Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think service charges should be banned?

61 replies

Precipice · 25/02/2024 19:34

I think it totally unacceptable for restaurants to add extra charges onto the bill and put the onus on the customer to have these charges removed.

To me, this is no different than if I went to Lidl or Waterstones and had my shopping totalled up as 20.99 and then the shop added an extra 2.09 automatically and forced me to apply to them to remove it; or if the item price said 12.99, but the till was deliberately set up to charge me 15.99.

I see this more and more. I think this should be made illegal under consumer protection.

YABU - it's fine for any industry to add on whatever extra charge they want as long as they eventually remove it for customers who raise it with them

YANBU - customers should only be charged according to listed price for the item/service chosen

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Computercalendar · 01/03/2024 02:31

"Both times the waiter serving us was obliged to bring their manager over to our table who repeatedly questioned us about why we weren't paying the service charge and if anything was wrong!"

This exactly what happens when I've asked to remove the service charge. It's very unfair and a lot of people don't know that is optional.

Starzinsky · 01/03/2024 02:18

I hate it. It does put me off returning to some places where the amount charged can't be jutified by the service.

QueenBitch666 · 01/03/2024 00:11

I always ask for it to be removed and then tip if I feel one is warranted

StarlightLime · 29/02/2024 22:54

Agreed. I asked for the service charge to be removed recently, after frankly appalling service. They were gobsmacked 😂
No problem at all tipping for good service.

LavenderFlowers · 29/02/2024 22:50

It's become such an unfair norm lately. Staff in restaurants are paid similarly to supermarket/childcare/hotel staff and they don't get tips. Tips should be for great service

Puzzledandpissedoff · 29/02/2024 22:33

Changingplace · 29/02/2024 22:14

It's different in the USA etc as waiting staff are not paid a minimum wage.

I don’t understand this at all, why businesses in the US have no legal obligation to pay their staff a minimum wage, must clearly make a profit and instead of paying their staff correctly expect their customers to top up staff wages, it’s an insane concept.

Actually they do now have a minimum wage for tipped staff, though it varies by state:

https://clockify.me/learn/business-management/tipped-wages/

Tipped Wages by State — Guide for 2024

Do you want to learn more about tipped wages in the US? Read our guide and find out about tipped wages in the US for 2024.

https://clockify.me/learn/business-management/tipped-wages

Changingplace · 29/02/2024 22:14

It's different in the USA etc as waiting staff are not paid a minimum wage.

I don’t understand this at all, why businesses in the US have no legal obligation to pay their staff a minimum wage, must clearly make a profit and instead of paying their staff correctly expect their customers to top up staff wages, it’s an insane concept.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 29/02/2024 16:18

We went to Six by Nico - they added on a 18% service charge and a charity donation without asking

This "charity donation" thing is spreading horribly in America - it's even started in the UK - and since like the service charges/tips we'll probably never know where the money really ends up it can be just another way to gouge money from the timid

Fortunately there's a useful response: "I already support my chosen charities so I'd prefer it taken off please"

LadyChilli · 29/02/2024 16:07

Cuddy899 · 29/02/2024 09:14

Oh this winds me up so much!!! We’ve just got back from America- the tip and tax (I understand the tax) put us off going out or nipping in somewhere for a drink! At every point they wanted tipping. So we just didn’t do certain things. And it’s now becoming similar in the UK- I agree there should be protection.

We went to Six by Nico - they added on a 18% service charge and a charity donation without asking. It added on £20. So again you have to factor that cost in- and decide if you want to pay it and are happy to go. I find it awkward not paying it so just avoid going now to places!

That's a huge tip. And don't even start me on the stupid charity donations places are adding to bills now. Just let me pay for my meal and leave a tip without feeling like an utter tightwad when I have to ask to manually remove a donation to a charity I've never heard of

Carnewb · 29/02/2024 11:24

westisbest1982 · 29/02/2024 11:08

The customer shouldn’t be subsidising the staff’s wages, regardless of how many people are being served. The waiting staff know what they’re getting into when they sign their contracts. Serving one person or 10, it’s what they’re paid to do.

