Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we need to change how we treat Anorexia

88 replies

S3aH0use7337 · 25/02/2024 19:43

My dd has suffered from this disease since lockdown. It has had a catastrophic impact on her life. Part of the reason she has been ill for so long is that the traditional way of treatment relies on family therapy. My dd has autism and this style of approach with parents being in control just didn’t work for her and often doesn’t with autism. Research shows autism and Anorexia can often be linked. My DD’s Anorexia wasn’t picked apart and she wasn’t given any coping strategies that suited her or proper specialist support just FBT. CAMHS pulled back from FBT when it clearly wasn’t going to work but didn’t have any ideas of what else to do and just tried to make her focus on other things with the idea that real would make her suddenly decide to get well.🤔 No tools were given to do that .The anorexia got more and more imbedded . Because FBT is the default treatment they were too scared to take the bull by the horns and try anything else. Because beds in units were in very short supply she just ping ponged in and out of paed wards without specialist care and the disease was left to get more in control of her life. I saw so many other young people in the same situation with trauma and ptsd becoming common.

Under adult services she has tried a different style of treatment with some success. It’s hard though because she has been ill for so long. I don’t understand why it isn’t tried earlier under CAMHS.

In addition to this is the issue re how adult sufferers are accessing care. It’s shocking but the iller you get the less help you seem to get with some areas now discussing palliative care instead.I have added a link which explains the truly shocking state of play at the moment.

So AIBU in thinking the whole area needs a massive rethink starting with a look at the FBT or nothing approach for young children, links to autism and the shocking struggle to access treatment as adults?https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2024/feb/25/illness-worsens-scandal-eating-disorder-treatment-england

Your illness worsens – so care is cut off. This is the scandal playing out in eating disorder treatment | John Harris

Patients I’ve spoken to in the east of England were desperate for help, with dangerously low BMIs. On what possible grounds were they discharged?, asks Guardian columnist John Harris

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2024/feb/25/illness-worsens-scandal-eating-disorder-treatment-england

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
S3aH0use7337 · 07/03/2024 08:40

WickerShit · 07/03/2024 08:07

I can't write anything detailed right now but I just wanted to say thank you to all who have posted about FBT not working for them. It didn't work for us. I think my whole family has PTSD from the experience. I have avoided all support networks etc as I was ashamed that as the parent/controller I had failed. I have also avoided reading all ED threads for the same reason.

This morning I have an appointment for me to talk to someone at 9.30 and as a result if reading this thread this morning I now feel optimistic that I can actually talk without being overwhelmed with shame and guilt and maybe even get some information about alternative treatments to try. Even if I have to pay I really don't care about the money.

Thank you all.

Thank you so much for posting. I just wanted to say well done you for sorting out support for yourself.I have been having support for me and it is an absolute godsend. I know the trauma and damage FBT caused us as a family. My dd has only just been articulating it. It damaged my self esteem, our marriage and my relationship with my daughter. I’m only just beginning to get my self esteem back and the relationship my dd and I always should have had. I don’t blame the therapist as the treatment was foisted on her too with no other option.it was a massive waste of money that let Anorexia get more entrenched and has ended up costing the NHS so much more. Just forcing this and offering no other structured treatment when it clearly isn’t working (for years)is madness.

OP posts:
Latenightanxiety · 07/03/2024 08:12

I saw a friends daughter suffer with it. Care was shocking. She ended up in a special home in the end after living with it for years and it getting worse.

WickerShit · 07/03/2024 08:07

I can't write anything detailed right now but I just wanted to say thank you to all who have posted about FBT not working for them. It didn't work for us. I think my whole family has PTSD from the experience. I have avoided all support networks etc as I was ashamed that as the parent/controller I had failed. I have also avoided reading all ED threads for the same reason.

This morning I have an appointment for me to talk to someone at 9.30 and as a result if reading this thread this morning I now feel optimistic that I can actually talk without being overwhelmed with shame and guilt and maybe even get some information about alternative treatments to try. Even if I have to pay I really don't care about the money.

Thank you all.

