Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we don’t need that much food

243 replies

Moonpiecake · 25/02/2024 11:19

I feel portions in restaurants and takeaways are bigger than most of adults need and also majority of people buy and eat more food than is necessary for our bodies.

If you are over 30, fit, healthy and manage to remain within the healthy body weight for your age and height how much do to eat.

I want to save money on food but also loose a few kilos and look and feel good so looking for advice

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
WtP · 25/02/2024 17:18

ShinyAppleDreamingOfTheSea · 25/02/2024 17:16

I'm pretty sure that the poster who said she spent £80 pm on food actually meant £80 per week - yet every other poster has picked up on this !

That said - my FIL used to spend around £7 on his weekly food from Asda . He had plenty of money but being frugal was everything to him and he had no interest in food beyond it being basic fuel .

She's already been back on to say that should have been per week

ShinyAppleDreamingOfTheSea · 25/02/2024 17:16

babybons · 25/02/2024 14:26

I don't believe anyone spends £10 a week on food.

one 2kg bag potatoes, 1 bag apples, I loaf of bread, I tin beans, I block cheese, 2lts milk, 6 eggs from ASDA is £9.68 (cheapest options too)

Now you could get creative with those ingredients, possibly stretch them out. No way on this earth is it going to make 21 meals!!

I live alone, I'm super frugal with my food budget, but unless you are eating porridge with water for breakfast, toast with one egg for lunch and a baked potato with cheese every night. I don't believe you spent £10 a week. Well yes you could, but it's not healthy food!

The cost of fresh items is eye watering, I grow a lot of food and I eat incredibly well all summer, I preserve and freeze, I forage. I have fruit trees etc, but in winter, it's a lot more expensive to eat fresh fruit and veg. A cucumber is 80p now, tomatoes, even tasteless ones are 90p. No one can eat well on £1.30 a day.

I'm pretty sure that the poster who said she spent £80 pm on food actually meant £80 per week - yet every other poster has picked up on this !

That said - my FIL used to spend around £7 on his weekly food from Asda . He had plenty of money but being frugal was everything to him and he had no interest in food beyond it being basic fuel .

MikeRafone · 25/02/2024 17:12

Moonpiecake · 25/02/2024 11:19

I feel portions in restaurants and takeaways are bigger than most of adults need and also majority of people buy and eat more food than is necessary for our bodies.

If you are over 30, fit, healthy and manage to remain within the healthy body weight for your age and height how much do to eat.

I want to save money on food but also loose a few kilos and look and feel good so looking for advice

ready meals come in a sensible portion size - purchase Tupperwares the same size as a standard ready meal box and meal prep

AhBiscuits · 25/02/2024 17:09

Calories on menus has been quite eye opening. I met someone at a skanky chain pub for lunch recently. They had one main course on the menu that was under 1000 calories. Many were closer to 2000 and some more than that. Way more than my whole day's calorie needs in a single meal.

Sadza · 25/02/2024 17:08

If you eat a mainly unprocessed diet rich in fruit, veg and beans it’s unlikely you will put on weight. If you’re eating from restaurants and takeaways the food is calorie dense and you can eat much much less of it

MoreDangerousThanAWomanScorned · 25/02/2024 17:01

BlueMongoose · 25/02/2024 15:37

Our favourite pub does smaller portions for a little less on some options, which is brilliant. I wish they'd do it on all of them, even if it cost the same, I hate wasting food or being tempted into overeating.
And why can't an adult get a child's option meal, or a child's size portion if they want to?

Because restaurants and pubs usually lose money on the kids' meals, but are happy with that because children are accompanied by adults buying full meals. They don't want adults buying children's meals for themselves because it means they won't make any profit at all, or indeed a loss, on that table.

Lassiata · 25/02/2024 16:56

"Adults don't need carbs" ffs.

ThereIbledit · 25/02/2024 16:50

Moonpiecake · 25/02/2024 11:26

Not sure exactly what I need so looking for advice.

Do we need 5 pieces of fruit and vegetables? Do we need 3 meals per day or can we do we 2? Snacks? Carbohydrates? Do we need to eat little and often?

Please don't rely on anonymous strangers on the internet for dietary advice.

Jabberwonky · 25/02/2024 16:49

People in the 60s and 70s were much slimmer but the recommended daily calorie intake hasn't changed much since then.

In those days, you were lucky to have a car . If you did then it was usually used by 'the man of the house' to get to work.
Women rarely drove and walked to the shops, school, see friends etc...
Most children walked to school.
Walking everywhere was a normal daily activity.

Much work was manual too.

