Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What is she up to?

807 replies

DontVisitCabotCove · 25/02/2024 16:18

DB, his partner “Jane” & her 2 kids have been staying with me - in my house - after the house they were buying fell through. They had been looking at other properties to buy but have since decided to end their relationship so that’s no longer happening.

Yesterday while my DB and I were out and unbeknownst to me, Jane had an estate agent over to value my house & as he was leaving he told her he’d send her an email with the valuation & they were talking about viewings etc.

Today Jane asked me to give her a letter stating that my brother is living here but wouldn’t tell me why she wanted it & was really unhappy when I said I’d give her a letter saying they were both temporarily staying with me as that’s the actual truth.

What on earth could she be up to? I’m honestly baffled!

Should I tell her that I know about the valuation? Should I tell my DB about all of this?

On one hand I don’t want to get involved in their troubles or make things worse (things are bad enough between them already) but on the other hand I feel I’m being drawn into it as it’s my bloody house she had valued!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
Alondra · 27/02/2024 04:18

OP, you and Mumsnet will never know her motive behind asking for a valuation of your property. What's obvious is that she did something very underhanded and completely out of order. You are taking great steps to protect yourself, talking to your solicitor being the most important one.

Just tell her to leave your property, not only verbally but by email as well. In your email, state clearly why she's no longer welcome to stay with you. Something like "Out of kindness, and as a partner to my DB, I allowed you and your children to stay in my home when the deal for buying a property deal fell through. Your relationship with my DB has ended and unbeknown to me, you had my home valuated without my permission or knowledge. I don't know why you've done this but you had no right to do it and I no longer feel safe with you in my home. Please leave, "insert the day you want her out", will suffice.

I'm so sorry that on top of your health issues, you are dealing with this crap. Flowers

Everythinggreen · 27/02/2024 01:08

I can't believe the audacity of some people! Who does this!! She doesn't even sound clever enough to be a sociopathic danger, she sounds dim enough to think she can somehow lay claim to a share in her ex boyfriends sister house, possibly been reading the fictitious stories found on reddit and quora. Beggars belief!

ClairDeLaLune · 27/02/2024 00:31

OP I hope you have now evicted Jane.

Fitzbillie · 26/02/2024 23:54

Seeing as we are going on flights of fancy… maybe the other heir is the intended victim of the scam…

DB and Jane set up finance to buy a house. The sale falls through —they pull out—. They ask OP to let them stay.

DB and Jane “break up”. OP is likely to let her homeless and heartbroken DB stay longer than she would be willing to host DB, Jane and her DC. Jane and DB arrange valuations of the property to establish proof that OP wants to sell up. It’s not improbable that OP might want to release equity in her property now she is unwell. They don’t even need to actually have viewings, although if DB is living there he could facilitate viewings when OP isn’t there, they have established evidence of OP’s intention to sell.

It would be very difficult to sell a property fraudulently while the owner is living there - usually these scams happen when the property is rented or empty so viewings can take place and mail be intercepted. If would be far easier for DB to “buy” the property without OP’s knowledge than for Jane to sell it to a third party.

DB could intercept any mail about the fake sale, has access to her ID to open an online bank account in OP’s name for the proceeds to be paid into, emails to and from the fake email address are from OP’s IP address.

The letter stating that DB now lives at the address establishes that it is his home so it’s reasonable that he might want to buy it and OP might have changed her mind since she wrote her will and now want him to have the house. It also might be for the purpose of making it easier to prove that he knew about OP wanting to sell the property before the EA valued it to avoid having to pay any EA fees for the fake sale.