Punxsutawney · 07/03/2024 07:58

Inpatient ED treatment is hard, really hard. I've been in a unit for four months now and I'm in my late forties. A lot here feels very humiliating, you lose control of so much. But I have no doubts it has saved my life.

BobbyBiscuits · 07/03/2024 07:44

As an adult, I was (officially) diagnosed with anorexia a couple of days after a severe accident, where I broke my hip and shoulder. I was off my head on morphine and could barely understand what the psych doctors were saying to me. I almost felt like they were pressuring me into 'confessing'. The consultant from the ED clinic came along and started trying to blame all my issues on my Mum. Who's an absolute saint and has never done anything wrong.

I was watched 24 hours a day for 5 weeks and had to eat around 4000 calories a day. They said if I was in the unit I would not be allowed to walk, and would have to be moved in a wheelchair. This was while I was recovering from hip surgery so needed to move. It was all very distressing and I ended up sectioned. I felt like I was being treated like a child, not a 40- something woman.

It scared the crap out of me though. I'm too scared to go back to the outpatients ED unit in case they try and make me put on more weight or section me again. Luckily I have kept the weight on since that hospital admission but I totally lost faith in the treatment as it seemed to be just force feeding people.

Shouldbedoing · 07/03/2024 07:32

www.facebook.com/ARFIDAwarenessUK

Shouldbedoing · 07/03/2024 07:28

@S3aH0use7337 Have you ever looked into ARFID. Can be mistaken for Anorexia, and is definitely an eating disorder associated with Autism. Kids can slip from ARFID into AN as well.
Sorry I had no time to read the thread beyond 25/2 if I'm repeating advice.

JaneSeymourTheOnlyOneHeTrulyLoved · 07/03/2024 07:20

@kittensinthekitchen I’m in tears reading your post as it’s so similar tommy DD and what we’ve been through and still going through.

If you ever want to PM me please do as no one who hasn’t been through this understands and I feel work is getting fed up with me and my outrageous request for (unpaid) time off to visit my daughter in hospital more than once a working week. I’m so exhausted by it all.

S3aH0use7337 · 29/02/2024 10:33

ChaosAndCrumbs · 29/02/2024 09:28

My anorexia wasn’t fully successfully treated throughout my teens (started age 11) and the only thing that helped at all was a lovely counsellor who I saw originally through a charity and then privately.

As an adult I needed and wanted psychodynamic therapy, but couldn’t access it. I was dying and at the point of considering a feeding tube. There was one therapist for the area and the other therapists worked under him. He glanced at my file and said no - never met me, even though I said I was very willing.

I ended up doing my own therapy on myself - using psychodynamic techniques and basic ways to work out trauma - which worked. I’m still a bit weird with eating but I’m healthy and happy. However, I will always be disgusted that they could turn me down and I had to do it alone. (My actual psychiatrist who knew me believed it was the right therapy and thought I was a perfect candidate for it, so this refusal was on the word of one man.) The message I got from that really, was I wasn’t worth helping. Luckily, now I’ve reframed that to see it was him and not me in the wrong.

I agree FBT is not always helpful. I’m also ND and it was missed all the way through until adulthood. FBT for teenagers is set-up to be tricky really, as they are at a point where they’re seeking independence and need to be able to learn about themselves to get to the root cause.

Edited to add: To all lovely mums with dc with anorexia, don’t give up hope. I was one of those who people thought would never recover and it was deeply entrenched, but in the end I did find what worked for me and have two beautiful healthy children and a stable, happy life. Hoping all of your DC manage to find what works for them, even if that is not FBT.

Edited

Thankyou Chaos.❤️

OP posts:
ItsallIeverwanted · 29/02/2024 10:30

@ChaosAndCrumbs thank you for your lovely message, it's great to hear from those down the line and know it is possible to recover. I feel it is for my dd, but we are going a longer different route perhaps! Thanks again.

ChaosAndCrumbs · 29/02/2024 09:28

My anorexia wasn’t fully successfully treated throughout my teens (started age 11) and the only thing that helped at all was a lovely counsellor who I saw originally through a charity and then privately.

As an adult I needed and wanted psychodynamic therapy, but couldn’t access it. I was dying and at the point of considering a feeding tube. There was one therapist for the area and the other therapists worked under him. He glanced at my file and said no - never met me, even though I said I was very willing.

