Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Concerned about women's rights? "Transphobe, far right!". Concerned about Palestinians? "Terrorist sympathiser! anti semite!"

83 replies

changefromhr · 25/02/2024 08:07

Tiresome.

OP posts:
FrancescaContini · 25/02/2024 11:23

Haven’t RTFT but agree with you, OP. It’s very tiresome.

IwishIcouldfinishabook · 25/02/2024 11:21

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 25/02/2024 10:47

No

But 99.99999 etc sexual assaults on women and girls are by male perpetrators and the offending pattern of an individual remains the same even after so called "transition "

Also, statistically, 6% of men are sex offenders. But if we are looking at prison populations for example, about 50% of MtF trans prisoners are sex offenders. The trans community is made up of about 0.01% of the population. So are sex offenders 'self identifying' as women to get access to women's spaces? That seems likely, as they are more likely to be sex offenders than trans. The trans rights movement has caused problems for themselves with their 'no debate' stance because if, as they said at the start, 'If a person says they are a woman, believe them' then they cant then turn round and say Isla Bryson isn't a real Transwoman, because s/he is, according to their own rules. They wanted 'no debate' which means they didn't want anyone to point out flaws in their own argument. So when those obvious flaws start appearing, they have now got nowhere to go. Because they thought men issuing death and rape threats against women who didnt agree with them was a good alternative to debate and discussion. This is all on the TRA movement, Stonewall and Mermaids.

IDontHateRainbows · 25/02/2024 11:20

midgetastic · 25/02/2024 09:23

Well every man has the necessary tools which women don't?

Potential doesn't mean "thinks they are a rapist"

You have exactly the polarised thinking the op was talking about

Every man is a potential rapist.... jeez

Puzzledandpissedoff · 25/02/2024 10:57

MidnightPatrol · 25/02/2024 08:25

Unfortunately we live in an era in which there can apparently be no nuance in debate.

Driven by IMO, the necessity for everything to be in soundbites (how can you explain the relative challenges in Israel / Palestine in a single sentence?) - and the way in which social media / media in general has created these reinforcing echo chambers full of anonymous (and often extreme) voices.

I would however see that I broadly only see this online and among younger people - real life conversations I have on these sensitive topics are generally pretty reasonable and balanced / can appreciate multiple perspectives.

Beautifully put

A useful indicator is to see how long it takes the more thoughtless to offer something they found on Twitter and the like ... I guarantee it won't be long

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 25/02/2024 10:47

Auvergne63 · 25/02/2024 09:21

FWIW, I couldn't give a flying fuck about 'gender', but I care very much what sex someone is because the male sex is a danger to the female sex and women and girls deserve safety and dignity away from males.
So you believe that every man is a potential rapist. Ok.

No

But 99.99999 etc sexual assaults on women and girls are by male perpetrators and the offending pattern of an individual remains the same even after so called "transition "

BeretInParis · 25/02/2024 10:37

aweegc · 25/02/2024 08:38

I see FAR more Islamophobia tied up with Western feminism than anti-Semitism, although I that term isn't helpful because it's vague (for a start it includes Palestinians, who are semites, or if it doesn't, it denies their history and identity). I prefer anti-Zionist and anti-Jewish. These are very different things as you have Zionists who are Christian (Biden being one) and anti-Zionists who are Jewish (many of whom are at the "hate marches").

The Islamophobia is rife though in many, many conversations (not only here) about Palestinian women. And that starts with the blanket assumption that they're all Muslim. I've seen staunch feminists saying we can't support Palestinians because that's supporting Hamas, which is deeply patriarchal. Right. So we can't support the women who are then oppressed (in our eyes) by Hamas AND the bombings, maimings, killings, displacement and starvation faced by them and their families?

Palestinian women are t waiting for Western feminists to do anything anyway. They already know...

And Israeli women aren't waiting for western feminists either. Which is lucky, given it took the UN 8 weeks to condemn the slaughter and sexual violence against women, girls and men that took place during the Hamas pogrom on 7 Oct.

IClaudine · 25/02/2024 10:12

How convenient to make a thread covering not just one but two of the most contentious issues on MN.

Wind 'em up and watch 'em go, eh OP?

takemeawayagain · 25/02/2024 09:58

Justifiedcheese · 25/02/2024 08:20

Never met a "GC" person who, when scratched even lightly, wasn't an out and out transphobe.

Many pro Palestinians are, in fact, anti semitic. RW or otherwise. Mostly LW anti semitic.

Sorry that these inconvenient truths are " tiresome" to face. Deal with it and maybe try some honest reflection.

