Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we don’t need that much food

243 replies

Moonpiecake · 25/02/2024 11:19

I feel portions in restaurants and takeaways are bigger than most of adults need and also majority of people buy and eat more food than is necessary for our bodies.

If you are over 30, fit, healthy and manage to remain within the healthy body weight for your age and height how much do to eat.

I want to save money on food but also loose a few kilos and look and feel good so looking for advice

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
NotARealWookiie · 25/02/2024 14:47

Yes you should have 5 portions of fruit/veg a day. I think the research actually said 7 but it’s marketed as 5 as easier to achieve.

Most people do need 3 meals a day yes.

Maybe just start thinking of the fruit/veg as the focus of the meal. People tend to over do protein and carbs.

caringcarer · 25/02/2024 14:45

I only ever managed half my Chinese meal. They are huge portions. We order 2 meals between 3 now. There is plenty for all 3 of us. I think portions have got larger over time.

Seasonofthesticks · 25/02/2024 14:31

1600 cals a day is a good ballpark. It’s surprising how much food that is when you’re packing fruit and veg into your diet

babybons · 25/02/2024 14:26

I don't believe anyone spends £10 a week on food.

one 2kg bag potatoes, 1 bag apples, I loaf of bread, I tin beans, I block cheese, 2lts milk, 6 eggs from ASDA is £9.68 (cheapest options too)

Now you could get creative with those ingredients, possibly stretch them out. No way on this earth is it going to make 21 meals!!

I live alone, I'm super frugal with my food budget, but unless you are eating porridge with water for breakfast, toast with one egg for lunch and a baked potato with cheese every night. I don't believe you spent £10 a week. Well yes you could, but it's not healthy food!

The cost of fresh items is eye watering, I grow a lot of food and I eat incredibly well all summer, I preserve and freeze, I forage. I have fruit trees etc, but in winter, it's a lot more expensive to eat fresh fruit and veg. A cucumber is 80p now, tomatoes, even tasteless ones are 90p. No one can eat well on £1.30 a day.

kitsuneghost · 25/02/2024 14:25

A restaurant can't tailor make tor everyone coming in.
Do you suggest they give men bigger portions.
What if the woman is bigger than the man
Do they know if I have a big appetite, small appetite
Do they know if I have eaten another 2 meals that day or if this is my only meal of the day
Do they know if I have an active or sedentary job

Just take the portion. If you want more order more. If you want less then leave some.

Lumiodes · 25/02/2024 14:25

Yes portions are usually too big. But if restaurants gave people smaller portions they’d have to reduce prices, and they don’t want to do that. It’s easier to make a profit from selling 10 people £20 worth of food each, rather than selling 20 people £10 worth of food each. They always give you huge piles of cheap carbs too - because it makes the meals look bigger (and therefore better value) but doesn’t cost a lot.

Kalevala · 25/02/2024 14:22

I'm 5ft 5 and eat around 2000 calories. Three meals or two meals and a snack, it depends what I'm doing. I eat whole foods, full fat everything. Lots of eggs, small servings of meat (things like curry, chilli, bolognese, keema, casserole), about five serves of veg including fermented, two of fruit, usually two recommended serving sizes for grains a day, kefir, greek yogurt.

Moonpiecake · 25/02/2024 14:22

We don’t eat out much and do the rare take away of fish and chips, 2 to share between 4.

I am 50 and feel I need to eat very little to not put on weight

OP posts:
LeavingRightNow · 25/02/2024 14:18

RampantIvy · 25/02/2024 14:01

I agree about portion sizes when eating out. It's one of the reasons we rarely eat out these days. When we do we just have a main.

We went out for an Indian the other day. DH and I had a main course each then shared one portion of rice and one naan between us. We didn't finish the rice or the naan. We didn't have poppadums or a starter.

We aren't competitive undereaters, we just can't manage huge portions these days.

Is it age-related? I could eat more at 25 than I can at 55. The portions might be just fine for a 21y old active man. Restaurants can’t cater for all appetites I guess.

