Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How to deal with nasty SIL suddenly become very rich

221 replies

User55567 · 25/02/2024 14:12

SIL (DHs sister) was very mean and bitter to us from Day1. DH and I have stable professional jobs and we worked very hard with zero family support. SIL didn’t have a job/ had no intentions of having one. She wanted to find a rich guy and just enjoy life. She spent 8 years on the hunt, while living with her parents. She then went back to uni for a masters, and then found a job straight after. This time she found a guy with “potential”. She married him and promptly quit her job and had 2 children.

All good, but all though these 15yrs of looking, finding and being with this guy, she constantly made snide remarks about our incomes, jobs, any thing nice we had, our holiday, everything. She constantly made in-laws put pressure on us to gift her things, while giving nothing in return. In-laws gave her property to “compensate”, bought her expensive things and constantly felt sorry for her and her “one income” lifestyle. Her husband once lost his job and still she won’t get a job saying “it’s his problem to sort out, I won’t take the stress”

She constantly told her brother about how her kids get a parent to look after them, about how bright her kids are etc, and how she “sacrificed” a career (she never had one!) because her kids mean more than money to her. All this while telling us we seem to have a lot of money because we both earn.

Now, her husband made a few million € in under a year as a small business he started as a side hustle really took off. She now can’t stop bragging and how she knew she is always meant for luxury, how she is the best wife (taking credit for his business success) and how her children are so lucky because they are set for life.. It seems to her like some “victory” over us. I already speak to her bare minimum - kept distance over the years.

DHs mental health is getting impacted over all these remarks and constant rubbing it in. He is now chasing “ideas” spending nights “researching” things. We already have very stressful jobs, I’m worried about him.

Wr are not poor, pretty comfortable but have salaries and mortgages like everyone else. We live a middle class life though and quite happy with it.

OP posts:
Josette77 · 27/02/2024 03:43

My brother is now a multimillionaire.
We aren't close, and to be honest he's a pretty big asshole, but I'm pretty proud of his business sense. He's smart and he always wanted to be rich. I'm happy for him.

Sounds like they had some hard years and those tough times are paying off. Just be happy for them. Sounds like things are turning around which is great for the kids.

Mumof3confused · 26/02/2024 22:14

His family dynamics seem very unhealthy and he would really benefit from some therapy to break free from the shackles.

GiselleRose · 26/02/2024 19:39

Just sounds as though the parents have completely indulged her and probably set their children up to compete with one another. She won’t change.

Just be glad that you value the right things, you work hard and appreciate the simple things in life, continue to teach this to your children. She sounds like a very uninteresting person to be around if her only conversation is to boast about how wonderful she is. Ask her about the last book she read as you are after a recommendation. Attempt to switch the conversation away from her shallow bragging.

ZombiesAreClammyDodgers · 26/02/2024 17:54

Vistada · 26/02/2024 09:10

"She carefully picks her social circle, where everyone is “less than” her. "

"something nasty is slipped into conversations every single time!"

OP, come on now, you can't miss the irony of these statements, surely.

Where is the irony here??

MandyRiceDavies · 26/02/2024 15:57

I think the issue here is less your SIL (who sounds annoying) and more your husband's reaction to her.

DHs mental health is getting impacted over all these remarks and constant rubbing it in. He is now chasing “ideas” spending nights “researching” things

This isn't a normal reaction to some saddo bragging about money. Sounds like you all need to disengage a bit and your husband needs to think about why it's affecting him so much.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 26/02/2024 15:53

SprinklesMcDoodles · 25/02/2024 14:22

She has achieved nothing for herself and it’ll come back to bite her in the future. She sounds like an absolute nightmare.

She has lovely and happy kids - I don't think that's 'nothing' op and this commenter are very judgmental and sound jealous

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 26/02/2024 15:52

Guavafish1 · 25/02/2024 14:16

Can't you both just ignore her?

Absolutely !
You can't blame your dh's mental health struggle and jealousy on her. If you don't like her don't have meet ups with her or set a boundary about entering into discussions
About finances- it's on you to set the boundaries

sandyhappypeople · 26/02/2024 10:28

User55567 · 26/02/2024 09:39

She wants me to stay these kind of things. She’ll start drama about how I find faults with everything she says and how she is always walking on eggshells around me.