Only for a large party the cost of delivering the meal with decent service increases because they'd need extra staff to do so. Why should anyone else subside that?

I don't agree with adding on service charges in general, but I also don't think that a large party, that incurs an extra cost to deliver, should not pay the extra that it costs to deliver the service. It's not subsidising wait staffs wages in that case, it's paying for what you're getting.

BobbyBiscuits · 29/02/2024 11:22

I'm personally more than happy that they have put the suggested tip on top of the total, as it saves me calculating. 12.5% I believe is the norm. If service is great then I tip a bit more. If it is utterly awful then I simply do not pay the tip. It is a suggestion. I've actually very rarely chosen not to tip, I take it as part of the cost. Being a waiter is hard work, much harder than lots of other jobs with a similar wage. If the food tastes bad it's not the waiter's fault either.

Choccyp1g · 29/02/2024 11:17

I always thought that they added the percent on for large parties because otherwise they would get a smaller tip overall.
Tables for two happy to tip £5 to £10 whereas customers balk at leaving £50 to £100 for a table for 10.

Not to mention the cheeky bill splitters who pay last and walk off with the tips.

WandaWonder · 29/02/2024 11:09

If it is clearly marked before you order then I have no issue, it is a choice to eat there or not

MandyMotherOfBrian · 29/02/2024 11:08

Move to Singapore! (Ok maybe not practical) I prefer to leave a tip when I have had excellent service and sometimes it has been accepted but I have been chased up the street in order to give me back my tip more than once - always with a smile too. I hope the wait staff are paid accordingly.

westisbest1982 · 29/02/2024 11:08

The customer shouldn’t be subsidising the staff’s wages, regardless of how many people are being served. The waiting staff know what they’re getting into when they sign their contracts. Serving one person or 10, it’s what they’re paid to do.

Carnewb · 29/02/2024 11:01

I agree I don't like that it's automatically added, but service a large group (say 8+) is much harder than serving 4 tables of 2. Trying to build up any rapport with a large group and deal with all their little requests, dietary requirements, preferences, plus keeping on top of drinks orders and running food quickly can be stressful. Because of that, I do think the extra work should be recognised, but it should be the company who recognises this, not the customer

See I disagree that the customer shouldn't pay for the extra that is required to serve a large group, if they want the service to be the same as if it were a table for two, it costs more when it's a large group to deliver that service, but the food is the same price. It would be the same takings for one group of 8 as four tables of 2, but would cost more to have the service at the same level, and if they keep the staff ratio the same, then the service suffers, usually of other tables meaning discounts applied there. It could end up being a loss maker.

I don't think it should be added automatically, but a communication on booking with an explanation.

Nala82 · 29/02/2024 10:53

alonglongshot · 25/02/2024 21:13

I was out today and the options for tipping were all as a % of the bill. Starting at 10%, 15%, 20% or 25%. No option to say, for example, £5.

Seems excessive to me.

Card readers, this was. Think I'll stick some fivers in my purse in future. The bill was for £32 btw.

I'm confused. 10% would be £3.20, and 15% would be £4.80. Why are they excessive, but a fiver is fine?

(I hope I've done my sums right....)

CatamaranViper · 29/02/2024 10:40

I've worked for too many dodgy companies where staff don't see tips unless they're handed to them personally in cash by the customer, so I always ask for it to be removed so I can leave a cash tip of my choice.

I agree I don't like that it's automatically added, but service a large group (say 8+) is much harder than serving 4 tables of 2. Trying to build up any rapport with a large group and deal with all their little requests, dietary requirements, preferences, plus keeping on top of drinks orders and running food quickly can be stressful. Because of that, I do think the extra work should be recognised, but it should be the company who recognises this, not the customer.

