England were desperate for help, with dangerously low BMIs. On what possible grounds were they discharged?, asks Guardian columnist John Harris

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2024/feb/25/illness-worsens-scandal-eating-disorder-treatment-england

OP posts:
WaitingForMojo · 26/02/2024 09:05

S3aH0use7337 · 26/02/2024 06:43

I also think just leaving adult sufferers to die with nothing because they are difficult to treat is not ok either. It’s barbaric and wrong particularly if part of the reason they’re so ill is crap or next to no treatment when younger.

Absolutely this.

ALL the evidence is for early intervention, yet services allow ED’s to go untreated for years.

WaitingForMojo · 26/02/2024 09:04

‘Just food’ is certainly not enough. Weight restoration and establishing regular eating should be a first phase of treatment. Without it, therapy won’t be effective. Unfortunately, under resourcing and poor understanding means that weight restoration is seen as a fix, and so people relapse, cycle through other ED’s, etc. ED’s are dangerous at any weight. We also risk leaving people having gained weight but without alternative coping mechanisms to deal with that. ED treatment is woefully inadequate.

WaitingForMojo · 26/02/2024 08:58

S3aH0use7337 · 26/02/2024 06:20

I totally disagree. My DD’s Anorexia was caused by undiagnosed ASC and ADHD , very low self esteem and poor coping skills. Without her self esteem improving, work on coping strategies alongside therapy to unpick her Ed she did not make progress and was continuously locked into hospital admissions. She was weight restored several times often to very good weights above her original size.

FBT does not work for many children. There is so little research on it and it does not have a 100% success rate. There is no research or work being done on anything else. Some families are barely doing it. I strongly suspect many doing it get well in spite of it and just go to FBT sessions because they have to and are given nothing else. We gave it 3 years. It did NOT work. Under adult services we see others who have transferred because it didn’t work. I see those parents online too.

I don’t have an issue with FBT being tried first but after a year of it not working and psychs saying patients need more control something else needs to be tried. Keeping patients locked in to an endless cycle of unsuccessful FBT or nothing is hugely damaging and allows anorexia to get entrenched. That is not ok.

I completely agree.

S3aH0use7337 · 26/02/2024 08:47

I have often wondered that too.

OP posts:
Girliefriendlikespuppies · 26/02/2024 08:46

S3aH0use7337 · 26/02/2024 06:43

I also think just leaving adult sufferers to die with nothing because they are difficult to treat is not ok either. It’s barbaric and wrong particularly if part of the reason they’re so ill is crap or next to no treatment when younger.

I completely agree with you there.

EDs have the highest mortality rate of any mental illness and a similar mortality rate to leukaemia. I also wonder if this was illness that affected more boys/men than girls/women if there would be more research and funding.

S3aH0use7337 · 26/02/2024 08:32

Exactly you wouldn’t give a child chemo over and again if it didn’t work, for years.The lack of attempts to look at and try other options is really poor and not helping those who end up in adult services as it puts more pressure on the limited resources there. I don’t get why my daughter couldn’t have had a child version of what she is having now after 1 year of failed FBT or even after the second or third year!

OP posts:
Slowlyimproving · 26/02/2024 08:25

So I'm also not convinced just food is enough. DD had an ED with purging for 2 years. Her weight was fine. FBT as in just being told 3 meals and 3 snacks, nothing else.didn't work.
She then started loosing weight and developed "typical" anorexia. With CBT-E, which she started at her lowest weight, she is slowly improving.

I agree options should be available. If one cancer treatment doesn't work, you try something else.

Punxsutawney · 26/02/2024 07:10

I'm autistic and currently in an inpatient ED unit. I've been here 15 weeks, with some time to go yet.

I'm 48, definitely not a teenager or young woman, so FBT would not be used. But my community care before admission was beyond awful. They threatened to discharge me after just 3 sessions of CBT-E because my ASD meant I was struggling with it. And after that, the care just got worse. They refused to make any reasonable adjustments at all.
Before I was admitted they hadn't seen me for 4 weeks and told me over the phone that they didn't consider me to be at risk (my BMI was in the 14's). The inpatient team disagreed and said I was at risk of re-feeding syndrome and definitely needed a bed.
I'm lucky that I have a great GP who recognised how unwell I was and advocated for me, but also understood autism.
My time with the community team was incredibly distressing and definitely made me deteriorate. I told my GP I felt I was being left to die.
This admission is one of the hardest things I've ever done, but I'm thankful to the team here, as I was becoming very unwell, with absolutely no help from my community team.