This just isn't true. This site is extremely GC - but you won't find another place IMO that is more pro boys/men wearing whatever they like, boys having completely free access to any and all traditionally girls toys and challenging almost any other gender stereotype there is.
The problem people have on here isn't with challenging gender stereotypes, that is absolutely applauded on here. The problem is when people start to conflate sex and gender. Gender can be whatever you like, it's a concept, a social construct made up by people and generally based on stereotypes - feel free to challenge and mess with that in any way you like. But when people think that because they can play with gender they must also be able to change sex - and so they're not just dressing like a woman but actually becoming a woman - then that is a problem. It's a problem because sex is binary and changing sex is not a biological possible not matter how much some people want it to be. It then potentially leads to biological men in women's prisons and changing rooms and biological men's crimes being recorded as crimes by women.

I also disagree that most people on here who think what is happening in Palestine is wrong are anti semitic. People are able to separate out what a Prime Minister does from what the average person does/thinks - we have to be able to do that in this country with the list of horrendous PM's we've had! The attacks on innocent Israeli people by Hamas were absolutely horrific. But the response has also been horrific. Completely innocent people on both sides have been treated appallingly. It's just all a very tragic situation.

The problem comes when groups of people say 'If you don't agree with every single thing we want then you're transphobic.' Or 'If you don't agree with every single thing the Israeli Prime Minister does then you're anti semitic.' There are plenty in of moderate people in both groups NOT saying this, but it's those that are that are generally the problem IMO.

Bigminnie1 · 25/02/2024 09:57

aweegc · 25/02/2024 08:38

I see FAR more Islamophobia tied up with Western feminism than anti-Semitism, although I that term isn't helpful because it's vague (for a start it includes Palestinians, who are semites, or if it doesn't, it denies their history and identity). I prefer anti-Zionist and anti-Jewish. These are very different things as you have Zionists who are Christian (Biden being one) and anti-Zionists who are Jewish (many of whom are at the "hate marches").

The Islamophobia is rife though in many, many conversations (not only here) about Palestinian women. And that starts with the blanket assumption that they're all Muslim. I've seen staunch feminists saying we can't support Palestinians because that's supporting Hamas, which is deeply patriarchal. Right. So we can't support the women who are then oppressed (in our eyes) by Hamas AND the bombings, maimings, killings, displacement and starvation faced by them and their families?

Palestinian women are t waiting for Western feminists to do anything anyway. They already know...

Antisemitism does not include Palestinians. Antisemitism is solely hostility or prejudice against Jewish people.

RufustheFactualReindeer · 25/02/2024 09:57

I agree with the poster who said that it happens a lot online and in the media

i see it a lot on here and i think it quite often shuts down debate, sometimes on purpose

Bells3032 · 25/02/2024 09:55

aweegc · 25/02/2024 08:38

I see FAR more Islamophobia tied up with Western feminism than anti-Semitism, although I that term isn't helpful because it's vague (for a start it includes Palestinians, who are semites, or if it doesn't, it denies their history and identity). I prefer anti-Zionist and anti-Jewish. These are very different things as you have Zionists who are Christian (Biden being one) and anti-Zionists who are Jewish (many of whom are at the "hate marches").

The Islamophobia is rife though in many, many conversations (not only here) about Palestinian women. And that starts with the blanket assumption that they're all Muslim. I've seen staunch feminists saying we can't support Palestinians because that's supporting Hamas, which is deeply patriarchal. Right. So we can't support the women who are then oppressed (in our eyes) by Hamas AND the bombings, maimings, killings, displacement and starvation faced by them and their families?

Palestinian women are t waiting for Western feminists to do anything anyway. They already know...

This first paragraph in itself is antisemitic. For a start it's denying hatred of Jews using linguistics. You are also massively incorrect saying semetic refers to Palestinians, it doesn't. Semetic does not by definition refer to any people it refers to languages. Furthermore, language is often more than the sum of it's parts - guinea pigs are neither from guinea nor pigs - things often come to mean more than their individual words. Antisemitic is a term coined in the 18th century to specifically refer to anti-jewish hatred. Please stop trying to deny Jewish people the right to self definition

I've also heard people saying islamophobia is incorrect as phobias are irrational and it's not irrational to be fearful of islam. This is equally abhorrent.

Itscatsallthewaydown · 25/02/2024 09:48

Usernamefoundunderthebed · 25/02/2024 09:19

Plopper?

Posted once and then fucked off

Underthinker · 25/02/2024 09:37

Justifiedcheese · 25/02/2024 08:20

Never met a "GC" person who, when scratched even lightly, wasn't an out and out transphobe.

Many pro Palestinians are, in fact, anti semitic. RW or otherwise. Mostly LW anti semitic.

Sorry that these inconvenient truths are " tiresome" to face. Deal with it and maybe try some honest reflection.

That's spectacularly unlucky given that most people in the UK have broadly gender critical views.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 25/02/2024 09:31

PonyPatter44 · 25/02/2024 08:32

Nobody seems to manage critical thinking any more, people just spout the overly polarised bollocks they pick up off social media.