I ended up doing my own therapy on myself - using psychodynamic techniques and basic ways to work out trauma - which worked. I’m still a bit weird with eating but I’m healthy and happy. However, I will always be disgusted that they could turn me down and I had to do it alone. (My actual psychiatrist who knew me believed it was the right therapy and thought I was a perfect candidate for it, so this refusal was on the word of one man.) The message I got from that really, was I wasn’t worth helping. Luckily, now I’ve reframed that to see it was him and not me in the wrong.

I agree FBT is not always helpful. I’m also ND and it was missed all the way through until adulthood. FBT for teenagers is set-up to be tricky really, as they are at a point where they’re seeking independence and need to be able to learn about themselves to get to the root cause.

Edited to add: To all lovely mums with dc with anorexia, don’t give up hope. I was one of those who people thought would never recover and it was deeply entrenched, but in the end I did find what worked for me and have two beautiful healthy children and a stable, happy life. Hoping all of your DC manage to find what works for them, even if that is not FBT.

Sandwiched2022 · 29/02/2024 09:02

boredybored · 26/02/2024 09:10

I haven't read your post but child eating services ( when I eventually got an appointment) told us to sit down and make her eat 3 meals and snacks and gave us a food list .
It had meat and yogurt in it and she eats neither and also Einstein don't you think we have tried all that .

Honestly I was shocked , literally is that all you have .

I waited so long and hung on to hope that she would get help and that was it !!!🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️

Dd also has high functioning ASD and this wasn't even mentioned or considered .

I feel the nhs just look at things so separately and never have a holistic approach to helping mental health issues .

It's useless .

We had exactly the same with CAMHS to begin with. My DD also doesn’t eat Yoghurts, custards, rice puddings and is pescatarian (commenced a few years before ED although we do now wonder if it’s all linked). It didn’t work and we had no support or empathy or even FB treatment for some time. DD now inpatient in ED unit and we are still trying to get to bottom of what therapy if any she is actually receiving now - she needs help with anxieties, homesickness as well as the ED. I don’t think you can just weight restore especially when she is still refusing to eat all meals. We are researching what else we might be able to do ourselves with her on visits. It’s all so heartbreaking.

Mstxxx · 26/02/2024 13:13

I agree, I just don't know what... I think anorexia can stem from so many different sources/issues that a one size fits all approach just doesn't work, but I don't know what/how would work across so many different issues.

A bit of an odd/perhaps controversial one - I've had anorexia since I was 18. It started unintentionally with me losing weight because I had a horrific job which meant all I did was work and sleep. I started noticing I looked 'better' and other people would comment on my weight loss which fed my need for attention that I didn't realise I had at the time. People then started commenting on how skinny I was (not in a good way) but that just fed the attention I wanted. Then I felt like I had a 'skinny' image to maintain. Despite only eating one low calorie meal per day and a lot of days basically nothing and being underweight and having no period, I never got admitted or taken seriously by health professionals. Anyway, in the end I guess by not getting taken seriously by health professionals or anyone, one day I thought 'no one actually cares'. And if no one actually cares, why do I deprive myself of nice food etc. Weirdly the lack of attention and realising no matter what I did I wasn't getting it, seemed to partially resolve the issue. That being said, I am a control freak so I am still a bit underweight but I don't deprive myself of food or hyperfocus on my weight. The control aspect definitely won't go away without some form of help - the attention side did though by people not feeding into it. I have also heard the term 'tactical ignoring' by a family member who is in the NHS so I wonder if that's a lesser known technique they use but don't publicise...

S3aH0use7337 · 26/02/2024 12:32

KidsDr · 26/02/2024 10:41

I have spent a lot of time working on children's wards and it feels like there is an epidemic of anorexia amongst teenage girls (very often comorbid with usually undiagnosed / late diagnosed ASD).