S3aH0use7337 · 26/02/2024 06:46

BirdsRoundandRound · 26/02/2024 06:43

@S3aH0use7337 just wanted to say, my daughter (15) is currently under Maudsley and we have been doing FBT for 18 months, with some success but stuck.

She will shortly be starting RO-DBT which sounds a little like MANTRA so perhaps is an alternative for under 18?

I'm not sure how widely this is available across the UK though

That sounds encouraging. Maybe things are slowly changing.🙏 The other issue re acute adult sufferers just being given palliative care is shocking. It can happen to anyone and sufferers want to get well.

OP posts:
S3aH0use7337 · 26/02/2024 06:43

I also think just leaving adult sufferers to die with nothing because they are difficult to treat is not ok either. It’s barbaric and wrong particularly if part of the reason they’re so ill is crap or next to no treatment when younger.

OP posts:
BirdsRoundandRound · 26/02/2024 06:43

@S3aH0use7337 just wanted to say, my daughter (15) is currently under Maudsley and we have been doing FBT for 18 months, with some success but stuck.

She will shortly be starting RO-DBT which sounds a little like MANTRA so perhaps is an alternative for under 18?

I'm not sure how widely this is available across the UK though

honestguvnor · 26/02/2024 06:35

I have asd and had an eating disorder from a young age (only mildly affects me now)

I am from a very disfunctional family so family therapy would have been horrific for me.

I thankfully improved as I got older and learnt more about what being healthy means.

I can see how other focuses could help if it was quite mild/early stages .

A woman I know who's anorexic and has asd whomanages through having a set food routine. She eats the same foods everyday at set times and never deviates. She can't prepare her own meals either. I wouldn't describe her as cured but she eats enough to maintain a healthy weight.

BeethovenNinth · 26/02/2024 06:33

FBT worked for us first time and not in relapse. FBT is exhausting

the autism/anorexia link may or may not be the case - but what does it matter if there is no help for either?

In desperation, after being sent home from A and E, we did ketogenic. I had read some interesting studies about keto and brain health; in bipolar and also anorexia. DD was willing as it meant she could control and still maintain weight

blow me, it worked. She is doing ok now. If she feels like relapsing, she has a few days keto.

i told CAHMS how we stopped the relapse and to look into it as there are some studies about it but they just looked bemused.

S3aH0use7337 · 26/02/2024 06:27

overdogged · 25/02/2024 22:48

@Girliefriendlikespuppies I totally agree with you - anorexia is a biological brain disease caused by weight loss in genetically vulnerable individuals. I had it myself at age 13, now fully recovered; my daughter was 12 times more likely to suffer also. Which she did, very badly, for 7 years and is just coming out the other side.

Food and weight restoration is the only cure. It's not caused by a wish for control or trauma, it's a brain disease as much as Alzheimer's caused by the effect of starvation on the brain. Family based therapy was useless for us - my daughter is also autistic. Only food and weight restoration helped.

CAMHS set their weight restoration goals far too low, causing the illness to go on longer in my opinion.

If you’ve met one person with autism you’ve met one. Food restoration absolutely does not help my daughter. She has been weight restored and then some countless times. The bar was not set too low, far from it. We have been told by psychs that she needs to be in control and driving things to recover,numbers are huge for her. She has made far more progress in control and driving things with a proper treatment program and therapy that is not FBT driven.

One size does not fit all and this needs to be recognised far earlier. If it was adult services wouldn’t be under so much pressure.

OP posts:
S3aH0use7337 · 26/02/2024 06:20

Girliefriendlikespuppies · 25/02/2024 22:36

This is correct.

Anorexia is a biological illness, it is triggered in people genetically predisposed to it by weight loss.

My dd also started restricting food during lockdown and had full blown anorexia within a few months. I also suspect she is autistic.

I would say FBT saved her life, it is brutal and we went through hell but once it was established it meant her weight slowly increased and all of the anorexic cognitions slowly disappeared.

She's never engaged with therapy so food has been her only medicine.

I strongly dispute there has to be a reason or trauma for someone to develop anorexia, all it takes is genetics and weight loss - that is it.

It is a horrific illness and I agree more funding and research are needed but I don't agree that FBT doesn't work. It's the only evidence based treatment and it does work for many children.

I totally disagree. My DD’s Anorexia was caused by undiagnosed ASC and ADHD , very low self esteem and poor coping skills. Without her self esteem improving, work on coping strategies alongside therapy to unpick her Ed she did not make progress and was continuously locked into hospital admissions. She was weight restored several times often to very good weights above her original size.