Well then you're not doing it properly then, the best way to do it is to publicly shame her for making those comments as soon as she makes them.

loud voice: 'What do you mean you don't think my kids are as clever as yours?' 'what a horrible thing for an auntie to say!'

Just call her out on it, but DON'T get angry about it, if she says 'I'm walking on eggshells' then just say with a smile: 'well you wouldn't be if you kept you're snotty opinions to yourself in the first place' make a joke of it, and laugh when you say it like it's the most ridiculous thing you've ever heard: 'what do you want me to do just sit here quietly while you insult my husband and kids?!!'

You need to either grey rock/ignore and be happy with that (which you're obviously not), or just TELL HER! For your husbands and children's sake I'd just tell her personally, but take the piss out of her rather than shout at her, she bullies you and him and your children and you let her.

Carpediemmakeitcount · 26/02/2024 09:46

I have a family member who talks out of their arse. I travelled a long way for an event and when we arrived at the venue the level of conversation was tedious. She was talking about what her neighbours have expensive hairdryers and designer clothes, okay anything else. Some people are simple minded and only focus on material. I am very low contact with her I can't bare it.

User55567 · 26/02/2024 09:39

HAF1119 · 26/02/2024 07:43

Ah I'd just deal with it upfront every time

If in front of your children saying hers are luckier than yours 'would you mind not saying that where the children can hear you? I want them to not focus on materialistic things or feel your children are better than them'

If she's just hashing out the same brags over and over 'it feels like you're trying to put down my life, I really am glad you have/do XYZ, but I don't want to be put down for not living the same life as you, we are happy as we are and always hope you are happy too'

She wants me to stay these kind of things. She’ll start drama about how I find faults with everything she says and how she is always walking on eggshells around me.

OP posts:
Vistada · 26/02/2024 09:10

"She carefully picks her social circle, where everyone is “less than” her. "

"something nasty is slipped into conversations every single time!"

OP, come on now, you can't miss the irony of these statements, surely.

SapphOhNo · 26/02/2024 08:53

You're going her and MIL too much of your bandwidth.

Go low contact, do it for your kids and your DH and get on with your otherwise happy stable life. Take their power away.

Janetime · 26/02/2024 08:49

Calliopespa · 26/02/2024 07:49

Imagine being the poor husband though. He was probably under enormous pressure to generate more income for this SIL who “ knew” she was “ meant “ for luxury. Who knows how he’s done it or if it might open up cans of worms . It could be fine . Sometimes side hustles throw up issues.

However, none of this impacts ( or should impact) on you or DH. As you were: keep calm and carry on.

Cmon now. I’m fairly positive the husband and rhe sil would have a very different take on this from the op who dislikes her sil and is envious. Potentially even that’s why the ops husband is doing what he is, as the op is so envious. Who knows. Only one thing is absolutely certain, if the sil and husband put their version down it would be very different indeed.

vincettenoir · 26/02/2024 08:02

It does sound both of you are giving this way too much headspace. Hopefully this is just your way of adjusting to the new dynamic and once you have got your head around it, it won't provoke such strong feelings in you.

Calliopespa · 26/02/2024 07:49

BigFluffyHoodie · 25/02/2024 14:26

You can choose to ignore her. You are happy with your life.

However, it sounds like your husband is jealous. He's probably feeling inferior against her husband. Especially as she keeps going on about it. And, TBH, he has earned his own money with his side hustle.

Imagine being the poor husband though. He was probably under enormous pressure to generate more income for this SIL who “ knew” she was “ meant “ for luxury. Who knows how he’s done it or if it might open up cans of worms . It could be fine . Sometimes side hustles throw up issues.

However, none of this impacts ( or should impact) on you or DH. As you were: keep calm and carry on.

Chouette77 · 26/02/2024 07:46

I have someone similar in my family. It's exhausting and can get you down. No advice but solidarity!

