Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Concerned about women's rights? "Transphobe, far right!". Concerned about Palestinians? "Terrorist sympathiser! anti semite!"

83 replies

changefromhr · 25/02/2024 08:07

Tiresome.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Everanewbie · 26/02/2024 12:31

Hi OP. I think you are right. People seem to choose a tribe and stick to the party view. There is rarely much space for for nuance or admitting someone in your tribe is wrong, or someone in the other tribe has a point. Anything inconvenient is fake news, conspiracy and so on. On both sides.

You can roughly trace political party lines over these tribes, but there are a few crossovers, the trans debate being one and you can pretty much guess what the talking heads on TV/Twitter etc. will say before it comes out.

People need to grow up and treat issues on their merit and not according to their tribe orthodoxy.

suspiriana · 26/02/2024 12:16

Concerned about Islamism? "Islamophobe" "Far-right" "racist" etc etc....

LiveLaughCryalot · 26/02/2024 11:58

Neriah · 25/02/2024 08:24

You mean - from those who don't agree with you? Because it couldn't possibly be your polarised position on anything, because you are right. Nuanced thinking, and the ability to engage in rational and open debate is increasingly a rare phenomenon. It is etirely possible to be concerned about Palestinians and also to be concerned about Hamas terrorism and anti-semiticism. It is also entirely possible to be concerned about women's rights and also be concerned about transphobia and the far right (who have no interest in women's rights anyway).

The OP's very premise screams their own polarised and "tribal" thinking.

Stop being all sensible will you! This is Mumsnet dontcha know. You far right fascist 😁

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 26/02/2024 11:51

The change of the definition of transphobia to suit those who view themselves as progressive is really fucking tiresome.

montysma1 · 26/02/2024 11:38

Justifiedcheese · 25/02/2024 08:36

And proceeds to denigate sensible, intelligent people who understand that gender is more complicated.

Such as proclaiming airily that the only sensible, intelligent position is one way.

See what I mean by the lightest scratch?

Edited

But she didn't denigrate anybody.
It's you that doing that.

EllaPotter · 26/02/2024 11:20

PonyPatter44 · 25/02/2024 08:32

Nobody seems to manage critical thinking any more, people just spout the overly polarised bollocks they pick up off social media.

Someone was sounding off the other day about "from the river to the sea", so I asked him which river, and which sea, and of course the fucktard didn't have the first clue. I'm not supporting a Hamas-led Palestinian government, because Hamas is scum, and the current Israeli administration is so awful it needs to go ASAP. I care about the Israeli and Palestinian women and children who have been left to suffer in this war, and the Israeli hostages need to come home.

You are welcome to call me terf and transphobe if you like. Men don't belong in womens spaces though, that's all. Men need to take responsibility for transwomen feeling unwelcome and uncomfortable in men's spaces.

Is it all though? What do you mean by "take responsibility"? Are you saying that transwomen don't belong in women's spaces either? If so, then you can consider yourself a TERF. In most places you would need to be more understanding, if not then you'll end up getting kicked out, and rightly so.

PTSDBarbiegirl · 26/02/2024 11:11

MissyB1 · 25/02/2024 09:08

I would agree with this. 👆

Ultimately nobody posting here lives in these areas. It's all just political footballing. Saying this on a forum in relatively safe Europe won't cause a cease fire. If you want to see an end to genocide of human beings, a majority of children then put pressure on your MP. Nobody can think murder, retaliation and terrorism is going to solve these issues by debating theology and the use of slogans. What's happening in Gaza is fucking wrong on a human level. Israel needs to be heavily sanctioned, weakened and Hamas needs wiped out.

PTSDBarbiegirl · 26/02/2024 10:58

Justifiedcheese · 25/02/2024 08:20

Never met a "GC" person who, when scratched even lightly, wasn't an out and out transphobe.

Many pro Palestinians are, in fact, anti semitic. RW or otherwise. Mostly LW anti semitic.

Sorry that these inconvenient truths are " tiresome" to face. Deal with it and maybe try some honest reflection.