DB wouldn’t even need to buy the house, just put some money in. If he owned the house with OP as a joint tenant, he would inherit the house instead of OP’s intended heir. If he stands to inherit the rest of OP’s estate, he would inherit the money he paid for the house back! Entirely plausible that a loving brother might use his house deposit to buy part of his DS’s home to save her having to sell up or get a mortgage to buy it from her for sentimental reasons … Entirely plausible that his DS might have chosen to make him a joint tenant in gratitude. Entirely plausible that she might have intended to update her will after the sale so the other heir didn’t lose out but never got round to it. Entirely plausible that brain fog meant she didn’t realise that being a joint tenant would mean she couldn’t leave her share to the other heir.

If OP doesn’t have alerts set up with the land registry, the sale would be unlikely to be discovered until distribution of the estate. It would be pretty hard to prove the sale wasn’t genuine without OP as a witness. Especially if the DB buys the house outright for the full market value. There is a good chance that the other heir wouldn’t suspect fraud or pursue it. Who wants to accuse a relative of fraud without strong proof?

That probably isn’t what is going on 😂 It’s a shame I am too honest to be a fraudster, I think I would be better at it than Jane 😂

Sorry you are going through this, OP. Don’t stress, you have had good advice on how to protect yourself. Hopefully my improbable criminal flight of fancy will make you laugh!

tensmum1964 · 26/02/2024 23:51

I find it extremely odd that you didn't confront her immediately about having your house valued. It's bstshit behaviour and I wouldn't want her living with me for another minute.

magentacloud · 26/02/2024 23:30

DontVisitCabotCove · 26/02/2024 18:43

So I saw the actual estate agent who came to my house and their manager; they were quite blasé about the whole thing and I got the impression that this isn’t the first time something like this has happened.

Basically they were under the impression they were dealing with me over phone and email (they wouldn’t give me the phone number or email address but confirmed the email address contained my name). They were fully aware that I’m sick and of my exact diagnosis which is why they apparently gave me some leeway with providing the information they were asking for before the actual valuation / market appraisal. Apparently just before the appointment “I” called up and told them I needed to go to hospital but that I’d arrange for a family member to let them in. When the agent got there, Jane introduced herself as Jane and said she was staying with me temporarily and confirmed I was at hospital so she wasn’t trying to impersonate me or anything like that.

Anyway long story short, they didn’t send the valuation, the email they sent said the valuation was ready but before they could go any further, they need to register my property and carry out some checks and asking me to fill out some forms and provide all the information in the checklist (photo ID, proof of address etc). There was no reply to the email.

As far as the estate agents are concerned, they did nothing wrong as they were genuinely trying to be accommodating considering my health and didn’t actually supply a valuation or do any marketing without all the necessary checks first.

Jane has denied that this is anything to do with her, she said she let the agent in because she had assumed I had just forgotten about the appointment (because of my “brain fog”) and then she forgot to tell me about it after. As the agent knew about my health and that I was in hospital, it all seemed legit to her apparently. When my DB bought up the letter though, her only response was it’s none of his business.

My brain is honestly frazzled by all of this.

Edited

This doesn't add up, as in your OP you wrote:

Yesterday while my DB and I were out and unbeknownst to me, Jane had an estate agent over to value my house & as he was leaving he told her he’d send her an email with the valuation & they were talking about viewings etc.

So if he thought he was dealing with your representative/a relative, then why would he say that he'd send the rep the valuation as it's supposedly your email, and why would he talk to her about viewings.

Rightsraptor · 26/02/2024 23:27

But we don't actually hold the deeds to our property any longer, not in paper form at least. Maybe if you've owned a property for years you do, but not for more recently purchased ones. The Land Registry holds them digitally

custardlover · 26/02/2024 23:14

I share a creeping feeling of worry.
Yuck.

LadyMinerva · 26/02/2024 23:13

madeinmanc · 26/02/2024 23:09

I'm so worried about the OP and her safety 😟

I sincerely hope Jane and the brother are out of the house by now.