LeavingRightNow · 25/02/2024 14:14

I eat much more when I am out for dinner. I am slim but good to know staff are judging me!

LeavingRightNow · 25/02/2024 14:13

i don’t think most people need as much as they eat. But food brings pleasure so here we are 🤷🏼‍♀️

Lourdes12 · 25/02/2024 14:02

Kids portions are usually enough for me but I’m petite and weigh 50 kg

RampantIvy · 25/02/2024 14:01

I agree about portion sizes when eating out. It's one of the reasons we rarely eat out these days. When we do we just have a main.

We went out for an Indian the other day. DH and I had a main course each then shared one portion of rice and one naan between us. We didn't finish the rice or the naan. We didn't have poppadums or a starter.

We aren't competitive undereaters, we just can't manage huge portions these days.

midgetastic · 25/02/2024 13:58

Different people need different things

I work best on 3 meals and multiple snacks , I need lots of veg , meat about once a week

The difference between me being a stable weight and gaining would be the equivalent of one slice of dry toast a day - that would be around a stone a year in weight gain - so it's unlikely there are huge savings to be made by eating less

You save more by eating wisely
I eat loads of veg - but it's often cheap veg , seasonal or frozen

Moonpiecake · 25/02/2024 13:57

Ladamesansmerci · 25/02/2024 13:35

Some poor advice on this thread. Absolutely do not eat only 500kcals/day. It's FAR too few. That's how people end up developing disordered eating. Genuinely, I work in mental health services, and a lot of people with anorexia aspire to 500kcals a day. Rapid weight loss is not good for you. Healthy weight loss is only 1-2 lbs a week. You will lose more initially if you're bigger as your water weight comes off.

I'm 5"1 and lead a sedentary life and my maintenance kcals (e.g. how much you yourself burn in a day doing nothing) is 1500. I loose at about 1200. For most people, this is too few, unless you're tiny like me and don't do any exercise. I personally don't eat breakfast because I'd rather have a larger evening meal. For most people though, a light breakfast is part of a normal day and most research backs up that breakfast is good for you and keeps you fuller throughout the day.

Carbs are also absolutely not bad for you. It's a modern myth. You need carbs for energy as part of a healthy diet. There are plenty of very healthy carbs, like wholegrain rice, sweet potato, etc. Diets like keto work because proteins/veggies generally have less calories so people naturally eat fewer kcals. Healthy fats are also great for you, like a handful of nuts, a bit of cheese, etc.

5 fruit/veg a day is a good target, but in reality it's better to have more like 7-10. It's easier to get them in than you think by blending onions/carrots into pasta sauce, throwing an extra handful of greens into whatever you're eating.

I personally eat tons, but I volume eat veggies! You're right that portions of pasta etc are very large now, but 50g of pasta will feel like nothing unless you bulk it out. If you cut carbs portions a little, and bulk it with things like a handful of nuts, veggies, pulses, etc, it will be less kcals but will be as filling.

Lots of wholefoods is generally the way to go.

And honestly, I wouldn't worry what you're eating in a restaurant. Pleas go out and enjoy your meal. Life is too short to be calorie counting the massive steak and chips you had out for a birthday. A giant portion every now and then won't kill you, not will a bit of chocolate, some processed foods etc.

Just do you. Eat a generally healthy diet, and don't worry if you have a fish and chip night on a Friday. If two larger meals a day or lots of smaller ones work better for you, do it.

But please, don't think eating 500kcals a day is normal because it really isn't.

No way I could eat 500calories per day.

I am also 5’’1 and agree reg 1500 maintenance calories and 1200 if I want to loose weight. I do a bit of excercise but not enough

OP posts:
HelpMeGetThrough · 25/02/2024 13:54

£20 a week for 3 meals 7 dasy a week for 2 people? 🤔

Are you in training to star on "Eat Well for Less"?

notacooldad · 25/02/2024 13:51

Just to add to my post, I'm a 58 year old woman going through the menopause.
I'm not worrying about plate size, I have cut out virtually all upf's and have food in the way it originally looks as much as possible, eg a potato boiled rather than a packet of crisps and I eat until I'm full.

