Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think service charges should be banned?

61 replies

Precipice · 25/02/2024 19:34

I think it totally unacceptable for restaurants to add extra charges onto the bill and put the onus on the customer to have these charges removed.

To me, this is no different than if I went to Lidl or Waterstones and had my shopping totalled up as 20.99 and then the shop added an extra 2.09 automatically and forced me to apply to them to remove it; or if the item price said 12.99, but the till was deliberately set up to charge me 15.99.

I see this more and more. I think this should be made illegal under consumer protection.

YABU - it's fine for any industry to add on whatever extra charge they want as long as they eventually remove it for customers who raise it with them

YANBU - customers should only be charged according to listed price for the item/service chosen

OP posts:
TheHateIsNotGood · 25/02/2024 21:01

Service Charges do not always = Tips for the staff. Service Charges are a surcharge on the Bill and are included as Sales; often these Service Charges aren't passed on to staff at all.

A cool tenner a night tips on top of wages for a night's waitressing isn't to be sniffed at, even in this day and age; unless it was a 'level up' from your general restaurant.

Lumiodes · 25/02/2024 20:29

The service charge is always way more than I’d leave as a tip. If I spent say £50 on two meals and drinks, they would charge 10% or £5 service charge, which seems like a lot for someone who’s doing their job that they’re paid for. They must be getting an absolute fortune if they get 10% of everything they serve. I used to be a waitress years ago and I never went home with more than a tenner from tips! I feel greedy asking for it to be removed from the bill though.

Carnewb · 25/02/2024 20:21

Kalevala · 25/02/2024 19:40

I think it should be allowed for large groups or days like mothers day, if clearly communicated at booking.

This is why some places charge more for mother's day, Christmas etc, extra pay for the staff factored in to the price of the meal because it's a premium day - one would hope they don't stick a service charge on as well though. But I expect some do.

Although I have to say I've worked many mothers days and although the prices have been higher, they haven't paid any extra because it's a 'normal' day, no extra for BH except Christmas day either, same goes for large parties, extra work for everyone but no extra pay for those doing it, although you do need more staff for the organisation, prep & delivery of a large amount of food in one go. So a service charge there would probably be fair actually, if applied and explained up front. Same as charging for an early check in, if you want the guarantee you'll get the room early we have to ensure it's ready, which may mean putting 2 staff in there and then there's the extra electric etc for the extra time the guest potentially spends in the room.

As someone who works in hospitality, I don't agree with the service charge being put on automatically, I think rarely is it going to the staff doing the work as a reward for doing it well. I don't think expecting tips is on either, although definitely gratefully received when given, for the compliment on a job done well as much as the cash that is very helpful!
I think if people want to tip then they can, putting the customer and the staff in a potentially awkward situation of asking for it taken off and the fall out from that (the customer feeling awkward about it and projecting that onto the staff in the way they ask, which as someone who has no say in the whole thing, from experience, makes you feel like shit and like you're being personally accused of ripping people off) is not fair to either party.

But then I have been asked more than once, to 'justify' prices by customers who feel they're too expensive and that it doesn't cost that, well where I work pays more than nmw for many employees (not just chefs and managers) which is unusual, and it's reflected in a happy and hardworking team, frequently complimented on their level of service - but people discount that, maybe because they feel like they deserve good service but don't want to pay for it.

TheHateIsNotGood · 25/02/2024 19:51

I'd rather give a tip according to the service and/or food received if tips are 'pooled' amongst the staff. And that any additional costs that the owners/management feel that they need to levy (such as heating/power) are charged separately or factored into the Menu Price.

Most reasonable people understand that the costs of cooking even basic ingredients has significantly increased as well as keeping the customers warm whilst they eat it.

Kalevala · 25/02/2024 19:48

If it's on every bill then it should just be added to the menu prices. If in particular situations only then it should be clear beforehand and be a non-negotiable surcharge. There should be no optional charge that can be removed on request.

the80sweregreat · 25/02/2024 19:45

Can you ask to have it taken off ?
I admit I never have done , but just wondering if it's possible?
I rarely eat out these days as most places are a rip off

Puzzledandpissedoff · 25/02/2024 19:44

Not sure the "YANBU" makes sense on this one, since the service charge will have been listed upfront too (at least it should have been)

Personally I don't mind either way and I'll leave either the service charge or a tip.
What I do mind i seeing a service charge and then being "invited" to leave a tip as well ... they've got to be joking

TinySaltLick · 25/02/2024 19:42

I'm indifferent, it's just part of the economic model. It would otherwise be built into the pricing of the consumables so would net out.

Restaurants are hardly businesses where it is easy to turn a profit

Kalevala · 25/02/2024 19:40

I think it should be allowed for large groups or days like mothers day, if clearly communicated at booking.

80skid · 25/02/2024 19:39

Seeing as they are required to pay their staff, adding a service charge on top of this is disgusting. Leaving a tip is a choice in recognition of excellent service, staffing costs are already factored into menu costs so I'm totally with you.

Changingplace · 25/02/2024 19:37

I agree, if I’m happy to pay a tip I’ll add it but I really dislike this habit restaurants have started of adding it on, I want my receipt to be for what I’ve actually had and for a tip to be optional.