Why should the brother go? So far there had been no indication he was involved.

canyouseemyhousefromhere · 26/02/2024 23:10

How stressful for you. Could she have been intending to try & raise a mortgage on your home?
A lucky escape for your brother.
Wishing you well.

madeinmanc · 26/02/2024 23:09

I'm so worried about the OP and her safety 😟

I sincerely hope Jane and the brother are out of the house by now.

Loopy3585 · 26/02/2024 22:35

MadMadamMimz · 26/02/2024 21:48

I doubt this woman was sophisticated enough to use a fake number. For completeness, I would still put through a SAR request with the estate agent. She must have left a number.

Firstly love your username

secondly as per my advice earlier I second this, at least you’d have the details they sent emails to etc.

GoingDownLikeBHS · 26/02/2024 22:29

So has Jane now left your house OP? Has DB told her to go? (Sorry if I've missed that bit someone put me right)

Ger1atricMillennial · 26/02/2024 22:09

Crumbs lucky escape- the estate agent plus the timing of asking for the letter gives it away. The EA has clearly indicated that she was expecting him, which goes against her statement that she thought you forgot. She is clever enough to get this information which is currently available to her AND set herself up with plausible deniability. I anticipate this isn't her first rodeo, it will be interesting how bold she is.

Is she using the system to find out how much you DB will be worth, and then attempting to prove that she and her family were resident at the property, so they are entitled to some of the money when she inevitably makes their relationship into a situation that can no longer continue. I can't imagine she would honestly thing that she would be able to actually sell your house.

But I agree it's all a bit St Mary Mead/Cabot Cove-esq if she had pulled it off. Perhaps there was more than one estate agent in case she was rumbled?

TyneTeas · 26/02/2024 21:54

Apologies if already suggested and I have missed it but you may want to apply for protective registration

https://www.cifas.org.uk/individuals

This places a flag on the national fraud database that organisations need to do extra checks for any applications they receive using your details

Flowers

Fraud Prevention for Individuals | Identity Theft Protection | Cifas

Cifas is well placed to offer individuals advice on identity protection and how to prevent and respond to the different ways fraudsters can impact your finances.

https://www.cifas.org.uk/individuals

WearyAuldWumman · 26/02/2024 21:52

samarrange · 26/02/2024 21:49

I'd be contacting the Estate Agent to let them know she doesn't own the house and to ask them why they felt able to do this (what reason did she give?).

If I may defend the EA here (never a popular position): If someone calls you up and says "Hi, I live at 4 Acacia Avenue and I'd like my house valued, can you come round at 2pm tomorrow?", and you turn up and they let you in — either because they answer the doorbell or because they are standing outside with the key — you are probably not going to say "Sorry, just a bit of due diligence first, can you please show me your passport and the deeds?". I think it's reasonable for the EA to assume that someone with access to the house who is asking for the valuation and says they're the owner, is in fact the owner. Maybe that due diligence should be a standard part of the protocol, but I'd bet it isn't in 99% of cases. Whenever we've sold a property, nobody asked for ID.

That also means that when the OP later turns up and says "Er, actually, I'm the owner", the EA has no obvious immediate way to work out who is telling the truth. From their point of view they are just dealing with a couple of people, of whom probably one is weird. All they can do at that point is activate the "Hmmm, something is fucked up here" mode that anyone who has to deal with the public for a living will develop over time. Once the OP shows them the deeds and her passport, hopefully the penny will drop, but psychologically it's a lot easier to believe the first person you met rather than the second, so I can understand it taking a while for the lies planted by Jane to be cleared from the OP's mind.

Aye. I recently sold a house I no longer live in.

When I got the no obligation valuation, the EA just popped round. No ID until I signed up with him...

Danielle9891 · 26/02/2024 21:50

I'm sorry for everything you're going through OP. Unfortunately there's always people out there who will take advantage of people so it's work keeping your eyes open.

Maybe she's struggling to find somewhere to rent (it is very hard to find a place at the moment) and tried to say she's selling the house so they knew she could afford the rent. A load of private landlords do affordability checks before they let out a house. Also, if the council thinks she has somewhere to live now they won't even help her. They would say she made herself 'intentionally homeless' if she moves out with getting evicted.