Thank you for illustrating why this is 'tiresome'.

sanluca · 26/02/2024 10:56

Yes every human is a potential murderer

When the country I currently live in had conscription, you could do an alternative to being in the army if you could demonstrate that you would never ever pick up arms, not even to defend yourself or your family. Most men (at the time only male people were conscripted, nowadays on paper it is both sexes, but nobody is conscripted anymore) were honest enough to state yes, if their life or their families was threatened they would fight back.

So yes, every human is a potential murderer, every man is a potential rapist. Most men won't rape, just as most humans won't murder. But looking at pornhub statistics more men are attracted to rape than you would ever want to consider.

Bells3032 · 26/02/2024 10:30

Stingofthelash · 26/02/2024 00:31

Oh, we've moved on from that. In the pro-Palestine marches, the new phrase is are you on 'the right side of history' or 'the white side of history'. Pretty much sums up the bigoted mindset of the virtue signallers and the rent-a-mob. More concerned with pushing their agenda than ending the conflict.

Ironic given that the majority of Israelis have the same genetic decent as those within Gaza!

Stingofthelash · 26/02/2024 00:31

ProfessorPeppy · 25/02/2024 08:31

The most unhelpful phrase in debate is, ‘the right side of history’. People - on the left and the right - are more concerned about being seen to be on the right side of the argument long term than anything else.

Long term, society will accept that single sex spaces are safer for women, but unfortunately there will have to be outrageous examples of criminal men exploiting the current state of the debate in order to get there. This is the fault of people who worry about ‘looking inclusive’.

The ME/Israel/Gaza question has to be resolved by serious diplomacy and discussion, which will come from pressure on regional governments. Taking sides is playing into the hands of bad actors. In the meantime, innocent civilians will continue to be killed.

Oh, we've moved on from that. In the pro-Palestine marches, the new phrase is are you on 'the right side of history' or 'the white side of history'. Pretty much sums up the bigoted mindset of the virtue signallers and the rent-a-mob. More concerned with pushing their agenda than ending the conflict.

DetOliviaBenson · 25/02/2024 15:35

Justifiedcheese · 25/02/2024 08:20

Never met a "GC" person who, when scratched even lightly, wasn't an out and out transphobe.

Many pro Palestinians are, in fact, anti semitic. RW or otherwise. Mostly LW anti semitic.

Sorry that these inconvenient truths are " tiresome" to face. Deal with it and maybe try some honest reflection.

I think you'll find there isn't a person on the planet that has "an excessive and irrational fear" of transpeople.

tryingtobenormalish · 25/02/2024 14:57

I think the worlds gone mad nothing makes sense anymore.

5128gap · 25/02/2024 14:45

Justifiedcheese · 25/02/2024 08:20

Never met a "GC" person who, when scratched even lightly, wasn't an out and out transphobe.

Many pro Palestinians are, in fact, anti semitic. RW or otherwise. Mostly LW anti semitic.

Sorry that these inconvenient truths are " tiresome" to face. Deal with it and maybe try some honest reflection.

You clearly haven't met many people in real life if that's your conclusion. Amused at someone who's world experience is so limited that they have never met anyone with complex and nuanced opinions telling other people what they need to deal with. Perhaps you might like to reflect on the fact that 'people I have met' and 'everyone' have different meanings, with the first being far too small a sample size to enable you to draw conclusions about the second.

pointythings · 25/02/2024 14:38

@Rosestulips you've summed up where I stand in the trans debate.

midgetastic · 25/02/2024 14:17

Yes every human is a potential murderer

Although even there I think that men make up the majority

Sexual assault is an extremely common act - murder isn't

you have women not walking home alone at night for fear of sexual assault yet at the same time people telling us that there is no reason to not want or get naked in a communal changing room with men

IDontHateRainbows · 25/02/2024 13:35

99victoria · 25/02/2024 12:11

Clearly, not every man is a rapist but nearly every rapist is a man 🙁

Well, i have news for you.

Every murderer is a human, therefore every human is a potential murderer.

So what?