Someone was sounding off the other day about "from the river to the sea", so I asked him which river, and which sea, and of course the fucktard didn't have the first clue. I'm not supporting a Hamas-led Palestinian government, because Hamas is scum, and the current Israeli administration is so awful it needs to go ASAP. I care about the Israeli and Palestinian women and children who have been left to suffer in this war, and the Israeli hostages need to come home.

You are welcome to call me terf and transphobe if you like. Men don't belong in womens spaces though, that's all. Men need to take responsibility for transwomen feeling unwelcome and uncomfortable in men's spaces.

Are you me? My exact position too.

Dogfisher · 25/02/2024 09:24

Auvergne63 · 25/02/2024 09:21

FWIW, I couldn't give a flying fuck about 'gender', but I care very much what sex someone is because the male sex is a danger to the female sex and women and girls deserve safety and dignity away from males.
So you believe that every man is a potential rapist. Ok.

FFS. Way to prove a point! 😂

midgetastic · 25/02/2024 09:23

Well every man has the necessary tools which women don't?

Potential doesn't mean "thinks they are a rapist"

You have exactly the polarised thinking the op was talking about

Auvergne63 · 25/02/2024 09:21

FWIW, I couldn't give a flying fuck about 'gender', but I care very much what sex someone is because the male sex is a danger to the female sex and women and girls deserve safety and dignity away from males.
So you believe that every man is a potential rapist. Ok.

Usernamefoundunderthebed · 25/02/2024 09:19

Itscatsallthewaydown · 25/02/2024 09:18

Oh no, I’ve posted on a plopper’s thread 🙄

Plopper?

Itscatsallthewaydown · 25/02/2024 09:18

Oh no, I’ve posted on a plopper’s thread 🙄

Itscatsallthewaydown · 25/02/2024 09:18

There’s plenty of antisemitism in the pro-Palestinian movement. Sorry to burst your bubble, but there you go.

snowbird21 · 25/02/2024 09:16

I don't think the adding of the suffix "phobic" is helpful at all, the term was originally used for fear of open spaces or animals etc now it's just added on almost to end debate. Any accusation that anyone is phobic is an attempt to stifle rather than engage in any debate at all - people are entitled to their opinions.

Usernamefoundunderthebed · 25/02/2024 09:16

It's the social media school of politics that's done it, there's no "and also" any more. It's possible to be concerned about women's rights and also trans rights they aren't mutually exclusive. It's possible to be concerned about the welfare of Palestinian people, condemn Hamas and not be an antisemite, but sadly most pro Palestine people I encounter are antisemitic (knowingly or not). As soon as they chant "from the river to the sea" I don't want to listen further.

MissyB1 · 25/02/2024 09:08

aweegc · 25/02/2024 08:38

I see FAR more Islamophobia tied up with Western feminism than anti-Semitism, although I that term isn't helpful because it's vague (for a start it includes Palestinians, who are semites, or if it doesn't, it denies their history and identity). I prefer anti-Zionist and anti-Jewish. These are very different things as you have Zionists who are Christian (Biden being one) and anti-Zionists who are Jewish (many of whom are at the "hate marches").

The Islamophobia is rife though in many, many conversations (not only here) about Palestinian women. And that starts with the blanket assumption that they're all Muslim. I've seen staunch feminists saying we can't support Palestinians because that's supporting Hamas, which is deeply patriarchal. Right. So we can't support the women who are then oppressed (in our eyes) by Hamas AND the bombings, maimings, killings, displacement and starvation faced by them and their families?

Palestinian women are t waiting for Western feminists to do anything anyway. They already know...

I would agree with this. 👆

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 25/02/2024 08:53

And proceeds to denigate sensible, intelligent people who understand that gender is more complicated.

I've never witnessed anyone even defining what gender is beyond listing a bunch of outdated sexist stereotypes. Sex is real, binary and unchangeable. Gender is what? Basically just personality traits and aesthetic preferences, categorised by what is supposedly womanly or manly. How very progressive and inclusive...

CocoPopsAddict · 25/02/2024 08:53

I'm genuinely interested to know what people who think 'gender is more complicated' think a man or a woman is.

How can someone 'feel' like a woman? A woman is born female. It's coded into every cell in our bodies. Surely 'feeling' like a woman is just imagination and a sense of wanting to ascribe to the gender stereotypes we all said we wanted to move away from.

I don't 'feel' like a woman. I'm just a woman. What am I missing, here? Like genuinely I don't give a shit if men want to wear dresses and makeup - they should be able to do that and still just be men.

Does that make me 'transphobic' @Justifiedcheese ? Because I neither hate transpeople nor am particularly afraid of them - they're just people. I just don't understand the rationale behind validating a belief that has no basis in objective truth.