The care is rubbish (not because people don't care). Paediatric staff working on a general paediatric ward have minimal training in mental health, we're supposed to be there to support acute physical health and that's what we're trained to do, what we have the resources to do. But these girls are essentially getting dumped with us "to keep them safe" because the services that should exist to specifically treat/manage anorexia/ED don't exist or are stripped back to bare bones. They get so bad they become seriously medically unwell and end up in hospital. So we can put in an NG, monitor electrolytes, enforce bedrest etc. But are we helping these girls to recover from anorexia? I actually think the ward environment traumatises/institutionalises them and possibly makes them worse, especially when we have several admitted at once as anorexia is socially contagious.

General paediatric wards should be at most providing a few days of urgent physical recovery, closely supervised by a specialist eating disorder service until they patient can be transferred into a specialist inpatient unit (or better yet, receive intense support at home). Instead, they wait weeks or even months effectively as prisoners in a totally unsuitable paediatric ward, with minimal input from overstretched specialist liaison services and whilst we don't allow them to lose weight I believe they often become more psychologically embedded in their anorexia in that time.

We see every patient on a ward round every day but there is literally nothing to say to the parents of an anorexic interminably waiting for an inpatient bed. It's just inadequate.

Adding to this depressing picture is the awareness that they may then just be abandoned to die as adults. The outlook for some of these (usually highly intelligent, promising) girls is so bleak it's absolutely tragic and a scandal. There are paediatric nurses leaving the profession because they cannot cope with the moral injury this situation (and more broadly the situation with adolescent mental healthcare) is causing.

I don't know what to say OP only that it's not in your head. Honestly if my daughter showed signs of anorexia I would be considering remortgaging the house to pay for aggressive early intervention from a private provider (do they even exist?). Obviously I'm a bit biased only going to see the worst / most failed, and I think possibly some get good early intervention supported by their GP, but it's a postcode lottery. I don't know what to suggest, there is absolutely no parity of physical and mental health. The situation with anorexics is like trying to treat diabetics with no insulin.

Edited

This. 💯 I gave up counting my DD’s long admissions on paeds after the 20th time. What exactly are you supposed to do in FBT for kids like this after each admission? The cost to the NHS is huge. Every meal and snack(6 in total) needs a member of staff for support for a fairly long time. They also have to do round the clock physical observations and ensure they’re not exercising in toilets . They then need several members of staff and security for an NG feed if the whole lot of unappetising large portions of hospital food isn’t consumed in it’s entirety. It’s traumatic, they try and bolt and it’s poor nursing staff left to manage this with sometimes several vulnerable teenagers on an admission at once whilst they’re supposed to be treating very sick babies and children.

Why are CAMHS not allowed to try other methods of treatment for young people going through this on a loop? Would it not make more economic sense to research other methods? The trauma of going through the above over and again unsupported by proper therapy has a massive long term economic impact to the NHS. It’s so utterly barbaric and outdated particularly when you consider that so many of these young girls have autism, can’t help being difficult to treat and the treatment methods are hugely traumatic for them as autistic young people.

OP posts:
ItsallIeverwanted · 26/02/2024 12:20

I should just say (in case that all seems too negative) we have had good support from adult services, regular health checks (between once a month and a few times a week if anything goes wrong) as well as therapy/psychiatric support, so if you have a younger child, in our area at least, they are working on the transition from child to adult services and they have been pretty good. My dd is stable and able to participate in college and for the most part, we have a handle on the thing, even if she is not fully recovered.

Comtesse · 26/02/2024 12:06

My family has no experience of anorexia but my chest hurts from just reading this thread. Flowers to you all - seems perverse that adults have treatment options that younger patients don’t (but I have zero expertise).

ItsallIeverwanted · 26/02/2024 11:58

@BeethovenNinth thanks for posting that, it's very interesting and I can see how (for some, not my vegetarian daughter, that has been going on since she was about 8) it could work. I also agree that eating lots of healthy fats, increasing protein etc is effective, that's been good for us (so easy to end up eating carby stuff if people are threatened by 'tasty' food).

I think the point is that there is not excellent evidence in any part of AN or ED treatment, FBT was trialled with intensive support and in a particular way and I am not convinced this then translates to lots of other situations, as I say, as a lone parent, being the 'baddie' and wresting control of the kitchen back off a 15 year old was nigh on impossible, not least because as the sole income provider, I had to work and look after my other child; it also created a very negative dynamic which again isn't helpful when you don't have another parent or therapist or someone the teen can turn to. In the face of everyone being 'against her', she proceeded to more extreme behaviours which have ultimately proved harder to shift and no amount of feeding changes (as they are just undone days later).