MerryChristmasToYou · 25/02/2024 13:50

@Caffeineislife , ah! Thanks for explaining.
Over the whole day is a different matter. The potato would be doable if it was a miniature one. Smile

I like pigging out if I have a meal out but I only do it about once a year, and I'm another 'one meal a day' person.

Generally, it's a veg-based meal and a large one.

Beautiful3 · 25/02/2024 13:48

RazzleDazz1e · 25/02/2024 11:32

Why don’t you just try a few things and see if they work for you? E.g. try 500 cals per day for a week and if you’re hungry eat more. Try 1000 cals and see if you lose weight. There’s no collective ‘we’ in any of this. Different people eat different amounts for different reasons, and see different effects. My sister eats like a horse (think 3 big meals and endless snacks) and maintains her weight at 55kg. I eat 1500 cals per day and maintain my weight at 75kg.

That's terrible advice to give! I do 1200 daily to lose weight, and the calories are enough for me. But when I was fasting 3 times a week on 800 calories, I was insanely hungry. So I can't imagine how anyone is going to survive on 500 per day?!

notacooldad · 25/02/2024 13:47

Do we need 5 pieces of fruit and vegetables? Do we need 3 meals per day or can we do we 2? Snacks? Carbohydrates? Do we need to eat little and often?

I aim for 30 plants a week erring more on veg, seeds, nuts, spices , herbs andgrains rather than fruit.
If I have filling meals I don't need to snack.
Re carbs , I have stopped as much as I can eating refined cards, so no cake, biscuits, sweets etc but do eat sweet potatoes, lentils etc.
I like to have a large breakfast of greek yogurt, nuts, seeds, and berries and have one or two small meals for the rest of the day.
I drink water at home.
I've been doing this for a few months and I definitely feel and look better. I have good skin anyway but I don't look as tired. I'm sleeping better and I feel more positive. My mood had dropped and was low before this.

betterangels · 25/02/2024 13:47

idontlikealdi · 25/02/2024 11:36

£80 per month? Seriously?!

Can't be serious. If it is, I want to know how In this economy.

Gwenhwyfar · 25/02/2024 13:46

"And honestly, I wouldn't worry what you're eating in a restaurant. Pleas go out and enjoy your meal. Life is too short to be calorie counting the massive steak and chips you had out for a birthday. A giant portion every now and then won't kill you, not will a bit of chocolate, some processed foods etc."

You have to realise that some people eat out pretty often when you include cafe lunches during the working day or needing to eat something between work and an activity. It's not just birthdays!

InnocentAndDeranged · 25/02/2024 13:45

Laughingfaceemoji · 25/02/2024 11:27

It’s hard re portions because everyone eats such different amounts. In a pub for example if I get burger or steak it normally come with chips, chances are I can’t manage them but then DP will hoover his and my leftovers.

We cook everything fresh and there’s normally enough from tea to do lunches too. We spend on average £80pm on food for two people. 3 solid, good quality meals a day.

£20 a week for 3 meals 7 dasy a week for 2 people? 🤔

NerdWhoEatsMedlar · 25/02/2024 13:44

It is impossible to know what women eat.

Most research agrees that the average normal weight woman reports eating 1,700ish calories but when you check with doubly labeled water they are actually eating 2,250. Even dieticians have somewhat of a discrepancy between what they eat and what they report.

No researcher can find the mythical MNer who puts on weight at any more than 1,200 calories.

Gwenhwyfar · 25/02/2024 13:44

KnittedCardi · 25/02/2024 13:34

I never finish a restaurant meal. It's crazy. I tend to eat just meat/fish and veg, or salad, but even then the portions are still huge. Calves
liver, a good example, and one if my favourites, three slices, three, really!? I would love for less, and be charged less. My restaurant owner friend says that the most complained about things, is not enough food! There are some very greedy people out there.

Some restaurants encourage that greed though with 'all you can eat' type pricing.

Swipe left for the next trending thread