BeretInParis · 25/02/2024 12:25

IwishIcouldfinishabook · 25/02/2024 11:28

I think the misuse of the terms 'far right' and 'far left' has minimised the horrors of what the actual 'far right' and 'far Left' is. So instead of being murderous ideologies that between them have resulted in the deaths of millions worldwide, they are 'anyone who doesn't agree with you'. So anyone to the left of Liz Truss is Far Left, and anyone to the right of Jeremy Corbyn is 'Far Right'. Its ridiculous 'Luxury beliefs' nonsense. Especially when the actual far left and far right have far more in common with each other than any other ideologies. Hence Far Right Islamists finding a friend in the useful idiots of the British Left.

Edited

Spot on

99victoria · 25/02/2024 12:11

IDontHateRainbows · 25/02/2024 11:20

Every man is a potential rapist.... jeez

Clearly, not every man is a rapist but nearly every rapist is a man 🙁

Dogfisher · 25/02/2024 11:48

IwishIcouldfinishabook · 25/02/2024 11:28

I think the misuse of the terms 'far right' and 'far left' has minimised the horrors of what the actual 'far right' and 'far Left' is. So instead of being murderous ideologies that between them have resulted in the deaths of millions worldwide, they are 'anyone who doesn't agree with you'. So anyone to the left of Liz Truss is Far Left, and anyone to the right of Jeremy Corbyn is 'Far Right'. Its ridiculous 'Luxury beliefs' nonsense. Especially when the actual far left and far right have far more in common with each other than any other ideologies. Hence Far Right Islamists finding a friend in the useful idiots of the British Left.

Edited

Good post.

Dogfisher · 25/02/2024 11:46

BeretInParis · 25/02/2024 10:37

And Israeli women aren't waiting for western feminists either. Which is lucky, given it took the UN 8 weeks to condemn the slaughter and sexual violence against women, girls and men that took place during the Hamas pogrom on 7 Oct.

Yes it was a disgrace. I think that many so called feminists ignored and minimised what happened on Oct 7 because these women were not on the 'right side'. Probably the same kind of 'feminists;' who think that transwomen are the most oppressed people in history.

CathyBoardman · 25/02/2024 11:45

It's infuriating and very alienating for left wing feminists, especially as a lot of the GC 'feminists' can see that standing up for women's rights does not equal transphobia but not that being pro Palestinian does not equal antisemitism.

It's 1. Really lazy thinking

  1. A distraction from the real issue.
etmoiandme · 25/02/2024 11:29

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

IwishIcouldfinishabook · 25/02/2024 11:28

I think the misuse of the terms 'far right' and 'far left' has minimised the horrors of what the actual 'far right' and 'far Left' is. So instead of being murderous ideologies that between them have resulted in the deaths of millions worldwide, they are 'anyone who doesn't agree with you'. So anyone to the left of Liz Truss is Far Left, and anyone to the right of Jeremy Corbyn is 'Far Right'. Its ridiculous 'Luxury beliefs' nonsense. Especially when the actual far left and far right have far more in common with each other than any other ideologies. Hence Far Right Islamists finding a friend in the useful idiots of the British Left.

MrsSkylerWhite · 25/02/2024 11:25

Neriah · Today 08:24

Dogfisher · Today 08:10

Yes, such idiotic polarised thinking. Much of of coming from the holier than though Left too. Very tribal and not much independent thinking involved.
**
You mean - from those who don't agree with you? Because it couldn't possibly be your polarised position on anything, because you are right. Nuanced thinking, and the ability to engage in rational and open debate is increasingly a rare phenomenon. It is etirely possible to be concerned about Palestinians and also to be concerned about Hamas terrorism and anti-semiticism. It is also entirely possible to be concerned about women's rights and also be concerned about transphobia and the far right (who have no interest in women's rights anyway).
**
The OP's very premise screams their own polarised and "tribal" thinking

Completely agree. There are two sides to most arguments (with a few notable exceptions), often with some truth to both. Because someone doesn’t agree with you, doesn’t automatically make them idiotic. You are guilty of polarised thinking yourself. Try to broaden your view and understand the position of both sides. You’ll be less angry.