More research on all the different approaches- FBT, keto, exercise/positive body based approaches, intensive inpatient treatments, would really help- what we have is a lot of unsupported parents with a book telling them to do FBT stuff (or printed sheets in our case) and not much else when that fails. We are building from the ground up and it is HARD but in our case there are a lot of other MH issues anyway, and I understand the ED to be a form of self-harm amongst other types of self-harm/trauma.

KidsDr · 26/02/2024 10:41

I have spent a lot of time working on children's wards and it feels like there is an epidemic of anorexia amongst teenage girls (very often comorbid with usually undiagnosed / late diagnosed ASD).

The care is rubbish (not because people don't care). Paediatric staff working on a general paediatric ward have minimal training in mental health, we're supposed to be there to support acute physical health and that's what we're trained to do, what we have the resources to do. But these girls are essentially getting dumped with us "to keep them safe" because the services that should exist to specifically treat/manage anorexia/ED don't exist or are stripped back to bare bones. They get so bad they become seriously medically unwell and end up in hospital. So we can put in an NG, monitor electrolytes, enforce bedrest etc. But are we helping these girls to recover from anorexia? I actually think the ward environment traumatises/institutionalises them and possibly makes them worse, especially when we have several admitted at once as anorexia is socially contagious.

General paediatric wards should be at most providing a few days of urgent physical recovery, closely supervised by a specialist eating disorder service until they patient can be transferred into a specialist inpatient unit (or better yet, receive intense support at home). Instead, they wait weeks or even months effectively as prisoners in a totally unsuitable paediatric ward, with minimal input from overstretched specialist liaison services and whilst we don't allow them to lose weight I believe they often become more psychologically embedded in their anorexia in that time.

We see every patient on a ward round every day but there is literally nothing to say to the parents of an anorexic interminably waiting for an inpatient bed. It's just inadequate.

Adding to this depressing picture is the awareness that they may then just be abandoned to die as adults. The outlook for some of these (usually highly intelligent, promising) girls is so bleak it's absolutely tragic and a scandal. There are paediatric nurses leaving the profession because they cannot cope with the moral injury this situation (and more broadly the situation with adolescent mental healthcare) is causing.

I don't know what to say OP only that it's not in your head. Honestly if my daughter showed signs of anorexia I would be considering remortgaging the house to pay for aggressive early intervention from a private provider (do they even exist?). Obviously I'm a bit biased only going to see the worst / most failed, and I think possibly some get good early intervention supported by their GP, but it's a postcode lottery. I don't know what to suggest, there is absolutely no parity of physical and mental health. The situation with anorexics is like trying to treat diabetics with no insulin.

DonnaGiovanna · 26/02/2024 10:20

I've only read the OP so apologies if I'm repeating any points already made, but thank you for bringing this up.

I've had the bad luck to have 2 dc go through this - one was neurotypical, FBT worked for her and within 2 years she was well and healthy again and I have confidence this will remain the case (it was strongly linked to lockdown and some friendship situations at the time).

Her sister is autistic and falls prey to anorexia at times when she is feeling particularly vulnerable. Both times in childhood YPEDS cleared up the behaviours but did nothing to look at the triggers. Only now, as an adult, has adult ED services made some inroads into this and I feel somewhat hopeful that she has some better tools and strategies to cope with the feelings that overwhelm her into starving herself. But why has she had to wait until adulthood for this? And yes, FBT was torture for everyone concerned.

ItsallIeverwanted · 26/02/2024 10:10

My dd also developed purging behaviours as a response to trying to circumvent FBT. She would stay up all night when I fell asleep and do it then, so even supervision in the day wouldn't help. She still has these, to a lesser extent, but the development of a new strand of ED came out of the problems with FBT and trying to control her eating, she wrestled back control by herself and now as an adult in adult services, this is not possible to contain in the same way. There's almost no help for bulimia and other eating disorders which don't respond to FBT and don't even make sense within it (you can't weight restore if the person doesn't keep the food down, even if you control the food environment and feed them).