Now, we drive everywhere even to school ( yes it's different if you're very rural or go to a private school) and so many physical jobs have gone . Added to that there are so very many people now who wfh and can barely bring themselves to get dressed in the mornings ( the average school run clearly displays this!) and so many that go to work in sedentary jobs that the recommended daily calorie intake should really be reduced.

Gwenhwyfar · 25/02/2024 16:46

NerdWhoEatsMedlar · 25/02/2024 16:36

Interest groups like WHO and NHS

The 5 is a British recommendation, not the WHOs. Many other countries recommend more fruit and veg.

The alcohol recommendations also vary by country and change quite a lot with time. They're not set in stone.

WtP · 25/02/2024 16:41

It's such a tangled web of information out there that you can get caught up in some really odd diets.
Case in point is my sister & I, both of the same parents but wildly different in size!
We are both tall, 6' in her case and 6'3" in mine, as children I was the skinny one who was teased about it as well which probably led to some body image issues.
Cue us in our 50's she's now the skinny one and I have "filled out"

The big differences are job & diet. She's an organic farmer who probably has 10+ portions of veg a day & I'm a part time facility's manager.
We both love cooking but hers is after a very active day mine less so!
What I have found works for me is 16/8 fasting, but you do have to drink plenty of water as well to keep the hunger pangs away till lunch time.
Also several previous posters have spoken about weight training, this is very important as many of us loose muscle tone in later life & that's what helps with general physical health if we can restrict it. Plus muscles require more calories to keep functioning, so just keep lifting things will really help.

Iamuhtredsonofuhtred · 25/02/2024 16:38

I’m 41, I am 5’3” and a size 8; my weight is normally 8st 11-9st.

This is a standard days food for me, I work 12 hour shifts so take it all with me. Breakfast is overnight oats with berries, lunch is a sweet potato, kale and lentil curry and dinner is mixed bean, tuna and tomato salad, with a raw fruit and nut bar, and apple for snacks. I only really drink black coffee, water and Diet Coke. I rarely drink alcohol, rarely eat meat, don’t eat much bread, tend to eat brown rice etc. I do however eat too much sugar, but because my meals are basically healthy it doesn’t seem to affect my weight too much.

I run 5k twice a week and do 30 mins of barre around 4 nights a week. I can eat around 1900kcals a day and maintain my current weight as I am pretty active (job where I’m on my feet all day), but the meals in the photo come to about 1600 cals as I’m going on holiday soon!

To think we don’t need that much food
NerdWhoEatsMedlar · 25/02/2024 16:36

PToosher · 25/02/2024 16:28

5 pieces of fruit or veg a day is one of those numbers made up by interest groups, like the recommended alcohol units per week.

Interest groups like WHO and NHS

RampantIvy · 25/02/2024 16:33

PToosher · 25/02/2024 16:28

5 pieces of fruit or veg a day is one of those numbers made up by interest groups, like the recommended alcohol units per week.

The "interest group" as far as alcohol is concenred is the NHS.

Is it age-related? I could eat more at 25 than I can at 55. The portions might be just fine for a 21y old active man. Restaurants can’t cater for all appetites I guess.

I think you are right @LeavingRightNow. At 25 (and two dress sizes smaller) I would have eaten everything plus a starter. Not now. Thank goodness my appetite has decreased with age or I would be the size of a house.

If it helps, I find an m&s ready meal for 1 is plenty for 2 meals.

Now that is competitive undereating. Their portion sizes aren't that big.

PToosher · 25/02/2024 16:28

5 pieces of fruit or veg a day is one of those numbers made up by interest groups, like the recommended alcohol units per week.

Gwenhwyfar · 25/02/2024 16:14

HangingOver · 25/02/2024 14:49

I feel portions in restaurants and takeaways are bigger than most of adults need

Doesn't matter for most people since usually a meal out or takeaway is a treat. No big deal.

Not everyone in the world is a MNer with small children who never goes out. Plenty of people eat out every weekend (including cafes and pubs) and also during the week for work lunches.

Gwenhwyfar · 25/02/2024 16:11

NotARealWookiie · 25/02/2024 14:47

Yes you should have 5 portions of fruit/veg a day. I think the research actually said 7 but it’s marketed as 5 as easier to achieve.

Most people do need 3 meals a day yes.

Maybe just start thinking of the fruit/veg as the focus of the meal. People tend to over do protein and carbs.

No, it's not true that people need 3 meals a day!

