Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What is she up to?

807 replies

DontVisitCabotCove · 25/02/2024 16:18

DB, his partner “Jane” & her 2 kids have been staying with me - in my house - after the house they were buying fell through. They had been looking at other properties to buy but have since decided to end their relationship so that’s no longer happening.

Yesterday while my DB and I were out and unbeknownst to me, Jane had an estate agent over to value my house & as he was leaving he told her he’d send her an email with the valuation & they were talking about viewings etc.

Today Jane asked me to give her a letter stating that my brother is living here but wouldn’t tell me why she wanted it & was really unhappy when I said I’d give her a letter saying they were both temporarily staying with me as that’s the actual truth.

What on earth could she be up to? I’m honestly baffled!

Should I tell her that I know about the valuation? Should I tell my DB about all of this?

On one hand I don’t want to get involved in their troubles or make things worse (things are bad enough between them already) but on the other hand I feel I’m being drawn into it as it’s my bloody house she had valued!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
HJ40 · 27/02/2024 12:41

Fucking hell. Well whether it's to try and scam you or DB, and whether now or in the future it's completely dodgy. I wonder if she has a history of it?

Gloriosaford · 27/02/2024 12:40

OVienna · 27/02/2024 09:38

Exactly. Total BS from Jane. You'd tell them to come back another time. Even if Jane has gone from the house, I wouldn't let this go. The only document she'd be getting out of me is an email letting her know the estate agent and the police have been alerted to potentially fraudulent activity.

Why would you tip her off? That would give her the opportunity to put in some work to cover her tracks.
Let her think she's got away with it until you've gathered enough evidence and figured out what she's up to etc.

crockofshite · 27/02/2024 12:25

This is a fascinating thread. Jane clearly has bad bones and is / was up to no good.
Thank goodness she was found at at this relatively early stage, Jane sounds quite organised/informed and this could have got very messy.

DamnSpots · 27/02/2024 12:05

Abeona · 27/02/2024 11:56

The second you impersonate someone you have criminal intent.

That's one helluva reach. I went to a conference a couple of months ago under a colleague's name. Stood at the reception desk and told them I was Jo Reynolds*. Jo was unable to attend because of a last minute train issue, I was in a position to drive there, someone needed to attend. Jo tried to phone the organisers to warn them but no one answered. When I rocked up at the very busy registration desk it seemed easier all round to announce myself as Jo Reynolds rather than to explain what had happened and wait around while everything got checked and a new lanyard was printed and issued. No nefarious intent, no harm done.

*Not her real name.

Yes, but in that example you had Jo's permission to impersonate her (even if not explicitly, she knew you were going in her place). Its the impersonating without the other person's knowledge that is bad. If you'd gone to the conference without Jo knowing, and essentially stolen her place that would be criminal intent.

Abeona · 27/02/2024 11:56

The second you impersonate someone you have criminal intent.

That's one helluva reach. I went to a conference a couple of months ago under a colleague's name. Stood at the reception desk and told them I was Jo Reynolds*. Jo was unable to attend because of a last minute train issue, I was in a position to drive there, someone needed to attend. Jo tried to phone the organisers to warn them but no one answered. When I rocked up at the very busy registration desk it seemed easier all round to announce myself as Jo Reynolds rather than to explain what had happened and wait around while everything got checked and a new lanyard was printed and issued. No nefarious intent, no harm done.

*Not her real name.

RedToothBrush · 27/02/2024 11:50

Craybourne · 27/02/2024 11:26

I’d feel otherwise if it was me!

Needing a guarantor I’d have more sympathy with than trying to sell OP’s house behind her and DB’s backs! (Just a couple of the suggestions on here.)

And it will also influence how seriously the police take it. So far they have not shown all that much interest.

Also helps OP decide what further action she might need to take and what to look out for. It’s assessing what level of threat Jane poses, and to whom.

If you mean impersonating her even ‘just’ for guarantor purposes is still bad, I agree.

Even impersonating someone to get a guarantor implies that they know you won't do it, for a reason and that they are liable to default otherwise you would.

Given the guarantor scenario is the best case scenario, you have to assume it's an attempt to defraud and treat as such by taking the 'off the deep end' response. Which it sounds like the OP is doing.

wombat15 · 27/02/2024 11:46

Craybourne · 27/02/2024 11:26

I’d feel otherwise if it was me!