That said, I feel we are making progress as she herself sees the damage (to skin, to potassium levels, to her heart, to her energy) that this behaviour is having, and has modified it a lot, so change is possible. We have a very supportive non-ED therapist who she is honest with, and that helps.

Skinhorse · 26/02/2024 10:06

Came on to say that I think the medical establishment are yet to wake up to the link between autism and anorexia. Implicit sexism has meant girls with autism have been ignored for decades - I remember anorexia being rife when I was at school among high achievers. It's long been associated with 'perfectionism'. How could they have missed this? 😓 all the best to you and your daughter.

Slowlyimproving · 26/02/2024 10:01

Just to say it again DD gained weight when she started cbt-E at her lowest weight, not FBT.
So whatever counselling, talking etc helped her despite her low weight and "starved brain". So to say weight gain before anything else is not always the only way.

kittensinthekitchen · 26/02/2024 09:35

My daughter was diagnosed with ASD at the age of 8. At the age of 10, it was agreed by CAMHS that she has a 'PDA profile', so even typical ASD strategies don't apply.

She's always had restrictive and repetitive eating behaviours because of her ASD, but first developed signs of an eating disorder during lockdown. She's now 15.

She was back under CAMHS (regular clinician, not ED specialist) in 2022, who discharged her after a few months when she gained enough weight so could get out of having to go. She was referred back under an emergency referral at the start of 2023, when she was down to eating one small thing average every 3 or 4 days. They did the usual on her first appointment, tried to scare her into eating, telling her how severe the consequences are, and gave a meal plan of 3 meals, 3 snacks and sent us away. When we went back two days later and her weight had dropped further and she hadn't eaten a thing, they looked at admission. Her potassium levels were so low they said she was hours away from a coma. Her core body temperature was 34.7. No bed could be located for her, so instead she was put on bed rest and we had nurses visiting for 1.5 hours 4 times a day, and started FBT.

As a single parent to her and a more severely autistic young adult, I'm broken. We've experienced things I wouldn't wish on my worst enemy. I can't close my eyes without hearing her screams, without being able to feel her in my arms as I laid night after night cradling her as she sobbed and fought.

On several occasions, she made it clear that she was not comfortable that her main nurse that we saw for our three times a week appointments with CAMHS (usually at home but did progress to clinic) was male. She requested a female. But apparently there was no alternative available.

For six months, we had zero weight restoration. Every so often she'd gain half a lb, but it'd be gone again by next weigh in.

Eventually, she was eating enough salad to raise her energy levels enough to do an event she had been desperately waiting for. CAMHS took this as a sign that she was cured, of course.

She was recently discharged from CAMHS, weight restored, but with their opinion that because she was able to gain enough weight to do the thing she really wanted to do, that this ISN'T an eating disorder, this is for attention, for control, and autism related. Apparently CAMHS isn't the place for her, and we've been encouraged to seek peer autism support (that I've been heavily involved with for the past ten years).

I'm broken enough to smile and nod, knowing that before summer, we'll likely be back.

She's now eating - yay - the same restricted one meal a day, that must be Just Right. But she's purging Every Day. She has damage and erosion on her teeth. Her stomach burns from acid. She is complaining of increasing rib pain every day. Of course, she is getting thinner again.

She is begging me for help, but also doesn't want to recover. She is terrified to gain weight. After weight restoration, she was offered no therapy, no other treatment. Just discharge, because autism.

I just don't even know what to do anymore Sad

boredybored · 26/02/2024 09:10

I haven't read your post but child eating services ( when I eventually got an appointment) told us to sit down and make her eat 3 meals and snacks and gave us a food list .
It had meat and yogurt in it and she eats neither and also Einstein don't you think we have tried all that .

Honestly I was shocked , literally is that all you have .

I waited so long and hung on to hope that she would get help and that was it !!!🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️

Dd also has high functioning ASD and this wasn't even mentioned or considered .

I feel the nhs just look at things so separately and never have a holistic approach to helping mental health issues .

It's useless .