Gwenhwyfar · 25/02/2024 16:09

"Do you suggest they give men bigger portions.
What if the woman is bigger than the man"

It's not about height - presuming that's what you mean by 'bigger'. Men have more muscle than women. In general, yes, men should be eating more. Various portion sizes would be good and the portions in general shouldn't be as big, it's a recent trend to have massive portions. Fine dining restaurants still have reasonable portions, but then people feel they're not getting value for money because they're so used to the massive portions.

Gwenhwyfar · 25/02/2024 16:06

Lourdes12 · 25/02/2024 14:02

Kids portions are usually enough for me but I’m petite and weigh 50 kg

There are days when a kids portion would be good for me too, but the places I go to don't allow it.

Chocoholic900 · 25/02/2024 16:04

What I've found work for me over the years...

On a workday having porridge for breakfast (topped with nuts & seeds) fills me up and keeps me going. If I have cereal or toast I tend to get so hungry in the evenings and just want to snack.

I weigh out portions of rice and pasta (2oz per adult) as otherwise I just pour and guess and over estimate and then over eat.

I eat breakfast, lunch & dinner and then in between only if I'm really hungry and after I've had a drink have a snack. I've found when I usually had a snack in the past I wasn't hungry I was either thirsty, bored, or just wanted a sweet treat but wasn't eating for hunger. (I used to snack A LOT)

I try to eat as little ultra-processed food as possible, though it is hard!

I have little to no self control with chocolate so I just don't have it in the cupboards, I know if I buy it I'll just eat 3 chocolate bars in a evening or an entire sharing bag in one go. Instead I buy myself a chocolate treat once a week and then have it over the weekend. Once it's gone it's gone vs bulk buying sweet treats and thinking I'll have 1 a day and never do.

I eat around 1,300-1,500 calories a day.

I do eat out, but only occasionally, but the portion sizes are always too big. I don't feel I have to eat it all though. Often stop eating the main even when I could eat more to squeeze in a dessert!

WinterDeWinter · 25/02/2024 15:59

Itisnearlyspring · 25/02/2024 15:44

This. By strength training I have also increased the amount of calories I eat to maintain weight by about 400 from 1500 to around 1900. Muscle is metabolically active and will burn calories even at rest.

I also think changing what you eat helps a lot. Not all calories are the same and are metabolised by the gut differently. I eat min 30g fibre and reduced starchy carbs and zero upf.

This is fascinating - the idea that you can generally eat more if you're more muscular, and not simply in order to fuel the addition of muscle. I'm 56 and have gradually put on weight - I'm having real trouble losing using the methods that have previously worked for me (slight calorie reduction, fewer carbs, more veg, very little alcohol.) But I know I have lost muscle for eg in my legs, because it's taking me more energy to get up the stairs/get up from the floor etc.

twingiraffes · 25/02/2024 15:54

Moonpiecake · 25/02/2024 11:26

Not sure exactly what I need so looking for advice.

Do we need 5 pieces of fruit and vegetables? Do we need 3 meals per day or can we do we 2? Snacks? Carbohydrates? Do we need to eat little and often?

If you're looking to lose weight and save money, basic vegetables are a lot cheaper than some other ingredients. Eat loads of veg. Fills you up and very good for your digestive system and gut health as well.

Itisnearlyspring · 25/02/2024 15:44

Dentistlakes · 25/02/2024 15:35

I eat 2250 calories per day, but I exercise 6 days a week (weights x5). Before I started lifting weights I would put on weight eating 1400 calories.

It’s very easy to overeat, especially if you eat out regularly. You really have no idea how much you’re eating, even if you go by the calories on the menu (they are very inaccurate). It’s not very surprising so many people are overweight.

This. By strength training I have also increased the amount of calories I eat to maintain weight by about 400 from 1500 to around 1900. Muscle is metabolically active and will burn calories even at rest.

I also think changing what you eat helps a lot. Not all calories are the same and are metabolised by the gut differently. I eat min 30g fibre and reduced starchy carbs and zero upf.

Workaholic99 · 25/02/2024 15:41

Moonpiecake · 25/02/2024 11:19

I feel portions in restaurants and takeaways are bigger than most of adults need and also majority of people buy and eat more food than is necessary for our bodies.

If you are over 30, fit, healthy and manage to remain within the healthy body weight for your age and height how much do to eat.

I want to save money on food but also loose a few kilos and look and feel good so looking for advice

If it helps, I find an m&s ready meal for 1 is plenty for 2 meals. Also I only eat deserts on weekends. I completely agree, portion sizes are insane these days.

I once read that 30 pieces of fruit, veg, nuts a week is better and more cost effective than 5 pieces of fruit and veg a day.