I would often chose to look after the larger parties myself (as a supervisor then manager) because I knew I was being paid (a tiny bit) more and had slightly more authority to speed up the kitchen or comp off items if needed without adding extra time onto the customers experience.

SplitFountainPen · 29/02/2024 10:33

usernother · 29/02/2024 09:07

I asked a waitress once if they actually received the money from service charges. She said they did but it was added to their wages and they'd rather have the cash.

It should be added to their wages, it's legally earnings. The only reason to prefer cash is to avoid tax, NI and UC deductions.

Precipice · 29/02/2024 10:19

merrymelodies · 29/02/2024 04:13

Don't go to North America if you hate tipping! It's a nightmare. Minimum 20% is expected for a meal and even places like Starbucks expect a 15% tip.

I'm not planning to! On the other hand, I can go to Japan, where I've heard a story of a friend-of-a-friend being pursued out onto the street to be given his extra change he'd left as a tip back.

But I don't think either of these extremes on the scale should weigh on what's done in this country.

OP posts:
Carnewb · 29/02/2024 10:13

I was told in no uncertain terms, probably about 6 months ago, to take the service charge off and a lovely long lecture about how I shouldn't expect tips and how it was disgusting etc etc, oh and told how I'd arranged my face was unacceptable too, that it reflected my attitude and was awful etc (didn't open my mouth after being told to be quiet when I tried to respond ).

Thing is we don't have a service charge.

At the end of his tirade -
"So are you going to remove it then?"
"We don't have a service charge Sir"
"What's this then?" Stabs at figure on bill
"The VAT Sir, already included in the final total"

Oh my, that did not go down well. Apparently I was then smug. 🤷🏼‍♀️

He'd already decided that I was going to have an issue with removing the service charge, and treated me accordingly, even though I had nothing to be affronted about because there isn't one, he directed his own discomfort at asking for it to be removed onto me by default.

I'd imagine that many people asking for a service charge do the same, they've decided the staff are going to be affronted because they feel uncomfortable and no matter what is actually said or done by the staff, they're treated like they have an issue even if they don't.

It's the companies putting this on, not the staff serving your table, you've no choice but to ask them to remove it, but don't take out the discomfort you feel for asking on them.

BranchGold · 29/02/2024 09:38

I completely agree, particularly about drinks such as wine.

It’s one thing paying 10/15% on the food service, or cocktails, which have taken time to prepare. But if the food portion of a bill is £60 and the wine could be £140, why is there an expectation of increased service charge?

Pulling a cork out of a pricey bottle isn’t any more effort.

westisbest1982 · 29/02/2024 09:31

Completely agree, and as a PP says, it’s a ridiculous concept when you think about it. Just add the charge to the food prices. Except they won’t of course, because that would rightfully deter potential customers.

The staff running these establishments know full well that must people are too timid to ask for the charge to be removed, and so the practice continues. I always ask, and be always the staff member looks a bit affronted, wherever it is. If the staff aren’t getting paid well, it’s not my problem.

ZetuianRose · 29/02/2024 09:22

I agree. I think it’s a bizarre concept when you break it down.

A business charges customers for goods or services at a price that covers their overheads and turns a profit. Customer views the prices and decides whether to purchase said goods or services.

But some businesses then feel they deserve “tips” or add additional charges. Why?

How come checkout assistants aren’t able to ask for tips? Is their job not as valuable as a waiter/ress? Is a bus driver less deserving than a taxi driver? Is a shop owner more able to cover their overheads than a restaurant owner?

It’s ridiculous. If your business model doesn’t cover your overheads then you shouldn’t be running that business, it’s not viable. You can’t advertise one price, then expect the customer to pay more on top.

ImCamembertTheBigCheese · 29/02/2024 09:21

My preference would be for all restaurants to have the service charge built into their food prices, would save so much hassle. Then if the customer wants to leave extra they can, but it is not expected.

I do think though that if a menu states there is a service charge, you should not get it removed unless the service has been very poor. You know that charge will be added to your bill, if you do not agree, dine elsewhere.