FBT does not work for many children. There is so little research on it and it does not have a 100% success rate. There is no research or work being done on anything else. Some families are barely doing it. I strongly suspect many doing it get well in spite of it and just go to FBT sessions because they have to and are given nothing else. We gave it 3 years. It did NOT work. Under adult services we see others who have transferred because it didn’t work. I see those parents online too.

I don’t have an issue with FBT being tried first but after a year of it not working and psychs saying patients need more control something else needs to be tried. Keeping patients locked in to an endless cycle of unsuccessful FBT or nothing is hugely damaging and allows anorexia to get entrenched. That is not ok.

OP posts:
WaitingForMojo · 25/02/2024 23:15

It absolutely is the only treatment with a decent evidence base. However, it’s often done badly and as an excuse to parent blame and give parents the entire responsibility without adequate support. That really does impact relationships and cause more problems.

WaitingForMojo · 25/02/2024 23:13

A FBT approach is working here for our anorexic, likely autistic, dd. So far, anyway. I do agree that the approach should be tailored to the individual. Our experience is that it’s very hard to access ANY treatment whatsoever, let alone a choice of treatment approaches.

I’m also recovered from anorexia, and also autistic. For me, addressing the food was important and looking for a root cause unhelpful. I agree that it is a brain disease. I don’t feel that weight restoration is the only answer, people often develop other ED’s, cycle between them, etc, even at normal weights. But a regular eating pattern and sufficient calories is essential.

overdogged · 25/02/2024 22:48

@Girliefriendlikespuppies I totally agree with you - anorexia is a biological brain disease caused by weight loss in genetically vulnerable individuals. I had it myself at age 13, now fully recovered; my daughter was 12 times more likely to suffer also. Which she did, very badly, for 7 years and is just coming out the other side.

Food and weight restoration is the only cure. It's not caused by a wish for control or trauma, it's a brain disease as much as Alzheimer's caused by the effect of starvation on the brain. Family based therapy was useless for us - my daughter is also autistic. Only food and weight restoration helped.

CAMHS set their weight restoration goals far too low, causing the illness to go on longer in my opinion.

Girliefriendlikespuppies · 25/02/2024 22:36

PostItInABook · 25/02/2024 20:28

The main problem is professionals and parents setting target weights far too low, especially for pre teens / teens. It is a fundamentally biological illness. The medicine to treat it is food / calories and weight gain. No amount of therapy will help when the brain is too starved. The psychological symptoms are because the brain is starved. Those symptoms will not go away until adequate nourishment is achieved. If target weights are too low this doesn’t happen and the sufferer becomes a chronic case. Therapy/psychological intervention is for when adequate nutrition and weight gain is enough to show an improvement in symptoms. Then therapy to develop coping strategies to prevent relapse.

FBT is really, really hard on everyone, but the point of it is to get the medicine (I.e. food) in to achieve the necessary weight gain to a proper level before other treatments can be successful.

This is correct.

Anorexia is a biological illness, it is triggered in people genetically predisposed to it by weight loss.

My dd also started restricting food during lockdown and had full blown anorexia within a few months. I also suspect she is autistic.

I would say FBT saved her life, it is brutal and we went through hell but once it was established it meant her weight slowly increased and all of the anorexic cognitions slowly disappeared.

She's never engaged with therapy so food has been her only medicine.

I strongly dispute there has to be a reason or trauma for someone to develop anorexia, all it takes is genetics and weight loss - that is it.

It is a horrific illness and I agree more funding and research are needed but I don't agree that FBT doesn't work. It's the only evidence based treatment and it does work for many children.

tryingtobenormalish · 25/02/2024 22:18

SM plays a big part .

CherryBerry99 · 25/02/2024 22:11

I have anorexia and am currently under an adult eating disorder client with the NHS. In my experience they don't really seem to have a clue. They almost ignore all emotional issues and focus solely on weight and food. I know that medical status obviously plays a key role but it needs to be considered in tandem with emotional state.
My therapy has been so disjointed, I've been under my clinic for over a year and I still haven't been given the therapeutic modality that I was told I would be and when I ask questions I'm given no straight answers.
I feel as though I'm being given no support to increase my intake and simply get questioned on why I'm not following my meal plan. If I was able to follow a healthy meal plan I wouldn't need to be under the team in the first place!
I'm actually trying to consider a way to pay for private ED treatment as I feel that the standard 'treatment' is very rigid and not tailored enough to individual patients.
It's a difficult one and I'm honestly not sure I see full recovery in my future.
I truly hope your daughter gets the help she needs, you sound committed to getting the best for her and that will go a long way towards helping her attain recovery.

