Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask that people stop asking kids if they’ve ’been away’ or ‘done anything exciting’ during the school holidays?

154 replies

Chubbymummyof2 · 25/02/2024 16:40

It’s the last day of our half-term holiday today and it’s been a week at home, partly because we’ve all had germs but also because everything costs SO much at the moment we haven’t got spare money to go on holiday or have exciting days out.
My daughter (12) had an eye test mid week and I know that the optician was only trying to make small talk but both me and my daughter felt pretty uncomfortable with the ‘have you been away’, ‘what exciting things have you done this week’ questions she just wouldn’t let it drop that we’d had a week at home. (It didn’t help that the optician had the worst listening skills ever and repeated every single question multiple times).
I wish that people could be a bit more mindful of that fact that not many people have much of a disposable income at the moment and that holidays/days out are a treat and they shouldn’t expect that just because kids are on half-term it means their parents have endless exciting (usually expensive) things planned.

Can we normalise holidays spent at home?

AIBU - am I being over sensitive, it was just small talk
YANBU - small talk doesn’t have to be about activities that require disposable income

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SkankingWombat · 26/02/2024 23:32

TwylaSands · 26/02/2024 20:10

Are you kidding? What actions do you think can be done for kids living in homes where the parents dont give a shit. What do you think social services do?

Reports of violence can be reported to SS or the police, with the families receiving support or the DCs being removed as a result depending on the severity. Not being fed would be a report to SS too, but also ensuring that DC just happens to get the more generously plated school lunch every day in the meantime. Neglect can be alleviated by quietly supplying the DC with things like toothbrushes or discretely washing dirty uniform/clothes in school.
Are you honestly saying it's better not to know? A don't ask/don't tell policy?

Cherrysoup · 26/02/2024 22:15

Bog standard question, loads of my kids asked me today if I’d had a nice holiday, I asked them back. 🤷‍♀️It’s standard. Nothing to be ashamed of if you didn’t go somewhere hugely exotic or were unwell. Bit ridiculous to tell people to stop asking, it’s just a polite conversation, nobody really wants to hear what you did.

Foolmeagain · 26/02/2024 21:29

JacobElordisBathWater · 25/02/2024 16:42

Surely it’s up there with “what’s Santa bringing?” and “any nice plans this weekend?”

Plenty of people have nice weeks and weekends without spending money. Beach, park, play date with friends, a sleepover, movie night.

Yes, this.

Admittedly my DC are a few years younger, but none of the things we did in half-term cost much. We had one day out at a local country park, one day at a local beach, another at a castle that we have a yearly ticket to, DH took them to his parents one day, another day we met their cousins (including a teenager) for a woodland walk.

They would (and did) refer to some of those as 'so much fun'.

coxesorangepippin · 26/02/2024 21:11

Totally agree

What is the kid actually supposed to say

MargaretThursday · 26/02/2024 21:10

TwylaSands · 25/02/2024 22:54

No it isnt this. It is that some children will have suffered, not left their homes, not been outside, no gardens, barely eaten, been surrounded by screaming, or violence, ignored, and they will have struggled with the return to school.

and it is more and more every year.

and it isnt about the cost. There are parents who just dont care. They dont want to do anything with ir for their children. It is of no interest to them whether it is free or not.

Edited

I think the children with parents like that are unlikely to be at the opticians, so they're probably safe asking there.

I believe that one reasons schools used to ask children things like this was to pick up on abuse. Now they wouldn't be questioning when the child says "not much" if all else is well, but it can be one piece in the jigsaw which can be very important when looking at safeguarding.

For what it's worth, we didn't do a lot in holidays but we always did a few things like a self catering cottage in UK or have a couple of day trips to things or maybe have the paddling pool out or buy something as a treat. Invariably when the question came they'd reply with such delights as "I broke my arm playing football" or "We found bats in the roof" or "next door rabbit died" or "not much; we didn't do anything" or "I lost my sticker on the bus".
Even now mine are adults, if you ask for memories you get "I remember when we couldn't find the car and we had to ask the traffic wardens for help" or "we were all sick in the car on the way back from that holiday" or "there were mice at that place". Not the things you would hope they remember.

x2boys · 26/02/2024 20:37

Surely this has always been the case?
I'm 50 and remember having to do composition, s as they were known back then about what i had done in the holidays
There will always be children whose parents have more money and do more exciting things
And then those who have visited grandparents ,been to the park etc etc .