But still she seems really sneaky so I wouldn't trust her.

WearyAuldWumman · 26/02/2024 21:49

MadMadamMimz · 26/02/2024 21:48

I doubt this woman was sophisticated enough to use a fake number. For completeness, I would still put through a SAR request with the estate agent. She must have left a number.

Yup. Get the number, block ID and then give her a call...

Mymilkshakebringsallthepapstomycar · 26/02/2024 21:49

@DontVisitCabotCove What a horrible experience you are having. Have you told Jane that she needs to leave immediately? The innocent act really doesn’t stand up in light of the letter she’s trying to get out of you but refuses to explain why. That’s not an innocent person’s actions.

samarrange · 26/02/2024 21:49

pollymere · 26/02/2024 21:32

You say her kids so I'm presuming they're not his... It's either for child support or to get a share of his assets which apparently include your house. I'd be contacting the Estate Agent to let them know she doesn't own the house and to ask them why they felt able to do this (what reason did she give?).

I'd be contacting the Estate Agent to let them know she doesn't own the house and to ask them why they felt able to do this (what reason did she give?).

If I may defend the EA here (never a popular position): If someone calls you up and says "Hi, I live at 4 Acacia Avenue and I'd like my house valued, can you come round at 2pm tomorrow?", and you turn up and they let you in — either because they answer the doorbell or because they are standing outside with the key — you are probably not going to say "Sorry, just a bit of due diligence first, can you please show me your passport and the deeds?". I think it's reasonable for the EA to assume that someone with access to the house who is asking for the valuation and says they're the owner, is in fact the owner. Maybe that due diligence should be a standard part of the protocol, but I'd bet it isn't in 99% of cases. Whenever we've sold a property, nobody asked for ID.

That also means that when the OP later turns up and says "Er, actually, I'm the owner", the EA has no obvious immediate way to work out who is telling the truth. From their point of view they are just dealing with a couple of people, of whom probably one is weird. All they can do at that point is activate the "Hmmm, something is fucked up here" mode that anyone who has to deal with the public for a living will develop over time. Once the OP shows them the deeds and her passport, hopefully the penny will drop, but psychologically it's a lot easier to believe the first person you met rather than the second, so I can understand it taking a while for the lies planted by Jane to be cleared from the OP's mind.

Mumof3confused · 26/02/2024 21:49

This is insane. She must have faked an email address with your name in it. She’s gone to some lengths to do whatever it is she’s trying to do!

MadMadamMimz · 26/02/2024 21:48

I doubt this woman was sophisticated enough to use a fake number. For completeness, I would still put through a SAR request with the estate agent. She must have left a number.

Milkandnosugarplease · 26/02/2024 21:45

Your brother has had a lucky escape

Give her nothing with your address on

DontVisitCabotCove · 26/02/2024 21:43

A police officer called me back and it’s all logged but they’re not going to do anything about it as there’s no crime.

He was quite matter of fact about the estate agent and suggested it was very likely a dead end as it’s highly unlikely whoever it is would have used any identifying information i.e. their real phone number.

He also pointed out that while I may suspect Jane, her story has plausible deniability and several other people including my family members and DP knew I had a hospital appointment at that time, details of my condition etc.

So basically there’s no crime and several different people who could have had involvement.

He sympathised though and said he understood how unnerving something like this can be but if my suspicions were correct, I’ve caught on early enough and alerted people that I’m aware now so I’ve probably headed off any potential problems.

He then gave me some general advice on what to do to protect myself and what to look out for (monitoring my credit file etc) and suggested following up with my solicitor regarding the land registry etc. So basically that’s it unless something else happens.

OP posts:
Wetblanket78 · 26/02/2024 21:33

Oh she's sneaky your dB is well rid of her.