JaneSeymourTheOnlyOneHeTrulyLoved · 25/02/2024 22:01

@takemeawayagain You’re so right. I was told that if my child didn’t want to be forcefully tube fed and they didn’t think it was in her best interests to continue, they would discharge her home to die.
As if she’s choosing not to want it. She’s 15, I honestly despair sometimes.

S3aH0use7337 · 25/02/2024 21:58

takemeawayagain · 25/02/2024 21:52

This research article is quite interesting, it suggests that none of the treatments currently available to adults have brilliant success rates and no one knows which might work better for any individual - but shared decision making with patients so they maybe more motivated might improve outcomes.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7575018/

Now to me this sort of thing just seems incredibly obvious, there are 3 ways of dealing with anorexia as an adult and patients get to chose the one they think will work best for them. Why on earth wouldn't you give people the options?

I also think it's shocking that FBT is the only option for children and can't tell why this is the case . Ok so even in autistic patients it might currently have the best outcomes:
https://attwoodandgarnettevents.com/treatment-and-support-for-autistic-adolescents-with-anorexia-nervosa/
But if it's not working then there needs to be other things to try surely? It might be the most successful thing, but that doesn't mean it's going to work for everyone. So what do you try next? Why are there three options for adults and only one for children? The A in MANTRA stands for adults - but why isn't there an equivalent for children?

The withdrawing of care when they decide you're not helping yourself enough is just completely shocking:
Dr Daiva Barzdaitiene, who achieved brief notoriety when she wrote a starkly worded article in the newsletter of the Royal College of Psychiatrists, published in 2022. When it came to what she called “severe and complex eating disorders”, she warned against “harmful compassion” – and, as she saw it, the fact that “countless attempts to treat people who do not want to change take away resources from the people who have recently developed an eating disorder and could be helped”.
Suggesting people don't 'want' to change like it's a choice they're freely making. But really it sounds to me like it comes down to money, which is probably at the heart of all the issues. It's far cheaper to blame people for not being fixed and discharge them for not trying enough then it is to keep trying to help them. It really is shocking.

I know I don’t get why there is no MANTRA equivalent for children . Iv my dd had switched to MANTRA a year after FBT not working I am convinced the outcome would have been better. Instead they withdrew FBT and left her with nothing meanwhile she pingponged in and out of paeds( along with others like her). It’s ludicrous.

OP posts:
S3aH0use7337 · 25/02/2024 21:54

Softleftpowerstance · 25/02/2024 21:50

I’ve never heard of FBT. I had anorexia as a teen in the 90s when awareness and treatment was even worse than it is now. But reading about FBT now has made my blood run cold. I cannot begin to describe how detrimental it would have been in my family. If this really is the go to dogma then I find that terrifying.

Yes it’s interesting I had Anorexia in the 80s and got better much quicker than my daughter who had FBT the last few years. I would have completely freaked out if I’d had to do FBT and I know there is no way my dad would have coped with it anyway.

OP posts:
takemeawayagain · 25/02/2024 21:52

This research article is quite interesting, it suggests that none of the treatments currently available to adults have brilliant success rates and no one knows which might work better for any individual - but shared decision making with patients so they maybe more motivated might improve outcomes.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7575018/

Now to me this sort of thing just seems incredibly obvious, there are 3 ways of dealing with anorexia as an adult and patients get to chose the one they think will work best for them. Why on earth wouldn't you give people the options?

I also think it's shocking that FBT is the only option for children and can't tell why this is the case . Ok so even in autistic patients it might currently have the best outcomes:
https://attwoodandgarnettevents.com/treatment-and-support-for-autistic-adolescents-with-anorexia-nervosa/
But if it's not working then there needs to be other things to try surely? It might be the most successful thing, but that doesn't mean it's going to work for everyone. So what do you try next? Why are there three options for adults and only one for children? The A in MANTRA stands for adults - but why isn't there an equivalent for children?

The withdrawing of care when they decide you're not helping yourself enough is just completely shocking:
Dr Daiva Barzdaitiene, who achieved brief notoriety when she wrote a starkly worded article in the newsletter of the Royal College of Psychiatrists, published in 2022. When it came to what she called “severe and complex eating disorders”, she warned against “harmful compassion” – and, as she saw it, the fact that “countless attempts to treat people who do not want to change take away resources from the people who have recently developed an eating disorder and could be helped”.
Suggesting people don't 'want' to change like it's a choice they're freely making. But really it sounds to me like it comes down to money, which is probably at the heart of all the issues. It's far cheaper to blame people for not being fixed and discharge them for not trying enough then it is to keep trying to help them. It really is shocking.