Needing a guarantor I’d have more sympathy with than trying to sell OP’s house behind her and DB’s backs! (Just a couple of the suggestions on here.)

And it will also influence how seriously the police take it. So far they have not shown all that much interest.

Also helps OP decide what further action she might need to take and what to look out for. It’s assessing what level of threat Jane poses, and to whom.

If you mean impersonating her even ‘just’ for guarantor purposes is still bad, I agree.

You don't need a house valuation to be a guarantor! They might prefer home owners but generally they are interested in the guarantor's income rather than the value of the property.

12345mummy · 27/02/2024 11:44

Not sure the EA will release the required info under an SAR as it’s classed as ‘personal’ info. Even though the girlfriend pretended to be the OP I don’t think the EA will give this info out and ultimately it sounds like they don’t want to be involved further.
OP - I’d be tempted to call social services regarding the children - this woman sounds like a regular scammer and it could be part of a bigger picture.

madeinmanc · 27/02/2024 11:28

The second you impersonate someone you have criminal intent.

Thanks for highlighting this, it's for this reason I was worried about the OP's personal safety. If there is criminal intent who knows where the boundaries lie? Who knows what they will do?

Craybourne · 27/02/2024 11:26

RedToothBrush · 27/02/2024 11:20

All explanations lead to defrauding the OP and exposing her to financial loss. It doesn't ultimately matter how.

The second you impersonate someone you have criminal intent.

The rest doesn't really matter in practice.

I’d feel otherwise if it was me!

Needing a guarantor I’d have more sympathy with than trying to sell OP’s house behind her and DB’s backs! (Just a couple of the suggestions on here.)

And it will also influence how seriously the police take it. So far they have not shown all that much interest.

Also helps OP decide what further action she might need to take and what to look out for. It’s assessing what level of threat Jane poses, and to whom.

If you mean impersonating her even ‘just’ for guarantor purposes is still bad, I agree.

Wheresthebeach · 27/02/2024 11:25

Craybourne · 27/02/2024 11:19

But OP offered to write the letter with different details – saying DB had been there temporarily with Jane – and Jane wasn’t happy with this.

If she just needed the signature she’d have just said – yes, great thanks.

Oh yeah...that's a fair point.

RedToothBrush · 27/02/2024 11:20

Lazydomestic · 27/02/2024 11:02

Most logical explanation is that she needs a guarantor to rent. Jane comes up with OP name and has been told that she needs proof of income / assets as well as signature. OP has said all financial details are well locked away - house valuation would give proof of assets…. Jane Set up new email address, & signs guarantor letter electronically & she satisfies conditions of the lease
But for being outed now if she payed rent on time - OP would never have known

Edited

All explanations lead to defrauding the OP and exposing her to financial loss. It doesn't ultimately matter how.

The second you impersonate someone you have criminal intent.

The rest doesn't really matter in practice.

Craybourne · 27/02/2024 11:19

Wheresthebeach · 27/02/2024 11:14

This makes sense. Much more likely than some attempt to gain control of the house. The letter she asked for would have a signature which she could scan/copy etc.

But OP offered to write the letter with different details – saying DB had been there temporarily with Jane – and Jane wasn’t happy with this.

If she just needed the signature she’d have just said – yes, great thanks.

Wheresthebeach · 27/02/2024 11:14

Lazydomestic · 27/02/2024 11:02

Most logical explanation is that she needs a guarantor to rent. Jane comes up with OP name and has been told that she needs proof of income / assets as well as signature. OP has said all financial details are well locked away - house valuation would give proof of assets…. Jane Set up new email address, & signs guarantor letter electronically & she satisfies conditions of the lease
But for being outed now if she payed rent on time - OP would never have known

Edited

This makes sense. Much more likely than some attempt to gain control of the house. The letter she asked for would have a signature which she could scan/copy etc.