PigsEnigma · 26/02/2024 20:16

We've not been away or spent a lot of money this half term. My son was asked 'have you done anything exciting this half term' and he said yes and listed...

A Teddy bears picnic on the floor in the lounge (we always eat at the table, a floor picnic with junk food is a novelty)
Hopped on a bus into town, £2 a ticket each to see a film in the kids club, again £2 each
Went on a woods walk and collected nesting materials for birds and made nesting material holders
Wandered around an owl sanctuary and a horse sanctuary (both free but we gave donations)
Genuinely he wouldn't have had a better time if we'd been away.

The most expensive part was probably the junk food for the picnic!

Fun doesn't have to be expensive.

Edited to add: we put their bed tents up too which is always good fun. They have their special dens for a week.

Motabilityblues · 26/02/2024 20:11

What about for the huge number who live in households that can’t do more. Those with disability, illness, or debt? Those with inadequate housing or those that don’t want to share their lives with people.

TwylaSands · 26/02/2024 20:10

SkankingWombat · 26/02/2024 11:58

In which case, even better you asked so that these kinds of responses (as per the examples given by a PP above) can be reported and acted upon.

Are you kidding? What actions do you think can be done for kids living in homes where the parents dont give a shit. What do you think social services do?

TwylaSands · 26/02/2024 20:09

Stompythedinosaur · 26/02/2024 19:49

I accept there are sadly dc who live in abusive or neglectful households. But I think it's probably a good thing if it comes to light?

it probably is in the light. But the bar for social services is very, very low.

Stompythedinosaur · 26/02/2024 19:49

TwylaSands · 25/02/2024 22:54

No it isnt this. It is that some children will have suffered, not left their homes, not been outside, no gardens, barely eaten, been surrounded by screaming, or violence, ignored, and they will have struggled with the return to school.

and it is more and more every year.

and it isnt about the cost. There are parents who just dont care. They dont want to do anything with ir for their children. It is of no interest to them whether it is free or not.

Edited

I accept there are sadly dc who live in abusive or neglectful households. But I think it's probably a good thing if it comes to light?

iwafs · 26/02/2024 12:09

I think you just need to learn to shrug it off, and teach your dd the same.

“We’ve had some much needed peace, quiet and downtime at home”

or whatever

tennesseewhiskey1 · 26/02/2024 12:04

Ffs. Grow up it’s small talk. How on earth do you plan to ‘stop this’ - petition the government to ban it?!

SkankingWombat · 26/02/2024 11:58

TwylaSands · 25/02/2024 22:54

No it isnt this. It is that some children will have suffered, not left their homes, not been outside, no gardens, barely eaten, been surrounded by screaming, or violence, ignored, and they will have struggled with the return to school.

and it is more and more every year.

and it isnt about the cost. There are parents who just dont care. They dont want to do anything with ir for their children. It is of no interest to them whether it is free or not.

Edited

In which case, even better you asked so that these kinds of responses (as per the examples given by a PP above) can be reported and acted upon.

echt · 25/02/2024 23:21

This thread has made me think. We were pretty poor growing up and only had one holiday. Also, it was the 60s, not a time when working class parents "did" things wth their children as they do now.
It was mortifying to have the same essay title every year: what I did on my holiday. Also bloody bone idle on the part of successive primary teachers.

The optician, though was just making small talk.

TempestTost · 25/02/2024 23:19

YABU.

There is nothing wrong with a question like this, and nothing wrong with saying, "We've just been home, not done anything really different." I, and I expect most people, have given that answer 1000 times.

It's important for kids to learn that it is ok not to have an exciting answer every time, and that the question doesn't somehow imply they ought to have done anything in particular. They can also learn, if they have some direction, that often if they think a bit they have done something interesting, even if they didn't go away. "We were all sick as dogs" is a good answer to the question.

Frankly it's no wonder so many young people are stressed and totally lacking in resilience, with adults "protecting" them from normal conversations because supposedly they are too damaging.

TheaBrandt · 25/02/2024 23:10

Weather is so bad in Northern Europe so unless you go proper long haul or ski not worth going away in England or norther Europe. We’ve never done much feb half term. Didn’t t occur to me to feel guilty! When they were younger would do a day out at a science museum or shopping or something and make a thing of it.

RosePetals86 · 25/02/2024 22:58

i think yabu on this op- sorry! I think it just sounds like friendly chat - you didn’t have to feel bad that you’d been home due to sickness! That would have just moved the conversation in a different direction.