HAF1119 · 26/02/2024 07:43

Ah I'd just deal with it upfront every time

If in front of your children saying hers are luckier than yours 'would you mind not saying that where the children can hear you? I want them to not focus on materialistic things or feel your children are better than them'

If she's just hashing out the same brags over and over 'it feels like you're trying to put down my life, I really am glad you have/do XYZ, but I don't want to be put down for not living the same life as you, we are happy as we are and always hope you are happy too'

misskatamari · 26/02/2024 07:42

You can't change her, so i would go minimal contact. DH though, he must have a lot of past wounds from this. Would he consider therapy to address this? Or even do some inner work privately, to help him work through his emotions. E.g. Nicole LePera's "how to do the work" book is very helpful in dealing with difficult family relationships. It will be easier for you to deal with SIL as you don't have the years of dealing with her in your formative years, and the favouritism/unfair parental treatment. It might not be something DH wants to consider, I know alas many men still aren't as open to such things, thats to how society has raised them, but he could probably find a way to a lot of emotional freedom and peace if he is willing to look deeper and address the emotions he will have to have supressed growing up with this dynamic.

puzzledout · 26/02/2024 07:32

Grey rock? 🪨

User55567 · 26/02/2024 07:21

Frenchmartini02 · 25/02/2024 18:35

Just have minimal contact with her. I have a SIL a bit like this. She relishes when things go wrong for me/DH, bitches about all family members & other SIL, is a real tight arse - she once stole the tip I'd left on the table after we'd eaten at a restaurant. She sucks up to FIL because she thinks he will "leave her more money in his will". Fortunately I don't live near her and so I only see her once a year and take the grey rock approach.

I think we have the same SIL ! 😂

OP posts:
User55567 · 26/02/2024 07:19

Anonymouseposter · 25/02/2024 22:29

There’s a strange dynamic in your husband’s family which has him and his sister competing with each other and you have jumped straight into it making it worse. Try to ignore her and enjoy your own life. Tell your husband to try to do the same. Build him up, don’t make him feel worse. If he can’t break out of this pattern he needs help with it. Odd too that his parents were pressuring him to give her things. He needs to create a bit of emotional distance and enjoy his own life. Tell him that you have enough and prefer his company to him spending time looking for ways to make more money. Detach- live and let live

Thank you. I had a conversation about this last night.

OP posts:
User55567 · 26/02/2024 07:18

Dont get me wrong, I don’t want their money to go away or her marriage to break. I just want her to shut up (and happily enjoy her life). I have nothing against her choices in life, honestly. She has been incredibly lucky!

For her, having something nice is not good enough. It has to be better than what others around her have. She carefully picks her social circle, where everyone is “less than” her. What she doesn’t realise is, there will be other dimensions in which these people will be better than her. Manners for example!
But with family, you can’t make that choice. For many years I put up with a lot of snide remarks for having a normal life with come comforts. It felt and still feels as if she’ll be satisfied or happy if something horrible happens to us. Now that they are significantly wealthier, I hoped she will shut up and look elsewhere for her dose of sulking, but no ! She now wants to extract juice by telling me how lucky/smart she/her DH and her kids are! Small remark, big brag, looking down at others, something nasty is slipped into conversations every single time!

OP posts:
Heathers4evs · 25/02/2024 23:11

I think you need ask her about the new house/car/holiday home she's buying for your PIL, and when she says she's not going to say you thought she was well off now but realise that MIL was exaggerating and it's all on tick. And if she says she really is rich, ask her when she's getting them the house/car/holiday home.

It will make it less fun for her to boast about her good fortune.

Anonymouseposter · 25/02/2024 22:29

There’s a strange dynamic in your husband’s family which has him and his sister competing with each other and you have jumped straight into it making it worse. Try to ignore her and enjoy your own life. Tell your husband to try to do the same. Build him up, don’t make him feel worse. If he can’t break out of this pattern he needs help with it. Odd too that his parents were pressuring him to give her things. He needs to create a bit of emotional distance and enjoy his own life. Tell him that you have enough and prefer his company to him spending time looking for ways to make more money. Detach- live and let live

TheSnakeCharmer · 25/02/2024 22:24

It would be extraordinarily unlikely that they were actually as well off as you think. The company and it's assets may well be valued at that amount on paper right now. They might have been temporarily lucky with a sudden income stream last year which has lead to a predictive company valuation based upon that figure. Unless they were to sell off their company, they will not have millions of pounds. And it would be unlikely that someone would make a decent offer on such a newly established unproven business. Also, through personal experience growing up, my parents owned several seemingly successful businesses. We were either flush with cash or stony broke and homeless. Running or owning a business comes with lots of risks. It can be just as easy to suddenly run up huge debts and become bankrupt.

She also had to live with her parents for 8 years. No amount of money can be worth that, surely?!

Just enjoy your life, which sounds better and more stable than hers in any event.