Craybourne · 27/02/2024 11:06

Lazydomestic · 27/02/2024 11:02

Most logical explanation is that she needs a guarantor to rent. Jane comes up with OP name and has been told that she needs proof of income / assets as well as signature. OP has said all financial details are well locked away - house valuation would give proof of assets…. Jane Set up new email address, & signs guarantor letter electronically & she satisfies conditions of the lease
But for being outed now if she payed rent on time - OP would never have known

Edited

This does make sense, except for – why does she need a letter saying her ex is housed at the same address?

Lazydomestic · 27/02/2024 11:02

Most logical explanation is that she needs a guarantor to rent. Jane comes up with OP name and has been told that she needs proof of income / assets as well as signature. OP has said all financial details are well locked away - house valuation would give proof of assets…. Jane Set up new email address, & signs guarantor letter electronically & she satisfies conditions of the lease
But for being outed now if she payed rent on time - OP would never have known

Craybourne · 27/02/2024 11:01

diddl · 27/02/2024 10:15

But should an EA accept that scenario?

I think it’s understandable they did, given the ‘owner’ had already told them to expect someone else there.

Sorry-for some reason I was thinking if they hadn't been told presumably they wouldn't go in?

If it was looked into though it would be shown that Op hadn't phoned the EA at all wouldn't it?

Yes, by the sounds of it the EA wasn’t prepared to share data with the OP provided by the original enquirer

A few posters have suggested a SAR, possibly followed by calling the number anonymously

Craybourne · 27/02/2024 10:58

BusyMummy001 · 27/02/2024 10:49

Why? They did not own a previous property together (it states the purchase of their first joint property fell through, hence OP put them up), they are not married and are no longer ‘together’ anyway now, and the children (who were with their father this last weekend) are not his? They have no joint assets as and she has no claim on anything of his. His housing status is an irrelevance to her financial position.

The only plausible explanation is the intention to commit fraud.

But she could just be ill informed or clutching at straws

Craybourne · 27/02/2024 10:57

BoogieBoogieWoogie · 27/02/2024 10:31

Hhhmmm....if there's doorbell footage of the EA leaving then there's surely doorbell footage of the EA arriving which could help clear up a lot of this thread's pearl clutching

😒

??

libbylane · 27/02/2024 10:54

I'd give no letter and ask her to leave. I'd also make sure she hasn't taken any paperwork. Any chance your brother owns some of the house? I'd have her leave pronto.

BusyMummy001 · 27/02/2024 10:49

Barney60 · 27/02/2024 10:29

Mumofteenandtween · 25/02/2024 16:30

It seems obvious to me - she wants to be able today “Fred is adequately housed in a house worth £XXX. Therefore I should get most / all our joint assets to house me and the children.”

I also think this.

Why? They did not own a previous property together (it states the purchase of their first joint property fell through, hence OP put them up), they are not married and are no longer ‘together’ anyway now, and the children (who were with their father this last weekend) are not his? They have no joint assets as and she has no claim on anything of his. His housing status is an irrelevance to her financial position.

The only plausible explanation is the intention to commit fraud.

BoogieBoogieWoogie · 27/02/2024 10:31

Hhhmmm....if there's doorbell footage of the EA leaving then there's surely doorbell footage of the EA arriving which could help clear up a lot of this thread's pearl clutching

😒

Barney60 · 27/02/2024 10:29

Mumofteenandtween · 25/02/2024 16:30

It seems obvious to me - she wants to be able today “Fred is adequately housed in a house worth £XXX. Therefore I should get most / all our joint assets to house me and the children.”

I also think this.

starfishmummy · 27/02/2024 10:23

Notforbeef · 27/02/2024 09:12

Jesus, read the thread. Jane has gone.

Where has OP confirmed that Jane has gone?

She has said in an early post that

"I’ve spoken to my DB, sent him the footage and he’s going to deal with her so she won’t be coming back; the kids are currently with their dad anyway so all good on that front. DB will pack up their stuff and move it out and I’ll get the locks changed tomorrow too."

So the DB planned to do it, but has it actually happened?

diddl · 27/02/2024 10:15

But should an EA accept that scenario?

I think it’s understandable they did, given the ‘owner’ had already told them to expect someone else there.

Sorry-for some reason I was thinking if they hadn't been told presumably they wouldn't go in?

If it was looked into though it would be shown that Op hadn't phoned the EA at all wouldn't it?

Swipe left for the next trending thread