TwylaSands · 25/02/2024 22:54

Stompythedinosaur · 25/02/2024 22:39

But, having no money doesn't mean you've done nothing! We were on a tight budget this half term and I had to work three days out of five, but the kids have still had a friend round to play, been to the park, had a film night, played roblox with friends, played cards etc. None of these cost us anything extra.

I think the issue is in thinking that the sorts of normal things dc do to be occupied don't count.

No it isnt this. It is that some children will have suffered, not left their homes, not been outside, no gardens, barely eaten, been surrounded by screaming, or violence, ignored, and they will have struggled with the return to school.

and it is more and more every year.

and it isnt about the cost. There are parents who just dont care. They dont want to do anything with ir for their children. It is of no interest to them whether it is free or not.

Stompythedinosaur · 25/02/2024 22:39

But, having no money doesn't mean you've done nothing! We were on a tight budget this half term and I had to work three days out of five, but the kids have still had a friend round to play, been to the park, had a film night, played roblox with friends, played cards etc. None of these cost us anything extra.

I think the issue is in thinking that the sorts of normal things dc do to be occupied don't count.

Phineyj · 25/02/2024 22:26

I have been to the optician lots of times for myself and with my daughter and never have they tried to make small talk! This person sounds like one of those stereotype hairdressers who goes on about what you're doing at the weekend...

Great small talk, making your customer feel sad and not picking up that you're annoying them.

Anyway. Hope you have a better Easter, OP.

Multipleexclamationmarks · 25/02/2024 22:06

For what it's worth I work in a school and we are not allowed to ask the children if they've done anything exciting or been away after a break because some will have done nothing and some will have been skiing.
Instead we say things like "its nice to see you back" and "it's good to have a break from school". I used to think it was a bit ott but after seeing how some kids brag and others just look down I get it now.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 25/02/2024 21:58

snoopyfanaccountant · 25/02/2024 17:27

I volunteer with young people and often ask them if they have done anything exciting or fun during a school holiday. In that situation it's about getting to know the young people I work with and taking an interest in them.

Edited to add that I phrase it this way rather than asking what exciting things they have done as it's easier for them to say that they have done nothing. It also gives no expectations that they should be doing exciting things.

Edited

From my own childhood and from working with kids, you could get answers like

'Apart from being punched in the side of the head repeatedly because I looked at her a bit funny, not really'

'Dad got pissed, smashed the house up and then told us he was going to kill himself'

'I was looking after my little sister because Mum had to work. It was dark and the lights didn't work, so we were scared when there was somebody knocking'

'The boy that lives across the road got stabbed in the park'

'The lady next door gave us some sandwiches because we didn't have any food during the day'

'We went to the food bank and they said we couldn't have anything because the job centre didn't make a referral, they just gave the address'

'We drew some flowers on the path with chalk and the woman across the road said we'd be arrested'

'Nothing. Dad went to the shop and left us alone, then he went to sleep when he came back'.

'Mum got angry with us because nobody let the dog out when she was at work and Dad hit her'.

'I watched TV. Mum doesn't like me annoying her and after she picked up the metre stick and said if I got up one more time she'd wallop me with it, I stayed still'.

'We did the shopping and I helped carry things home'.

or, just the usual, not saying anything to let on just how awful the week has been, answer;

'Nothing'.

And then of course, the person asking then says 'Oh, you must have done something, mustn't you? All that playing, you're so lucky'.

Small talk can be intensely threatening for neglected, abused and vulnerable children.

Elphamouche · 25/02/2024 21:45

It doesn’t need to cost the earth though. Movie nights, pamper nights with face masks etc.
If you’ve got a dog, take them somewhere new.

We were never a family that did many days out, and we never went away in half terms. Only ever in term time because we couldn’t afford half term.

WimpoleHat · 25/02/2024 21:06

Even the one who had actually gone away to Japan forgot to tell me that and said he'd played a new computer game!

Reminds me of the time my DD had to write one of those “what I did on my half term holiday” type sheets when she was six or so. We’d had a short break to Italy. I’d taken them to the theatre in London. And, on the Sunday, we’d been to a National Trust place and gone for some dinner in a pub on the way home, where she briefly bumped into one of her classmates on the way in. What did her diary say? “I went to the pub and I saw Lucy and Mummy had wine.” Great…..